7 ms·
Rick Rubin’s creative genius
- boredumb 3y agoWhy is HN suddenly full of latimes/new yorker/nytime/bbc/gizmodo/etc articles? I had an internal bet that i'd find an iflscience.com post before the end of the week.
- _Parfait_ 3y agoReddit's down my man. Hopefully it doesn't trigger Hackernews' eternal September.
- Solvency 3y agoHave you noticed the downward trend in topics and discussions in the last 2 weeks? And that nearly every day another topic is about Reddit/spez? There's your answer.
- the_only_law 3y agoIt’s not like this is particularly new, just recently you had people complaining about the swath of AI posts, cryptocurrency before that and other shit in the past.
- acheron 3y agoI don't think this is a particularly new thing. It randomly comes and goes. Maybe there's a peak now because of the reddit BS but I doubt it will last long.
- paulcole 3y agoYeah I agree. It's frustrating to see HN become less of a tech echo chamber. Can't we just get back to blog posts about how technical debt is bad and why managers with MBAs are clueless?
- boredumb 3y agoThis is a forum for a VC tech-incubator.
- quickthrowman 3y agoThe very first paragraph of the guidelines, written by someone that works for said VC tech incubator: On-Topic: Anything that good hackers would find interesting. That includes more than hacking and startups. If you had to reduce it to a sentence, the answer might be: anything that gratifies one's intellectual curiosity. The article generated 90 posts of discussion, I would say plenty of users found it interesting, even if you did not.
- robg 3y agoI’ve been on HN since 2007. It has always been general interest.
- robg 3y ago*On-Topic: Anything that good hackers would find interesting. That includes more than hacking and startups. If you had to reduce it to a sentence, the answer might be: anything that gratifies one's intellectual curiosity.* https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- dang 3y agoThose sorts of articles have always appeared here. Maybe there's been a random up-fluctuation - I have no idea, but it's expected in any random sequence. If so, it will pass soon enough. Edit: I see acheron already said this
- acheron 3y agoI mean, I get it, I probably complained in the past about a bunch of Guardian articles on the front page. But eventually I realized that mostly it's just the effect where you notice things that bug you and then forget about them when they're not there. A bunch of Guardian articles show up, I get annoyed, then some amount of time goes by while I don't think about it, and then randomly some more appear and I remember again.
- dang 3y agoOmg you have hit on my personal pet point that no one ever notices! https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&query=by%3Adang%20notice%20dislike&sort=byDate&type=story&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...
- ergonaught 3y agoI noticed a few years ago that Rick's been involved in so many of my favorite albums it is nearly disturbing. I don't know what he's after but it's what I want to hear, apparently.
- jkubicek 3y agoTo me, the weirdest part of Rick Rubin as a producer is that he has no distinctive sound. As best I can tell, there's no way to listen to an album and know he produced it. I've watched a lot of interviews with Rick and about Rick, and his role seems to be entirely limited to being a muse for artists. He's not technical, he's not a musician, he doesn't really do anything beyond taking naps in the recording studio while the musicians record, occasionally opening his eyes to ask them how they feel. To be honest, it would almost be possible to argue that Rick Rubin doesn't do anything worthwhile if he didn't have an outrageously long and unimpeachable resume to back up his contributions.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- rndmnflnce 3y agoIt's kind of crazy. He's basically a filtered and focused amplifier for an artist as opposed to typical producer/collaborator. he's the ultimate 'PED' for artists!
- acheron 3y agoYes I've noticed that too. For one example, compare Tom Petty doing Full Moon Fever with Jeff Lynne, and then a few years later doing Wildflowers with Rick Rubin. Lynne has a sound, and it's all over FMF. Rubin doesn't have anything distinctive in the final product of WF, but you read or watch things about the recording and he's talking with Petty about it the entire time.
- musicale 3y agoThose ELO albums with Tom Petty, George Harrison, Roy Orbison et al. where pretty good.
- criddell 3y agoIt seems like he often takes on a passive role but has no problem being more active when necessary. The story of how he pursued Johnny Cash and introduced him to Nine Inch Nails’ Hurt is one example. I’m reading Rubin’s book now and I really like it. It’s full of his observations and advice which includes not listening to advice. Very short chapters that are easy to read but I try not to read more than one or two a week because I find myself thinking about what I read for days.
