8 ms·
Vision Pro
- hn_throwaway_99 3y ago> There’s a strong echo here of mobile 20 years ago. From the late 1990s to 2007, we had mobile internet devices that were OK but not great, and slowly improving, we knew they would eventually be much better, and we thought ‘mobile internet’ would be big - but we didn’t know that smartphones would replace PCs as the centre of tech, and connect five billion people. Then the iPhone came, and the timeline broke. While I think the statement here is generally accurate, the analogy feels so off the mark here to be downright misleading. The pre-iPhone cellphone and "mobile internet device" era was totally different than the current VR/AR era. Most importantly, people actually used their devices all the time, they just wanted them to be better. There was a reason they called them "Crackberries" - Blackberry fans were on them 24/7, and they got tons of utility from them. There was none of this "If we build it, I hope they'll come" feeling of the current VR/AR era. Honestly, it saddens me to think that technology used to be about solving problems for humanity and has morphed into more of this "What substances can we sell to the masses that are sufficiently addictive to make our stock price go up?" I fully understand how much Meta, Apple and others "want to make fetch happen". Many of us are simply just not interested.
- andsoitis 3y agoWhile I tend to agree with you, I think one of the reasons why VR devices today are not selling like hot cakes is because they're mostly (wholly?) targeting gaming, for all practical reasons. Ignoring price for a moment (remember that early Apple computers cost $11,000 in today's money), Vision Pro is positioned for general computing, including games, and has a vibrant App Store so there's actually something to do.
- christoph 3y agoCurrent VR headsets simply haven't been good enough for anything other than games and porn. Text is too difficult and painful to read for any extended period, which is an absolute minimum barrier to entry for almost any other computing task. I honestly believe Apple have solved this problem. Yes it's expensive, but I don't get any real indication they are lying about text being legible and comfortable for extended periods of time, which is a game changer IMO.
- lttlrck 3y agoEven if they have solved the resolution and image quality and physical comfort, having a bright OLED inches from your eyes induces more eye fatigue than looking at a monitor. All you can do to alleviate it is close your eyes. You can't rest them by gazing out the window, across the room. Things you do naturally without realizing, that give your eyes a break. In my experience this is as much an issue as headset physical comfort. In fact it's the one aspect that prevents me wearing a headset beyond a couple of hours. (Plus it is a real pain to drink coffee, have a snack, open the mail; all the little side tasks we tend to do at desks)
- mgkimsal 3y ago> You can't rest them by gazing out the window Please tell me we'll have a virtual window app for the VP that will simulate looking out a window. Anywhere. And it'll be touted as a way to rest your eyes without removing the VP.
- charcircuit 3y agoThe headset is not varifocal so an app like that can't be made.
- kgabis 3y agoIs there any headset with a long focal distance? Even dumb glasses that simulate looking outside would be really useful in some work environments.
- charcircuit 3y agoYes there are headsets that place it at infinity
- WhatIsDukkha 3y ago"""having a bright OLED inches from your eyes induces more eye fatigue than looking at a monitor""" That's quite a claim that I've seen no evidence for in the years I've been using and following this industry. Actually the light hitting your eyes is much dimmer that you are regularly exposed to all the time so...
- wpietri 3y ago> there's actually something to do What do you imagine people doing that isn't done about as well on some other Apple device? I can sort of get the gaming use case; I think it's wildly oversold, but it's legitimately different. But even Apple's launch video doesn't suggest that general computing will be notably improved here.
- bbor 3y agoIn a word: immersion.
- wpietri 3y agoJust to be clear, that's not doing something different. Also, I'm skeptical that immersion matters all that much. People manage to get quite immersed in their phones, after all.
- bbor 3y agoThere’s not much to argue here, but thanks for making your guesses heard! I like mine, lol. Only time will tell how much people value “feeling like you’re there” while chatting with the grandparents, watching a movie, or, yes, browsing the internet. Although as this great article points out, the vision pro is mostly AR so it’s more about “feeling like that is herel”
- Tagbert 3y agoAs attested by people who have had the Vision Pro demo at WWDC, afterwards, looking at the screen on a laptop feels very limiting and artificial. Your engagement is quite different when you are fully surrounded by an environment and can interact with it fluidly vs the separation of a small, rigidly bound rectangle.
