7 ms·
Don’t lie to me, Argentina. Imagine a world without statistics
- llopatin 15y agoAnother fact not mentioned, is that Argentina's government pressured McDonalds to lie on the price of the Big Mac as to appear lower on the chart of the Economist's Big Mac Index (http://www.economist.com/node/21542808 http://www.economist.com/node/21542808). The Big Mac combo in Argentina is AR$21.50 (approx USD$4.90) and the next cheapest combo is around USD$8.50.
- wslh 15y agoIndeed the typical big mac (two hamburgers) doesn't appear in the big photos just in a little menu in small letters. There is then another big mac combo with three hamburgers with the real price but because is not "the real big mac" it is not part of The Economist index.
- pyman 15y agoA federal judge, following orders of president Cristina Kirchner, ordered MD to remove it from the menu. They are trying to hide the inflation rate while they spend all the money from the federal reserve. Once that money is gone, the economy collapses once more. Ah, and Cristina Kirchner doesn't care what we say here, she knows very well that the people who voted for her in this past elections (54%) don't know how to read (English, of course).
- pvarangot 15y agoAnother funny fact is that one of the USD 8.50 combos is the "Triple Mac", which is basically a Big Mac featuring yer another slice of meat on top of the lowest one. One can build his own "Triple Mac" for arround USD 7 by buying a Big Mac and another hamburger. Also FYI no official information about the government really regulating the Big Mac price is available... only rumors. Both the government and McDonalds deny theiy have engaged in talks regarding the Big Mac price, McDondalds alludes they are only segmenting the market to allure to cheapskates and the lower substrates of the market. I'm not defending the government here, only telling what I found out.
- wslh 15y agoWell nobody recorded the conversation... But what I just realized this week directly is that I can't find certain very important medications because the same minister (Moreno) stopped importation of foreign elements. So... if he stopped critical imports related to health I can only think that the big mac story is real. Also, Mc Donalds will be harmed if they recognize it, this is the reality.
- Fargren 15y agoThe common officialist argument, for whatever it's worth, is that publishing the real values would induce panic and further inflation. Basically, they claim that it would be irresponsible to disclose the real values.
- mc32 15y agoBut don't they realize that then this gets baked-in in people's expectations. I.e. when they say 5% people know to adjust accordingly and think, oh 10%, and so on. Short term this might work, but long-term (year or more) it becomes useless.
- tatsuke95 15y agoMuch of modern macroeconomics revolves around the theory of expectations. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rational_expectations http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rational_expectations So, one way to diminish the crippling effects of inflation is to lie and say there is none. Of course, as you say, in the long run you'll get hammered, as people's expectations fly out of whack and they are required to guestimate future rates of inflation.
- wisty 15y agoAccording to modern macroeconomics, people are omniscient, and will see past fake statistics. Also, recessions can't be predicted, because everyone is smart enough to prevent them.
- adrianscott 15y ago"People are omniscient" -- one of several false assumptions that lead to unrealistic results from the theories (and disaster/losses to banks/investors/govt's who base their actions on them)
- erichocean 15y agoHe was being sarcastic.
- rubyrescue 15y agoi just hired someone (developer) from INDEC. It turns out that they pay their people "en negro" - that means the official inflation group for the country doesn't pay their taxes - they hand cash to their employees and don't report it - or report a small amount and pay a lot more 'under the table'. Yet there are advertisements (paid by the government) all over the buses in Buenos Aires that say "Trabajo mejor cuando mi trabajo es en blanco" - I work better when my work is "in white" - in other words, when my employer pays the proper official taxes. The level of hypocrisy in this country is staggering.
- pvarangot 15y agoThis is a well spread practice in the federal government around here, since you've been in Argentina for many years by now I'm surprised you've just found out. The government is the biggest "en negro" employer of the country. It's also the biggest hirer of workers under precarious conditions such as fixed time contracts. Ironically, one of the biggest "en negro"-hiring branches of the federal government is the Labour Ministry. I suppose you're also not surprised by this, since you must already know the government to be the biggest everything in Argentina :P Hiring "en negro" or under precarious conditions is not only terrible because of tax evading, in this case they would only be cheating themselves. It mainly sucks to be employed that way because you loose (or its harder for you to enforce on your employer) most of the labor benefits you usually get when you are employed by someone here. In Argentina that means no social security, health plan, granted days of leave to study for exams, extra money on holidays, bonus 13th month salary, increasing days for vacations when employed for more than 5/10 years, etc... the list is in fact pretty extensive.
- pirer 15y agoIt is not only the government that promotes these practices, but also, small businesses and workers. The idea behind this is the fact that neither party sees benefits in working completely "white".