- AS37 3y agoThis brings to mind his advice that is basically 'If you want 10 good songs, write 30'. His method remind me of Nail Gaiman: "And I think it's really important for a writer to have a compost heap. Everything you read, things that you write, the things that you listen to, people you encounter-- they can all go on the compost heap. And they will rot down. And out of them grow beautiful stories." (And of course the pottery teacher story.)
- fuddle 3y agoI found the story of how Rick Rubin convinced Johnny Cash to cover Hurt by Nine Inch Nails quite interesting. https://www.musicradar.com/news/rick-rubin-johnny-cash-hurt-best-of-2022 https://www.musicradar.com/news/rick-rubin-johnny-cash-hurt-...
- robg 3y agoSimilar cross over with Walk this Way leading to Run DMC’s mass adoption. Where the guy loves music and knows how to sell it. https://www.loudersound.com/features/walk-this-way-run-dmc-aerosmith https://www.loudersound.com/features/walk-this-way-run-dmc-a...
- paulpauper 3y agoI wonder how much of this success can be explained by survivorship bias? I am sure there are/were plenty of producers equally or more brilliant but who never got a chance, couldn't sign the Beastie Boys or Run-DMC, or worse timing. it is easier to be a legendary producer when you happen to get all the best most talented acts ,too. There were so many producers in the early 80s hip hop scene.
- robg 3y agoHe was there at the beginning with Run DMC then the Beastie Boys, the latter was a punk rock band until he started to push them and as a member.
- aschearer 3y agoThere really are talented people in this world. A bitter lesson.
- alangibson 3y agoThat doesn't pass the smell test. He's still producing hit records. If it was just survivorship bias, certainly we'd be talking about him in the past tense given how notoriously difficult it is to stay alive and relevant in the entertainment industry.
- paulpauper 3y agoit is easier to produce hits when you already established yourself, because then you get the top talent and have more money and media attention for subsequent records . they are not totally mutually independent events.
- throwaway1004 3y ago>how notoriously difficult it is to stay alive and relevant in the entertainment industry. This smells really bad: the entertainment industry is notoriously hard for the majority of artists to gain a foothold, but there are just as many notable cases of sub-par artists getting ahead through nepotism etc. And that's only discussing the talent, the business end of the music industry has that issue to reductio-ad-absurdum levels.
- robg 3y agoLoved this podcast with Rubin and him being asked right up front what a music producer does. https://open.spotify.com/episode/1sMxk3DfydYWasJVZ4Nqy5?si=JA3Qf7vmTHyx8ajqs3Sp3Q https://open.spotify.com/episode/1sMxk3DfydYWasJVZ4Nqy5?si=J...
- hangonhn 3y agoI loved that episode. The part where he talked about being in tears from watching Alpha Go beat humans in Go using a move no human has ever considered almost made me cry. It was amazing to have someone who's not from our field appreciate the beauty of our creations. Rubin is quite an extraordinary person who can see the beauty in many things.
- Flatcircle 3y agoHe was sorta the technical producer on the early beastie boys records in the sense that he was able to get them recorded. After that he had the resume to get other jobs which became a sort of fly wheel since those later records also became legendary. Now he’s practically a life coach and has the awesome recording studio in Malibu. it’s a case study in having a great resume. Hard to argue with a guy who was affiliated with all those great records.
- jimt1234 3y agoEarly rap records were mostly rappers, backed by house-bands playing disco music. Rick noticed that these early records didn't sound like what was being played in the streets (block parties and underground clubs). This bothered Rick, so he set out to produce a rap record that matched the sound he heard in the streets: "It's Yours" by T La Rock. This record is rarely mentioned as a hip hop classic, and it's generally overlooked as one of Rick's greatest hits. However, IMHO, the importance of "It's Yours" can't be overstated. Most significantly, it introduced the world to rap music from the streets, where it all began, with a DJ (and a beat), and a rapper on a microphone. That's it. No house-band. No made-for-radio, wanna-be disco sound. If not for "It's Yours", rap music might have died with disco. Hard to believe now, but it's 100% true. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KfndwTrDXbo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KfndwTrDXbo
- jimt1234 3y agoI'm kind of a hip hop trivia nerd, and this year is huge for guys like me: August 11th is generally regarded at the 50th anniversary of the birth of hip hop. https://www.pbs.org/opb/historydetectives/investigation/birthplace-of-hip-hop/ https://www.pbs.org/opb/historydetectives/investigation/birt...
