7 ms·
Network of channels tried to saturate YouTube with pro-Bolsonaro content
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- boringg 3y agoNot reading the content -- but being part of the team trying to figure out new people trying to influence youtube could be an interesting problem to work on probably from an academic perspective. In actuality you probably deal with a lot of garbage content.
- Morthanc 3y agoNot surprising. The rapid increase of the amount of pro-Bolsonaro content was clearly visible, even spilling towards users like me with no history for viewing political content on the site, especially on 'cuts' for YouTube Shorts.
- marcodiego 3y agoSociety should discuss if recommendation algorithms and targeted advertisement must be regulated. It is known that people have more probability of sharing content that shocks them more. It lights a cycle where recommendation algorithms will give users ever increasing extremism inducing videos. This makes people more radical and makes them consume more of the same drug-like content. Result: polarized society and a few content creators making a good amount of money generating extremist content and google and advertisers making billions regardless of how much they threat democracy elsewhere. Yes, people are making lots of money with lies and half-truths. It is well known and I think that some liars know they are lying but don't care because they are making money. My girlfriend's father ate so much of these absurd things that nobody sane can talk to him anymore. Last year, after elections, he insisted that Lula was dead and that someone was impersonating him. At the new years eve, instead of spending time with his family, he was watching one of these youtube channels expecting to see a coup in brazil. He is still saying to everyone that our money in banks will be seized by the government. Summarizing: recommendation algorithms and targeted advertisement are destroying families and people.
- harrisoned 3y agoPeople click on what they want. Those are symptoms of underlying issues from someone who shouldn't be using such services in the first place. Protecting people from their own mental and moral malleability and ignorance is futile, as there will always be an issue to be resolved. The focus should be on education, and (for parents) control on what they should be accessing.
- marcodiego 3y ago> Protecting people from their own mental and moral malleability and ignorance is futile Drugs are regulated for the very same reason. While prohibition may be a polemic topic, regulation is not.
- harrisoned 3y agoThe example is good, and look where we are. Regulation brings immediate partial results to a problem, but doesn't solve it. I agree that the problem should be resolved, but those methods are only put in place to please shareholders and the law. The hard path, of education and compromises (and possible lower revenue) no one wants to take. Those services exploit "mental and moral malleability", and for that there will never be enough regulation to solve unless you take down all services.
- fugalfervor 3y ago"We made an addictive product. Fuck you for being addicted to it."
- ticviking 3y ago> The focus should be on education, and (for parents) control on what they should be accessing. I've worked in education, and spend a good deal of time working with folks who are in dire straits. The hard fact that a community where our 'median commenter' is above the median in the general population hates to realize is that roughly 1/3 or so of all people are just not remotely the type of person who can do the abstract meta-cognition to see they're being manipulated. No amount of education will actually make them see something to abstract for them to grok.
- Camisa 3y agoI made an effort not to click on anything political for a few months and there's absolutely no video in neither side except for the "breaking news" section that youtube adds, not even on youtube shorts. We tend not to notice when things are right, but god damn how much I love youtube recomendation algorithm. I really hope it never corrupts itself. The "Do not recommend" works, and not just for the specific channel, but the overall category and related content, it's amazing.
- jackthetab 3y agoHuh?! I despise their recommendation algo. So much so I've stopped clicking on even mildly-interesting-looking vids on my YT (Premium) home page. I watched one, ONE, video about James Randi; the next day half the recommendations were clips about him, most from...I need a name for those channel operators who re-post other peoples vids just for impressions. "Scumbags"? "A-holes"? But I digress. I click on one British historian and see 10 videos from other British historians the next day. I click on a gay comedian's video, and see 10 other gay comedian videos. Wait a day and I'll see gay British historians' videos! WTF? I used to spend several minutes during each session selecting "Not interested" and "Do not recommend" to tweak the algo and I don't see any proof that it works. I just ignore the home page these days. Much like I do Twitter and Reddit...