- wpietri 3y ago3D is known for its strong novelty effect. At least 5 times people have declared that it will change everything: the Brewster Stereoscope, the DOD purchasing 100k Viewmasters in the 40s, the 1950s wave of 3D movies, the 90s wave of VR, and the Avatar-era wave of 3D movies and TV. As you may have noticed, none of those things are more than a rounding error in the market. And that's before we get to exciting failures like Magic Leap, which people were similarly excited about. And I'll again point you to phones. Despite tablets, laptops, and ever-larger TVs, people spend an awful lot of time on those small, rigidly bound rectangles.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agocurrent VR headsets, and I mean just the Quest, is selling fine. For casual gaming and fitness more so than hardcore gaming.
- awestroke 3y agoOh really? There is already a "vibrant App Store" (whatever that means) full of VR ready apps? Before anybody has received the hardware? Or do you mean you can install iPhone apps? That's a completely different thing and makes your statement highly misleading Also, are you implying that the Quest App Store is somehow not "vibrant"? There are many reasons why I am super excited about the Vision Pro, but the App Store do not number among them
- irjustin 3y agoI agree. All AR/VR devices are replacing... AR/VR devices. But if you want to displace the iPhone/smartphone it has to be 1000x better, which today's tech simply can't do yet. If the glasses that I'm wearing right now could become an AR device at Vision Pro's abilities then take-my-money would be in full swing and easily displace the iPhone as the "center of our lives" computing device.
- nofeelings 3y ago> the glasses that I'm wearing right now could become an AR device at Vision Pro's abilities Nevah gonna happin without breakthrough in lithography. Sub nanometer needed prolly. Ur right tho
- CamperBob2 3y agoI don't see that lithography is the barrier to practicality here. IMO trying to make AR or VR happen without some kind of direct link to the visual cortex is like trying to build an iPhone before multitouch capacitive touchscreens were practical. Smartphones went from "Pointless waste of time" to "Inevitable and incomprehensibly-important technology" overnight when that happened. Jobs had the sense to wait by the river, probably as a result of prior misfires with things like the Newton. Cook, well, not so much.
- fomine3 3y ago> Most importantly, people actually used their devices all the time, they just wanted them to be better. There was a reason they called them "Crackberries" - Blackberry fans were on them 24/7, and they got tons of utility from them. There are some enthusiastic people who use HMD (like Quest Pro) over 10 hours everyday for virtual display. Though currently the number of people is far less than Blackberry era.
- Miraste 3y agoThere is also a difference in kind. "Crackberry" types were businesspeople, executives, politicians. People high in social hierarchies with a lot of sway. The people who use VR to that degree are, and I mean this as affectionately as possible, very unusual. That's probably a big reason Apple has ignored the current VR market segment.
- fomine3 3y agoDifficulty of demonstrate is also a pain. It's easy to demonstrate to friends or mom that BB is useful, but demonstrate any HMD usage/functionality is one of the most hardest thing ever. What most people can do best is just send WWDC video.
- NikolaNovak 3y agoThere's truth to this.my best friend was bugging me to try his Quest 2 for probably a year before I relented and tried it on and understood.
- FormerBandmate 3y agoCrackberries were for people who always needed to be connected. There was no TikTok for BlackBerry, people barely used them for talking to their friends. The modern iPhone barely has anything in common with them
- hnbear 3y ago> people barely used them for talking to their friends In the UK Blackberry and BBM remained very popular for a long time. That Blackberry was additively used for email (even in a business setting) implies a lot of use for friends. The crackberry addicts were emailing their friends, who were likely also work colleagues, fellow execs, etc.
- allenu 3y ago> I fully understand how much Meta, Apple and others "want to make fetch happen". Many of us are simply just not interested. That thing that gets me is just how weak the scenarios were in their promotional videos. After building this device, the best that they could offer as benefits were viewing 3D photographs of your children, looking at multiple screens around you, or watching a single large screen for a movie or photo-browsing. (I mean, they showed somebody browsing the web. Why even dedicate time your video to show that?) It feels like they're either out of ideas or really playing it safe. I'm guessing they do want to make "fetch" happen but don't really know how and are just going to bet on third party devs creating some killer app they haven't thought of. They've certainly got the time and money to work it out over the next few years.
