5 ms·
US moves to block Microsoft's Activision takeover
- LatteLazy 3y agoIf the UK already blocked the deal, why does the US need to? I guess it is likely better for the companies involved to know they don't just need to appease the UK but also others, but it seems like a non-story...
- jacooper 3y agoThey are independent nations with independent ruling bodies, the UK banning the merger doesn't mean the J.S. shouldn't do anything.
- LatteLazy 3y agoI am just asking what the point is? Why bother with all the paperwork banning a merger that is not going to happen? The US (or UK or anyone else) has every RIGHT to book on it. But why spend time and energy exercising that right if it makes no difference and another country already vetoed it?
- schnitzelstoat 3y agoThey could proceed but cease operations in the UK, I'm not sure exactly what that would look like. I guess using a local distributor like they did with NetEase in China? It would be pretty crazy, but it's not impossible. They aren't going to pull out of the USA though.
- frumper 3y agoSome other outlets reported that Microsoft and Activision were talking about completing the deal despite the UK regulator. The EU already gave it approval to happen, and the US hadn't specifically blocked it. https://www.nytimes.com/2023/06/12/technology/ftc-sue-microsoft-activision-deal.html https://www.nytimes.com/2023/06/12/technology/ftc-sue-micros...
- LatteLazy 3y agoThat's fine if both companies (or the one resulting company) never wants to do business in the UK again...
- frumper 3y agoOr they think the UK citizens won't throw the regulators and their bosses out of a job. I doubt many citizens in the UK feel strongly enough about the merger to want access to neither if they merge. People don't particularly like when you take their toys away.
- worrycue 3y agoIf all that ends up being blocked are consoles and games, there are plenty of substitutes - in some cases near perfect substitutes.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> fine if both companies (or the one resulting company) never wants to do business in the UK again There are loads of solutions to this problem, the most obvious one being pulling Activision titles out of the U.K. or spinning off independent distribution rights to that market.
- topkai22 3y agoThe UK blocking the merger doesn’t necessarily stop it. It could be overturned on appeal or the deal could be modified to suit the UK’s concerns. It’s also theoretically possible that the deal goes through despite the CMA not approving it. I’m not a lawyer and I don’t know if that looks like Microsoft no longer selling games and gaming in the UK (possible) or no longer doing business in the UK entirely (not likely). Besides, the US filed suit back in 2022.
- 908B64B197 3y ago> or the deal could be modified to suit the UK’s concerns. The argument given by the UK's bureaucrats had something to do with cloud gaming. I guess they could make Activision's tittles available on competing cloud gaming platforms in the UK.
- LikesPwsh 3y agoIt saves MS from attempting to reverse the decision in British courts, so probably net saving of human time and effort all things considered.
- jacooper 3y agoNation* / U.S.
- anotherman554 3y ago>>If the UK already blocked the deal, why does the US need to? The UK could reverse their position. It makes no sense for the US to rely on a foreign countries ruling, as they have no control over whether it changes.
- IncandescentGas 3y agoBecause Microsoft may punish the UK’s ruling by ignoring it and halting game sales in the UK
- stuckinhell 3y agoI hope more monopolies get busted
- kyriakos 3y agoBit too late for that I believe. This one wasn't going to create a monopoly since Microsoft is not anywhere near being the largest provider in the gaming industry.
- wilg 3y agoMicrosoft isn't a gaming monopoly, and regulators aren't even claiming they are. Just that this deal would create some kind of "cloud gaming" antitrust problem which makes no sense because that isn't a distinct market from "gaming", and it isn't proven people even want cloud gaming, and also there are really no other people even trying cloud gaming.
- theknocker 3y ago[dead]
- jaybrendansmith 3y agoOk great. They are blocking this one because Microsoft, but its perfectly ok that all of broadcast media is owned by four companies, all of food is owned by four, and all of computing is owned by five. And we sit here and wonder why most of inflation is actually just profit-taking.
- jdmdmdmdmd 3y ago[dead]
- andsoitis 3y ago> all of broadcast media is owned by four companies In television, the vast majority of broadcast and basic cable networks, over a hundred in all, are controlled by seven corporations: Fox Corporation, The Walt Disney Company (which includes the ABC, ESPN, FX and Disney brands), National Amusements (which owns Paramount Global), Comcast (which owns NBCUniversal), Warner Bros. Discovery, E. W. Scripps Company, Cablevision (now known as Altice USA), or some combination thereof. Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Concentration_of_media_ownership#:~:text=In%20television%2C%20the%20vast%20majority,(which%20owns%20NBCUniversal)%2C%20Warner https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Concentration_of_media_ownersh... > all of food is owned by four According to Business Insider article from 2016, these 10 companies control almost every large food and beverage brand in the "world": https://www.businessinsider.com/10-companies-control-the-food-industry-2016-9 https://www.businessinsider.com/10-companies-control-the-foo... > and all of computing is owned by five I wonder whether "computing" and "owned" makes sense in the way you phrase your argument.
- jaybrendansmith 3y agoI sincerely appreciate the corrections, and I don't think it wrecks my argument to have the totals be seven, ten, and five. And owning should be construed as something more extreme than simply dominating in the latter case.
