10 ms·
San Francisco library turning off WiFi at night to keep homeless from using it
- Ebree 3y agoMy air being free of electronetic toxins when I sleep between 22:00 and 6:00 is my basic human right. Intense sounds, WiFi, unnatural lights, phone signals, even freaking radio waves (I forgive moon, it must have some natural function we are adapted too). it's not natural so it's not humane. My personal space is sacred and my neighbour has no right invading it in any shape or form. I don't care if he lives 100m from me or 30cm away behind wall in the same building. it's all the same. Also the ground under and air above from center of earth all the way up to end of atmosphere is my space, everything founded in that soil as well. If it's mine it's mine. If I decide with milion other people to concentrate in one big spot our sky will be free from artificial crap obscuring free natural sky view. Your globalist collectivist agenda is completely irrelevant to me. And if you cross our sky we have full right to get your crap out of our sight in self defense by any means we decide to use. Clear borders and agreed rights keep everyone more happy and more free. If people want to kill themselves slowly, poison themselves, test any new fake things on themselves let them. But keep them away from those who want to live the whole naturally designed length of time that we were given being born on this planet from nature. And if you shorten my life I get right to shorten yours, what's only fair but creates a never ending cycle on enmity and incompatibility. Also city is not natural human growth environment.. but that's another topic.
- damnesian 3y ago>Neighbors of the library collaborated with the city to urge the library to turn off its Wi-Fi at night in hopes the Castro neighborhood’s unhoused population would move on. Theoretically, wifi access could help people move on by giving them the network access even old tech could use to look for jobs, living situations, long-lost relatives, access e-counseling and telehealth visits, etc. It's not the only thing the haves have taken from the have-nots to get them to move on. Bottle and can deposits used to be a much bigger deal in the US. It served its purpose of retrieving bottling materials for reuse to save costs and removing them from the landscape. But some noticed it gave the homeless a little spending cash too. The people in my otherwise fairly liberal city voted in the 90s to remove the local deposits from cans and bottles in order to force the homeless to move on. Fast forward to 2023. The homeless did not move on. They stayed and are begging more intensely. Many "prominent" homeless (a guy I know just as the Cowboy for his begging flair, for instance) are still here 30 years later.
- reaperducer 3y agoin hopes the Castro neighborhood’s unhoused population would move on. We really need to implement solutions better than "go be homeless somewhere else."
- joenot443 3y agoIn NYC the DHS intakes and beds 60,000 homeless people _every single night_. To say that there aren't solutions in place is incorrect. At least in NYC, the folks you see sleeping on sidewalks have broadly chosen that position over a bed in a shelter. It's a point of pride for many New Yorkers that if you're homeless and willing to get clean, the city will provide a bed for you every night. https://www.nyc.gov/assets/dhs/downloads/pdf/dashboard/FYTD23-DHS-Data-Dashboard-Charts.pdf https://www.nyc.gov/assets/dhs/downloads/pdf/dashboard/FYTD2...
- criddell 3y agoAre there similar services for people who won't or can't get clean?
- droopyEyelids 3y agoThere are very few shelters that take people who are actively using drugs. That's partially because drug use among the homeless is a proxy for antisocial behavior. It's definitely not a perfect metric, but it's the best that people providing care have to keep their operations running.
- reaperducer 3y agoAre there similar services for people who won't or can't get clean? I have a vague memory that there was a court decision stating that someone cannot be forcibly made un-homeless unless they're a danger to themselves or others. I'm sure there are some IANALs here who can clarify my murky memory.
- hgsgm 3y agoBureau of Prisons
- nocsi 3y agoKinda goes against the ALA Library Bill of Rights to deny the homeless access to information. Rather than blocking access, they should've just throttled it and enforced a captive portal every 15 minutes after hours.
- nomel 3y agohttps://www.ala.org/advocacy/intfreedom/librarybill https://www.ala.org/advocacy/intfreedom/librarybill Which item specifically? Having "open hours" seems reasonable.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- hellotomyrars 3y agoSo they should make it really annoying so they can pretend they’re maintaining open access but still try take something away from a group of people who already have next to nothing? Go be homeless somewhere else is not a practical solution and never has been.