- wpietri 3y agoExactly. I was watching carefully for some new capability, something that couldn't be done before. But I didn't see anything, except maybe "watch movies on a plane without looking down at your tablet/phone". Maybe I'm weird, but if I were so sensitive to bad experiences that I couldn't just watch a movie on a tablet, I wouldn't be on a plane in the first place.
- cubefox 3y agoThe only "new capability" for VR headsets seem to be ... VR games. But Apple very much doesn't want to advertise the headset as a game console, even though VR games are obviously a type of app it can run, just with hand gesture controls instead of dedicated VR controllers.
- dylan604 3y agoI'm guessing Apple is hoping that the apps will be the killer thing. They claim to have not expected the app store to be so successful, so maybe they're hoping they don't need to create the killer app that someone else will. That's why they are introducing the dev tools for it so much sooner than it being available. They are banking on killer apps being announced before launch
- 3y ago
- nofeelings 3y agoNot tru. Ppl already use laptops and desktops a lot already. Vision will be evolution to spatial type of computing which is why Apple says it
- recursive 3y agoWe already have laptops and desktops. It's not a given that this goggle thing will be a general improvement. Personally, I'd rather use a real screen, even if this was free. Which it very much is not.
- nofeelings 3y agoWanna bet? In 50 years 1 billion or more will be using something like the vision pro. The visual exp will b better.
- recursive 3y agoI have no idea what will be happening in 50 years. I'm not taking that bet. But if your prediction is correct, then I think we'll have some better use cases than looking at fake screens. That's my bet.
- nofeelings 3y agoLol ppl are using paper after centuries. Screens r da digital equivalent to paper workstation. Better visual exp is worth it alone. It doesn’t need 2 b better than that. All useful perceived vision will b 2D plane. Stone tablet, paper workstation, crt monitor, lcd, vr. All showing 2d planes
- recursive 3y agoYou keep saying "better visual experience". What's alleged to be better about it? I watched the short promo video, and didn't catch anything about that. The reason why I would prefer to use a real screen is that I (imagine) the visual experience to be better. At least we agree about the reason.
- captainill 3y ago[dead]
- gsatic 3y agoThis is what happens when ever optimizing robots like Tim Cook are put in charge of anything. They should never be in charge of setting the heading of the ship. Keeping the ship running and afloat sure that's what optimizing robots are good for. Don't mistake them for leaders or visionaries. Apple has been a mindless ship on autopilot since the iPhone 4.
- MuffinFlavored 3y ago> There’s a strong echo here of mobile 20 years ago. I don't know. Holding a phone in your hand is very different than putting something directly onto your face.
- Tagbert 3y agoNot so much the implementation of mobile but the impact of a new way to interact with information.
- wokwokwok 3y agoThere's this weird bitterness in the comments about the Vision Pro. Like... > the analogy feels so off the mark here to be downright misleading. I mean, come on, you're obviously nitpicking here. It's not 100% the same, but the parallel between having devices that were basically dumb phones -> internet computers is there, and there was no real indication at the time that a smart phone like blackberry would become a mass market device. None. Zero. It was a niche device for rich people; most people were, and let's be absolutely honest here, absolutely, perfectly OK with simple feature phones, sending text messages and making calls. So, the analogy here is pretty clear; once the device existed, it created a market that didn't exist or maybe extended a tiny market that already existed, but come onnnnnnnn, is it really that epic a stretch to imagine that it might happen again? ...can you not imagine this as a gen1 device that improves over time? It is really so completely different? I don't think it is. I'm not convinced it will, but the parallel is not nearly as misleading as you're making it out to be. Here's what I think is interesting: People want this is fail. Lots of people. Not because they don't like apple. Not because they don't like VR. They just seem to hate it because its expensive and people are being positive about it and they feel like it's somehow wrong for apple to be: - Selling something this expensive - That is a risky bet that might not play out - That people are willing to talk about favorably on the basis of the Apple brand. ...but, here's the thing right? 1) Who cares? They're rich. Let them fail. 2) Apple has the brand it has because it can deliver, and it has delivered in the past. What kind of numpy stands here and thinks... "Oh gee, these guys at Apple are stupid. They're never going to sell these. They'll regret this. Look at all their failed products and their unsuccessful business. Haha!" > I fully understand how much Meta, Apple and others "want to make fetch happen". Many of us are simply just not interested. ...if some people are excited and enthusiastic about it... ...let them be enthusiastic about it?