- andsoitis 3y agoNear 100% of my food come from producers not one of the 7. I live in Los Angeles, so that might be a good explanation. But then, how would you economically produce and distribute food to people in more rural locales, if not for some consolidation? The question of course is what is a reasonable number - is it 7? Or 20? There's no objective answer etched into a tablet somewhere. Instead, dynamic social forces produce an outcome.
- wilg 3y agoMy question is what happens if they were to merge under US law even though the UK blocked the acquisition? How can this really be a veto system? There must be some interesting funny business you could do with this.
- fyzix 3y agoWhy would the US jeopardize one of it's giants to appease a Japanese giant?
- animal_spirits 3y agoJeopardize? Are you saying it is more important for big corporations to become bigger at the expense of public?
- hnfong 3y agoLooking at the last 20 years of big tech development, I think my answer is “yes”. Or are you actually being sarcastic?
- animal_spirits 3y agoNo, I'm not being sarcastic - I'm genuinely curious at your viewpoint. I feel it is an inevitable outcome that once large organizations reach a size where they have the ability to wield their influence over large sections of our economy it becomes a survival mechanism to do so. I personally want less corporate influence over my life (my government in particular) and I oppose them getting large so that they have less power in this area. Do you think this is not the case?
- hnfong 3y agoI studied a bit of law in Uni in a non-US jurisdiction, and my personal observation seems to be that there’s a bias towards lenient law enforcement towards large corporations with well connected executives and board members. You can say this is a result of corruption, which i agree, but it also seems to work to the US’s favor when it comes to global competitiveness of the big companies. Large and powerful companies with unchecked power is bad for equality and fairness within the country, but those same companies are also given an “unfair” advantage when they compete with other countries’ companies. I suspect this contributes to US being able to maintain their global influence, and is partly why Big Tech are all in America. If they were founded anywhere else, they probably would not have the chance or ambition to expand since they would have been regulated long before they grow to current sizes. I definitely agree that this leads to the overwhelming corporate influence you mentioned, which is bad. Just pointing out another perspective from the national power front.
- TheCaptain4815 3y agoDon't want to comment on the legally or market forces bit on this, just want to comment as a gamer I'm elated. Microsoft has destroyed pretty much every franchise it touches, with Azure being able to subsidize huge losses for the garbage they've been producing. Halo infinite might literally be the biggest flop in entertainment history. 500 million dollars spent and within a FEW MONTHS you had the player count for a FREE multiplayer game in the 5 digits. These studios and game managers know their jobs are very secure, especially if they fall into Microsoft's ESG requirements, so game quality has taken a complete nosedive. Gone are the small, nerdy, and passionate studios building these games that existed even during the Xbox 360 era from Microsoft.
- SuperMario1758 3y agoAny other studio and I would agree with you, but as an old school Blizzard fan I was hoping Microsoft could right the ship. The Blizzard of today is not a studio that is small, nerdy, and passionate, so what's to lose?
- Akronymus 3y agoI wouldn't even call it Blizzard. It's simply activision to me.
- lockhouse 3y agoBe careful what you wish for. Who else is going to be able to compete with Sony? If Microsoft never makes another XBox generation, how good do you think the PS6 will be? Would they even bother making a PS7?
- tapoxi 3y agoNintendo? They're way out front in terms of hardware and game sales. Not to mention Microsoft makes Windows, and has significant control of PC gaming.
- ragequittah 3y agoSitting over here playing flight sim, aoe 4 (and 2 every now and then cuz that remaster was fantastic), Forza horizon, looking forward to starfall after the epic gameplay trailer, and wondering someone can have such a drastically different view. Not to mention all of these games are on gamepass, which saved me 100s of dollars.
- solardev 3y agoAs a gamer, I'm mostly sad about this. It's not like Activision was some beloved indie studio anyway, not for a long long long time. Having them snatched up by Microsoft would've been no real loss to the gaming community, but would've opened up synergies for Game Pass and cloud streaming and maybe even given the consolidated company a shot at competing with Sony and Nintendo in terms of ensuring viable platforms (not to mention Apple and Google, or Chinese giants like Tencent). Meanwhile, most actual games innovation happens at the indie level, not AAA, anyway. So it's not like there was going to be much of a cultural loss. I normally dislike Microsoft, but to their credit, they've been very loyal to their PC and Xbox gamers, and did a lot of work combining their markets (seamless controller support in Windows games, mouse keyboard support in some Xbox games, cross buy and cross play, streaming, etc.), despite having been a distant third place (or worse) for decades now. They didn't give up on it like they did the browser wars or Zune. Having a continued viability in Windows and Xbox gaming is a good thing for the community, even as (or perhaps especially while) Proton and Crossover/Apple Game Porting Toolkit and Steam Deck etc. are just getting off the ground. Those efforts are only possible because of the Windows APIs, which are similar enough to the Xbox ones that porting is viable. I doubt there would be a similar path from Playstation. It seemed like this acquisition would've been a win for gamers. And the market. And maybe Blizzard too, for all its recent culture woes. And I get why the regulators thought this way (two huge companies), but I doubt they really understand the nuances of the gaming ecosystem. Sigh. Maybe when Gen Z gets to run government.