- vegardx 15y agoJust out of curiosity, are you afraid that what's happening in Greece right now also will happen in Argentina? With pay raise to avoid internal conflicts and benefits beyond this planet, I see an impending doom. Is it also possible that Argentina has been on it about Falkland Islands lately, because the government also see the impending economic doom and need something to blame it on / shift focus? Very much speculation from my part, as my knowledge of Argentina is about as much as a famous footballer, but it would be interesting to get your thoughts on it!
- narrator 15y agoOn a related note, Hong Kong produced no economic statistics on purpose for many years. >Cowperthwaite was similarly opposed to five-year development plans, noting that revenues to offset expenses were not predictable. The publication of official statistics was curtailed, for fear that it would encourage civil servants to meddle. http://www.economist.com/node/16591088 http://www.economist.com/node/16591088
- heelhook 15y agoI'll take no statistics over doctored statistics any time.
- squeed 15y agoCheck out the comments in that article. Am I the only one who stops listening when the Economist is accused of conspiracy? Sure, they have certain biases which are pretty easy to spot, but accusing them of being an American mouthpiece seems way off the mark.
- wslh 15y agoThe Argentinian government has an army of "social media soldiers". They are very easy to spot, if you read something completely irrational it's a "social media soldier" work or some kind of blind government fundamentalist.
- pessimizer 15y agoConspiracy theory vs. conspiracy theory?
- frankydp 15y agoThe instant red herring responses on any comment is pretty blatant. Not that I assume it is government but it does seem pretty systematic.
- saryant 15y agoThey should just limit comments to those who have paid subscriptions. Typically the Economist has a decent comments section when nutters like this batch don't show up. Sure, if it's part of a concerted effort by an organization they can just buy a few subscriptions but at least it'd keep the one-offs out.
- tatsuke95 15y agoIt's pretty much impossible to read any article about banking/economics/finance nowadays without people spewing nonsense about conspiracy. Pretty sad, when the understanding and information is so important to everyone in the world.
- ahi 15y agoAgreed, but it's not called the Washington Consensus for nothing.
- martincmartin 15y agoWhy the bias towards official figures? In other words, for other countries where unofficial figures are better than official ones, why not use those? Why do the official figures have to be so glaringly, grossly wrong before they report unofficial ones?
- wslh 15y agoAnswering in this context: because Argentina had a good statistics institute that was destroyed by three governments. So now you are paying people for lying in your face. And speaking generically not all countries have a private sector that can afford country wide statistics research.
- aortega 15y agoIt was not destroyed. Some clever guy realized that people automatically trust statistics and you can fake them. Locally, INDEC lost all credibility years ago. The Economist just realized it, next time they will realize the "big mac" index is also totally useless here. Meanwhile people are having 25% raises in dollars every year, meaning that temporally we have a lot of money, until all business go broke, that is.
- RobertKohr 15y agoI don't know, the big mac index does a fairly good job at being an independent measure of inflation (and by a company that isn't trying to manipulate the price to hide inflation). Big mac's goal is to measure currency exchange rates, which I think is a little wonky since county to country a big mac doesn't work out so well, and I wish the used it to focus more on inflation.
- arjunnarayan 15y agoOh that was reported on 3 months ago by the New York Times: http://latitude.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/11/24/argentinas-big-mac-attack/ http://latitude.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/11/24/argentinas-big-...
- GFischer 15y agoArgentina is also taking a lot of other extreme measures to combat inflation and flight of capital, like not printing money, leading to a shortage of coins for example; and severe restrictions on exchanging pesos for dollars, hurting tourists and imports. Newspapers even report the paralell exchange rates! I suspect there will be an economic crisis in the next few years, and it will hurt us Uruguayans as usual, we're already feeling the pain of export restrictions and now they want to restrict services and software which will direcly affect several friends and colleagues.
- Jebus 15y agoSeriously? Not printing money? Inflation does not come from people's imagination.
- GFischer 15y agoSorry, I was thinking along the lines of loboman's argument, but I was probably wrong. What they're not doing is expanding the supply of coins and large denominations (500 peso bills for example). Edit: loboman's link says that they're not creating new coins and low denominations: "falta de numerario de baja denominación que se traduce no sólo en los problemas de cambio y devolución en las operaciones comerciales, sino también, en el deterioro de los papeles de baja denominación"
- Jebus 15y agoWould you mind explaining the downvote? I friggin live here and I KNOW they are printing more money than ever. Their modus operandi is basically this: - Take money from the middle class through unconstitutional high tax rates (that never come back in the form of infrastructure, education, security, etc), so they become poor. - Give money to the poor so they keep voting favorably - Give money to already rich friends and the Congress members, to have more power - Get crazy laws approved, so that middle class has no escape. Eg: We can no longer buy other currencies, not even gold, so we are forced to stick to the pesos. - Print print print! (more pesos) This way the money flows like this: people's savings and salaries -> government - Profit
- aortega 15y agoInflation and economic disaster is the norm in the latest 30 years of this country. I believe this government is saying "fuck this, we might as well try something new before everything crash". I believe they actually succeeded in delaying the inevitable crash. All the world economy is crashing anyway.