- jltsiren 3y agoThe way I remember it, the first iPhone was criticized for not having 3G, which was a standard feature ordinary people were already using. But maybe that depends on the country. At least at some point, the Japanese were supposed to have really fancy phones, while the US was behind the rest of the developed world in mobile technology. In Finland, mobile internet was already a big thing during the dot-com boom. The early attempts failed, because the hardware wasn't ready. Regardless, "mobile portal" remained one of the big buzzwords, and even taxi drivers knew that the mobile was the future. In a few years, new phones got color displays, cameras, 3G connections, and GPS receivers. Ordinary people bought them, because flagship phones were cheaper than they are today. And then mobile internet started finally making sense. I remember using the local public transit journey planner on my phone in 2005 or 2006 to determine the right stop after taking an unfamiliar bus.
- fragmede 3y agoYou okay there buddy? Your cynicism's showing. That's either been the case forever, or never. Grandma can't take a plane flight to be with the kids, and the kids are too young to fly to her. But in Mixed Reality (MR), it's just like she'e there. Same with life-saving surgery where the surgeon and the patient can't be colocated.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Freedom2 3y agoDid you read the Vision Pro thread in HackerNews? I think you might be mistaken - many of us are interested! Here's some choice quotes: > I will happily go on the record as saying that this will be as revolutionary as the iPhone, perhaps even more so. > But it's going to be a hit. HN is going to be swamped with "How I used Vision Pro to..." posts when it comes out. > Well fuck me. This thing looks absolutely insane. It’s come in at $3499 and if it performs as good as those videos make out then, if anything, it’s a bargain. > I think Apple designed an incredible piece of hardware here
- outworlder 3y ago> people actually used their devices all the time, No, not really. Like Steve Jobs said, smartphones weren't very "smart". Most people did not have blackberries (those that did have Blackberries, were mostly business users). The rest of us that were technically savvy were playing some crappy java games(the ones allowed by mobile carrier stores), and browsing the web with WAP browsers in our flip phones. Most people were not even doing any of that. And why would they? The experience was terrible. https://www.statista.com/statistics/263437/global-smartphone-sales-to-end-users-since-2007/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/263437/global-smartphone... Using the same metric, people already use VR headsets, and just "want them to be better". Sure, the marketshare is a fraction of phone marketshare(https://www.statista.com/statistics/677096/vr-headsets-worldwide/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/677096/vr-headsets-world...). But we can argue that most headsets are tethered to high end PCs, Meta's version is one of the few decent standalone versions. Apple's device has lots of potential. It's all about the execution now, and subsequent devices.
- hn_throwaway_99 3y agoHow many people do you know that had pre-iPhone smart phones, bought them and used them for a couple months, and then "abandoned" them on the shelf, a common phenomenon with current VR/AR gear as mentioned in the article. In my experience, practically nobody. I agree that the Vision Pro is a technological marvel, but it's still a solution looking for a problem, and it's striking to me how even Apple had a difficult time presenting actually compelling use cases in their videos. To be clear, I think there are some viable uses: gaming obviously, and potentially media consumption, but even there this solution is so much worse than a home theater system (as another commenter mentioned, I can get a group of people together in my house to all watch a movie on a big screen TV that costs much less than the headset that each of my friends would also have to own).
- jnsie 3y ago> How many people do you know that had pre-iPhone smart phones, bought them and used them for a couple months, and then "abandoned" them on the shelf, a common phenomenon with current VR/AR gear as mentioned in the article. The difference, IMHO, is that those with pre-iPhone smart phones were largely business users who didn't have a choice. Not that there weren't exceptions - I'm sure many had personal smart phones - but I vividly remember (in both Europe and the US) conversations with friends where the idea of paying for a data plan was considered the height of absurdity and would never happen for personal use.
