9 ms·
Men who helped run Megaupload sentenced to prison in New Zealand
- tjpnz 3y ago>Fitzgerald said that while the victims of Megaupload included wealthy multinational film and music companies, they also included small companies like a New Zealand software firm, Stuff reported. Given how long this has dragged on for the real victims are the New Zealand taxpayer.
- throwaway290 3y agoBut good job standing for honest small NZ software businesses! I mean, no way it was done just to protect the interests of those wealthy multinationals right? /s Disclaimer: actually I do think NZ fares better than many countries on this so let me know if my cynicism is misplaced.
- throwaway2990 3y agoAt this point he just gives New Zealand a bad name. With all the propaganda he pushes. So he’s cost every NZ citizen paying taxes in NZ and made the country look bad with his public peddling of propaganda for Putin and the CCP.
- George83728 3y ago[flagged]
- mindslight 3y agoThe bad look from Dotcom pushing Russian empire propaganda is dwarfed by the bad look from the authoritarian corporate copyright maximalism persecuting him in the first place. The Russian shilling is patently false and outright cringey, but going down such a rabbit hole is understandable when one is under direct attack from the US economic empire.
- kanbara 3y agounderstandable? i have lost any ounce of compassion when dotcom, greenwald, snowden and others have went full-bore pro-kremlin. the us and copyright bs is an iconic duo which i hate, but going after piracy is whatever compared to destroying democracy and freedom and pushing people to support legitimately evil empires
- mindslight 3y agoThe US economic empire is/was directly attacking these people. The Kremlin / Russian empire is not. Are you not able understand that when something is directly and personally attacking you, you're heavily inclined to not buy arguments that it could be a force for good in other ways? I'm not saying their arguments have merit, or that people should listen to what they say (actually the opposite, which is incredibly tragic with Snowden). Just that their downward spirals are understandable.
- DoItToMe81 3y agoSnowden and Greenwald haven't gone "full bore pro-kremlin". You have not read a single word either have said and have constructed an image of them based on propaganda and lies.
- aerio 3y agoSnowden never says anything pro-Kremlin you dimwit. He DOES criticize the west for perfectly valid reasons.
- justrealist 3y agoSnowden literally got Russian citizenship.
- aerio 3y agoIs that the same as speaking pro-Kremlin messages? At the time he was fleeing the US and Russia thought they could stick it to the yanks. Believing Snowden is pro an even more authoritarian government means you have no idea what the guy stands for.
- jhrmnn 3y agoThis made me think—what if we postulated that companies cannot be victims of a crime. Only physical persons can. So if all you do is harm to a company, it cannot be a crime by definition, the act can only be treated as a company doing harm to another company, and as a company you cannot go to prison
- devmor 3y agoBy doing harm to a company you can still do harm to the owners, employees and clients of that company. You'd only be changing the entities involved in the process, not the outcome.
- jhrmnn 3y agoTrue. But then why do we almost never hold persons criminally accountable when they do harm through a company they control. Shouldn’t this be reciprocal?
- zdragnar 3y agoA person doesn't control a company like they do a car. Proving criminal liability for an individual requires evidence tied to that individual. Much easier, and a lower bar, to hold the corporate entity liable.
- lcnPylGDnU4H9OF 3y agoWe could choose to hold executives and/or majority shareholders responsible instead of a "corporate entity".
- devmor 3y agoWe certainly could and I think, given a stringent set of regulations around record keeping of corporate decisions, we should. Passing such a set of laws seems like a pipe dream at best, though.
- 3y ago
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- plagiarist 3y ago[flagged]
- duxup 3y agoOpen season on people with X amount of money?
- class00000001 3y ago[flagged]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- bottom999mottob 3y agoI think open season on anyone two standard deviations from mean income is fair. /s
- cheaprentalyeti 3y agoGlobally, anyone who has leisure time to read this website is probably at least two standard deviations above the mean income. In the future, anyone with a working computer instead of a 25 dollar surveillance appliance from the cell provider is going to be considered rich.
- wongarsu 3y agoI'd be happy with enforcement resources allocated proportional to the number of victims, instead of mean wealth of victims.
- duxup 3y agoEmployees at a given company?