- criddell 3y agoI would guess it isn't the librarians asking for the wifi to be turned off at night.
- throw9away6 3y agoGood now run sprinklers all night to keep the ground wet to prevent fires
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- warent 3y agoThis is such a lazy approach to social issues. Being poor and homeless is so hard. The system is built with countless chicken-egg problems that make it almost impossible to climb out of poverty. On top of this, elitists who are so disconnected are arbitrarily enforcing this kind of amoral depraved nonsense. Should we just keep stripping the needy of more and more resources until eventually maybe they'll just disappear or die because fuck them for existing and inconveniencing us? Good grief.
- sporkland 3y agopeople are shooting up and shitting in front of schools, houses libraries leaving their empty needles and feces for the rest of us. Good grief, it's way beyond inconvenience. It's deeply damaging the safety and quality of life for a large number of poor and rich people to keep allowing people to freely chase their addictions without constraint (and I have a lot of empathy for the pain those people are carrying that is pushing them towards drugs). I have no idea if you actually live here or are just another out of touch out of towner looking down our noses at us. I do believe that the homeless are getting an unfair share of a blame for the actual crime happening in San Francisco, but they are deeply contributing to the overall levels of lack of safety and the knock on effects of shootings related to turf wars related to supplying them with illegal drugs.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- aeternum 3y agoThe city is just so inept. It is such a nonsensical policy to allow encampments but lock the bathrooms and turn off the internet. The city policies force them to defecate in the street/bushes and god forbid they use the internet to search for potential employment or other services.
- warent 3y agoMeanwhile people say "But the homeless people will just use public wifi for porn!" Like... okay, and what are you using your wifi for? Regardless, removing this would just make them more stressed and irratic. There are worse things than legal porn on public wifi. If this tradeoff means 1% of them feel relaxed enough to actually do a job search afterward, and get motivated to get money for a more comfortable, more private place, then it's worth it. But this is all a red-herring and not the real issue. The lack of a panacea--a silver bullet solution to homelessness--does not mean all our resources are just a suboptimal waste. These incremental improvements are worthwhile when the cost tradeoff is so tiny (e.g. an internet modem with a properly configured firewall basically runs itself)
- skymast 3y agoWifi is a human right, isn't it? I mean, if they can't afford it, we should provide it to them at tax payer expense.
- bastard_op 3y agoCity of Santa Monica was having to do the same thing to keep homeless from piling up around the library for Internet access. The Library became the hub for all homeless in the region for the wifi alone. Seeing as they run a data center in the basement I had to access working there, it was always an adventure to visit.
- hbcondo714 3y agoI had a similar experience not too far away in Marina Del Rey. I would work remotely out of their small public library but there were so many homeless people to the point all the tables were occupied. They mostly used the electric outlets and DVDs so I ended up going to a paid co-working space and being around like-minded individuals with plenty of space.
- notaustinpowers 3y agoEvery day I start to believe more and more that people won't stop with homelessness until every homeless person is dead. "Emergency housing is a drain on taxpayer dollars." "Job placement is taking jobs away from locals." "Soup kitchens are another drain on taxpayer money." "Homeless services are a waste of money." It makes me sick how people can act when it comes to the homeless population when so many of us are just 1 bad month away from being homeless ourselves.