- drunkenmagician 3y agoI feel the analogy comparisons are not about the device type or use cases for them, rather its about the potential for it to be a paradigm shift in device categories. To me it feels more like the shift that the original Mac introduced to the public at large, from command line based computing to GUI computing, and the potential for new categories of app interactivity.
- mytailorisrich 3y agoI think the aim of the Vision Pro is to make people use them all the time as well. The product is not designed for gamers for instance but provides a VR interface for pretty much your everyday iPhone/Mac/Watching movies use. Personally the thought of people putting that on as soon as they get home/in office or even in the street is somehwat nightmarish but I think they're hoping for something like that...
- benedictevans 3y agoThe next paragraph makes exactly that point: "where the iPhone was a more-or-less drop-in replacement for the phone you already had, nine years after Meta bought Oculus, VR is still a new device and a new category for almost everyone. Indeed, the Vision Pro actually looks a bit more like the original Macintosh, which was over $7,000 (adjusted for inflation) when it launched in 1984, and most people didn’t know why they needed one."
- kepano 3y ago> where the iPhone was a more-or-less drop-in replacement for the phone you already had, nine years after Meta bought Oculus VR is still a new device and a new category for almost everyone. Soon enough the category will be a replacement for your home theater and/or your mobile entertainment device (i.e. tablet). As simple as it might look, the most compelling mass-market use case I saw from Apple is... watching a movie on an airplane. That experience is pretty crappy on current headsets because the resolution is low and the optical aberrations are very noticeable. The dual micro-OLED approach solves those problems. As production ramps up on micro-OLEDs the category will become 10x more affordable, and within 10 years I'd be surprised if 50% of people on commercial flights are not wearing this kind of headset. To borrow a Steve Jobs phrase, I think of these devices can eventually become "a bicycle for the senses"[1] and open up all kinds of exciting use cases. But to get to mass-adoption you have to nail the basic stuff like watching a movie or TV show. We just haven't had a good device that can do that yet. [1]: https://stephanango.com/bicycle-for-the-senses https://stephanango.com/bicycle-for-the-senses
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> the most compelling mass-market use case I saw from Apple is... watching a movie on an airplane It’s also an environment steeped with signalling, something Apple excels at.
- kepano 3y agoGood point! The white earbuds (wired or not) are perhaps the best example of that.
- FormerBandmate 3y agoWhat signal does the Apple Vision Pro provide besides “please don’t talk to me”? The main flex on a plane is your seat tbh
- c23gooey 3y agoA status signal. "I can afford $4k to watch a movie on this plane and you can't"
- michaelsshaw 3y ago>or contact lenses projecting onto your retina, or some kind of neural connection, I don't know why anyone would voluntarily receive medical devices and procedures for the sake of having cool tech, particularly brain surgery. In a time where a lot of people are reducing their online footprint, you'd have to be crazy to think that anyone would risk their lives to "sign-in" to a kind of social network that you can't ever leave.
- Gigachad 3y ago>In a time where a lot of people are reducing their online footprint No they aren't. The average person is increasing it. Social media platforms are bigger than ever before. I 100% expect that if they released a brain chip that gave you instant access to GPT-10 making you smarter than everyone else, people would buy it. You'd be unhirable if you didn't because everyone else has instant access to all human knowledge.
- michaelsshaw 3y ago>No they aren't. They are. Not necessarily en-masse, but 10 years ago the terms "digital footprint" and "third-party cookies" were not commonly known terms. They are now.
- bbor 3y agoEh I give credit for the cookie thing entirely to GDPR, and I question the general usability of “digital footprint”. So I think you’re extending your personal experiences a bit far. That said, just looking at Europe to avoid “new internet user” bias from poorer nations, this random website says that a few (facebook, Instagram, and Twitter notably) shrunk a little last year, so hey, maybe I’m the out of touch one https://www.statista.com/forecasts/1334334/social-media-users-europe-by-platform https://www.statista.com/forecasts/1334334/social-media-user...
- somsak2 3y agodo you have an actual source? these are just terms for a trend that very few people are actually following. total time spent on digital devices and social media is only going up. https://www.statista.com/statistics/1045353/mobile-device-daily-usage-time-in-the-us/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/1045353/mobile-device-da... https://www.oberlo.com/statistics/how-much-time-does-the-average-person-spend-on-social-media https://www.oberlo.com/statistics/how-much-time-does-the-ave...