- fnimick 3y ago
- BLKNSLVR 3y agoContrast this: "wildly popular pirating website Megaupload" and "the victims of Megaupload" With: "After their 2012 arrest, Dotcom and the other two men set up a legitimate cloud-storage website called Mega." Maybe I'm a little bit soft on the whole copyright infringement thing, and maybe time has blurred my memory, but I don't really separate Megaupload and Mega. I thought they were both just online storage lockers. The primary difference, as far as my understanding, being that the US was really focused on copyright infringement as a top priority evil back when Megaupload existed, and a low-level annoyance in the time of Mega. I also think Kim Dotcom isn't exactly the kind of person we'd encourage our kids to grow into, but what the US and NZ authorities did to him, raiding his home, where there were children present, with semi-automatic weapons out, is a far worse criminal act than any scale of copyright infringement. KDC isn't someone I would ever want to feel sympathy for, but the US authorities made it happen.
- yreg 3y ago>I don't really separate Megaupload and Mega As far as I understood Megaupload's business plan was selling "fast" download access to pirated material. I don't care much about piracy, but intentionally making money on it seems somewhat disgusting to me. I consider Mega a legitimate cloud storage service. Nevermind what I think about the fiunder, I find it to be one of the most privacy minded services, so I support it and wish it well.
- formerly_proven 3y agoThe business model was selling bandwidth subscriptions and revenue was shared with file uploaders according to download bandwidth.
- yreg 3y agoAnd this was designed with piracy in mind, was it not? It's pretty obvious in my opinion, even though I have no way to prove intention.
- 3y ago
- juujian 3y agoNot Kim Dotcom :(
- justrealist 3y agoI know you shouldn't throw people in jail even in part because of bad opinions... but Jesus Christ, listen to him talk about Putin, Russia and NATO, and try to be the impartial hand of justice.
- guitarbill 3y agoKim Dotcom is not a fan of the West? Who could've expected that...
- throwaway2990 3y agoI’m not a fan of the west and I can still hate Putin and the CCP. Kim just peddles propaganda now.
- justrealist 3y agoYeah you can be skeptical of the west without jumping straight into the deep end of Russian/Chinese imperialism apologia.
- prmoustache 3y agoMaybe that is just him negociating a last minute exit door to Russia Carlos Ghosn style in case nz justice system is about to extradite him
- guitarbill 3y agoIt certainly doesn't excuse it, but it's hardly surprising. I'm not sure how principled I could be if I'd been through the same ordeal. But hey, two wrongs don't make a right.
- BLKNSLVR 3y ago
- NoMoreNicksLeft 3y agoIf they were to ever fall into the hands of US prosecutors after their prison sentences are concluded, does double jeopardy apply?
- pseingatl 3y agoNo. For the same reason, you can prosecute a separate federal crime based on the same conduct even if a particular State has prosecuted that conduct under its own statutes. This is called the "separate sovereigns" doctrine. Keep in mind that at the time the Constitution was written--and for a long time thereafter--there were almost no federal crimes (counterfeiting, piracy and customs offenses come to mind) so that crime was a State matter.
- NoMoreNicksLeft 3y agoI'm aware of the fed/state split, but my understanding was that they are usually very careful to avoid doing that so as to avoid SCOTUS getting ahold of it and making a ruling? There are rare exceptions, like with the Rodney King cops (prosecuted federally as civil rights violations instead of aggravated assault, etc. so as also to deny SCOTUS any opportunity for review on double jeopardy grounds).
- zerocrates 3y agoOverlapping state and federal prosecutions aren't ultra-rare... the killers of Ahmaud Arbery come to mind: state court convicted them of murder, the feds for hate crimes and gun crimes. That kind of split where the federal charges don't sort of squarely address the core content is common, because something like murder in a general sense isn't a federal crime. As for avoiding the Supreme Court, the case of really tightly matching prosecutions and whether that violates double jeopardy has already happened: the court upheld "separate sovereigns" in Gamble v. US in 2019, a case where both the state and federal government charged someone with illegally possessing a gun as a felon, based on a single traffic stop.
- hvs 3y agoIANAL, but they weren't convicted of crimes against US companies but NZ ones. If the US got them they could theoretically be charged with "different offenses" than the ones they were charged with in NZ. That said, it is much more complicated than that: http://opiniojuris.org/2019/08/30/the-u-s-supreme-court-on-international-double-jeopardy/ http://opiniojuris.org/2019/08/30/the-u-s-supreme-court-on-i...