- snailmailman 3y agoComplete opposite experience from me. I don’t seek out political content on YouTube. I mostly watch some gaming content. Much of it (GDQ streams for instance), is pro-LGBT and left leaning. Despite this YouTube constantly pumps far-right content into my recommendations, and there’s seemingly no way for me to stop this. Straight up offensive content, including YouTube shorts ranting about Trans people, misgendering them. Misogynistic shorts with comedians joking how “women belong in the kitchen haha”. Interviews with Andrew Tate. Not to mention the constant ads from religious nuts. Or the constant political ads. Their recommendations suck. I skip these shorts partway though, and I avoid clicking the suggestions elsewhere, but it’s an endless stream. YouTube constantly is trying to get me to watch this awful content. I’ve stopped using shorts, and basically exclusively check my subscription box. The home page and suggestions are useless for me. I put up with YouTube as a site, but I’d honestly prefer to watch the same content elsewhere if I could. Those recommendations are making the world a worse place.
- no1groyp 3y ago[flagged]
- monero-xmr 3y agoThere are networks of groups trying to saturate the mainstream news with pro-Their Issues content. That's what activist networks are - they get donations, members, PR firms, etc. and seek to influence politicians and the population with their viewpoints. Is this shocking? It's how democratic politics works - coalitions, influence, impact.
- jerf 3y agoYeah, literally everyone is doing it. I know HN doesn't love the "What aboutism" arguments, but everyone is doing it, so I tend to look askance at articles clutching their pearls about how some particular group is doing it, because I positively guarantee you "their" side is doing it too.... because everyone is doing it. Me, I'd like "everyone" to stop, but that's not really on the table. All a legal ban would be is a privileging of the party in power at the moment, as they would be the enforcers and they would not enforce it against themselves.
- no1groyp 3y agoIllegal in many countries such as France
- jerf 3y agoDo you have an example of someone being stopped from doing this sort of thing with the leadership's propaganda? Because I'd lay quite a lot of money down at good odds for you that they absolutely have a line item somewhere on some budget for paying people to flood the internet with their message, no matter how illegal it is. Being illegal just means they have to hide the line item better.
- no1groyp 3y ago
- BLKNSLVR 3y ago"a complex, web-like influencer system of channels that shaped political narratives" So, political advertising in a very slightly more modern form. Both parties I get to choose between every few years have their political advertising machines that could be described as above. All of it sucks and there should be laws against it, but the people who make the laws are the ones doing it. Spend money, reach voters. Just another variation.
- hammock 3y agoIt's not clear that money was involved here, or how much. Rather than jumping to paid advertising, this might be a "more modern form" of political free speech and advocacy
- ticviking 3y agoHow would we tell the difference?
- localplume 3y ago[dead]
- nradov 3y agoYou have the option of voting for a third party candidate. They won't win in this next election, but it helps to build momentum for future elections.
- mrguyorama 3y ago>but it helps to build momentum for future elections American third parties have not shown any evidence of this. Meanwhile we have strong evidence of the spoiler effect they have. We can only play the game we currently have
- smt88 3y agoThe "game we currently have" does have a way to support far-left or far-right candidates: you can vote for them in the primary. You can support them and vote for them every minute until the general election, and then you just need to pick one of the top two candidates.
- carlosjobim 3y agoHow can it be surprising that a presidential candidate is campaigning during the election? I read the article and it strikes me as completely absurd. Of course a candidate is going to use his network of supporters to try to influence voters in every channel available, including YouTube. The writers try to present this as something strange, and I can't really understand why? Brasil is a democracy. Candidates will use all legal means to try to influence people to vote for them - that is what they are supposed to do.
- hammock 3y agoAccording to the article, “98 percent of volunteers ranked public security, race, LGBT+ issues, and the economy as political themes,” and at the same time “98 percent of volunteers ranked…transportation, health, education, indigenous and feminist issues as adjacent to politics.” Is that plausible? Did they miswrite something?
- jibe 3y ago1,200 videos over almost two months is my going to saturate anything on YouTube. Isn’t this just marketing?
- motbus3 3y agoHonestly, you are giving too much credit for these guys. It was purely brute force