- Arn_Thor 3y ago> It’s also interesting that Apple doesn’t show this being used outdoors at all, despite that apparently perfect pass-through. One Apple video clip ends with someone putting it down to go outside... Because that would be inviting ridicule. It's still way too large and bulky and, let's face it, comical to be used outside. Maybe in an office... Maybe. Clearly it's not intended for outdoor use.
- dmix 3y agoIt's basically like an TV/monitor combination. You don't bring monitors outdoors but they are still extremely useful at home for specific stuff. The high-end passthrough is still very important for home use even without tacky "dolphins coming through your walls" usecases. Anyone who has used VR for extended periods of time with headphones and tried to have a drink/look at their phone knows how frustrating that is to take the whole rig off or try to peak down. The fact VR people were excited you could read your Apple watch without taking off your headset says a lot about the current state of using VR for extended periods w/o quality passthrough.
- bbor 3y agoI mean… it’s an AR device, or at least it’s trying to be, as covered in the article. Do you have a different take? I think calling this “passthrough” is a little dismissive, but perhaps I’m just biased towards previous usages of the term which were for meant for the usecases you mention, not extended continuous use
- Tagbert 3y agoWhy would you take it off to have a drink? What is wrong with peeking down? Both seem quite doable in the VP.
- dmix 3y agoIt's a pain in the ass when you're playing a game in the middle of the room (like when I boxed every day for a month on it) then have to awkwardly walk across the room to the endtable to pick up a glass while pretending I'm a kid cheating during a blindfold game, peaking down. Also when I boxed I would use this face cover for sweat which also blocked light really well so I basically had to take it off: https://www.amazon.ca/SAYAFAN-Adjustable-Breathable-Oculus-Workouts/dp/B09V15YP8X/ https://www.amazon.ca/SAYAFAN-Adjustable-Breathable-Oculus-W...
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> Meta is trying to catalyse an ecosystem while we wait for the right hardware - Apple is trying to catalyse an ecosystem while we wait for the right price Ignoring that these are the same thing, there is something deeper about the firms’ this reveals that I’m having a tough time enunciating. In essence, Apple is pursuing a time-tested strategy: start at the top of the market and build your way down with scale. Facebook is doin…something else.
- bbor 3y agoI don’t understand either point, would appreciate elaboration if you find the time. Your first sentence says they’re the same thing, but then your second sentence discusses their differences? Maybe “ignoring for a moment” is just doing some real heavy lifting? Re:strategy, I feel like there are many examples of companies who didn’t start with top-shelf products - I mean, we could start with the iPad and iPhone, which were expensive but I don’t think quite to this degree. But I’m assuming you know more about this - is Tesla the main counterexample?
- JumpCrisscross 3y agoThey're both waiting for the same thing: good cheap, hardware. They both want to a retina headset for $500. Apple started with retina and compromised on price; Facebook started with the price and compromised on quality. Moreover, the advances of one are likely to influence the rate of progress of the other. They're on the same track, they're just marching from opposite sides. Barring IP boundaries I don't understand, if one of them gets it the other can too. The phrasing implies they're pursuing separate lines; they're not–they're pursuing the same line from opposite directions. Both need better apps. Apple seems to be betting on outside developers. They're corning the high end market and beckoning builders with those consumers' disposable dollars. Facebook is going straight for scale. That, however, means burning cash not only to absorb the devices' thin margins but also the in-house development of their software. It's interesting seeing Apple playing a conventional industrial strategy, and Facebook playing the Vision Fund-esque blitzkrieg line. (HoloLens appears to be more focussed on gamers for the moment.)
- belltaco 3y ago> It’s also interesting that Apple doesn’t show this being used outdoors at all, despite that apparently perfect pass-through. One Apple video clip ends with someone putting it down to go outside... I wonder if this was to counter the possible "glasshole" narrative from popping up again like it did with Google Glass, because the device can record whatever the person is looking at(in immersive 3D VR no less!). Not to mention potential safety issues.