- jimt1234 3y agoOne last thing, another generally unrecognized, but highly influential producer in creating what would become the hip hop sound was the late Larry Smith. RIP https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Larry_Smith_(producer) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Larry_Smith_(producer)
- quickthrowman 3y agoThanks for sharing, I’ve never heard the full song but I’ve definitely heard bits and pieces of it. Off the top of my head, I can name at three songs that sample it; Nas - The World is Yours (throughout), Beastie Boys - Paul Revere (also produced by Rick Rubin!) and Girl Talk - That’s Right. It reminds me of the first time I heard Top Billin’ by Audio Two, I had heard samples of it many times but never the full song.
- weinzierl 3y agoIf you like to hear a counter perspective watch the Beastie Boys documentary on Netflix. It's not about Rick Rubin primarily of course but it paints a much more sober picture of the man.
- takinola 3y agoFor those of us who don't/won't watch the documentary, can you please summarize the other perspective?
- weinzierl 3y agoI'm not sure if I am able to, because it is very ambivalent. I think on one hand they looked up to him but on the other hand they found him alien. It would be easy to think that they admired him in the beginning but later were disgusted and felt screwed over, but my interpretation of the documentary is that they don't feel like that. It's more like they always had and maybe still have mixed feelings. Just my take away.
- lawgimenez 3y agoI read the Beastie Boys book sometime last year and Rubin was everywhere with the Beastie Boys. Involved with record dealings with Rush Management and Def Jam, not only those but also on a personal level. Beastie boys and Rubin were really close. Rubin was also instrumental in kicking out Kate of the Beastie Boys original drummer.
- weinzierl 3y agoI think it is fair to say that Rubin's influence on the Beastie Boys during that phase is hard to underestimate. They would not have become what they are if it weren't for Rubin and I think they acknowledge that in the movie and probably also the book. But it is also true that all of this happened roughly between 1984 and 1988, so a pretty short time frame in relation to both their careers. Also reading up a bit on Rubin's perspective I think he had quite an ambivalent view of the Bestie Boys as well.
- vondur 3y agoHe did Slayer's first three records, Reign in Blood, South of Heaven and Seasons in The Abyss. All of them had distinctive drum sounds. Most of the early thrash metal records had pretty bad recordings, or the drums we hard to define. Not so with these records, the drums were very easy to hear in the mix with the rest of the heavy guitars.
- throwaway1004 3y agoThe engineers invovled would certainly be responsible for this, Rubin himself has little-to-no technical ability or involvement with the actual process of creating music, instead he provides commentary, veto, and direction towards a high-level objective for the product being produced. But, he almost-certainly was the guy who told Slayer "yeah... that... playing really fast and loud, all the time... keep doing that..." and we all owe him for that!
- Perceval 3y agoSlayer had 4 albums before Reign in Blood: Show No Mercy (LP), Haunting the Chapel (EP), Live Undead (Live), Hell Awaits (LP). However, the production difference between the pre-Rubin albums and the Rubin albums is stark, and the value of Rubin's help is really noticeable.
- vondur 3y agoOh I'm aware of all the Slayer records. The first show I saw them on was the Reign In Blood Tour back in 1987 at the Olympic Auditorium in Los Angeles. Went to their last show at the Forum here in Los Angeles back in 2019.
- siquick 3y agoHighly recommend the audio book version - the combination of his tone of voice and the content feels magical.