- derefr 3y agoThe problem is that unlike people with homes (who are generally stuck in one place — wherever their home is), homeless people have nothing holding them to places inhospitable to their presence. So the homeless diffuse around countries, drifting from place to place, until they settle in an "attractor" city — a local optimum for homeless hospitable-ness (with more social-welfare programs for them; less police suppression of homelessness; milder climate; more walkability; etc.) These attractor cities then experience undue burden of having to fight basically an entire country's homeless problem using only municipal (rather than state or federal) tax dollars; where every social welfare program they add, creates "induced demand" by making them into more of an attractor city for surrounding homeless populations. The homed people living in these attractor cities, experience a reality where they can choose to vote in progressive parties that throw however-much money at the problem of homelessness — adding public housing, shelters, food programs, jobs programs, etc. — with the only result being ever more homeless people showing up in the city. Which causes these homed people in these attractor cities to get burned out on the idea of solving homelessness. (An aphorism: "the river sees more water than the lakebed.") AFAICT, the only way out of the problem, is to 1. set aside federal funding for solving homelessness (which could be done easily enough in the US if anyone without a permanent residence in a particular state, were interpreted by federal law as not being "of" any state, but still a US national, and therefore a person the federal government has a duty to take care of directly — basically the same as how the federal government does insurance, postal delivery, etc. for actively-serving members of the military); and then 2. use that funding to start offering social-welfare programs for homeless people in places that don't already have large homeless populations, with the aim of creating more, smaller attractors, dispersing the homeless population, so that it's not all having to be dealt with by just the one or two natural attractor cities per country. Yes, both of these things are big political lifts. I see it as something like the federal highway system, or for that matter, like military bases: cases where it's in all our best interests to relinquish local NIMBYesque control, in favor of top-down eminent-domain use of land for serving the needs of the country as a whole.
- whatshisface 3y agoIf your forum's moderation is a fraction of a percent more tolerant towards a group of people who generally aren't tolerated, you will end up with the entire group on your forum, oftentimes in numbers exceeding those of your original community. If you want a couple examples from the recent past, do you remember how a lot of communities made rules against posting stuff about My Little Pony (at one point, 4chan, a site that will normally allow anything, had to create a site-wide rule about it), or the way some subreddits became alt-right hubs over the course of a few weeks after someone found out the moderators would let them post stuff about it? The effect of this is to force everyone into a posture of equal hostility, even if they do not themselves care one way or the other. This is exacerbated by the fact that any amenities designed to service the homeless (like a wi-fi tower out in a field where an encampment wouldn't bother anyone) would amount to officially recognizing the existence of the buildings erected there. I do not think the city could handle the contradiction of forcing one type of resident to go through an elaborate permitting process to build a shed, but allowing another resident to erect a temporary home in an officially recognized location. They are stuck turning a blind eye to it. If you combine the two effects, you end up with the case they have now, where small-scale amenities will be overwhelmed, while large-scale amenities or directly intentioned actions are impossible because they would violate the fiction that none of this is happening. I know it sound hard to believe - that within the eyes of the system there are no homeless encampments: but just to offer one piece of evidence in support of it, I am not aware of any fire inspections going on in the tent villages.
- stuckkeys 3y ago"No porn for you" Probably some dumbass in the department that came up with this agenda. Okay, what is that going to solve? Maybe, just maybe come up with a plan to help these folks instead of kicking them down even further. I love it when politicians flex with "We are the greatest country on earth" STFU. You are not. Take care of your people.
- Tozen 3y agoBragging about how great they are, while walking over and shooing away all the unemployed, hungry, desperate, and destitute around them. > Take care of your people... Don't view or consider them as their people, and in some cases, don't even think of them as people at all.
- km3r 3y agoWhat else do you recommend a library do (within their limited budget), while also solving the issue that these encampments are making the library unsafe and dirty?
- stuckkeys 3y agois not the library that is calling these shots.
- Tozen 3y agoSo, instead of finding ways to help the less fortunate and reduce homelessness, it was seen as better to find ways to get the problem to go elsewhere. As if turning off the WiFi means the homelessness problem will just disappear too.
- 8f2ab37a-ed6c 3y agoSan Francisco's population of 800k never signed up to single-handedly bankroll the US's homeless population in one of the world's highest CoL cities.
- Tozen 3y agoBut that's not what's going in this case. Turning on existing WiFi at a specific location or providing more free WiFi throughout the city, is not bankrolling all of the US's homeless. And regardless, San Francisco's homeless problem won't go away by ignoring it or pretending to. Makes more sense for the city and area to deal with it, by coming up with more effective and humane solutions. To not do so, creates a worldwide bad look and increases the embarrassment. Various people (or groups) are already making fun of the US by constantly reporting on and shooting videos of its huge numbers of homeless, to push back on the bragging, bravado, and hypocrisy.