- Xen9 3y agoKDC claimed in a Twitter audio room that he was one of the biggest funders of WikiLeaks and the whole copyright shit was not actually about copyright but US going after WikiLeaks.
- DoItToMe81 3y agoHe bullshits constantly and expands his legend to well beyond what it actually is. It's entirely in character for the US to do this. They've demanded the extradition of children over LulzSec script kiddying before.
- I_am_tiberius 3y agoI wouldn't believe a word he speaks or writes. Following his twitter thread the past 10 years is really sad. Not sure if it's some sort of mental illness or if he does it on purpose but he seems to have developed some sort of hate for the United States. It's clear that the way they raided him was not fair but the things he writes and the conspiracies he spreads are disgusting.
- throwaway829 3y agoAmerica has been at perpetual war for decades. Other counties are hated for much less than this.
- jstarfish 3y agoI wouldn't believe him either, but this isn't mental illness. This is someone trying to beat a propaganda machine at its own game (the government doesn't sue for defamation). Say enough random shit over time (pretexting) and some of it will resonate with the crazies and the ignorant. The truth doesn't even matter these days; it's entirely about influencing public perception.
- intunderflow 3y agoIf the US government spent a decade destroying my life I'd also hate the United States, I'm not sure why that's surprising?
- teh_klev 3y agoThis is a reheat of the source article mentioned by ABC which has a far more detailed coverage: https://www.stuff.co.nz/national/crime/300905942/megaupload-pair-jailed-for-their-part-in-kim-dotcoms-online-empire https://www.stuff.co.nz/national/crime/300905942/megaupload-...
- 0xDEF 3y agoTheir boss, Kim Dotcom, is an actual "Mega" asshole but nobody deserves to go to prison for data piracy.
- hiidrew 3y ago> "The sentencing of Mathias Ortmann and Bram van der Kolk ended an 11-year legal battle by the men to avoid extradition to the United States on more serious charges that included racketeering." 11 years, how exhausting. I can't imagine. Both were sentenced to a little over 2 years, I wonder how their sentencing would have changed if they would have been extradited?
- smashah 3y agoIf they can argue that because mega upload can be used for copyright infringement so people need to go to jail then so do the devs of ytdl, WeTransfer, YouTube, Google drive/chrome, etc. etc. etc.
- I_am_tiberius 3y agoI don't think so. I remember, Megaupload allowed to view movies, which you could even watch online. After a few minutes the movies stopped and asked you to pay if you wanted to continue. Everyone knew it was a database of pirated movies. Saying they are equal to youtube etc. is just an insult to people who used the site. At that point, everyone you asked would have told you it's a pirate site.
- zirgs 3y agoIt's crazy that they thought that they could get away with something so blatant.
- smashah 3y agoMy point is to say where does it end? What about the devs of BitTorrent/uTorrent? "Everybody knows that these two programs are mostly used for piracy". How about the whole p2p concept? "Everybody knows p2p means pirate 2 pirate". People are dumping whole movies on Twitter right now. So Twitter staff should go to jail? Nobody should go to jail for piracy period. Hope I made my point clear.
- I_am_tiberius 3y agoI'm in general no big fan of locking people away so I agree with your statements in regards to piracy and jail. But the punishment needs to be higher than the benefit is for its users. You compare Megaupload with p2p architectures. Of course torrents are used for criminal activities but they can't be stopped. You wouldn't compare twitter with Megaupload if you had seen Megaupload. The site was essentially like Netflix but for all movies in existence. Saying now that it's only the fault of its users if the site was designed for piracy in mind, is ridiculous.
- croes 3y ago>Fitzgerald said that while the victims of Megaupload included wealthy multinational film and music companies, they also included small companies like a New Zealand software firm, Stuff reported. Is it the same kind of victim as in this study of the EU? https://gizmodo.com/the-eu-suppressed-a-300-page-study-that-found-piracy-do-1818629537 https://gizmodo.com/the-eu-suppressed-a-300-page-study-that-... How much did small business revenues increase after Megaupload was shut down?