- dmix 3y agoIt's too early for Apple to gamble on that sort of micro-hardware AR stuff anyway. It makes a lot more sense for them to pack it full of CPU/GPU + high end screens (basically VR but with Retina displays + M2 chips). I see it like an iPad, it's for hanging out at home for entertainment and occasionally a bit of serious work when you need to do something simple like answer emails. But most of the time you'll still be using for laptop for real work. I'm sure some hardcore people will try to work fulltime with it on, people are already trying that with Quest 2s. Which I always found a bit crazy.
- zmmmmm 3y agoMy guess is that a lot of their magical experience they demo'd is still highly tuned to the specific environments they showed it in.
- dmayle 3y agoI am not an Apple fanboy (I run Nix on x86 mostly, some Arm), but I actually think they've managed to get it completely right on this. There are a few key pieces that I see as signs that this will eventually hit it out of the park. With that being said, I do believe this is a v1, but remember that the first iPhone was very much a v1 as well.. (I stayed out until the iPhone 3GS myself, and prefer Android phones nowadays). The signs: 1. The battery seems replaceable. I had an original Google Glass... after 2-3 hours of use you had to take it off your head and let it charge, meaning that you would never get used to always having it on. If people have to choose between having a useless hunk of heavy metal on their head, or not being able to use it while it recharges for a few hours, you have failed. 2. Making it AR-first and having that weird external display. Real life will intrude. Can you answer the door, turn off an appliance, do anything else, without having to pull something off of your head and unstrap some controllers from your hands? With the Apple model of handling things, you can pop out to real life without having to get in or out of using it. If you have to take it off, you're just a little bit less likely to put it back on. 3. Tapping your own fingers to click. This was something I brought up to FB/Meta when I was working there, but they decided not to use it. The only way you can give a tactile/haptic response to virtual items, is if there's also some sort of physical item. Tapping your own finger is the single easiest thing that makes sense. I hope that Apple adds future support for augmented 'props'. Imagine an empty artists palette (typically white plastic), that has virtual colors in swatches, or in a color wheel. You can tap on the physical palette to choose your color, to virtually mix the paints, etc.
- gonehome 3y agoTapping fingers to click is enabled on the current quest fwiw, it's just not the default since typically the default is to use controllers. The thing the quest is missing is eye tracking, I'd guess because of the cost - but that eye tracking is going to be a really big deal for good UX I think (along with the much better latency). Meta also has the issue that because they're targeting social (given what the company is) the value isn't really there unless all your friends have headsets too (outside of the gaming niche). This is really hard. Apple by focusing on the utility for an individual side steps this in a way where it's a lot easier to bootstrap imo, especially with the ability for them to rely on their existing platform.
- nofeelings 3y agoHn ppl r so wrong usually abt Apple. Wrong abt this too. Go look at thread on iPad, on Apple Watch. This will succeed. Immersion is good, and resolution needed for good experience is finally here. The end. I got a good laugh readin the Apple Watch announcement thread. Will laugh in a few years at this thread and others 2
- Reubachi 3y agoDisingenuous from the get go. This device starts at 3x000. How much did apple watch/iphone v1 start at?
- paul_grisham 3y agoThe Vision Pro is just combining a screen with horse blinders. Absolutely depressing product and laughable that companies pretend that these technologies bring people closer together.
- pazimzadeh 3y agoIf the weight isn't too bad, it seems like it should encourage better posture since you can arrange the content anywhere?
- pazimzadeh 3y agoIf the weight is not too bad then then working with it should help posture since you can position the windows anywhere in any environment
- spiralganglion 3y ago> Apple’s Vision Pro isn’t an iPhone moment, or at least, not exactly. At $3,500, it’s very expensive in the context of today’s consumer electrics market, where the iPhone launched for $600 (without subsidy, and then rapidly switched for $200 at retail with an operator subsidy) This doesn't sit right with me. The iPhone launched at $600 into a market where most consumers were paying between $0 and $35 for a dumbphone. So while the absolute prices are different, the orders-of-magnitude difference between "what the typical consumer pays for a product in this category" and "what Apple is charging for their radical entry" is about the same. (No, I'm not trying to say that Vision Pro is the iPhone moment for VR/AR — I agree that it's probably not. I just don't agree with this particular argument.)