- 8f2ab37a-ed6c 3y agoThe WiFi debacle is a symptom of the underlying problem of the US dumping its homeless population into an astronomically high CoL, 7x7 mile waterlocked city where regular folk with regular jobs already cannot afford to live, and expecting miracles. And miracles aren't happening despite the $700M/year budget for it obtained from the local polity. I'm not sure where you see "ignoring". SF is incapable of digging itself out of that hole. Clearly it's not a problem of insufficient spend, and the local politics will not allow for the necessary level of action, so this will continue in perpetuity until there is outside intervention. "We need to humane harder" is clearly not working. It feels good in the short term, but 10 years later things only get worse and we're scratching our heads wondering why nothing is improving.
- kazinator 3y agoThere should be free Wi-Fi everywhere in the city, so people don't have to concentrate around a library.
- scoofy 3y agoThere essentially is: https://sfgov.org/sfc/sanfranciscowifi https://sfgov.org/sfc/sanfranciscowifi
- renewiltord 3y agoThe funny thing is that Chris Sacca was going to get SF city-wide WiFi, but the supervisors stopped him because they're razor focused on what matters for them: their career. It makes sense that local residents would do this. Internet Access is to us humans like light to a moth. But we could have been moths that were forever lit.
- bombcar 3y agoThat's the real solution to something like this - blanket the whole city so there's no reason to congregate near the library. Or explicitly put up free wi-fi where you want the homeless to congregate.
- nubb 3y agoeveryone acting so shocked here probably hasn’t had your home robbed, your car windows broken, or been assaulted and/or robbed by a drugged out bum. at some point enough is enough and they gotta go. i think it’s a juvenile attitude to look down your nose at the endless victims and tell them to just be more understanding of the hardships the homeless face.
- 2023throwawayy 3y agoSo what is your proposed solution? All I hear is "they gotta go". Go where? On who's dime?
- 8f2ab37a-ed6c 3y agoTo be fair there's gotta be a more cost-effective place to house the unhoused than the Castro, West Village or Beverly Hills. I'm sure we can find cheaper stretches of land somewhere in the US.
- 2023throwawayy 3y agoTo be fair... "Go somewhere that rich people aren't" isn't much of a solution.
- michaelt 3y agoIf the average home in San Francisco sells for $1.2 million, and the average home in Willard, New Mexico sells for $120,000 is it really so dreadful to help ten times as many homeless people?
- FireBeyond 3y agoTell us all about Willard's booming economy and the wide swathes of open jobs available to new residents there... ... in a town of 250 people, where nearly a third of the population lives below the poverty line. The ONLY people that benefits is the residents of SF or wherever, that successfully managed to "make it someone else's problem".
- Sparkyte 3y agoThe problem is that we decriminalized drug use. We have a heavily funded homeless system now and it works great but there is one little itsy bitsy problem... drug users and mental health folk. Rather than change the criminalization model, decriminalized drugs makes it more accessible than ever. Makes it so much harder to treat. What should happen is that we change our criminalization model to come health and safety first. Treat the crime almost as a juvenile offense, keep it as a different record non-impactful. The lack of broadening our criminalization system is the problem. For those with mental health you obviously can not criminalize this. You would want to move toward a home where people live and manage together. Standard and normal homeless would then get exactly what is needed. Treating every problem as if it was the same is how we wound up with so many people on the streets. Every problem needs a human solution and not a one fits all category.
- warent 3y agoFor those with mental health you obviously can not decriminalize this The exact opposite is true. It must be decriminalized for those with mental health issues. Criminalization of drug use was never about crime or drugs. It is to install a pipeline for people in poverty to be directed into a for-profit prison system in which they are used as legal slave labor under the 13th amendment. Drug use is not ever a criminal issue. It is a health issue full stop.
- km3r 3y agoIt is a health issue. But it clearly puts you in a state of mind where many people are unwilling to get help. Criminalizing drug trade (and to a far lesser extent, use), allows the government to get people the help they need. Yes we need more medical and addiction care focused prisons, but for now, the streets aren't working.
- Sparkyte 3y agoI completely agree.
- Sparkyte 3y ago
- broupannoiffuto 3y ago[flagged]
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 3y agoWhile your comment is a bit inflammatory I think it's important to point out that while "leftist" intentions are usually charitable, reality is harsh.