- throwaway1004 3y agoAccepting the conceit that the music industry is a meritocracy and that demand drives supply, Rick Rubin is clearly a 10Xer genius who gets the best of the best out of the best of the best while the tape is rolling. Entertaining the conspiracy theory that the music industry is a cartel ran by a group of unscrupulous and insular gangsters with functionally-unlimited ability to promote and push garbage on the public, with marketing dollars and pay-for-play airtime being the primary means of popularity, one might assume that Rick was involved in projects whose success was a fait accompli, and that Rick's presence and observance in the studio goes beyond music. Personally, I've noticed the wild variance in artists' opinions about working with Rubin: some say he's a genius and inspirational, but just as many say he's a useless loafer who checks-in from time to time without adding anything creative or useful. It seems, to me, that the former group come from "non-muscian" backgrounds: they are "artists" who usually contribute vocalisations which are a component of tracks created by producers; the latter group tends to include musicians and bands who are self-starters capable of producing songs on their own but expecting a pro producer to help the effort.
- crtified 3y agoVarious band accounts over the years have described Rubin's role as a mentor and kind of 'album godfather' - a role which encompasses almost therapy-like factors and mental approach, but also some technical overview and experience. His work in the late 2000's with band Metallica for their 2008 album Death Magnetic was well publicised in the scene around that time, and several small videos and excerpts still exist, e.g. [0],[1],[2]. The value of that venerable mentor style role is clearly immense, as anybody ever well mentored through a big project by an accomplished elder - or indeed, had a good parent(s)! - can attest. A few of the Metallica band member comments: * "Rick made us comfortable revisiting and being inspired by our old albums..." * "He knew what the ultimate Metallica album should sound like in his head..." * "Rick was very clever technically, even in the tuning of the songs, he questioned why we had everything tuned down a half step.." * "He did not want us to go into the studio until we could play these songs in our sleep." * "Rick Rubin is a guy who listens to music, and says That's Good, and That's Not Good..." * "His contributions are big picture, he's not a musician" -- [0] What Rick Rubin Actually Was Doing While Recording "Death Magnetic". Metallica Interview : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bm0AOVdPriI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bm0AOVdPriI [1] Metallica's Lars Ulrich on working with Rick Rubin VS Bob Rock : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Atjw-dSM6kE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Atjw-dSM6kE [2] Lars Ulrich on Death Magnetic, Rick Rubin - "What did Rubin bring to the table?" : https://youtu.be/GzMINDnoRRs?t=822 https://youtu.be/GzMINDnoRRs?t=822
- Perceval 3y agoDespite the occasionally cringe lyrics and snare drum sound on St. Anger, the songs overall are much better and more memorable on St. Anger than on Death Magnetic, which was mostly unmemorable and sounded derivative. I'm sure hanging out with Rubin is way cooler than hanging out with Bob Rock, but just in terms of song composition the popularly maligned St. Anger is a good album.
- adultSwim 3y agoHis work is great but he's kind of a scumbag. I have a hard time looking up to horrible geniuses.
- whitepoplar 3y agoI'm not familiar with Rubin beyond his public persona. How is he a scumbag?
- randycupertino 3y agoI read his book, "the creative act" and he comes off pretty arrogant. One of the chapters actually opens with him saying, "I AM art" and how fortunate the reader was that he took time to impart his creative knowledge into a book. He's a talented artist and producer, no doubt, but the book was very pompous about his creative philosophy and felt like he'd just been surrounded by yes-men and believing his own hype for the past 20 years. He considers himself a modern Zen master/ Jedi of the new millennium and writes his own koans, lots of name-dropping about his model wife and their rich neighbors in Malibu, writing his own fortune cookie phrases etc. Also the book didn't have much actionable advice on how to actually use creativity in your own life, it was more about how awesome Rick Ruben thinks he is. All in all I can't recommend.
- _smfg 3y agoI'm 3/4 through the book and there's been no mention of his wife nor his rich neighbors in Malibu? What part of the book are you talking about? There was actionable advice in the book... Rick talks lots about ways to get into the flow of creativity, having faith, and developing awareness. Disclosure: I'm a creative, so maybe his artist freakery speaks to me.
- unixhero 3y agoI have mistenrd to interviews with him. I have to say for a guy this well respected, he certainly says very little of substance.