5 ms·
I don't think this is reasonable or even in users interest if they stop and think about it. I don't want social media platforms to be required by law to turn o
by s1artibartfast 3y ago
I don't think this is reasonable or even in users interest if they stop and think about it.
I don't want social media platforms to be required by law to turn over all of the data that they have collected on me to anyone who asks.
EDIT:
So in section 2.A.3, anything that could be publicly visible to third parties is now accessible to those thirds parties via API. Anything you privately shared with third parties is now accessible to them via API. Your public comments, likes, friends ect. Alternatively, your private messages can be exported via API if the recipient gives permission.
>2. A SOCIAL MEDIA PLATFORM MUST PROVIDE THE FOLLOWING INFORMATION TO
ITS CURRENT USERS OR THEIR AUTHORIZED REPRESENTATIVES THROUGH THE API
CONSISTENT WITH SUBDIVISION ONE OF THIS SECTION:
(A) THE USER'S PERSONAL DATA THAT THE SOCIAL MEDIA PLATFORM CONTROLS,
INCLUDING, WITHOUT LIMITATION:
...
(III) THIRD-PARTY DATA WHICH IS EITHER (A) GENERALLY AVAILABLE TO ALL
ACCOUNT HOLDERS, OR (B) MADE AVAILABLE TO THE USER BY THE ACTION OF THAT
THIRD PARTY, AND WHICH IS COLLECTED BY THE SOCIAL MEDIA COMPANY TO MAKE
CONTENT DECISIONS THAT DIRECTLY OR INDIRECTLY IMPACT A USER
It is hard to believe I am reading section 3.A correct, but this would also require the social media company to update their database at the request of the API user. pretty wild.
>3. A SOCIAL MEDIA PLATFORM MUST PROVIDE ACCESS THROUGH THE API NECES-
SARY TO ALLOW THIRD-PARTY APPLICATIONS ON BEHALF OF ANY CURRENT USER TO
WRITE, UPDATE OR TAKE ACTION ON:
(A) THE USER'S PERSONAL DATA THAT THE SOCIAL MEDIA PLATFORM CONTROLS,
INCLUDING, WITHOUT LIMITATION:
(I) DATA THAT IS GENERALLY AVAILABLE TO ALL ACCOUNT HOLDERS, INCLUDING
USER'S NAME, USERNAME OR HANDLE, PROFILE PHOTO, BIO, AND LOCATION;
(II) USER DATA AND DATA GENERATED BY A USER AND COLLECTED BY THE
SOCIAL MEDIA PLATFORM THAT FORMS THE BASIS FOR SOCIAL RECOMMENDATIONS,
INCLUDING USER FOLLOWS AND FOLLOWER DATA, AS WELL AS THE TOPICS USERS
MAY FOLLOW;
So in theory, anyone could make an API request to reddit and it would have to turn over all public information on the site, at no cost.
- danaris 3y agoThat...doesn't say what you are claiming it says. Clause 2 requires the API to allow access to a user's data by that user or someone they authorize. Sure, there's a reasonable concern about coerced authorization by third parties, but that's a separate problem, and not worse than what we have now. Clause 3 isn't quite as explicitly narrow, but it still specifies being able to access the listed data on behalf of a current user. Neither of these are saying "anyone can access all the data." They're saying "anyone can access their own data". > this would also require the social media company to update their database at the request of the API user. And this is pretty obviously required in order for the API to allow third party apps that are more than read-only. "Updating their database" is necessary to make posts, react to posts, or change your profile information.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoI think between the two sections, the API can access any information that the user could. This means all public information, their own private information, and the private information of others that has been shared with them. I think the two of us agree on what the law says, I just happened to think it's ridiculous. It would require every large social media company to actively support competitors that are cloning their website, require them to manage the database for those competitors, and do it at no cost. I coul make a Facebook 2.0 app that shows users everything that they could see in Facebook, but strips out the Facebook ads and puts in my own. Facebook would be required to manage the data of my users at no cost. My app could even submit advertising posts on behalf of my users to Facebook, which it would have to write
- danaris 3y ago> It would require every large social media company to actively support competitors that are cloning their website, require them to manage the database for those competitors, and do it at no cost. Well...yes. That seems like the point, to me. Having data siloed by massive megacorporations who abuse that data to generate ludicrous levels of quarterly profit does not benefit us as a society. I do not believe that any particular business model deserves a guarantee that it be allowed to continue in perpetuity. What this would do is force social media services to compete on features and user-friendliness, rather than just network effects, dopamine farming, and lock-in. It would lower the barriers to entry for competitors in the social media market, and lower the barriers to exit for social media users who want to move from one network to another.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoYes, that seems like the point to me too. I just happen to think it is unreasonable and rediculous. I agree that business dont have any garuentee to continue, or even without restriction. I dont think that compelled action is appropriate. I think there would be a better legal and moral basis for banning social media outright, than requing them to provide API service to competitiors.
- shortcake27 3y agoWhat do you mean? An API doesn’t automatically grant full access to your private data. It just provides an alternative way to access the data you have already chosen to make public.
- wuiheerfoj 3y agoIt doesn’t, but it makes it easier to mandate an API for ‘special government access’ when there’s already an API mandate in place
- aaomidi 3y agoThat’s called a court order, and already happens all the time.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoNot with an api
- s1artibartfast 3y agoThis API grants full access to read and write your own personal data, or export anyone else's public data. I care less about the use case where I request my own private data. I care more about the use case where someone else can request any public data I shared, or someone else can export any private data I shared with them only.
- danaris 3y agoThis API only grants access to data that the user connecting to it can already access by logging in via the website. You are misreading it.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoIsn't that exactly what I said?
- rektide 3y agoThere's a pretty basic feeling I have that if as a user you can browse & get data from a site, you should be the ability to get that same data in more direct useful & unencumbered form. The thing is, anyone doing shady things probably already has complex ways of scraping & extracting data they want anyways. The only people this walled gardening hurts are good everyday users, are citizens. Worrying about "oh no what if we could easily get public data" feels like a way too conservative reaction that's not in touch with where we are already.