- zmmmmm 3y agoAbsolute prices matter though right? People's salaries and expendable income is not relative in the end.
- BroodPlatypus 3y agoWell in my opinion cost is relative to the value it brings. I think by proposing such a jump in price, ($60 to $600 for iPhone, $300 to $3500 for Vision Pro) Apple is implying they believe that this breakthrough is worth more value to the end user. Whether they’re correct is for the markets to decide. But if I were to wager, I believe their constrained release of a (rumoured) million units will drive demand and carve themselves a nice premium chunk of the market. So while absolute price does matter, I would say this product will result in the consumer waiting on upgrading their TV, sound system, or computer. With the vision pro, I’d be willing to trade off not having ‘bleeding edge’ tech in semi-stagnant fields such as display panels, audio interfaces, and laptops.
- benedictevans 3y agoIt was $600 without a telco subsidy, which was a mistake, and one reason the first model really didn't sell. Then it went to $200 with subsidy in the USA (more complicated elsewhere). I presume you know that '$0' feature phone was actually $100 or so but subsidised to $0.
- m3kw9 3y agoThe Vision Pro doesn’t need to be light as a feather to succeed like what Ben Evans seem to suggest. It needs to be light enough, but it will likely be the new entertainment experiences that will give it massive traction. Apple isn’t gonna go Alphabet on this thing and axe it 12 months in. When the price/size comes down to iPhone territory and power/features keeps ramping up, it isn’t hard to see this as a must have entertainment device at least, plus it can do work.
- bitwize 3y agoThe Vision Pro is in the same position as the Mac was in 1984: overpriced, doesn't seem to do much and people don't understand what they might use it for. In a relatively new untested product category no less (VR goggles/personal computers). But it's going to change the world.
- dmm10 3y agoOr perhaps the Lisa
- AnonHP 3y agoA little on Meta: > It’s worth remembering that Meta isn’t in this to make a games device, nor really to sell devices per se - rather, the thesis is that if VR is the next platform, Meta has to make sure it isn’t controlled by a platform owner who can screw them, as Apple did with IDFA in 2021. Also, Meta wants to be the gateway to connect businesses with people (the primary requirement for the company) and to connect people with people, slurping every bit of data it can from all its sources in an attempt to become like the Eye of Sauron (unsure if this analogy holds). As such, Meta has self-imposed limits on what its headset can ever be.
- zmmmmm 3y ago> Meta, today, has roughly the right price and is working forward to the right device: Apple has started with the right device and will work back to the right price. I like this analysis, though I think it still misses some fundamentals. To me, if you go back to root cause analysis on "why has VR/AR not succeeded yet" you have to come to some basic conclusions: 1. The value proposition isn't there. It just isn't valuable enough to have a giant screen or bring a virtual object into your space that you will pay for it and wear a special device. Apple did not solve this. They presented the same things you can do for 10 years, claiming that better quality will make it worth it. But I call BS on that - quality on the Quest 2 is easily good enough that consumers would do it for the use cases Apple presented (photos, movies etc) if the value was there. 2. Form factor. People simply DO NOT LIKE having a giant thing on their face. Apple failed comprehensively at this. The Vision Pro is just as bulky as other headsets - eg: Quest Pro. They also HATE being attached or wired to things and Apple has put a giant wire coming out of your head. The fact that Apple hasn't addressed the fundamentals leads me to the conclusion this device will at best be a dev kit for whatever eventually makes it to mass market. Perhaps 2 years from now it will indeed be Apple with a glasses like form factor. I'm a strong believer in the future of this type of device but I really do think Apple has basically just created another VR type device here: it "blows people's minds" and I'm sure a legion of Apple enthusiasts will go buy it (probably me too). But after the novelty wears off, it will sit in the corner because it has the same fundamental problem: it just isn't better at what it does than not using it. At least, novwhere near enough to justify the price and inconvenience involved.
- adultSwim 3y agoThis is great but please bring back Intel's smart glasses. Red only Terminator vision overlay in a lightweight relatively inexpensive package. https://www.theverge.com/2018/2/5/16966530/intel-vaunt-smart-glasses-announced-ar-video https://www.theverge.com/2018/2/5/16966530/intel-vaunt-smart...