- piloto_ciego 3y agoI think most of the people spouting this kind of stuff have zero concept of reality. They’ve never had to worry about where they would get their next meal or any sort of real existential crisis in their lives. “There but for the grace of god go I” or something.
- 8f2ab37a-ed6c 3y agoClosely related to this post from two weeks ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36162154 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36162154
- cuttysnark 3y agoI'm honestly surprised the public library is the only place to get free 24/7 wifi in San Francisco. Bizarre.
- scoofy 3y agoIt's not: https://sfgov.org/sfc/sanfranciscowifi https://sfgov.org/sfc/sanfranciscowifi
- scoofy 3y agoSo, I live in SF, work in these libraries, and my gf lives in that immediate area, and I can be found at that library pretty frequently typing away on sublime text. As is typical with SF stories about homelessness. This article either seems misinformed about the facts on the ground, or can't seem to wrap its head around the fact that SF goes above and beyond to support the folks living on the streets here. --- Issue 1: Redundancy. The article seems to completely ignore the SFWiFi program that exists along Market St, and in nearly all public parks: https://sfgov.org/sfc/sites/default/files/San%20Francisco%20WiFi/sf-wifi-faq-1oct14.pdf https://sfgov.org/sfc/sites/default/files/San%20Francisco%20... Here, using the Eureka Valley (Castro) library wifi is fairly redundant, as the library is 250 feet from Market street. Most of the folks I see on the street in the immediate area (north side of 16th) should be able to access #SFWiFi where they are. --- Issue 2: Location. The area directly adjacent to the library in question is very tight, and very, very residential. Pond St and Prosper St which flank the library can best be described as residential allies. They are tiny, quite streets, with narrow sidewalks. It would be pretty unreasonable that folks staying up using the wifi on these streets wouldn't be a non-negligible disturbance to the residents there. https://goo.gl/maps/UYsq79P5WXfhCJ8m8 https://goo.gl/maps/UYsq79P5WXfhCJ8m8 The area where I do see people regularly congregate at night are on the north side of the street directly west of Dinosaur Sandwiches. I know this because I live by the panhandle, and this my preferred walk back on nights I'm out to late in the mission. The encampments in this location can range from small to making-the-sidewalk-impassible, but generally speaking, I could see how the noise could be an issue for the people on Pond St. --- Issue 3: Crime. This quote from the story piqued my interest: >Legislative aide Jackie Thornhill told The Verge in an email that “obviously the presence or lack of all night wifi isn’t going to make a huge difference on its own,” but she believes it’s one of many reasons the library is so attractive to criminal activity. Thornhill also sent a spreadsheet of 911 calls that she says shows crime has been down for the last nine months. I have personally witnessed multiple actual drug deals go down inside this library. I brought it up with the staff there, and they basically shrugged with a "it sucks, but what are you going to do?" It's the only library that I've witnessed actually crimes happening while I worked. Which is saying something, as I am a bit of a SF library fan, as I work for myself doing computery things. Even the civic center library, with all it's eccentricity seems to not be dealing with the issues that the eureka valley library is. (Aside: the best library in town is the UCSF Parnassus library, however it has been closed to the public since the start of covid) --- In all, this article seems to be a classic case of well meaning, but probably mostly uninformed blog-as-journalism writers putting together a story weighted to find outrage where it may or may not actually exist. Do I think turning the WiFi off is a good thing? Probably not. Do I understand why local residents are calling for it? Sure. If I actually knew if late night noise, (with a generous) etc, have become a problem, I'd probably support them. Do I think turning the WiFi off is some sort of huge problem for folks living on the street? No. There is easy access to public WiFi within a block of there. So much so that I've turned off auto-join #SFWiFi from my phone because it can have a weak signal an interrupt my browsing-on-foot all over the city.
- Simulacra 3y agoNIMBYISM..In San Francisco?! Say it ain't so... /s
- sharts 3y agoSo then provide city-wide free wifi. Honestly, the cruelty and barbarism of latte liberals is unmatched. No bathrooms, no wifi, no housing, no policing, no medicine. Pull yourselves up from your own bootstraps like the rest of the self-made billionaires. And do it out of our sights.