- roderik 15y agoWut? Argentina had 10 years of recesion, with actual deflation. Inflation is not the norm in the last 30 years.
- marianoguerra 15y agothat's because at that time the goverment tied the peso value to the dollar by law. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argentine_Currency_Board http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argentine_Currency_Board
- roderik 15y agoyes
- Jebus 15y agoCan't wait to leave this country. I'm sorry for the honest people who don't have an option. I'm going to Uruguay or Brazil. =)
- roderik 15y agoAnd why we should care about that? Please guys...
- roderik 15y agoSorry, I didnt mean to be harsh. I wanted to point that your comment is not actually relevant to the topic, and its distracting. Good luck!
- GFischer 15y agoBoth are probably better off than Argentina right now, but I would try for something more drastic if I was thinking of emigrating (personally, I'd try Canada, Australia/New Zealand, or the United Arab Emirates for work reasons). Besides, you'll get some of the disadvantages of the Argentinean government here in Uruguay as well.. they'll just be milder.
- tokenadult 15y agoSeeing this thread brought to mind the brief article "Don’t Cry For Argentina" by Paul Krugman last year, http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/06/23/dont-cry-for-argentina/ http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/06/23/dont-cry-for-arg... and I'd be very curious to find out what HN participants who are familiar with Argentina (I am not) think are appropriate lessons to take for other countries from the economic experience of Argentina.
- aortega 15y agoI have this advice: Argentina is the "hurt me plenty" or "nightmare" doom level but for business. Entrepeneurs from all the world come here to train. If they survive, they are ready for everything.
- wslh 15y agoObviously this is just one opinion from an Argentinian but I think there are only two lessons. The other economic analysis (GDP growth) are explained because the country came from a really strong recession (subzero situation), and the commodities rocketed sky-high while the agricultural sector improved a lot in terms of efficiency. The rest of things remains the same: an hyper-corrupt country, without justice (except when the government pushes for specific cases), with a lot of poor people and people living of social assistance handled by government lords in change of favors (votes). Lessons for other countries: - You can renegotiate your foreign obligations (what is happening in Greece). The default is not the end of the game. - Stay away from IMF bureaucrats
- colonel_panic 15y agoWhy now? It doesn't escape my notice that an influential British magazine is majorly dissing the Argentine government just as Britain and Argentina are getting into another tiff over the Falklands and a bunch of oil is found there.
- wslh 15y agoWhat matters is the truth here beyond who says it.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- toyg 15y agoIt would be nice if the Economist also recognised a lot of other official statistics from all over the world are routinely faked or "massaged", especially when it comes to inflation and unemployment levels. Some European countries experienced very high inflation rates almost overnight when the common currency was introduced, up to 100% in some areas, but 15 years later official figures are only just starting to recognise that. The definition of unemployment in most countries is basically "tweaked" every time a general election is looming. Hell, even rating agencies have lost faith in most official sources, and are now pulling ratings out of their (probably gold-plated) ass most of the time. The Argentinian government is just guilty of being a bad liar in a sea of very slick liars.
- ahi 15y agoThe Economist has its own biases. Argentina gets picked on because they aren't on the same team.
- pyman 15y agoMenem, the former president, was jailed for selling arms to Croatia. After that his wife left him for not investigating the death of his son, who was killed by the drug cartel. He built a clandestine airport in Anillaco (his home town) which he used to smuggle arms and drugs. Menem, today, is a National Senator, the airport is still open and the government dropped all charges against him, including: corruption, illegal enrichment and arms smuggling. People are willing to tolerate this, that's why the country is doomed.
- roderik 15y agoWell, they are blind trusting the privates right? The comments here have not many data supporting the arguments. "I live here" is not good enough, ever heard about antropological fallacy?
- wslh 15y agoWhat do you mean? Please explain.
- roderik 15y agoThere is no "citation needed" meme. There is two metrics (or many, one from the .gov and the others from private analysts) and everybody repeats that one is wrong without explaining why. I have no interest in defending the .ar goverment, but this article is not really good. They should say something like "this another metric or method should be used, these are the correct parameters, because of a, b, and c. The ones used by the Argentinian gov are wrong because of d, e, and f". Also remember that the index is not an absolute number, it is relative to certain parameters. Saying that "15%" is low or high just like that is absurd, its like saying that a distance of "10" is too large without referring to a scale. OTOH, the argument usually exposed is also wrong, it reads like: "The people buying every day in the local store knows that inflation is higher." Thats a fallacy, the only thing I can know from going to the store is the price from that store. An index cant be used for predictions directly. I would like to repeat that I have no sympathy with .gov.ar, I think they do many things wrong. Sadly, those things are not the ones pointed by the media. I am interested in changing the status quo but, imho, the only democratic, honest way to do it is using rationality as a tool for making our best possible decisions.
- Jebus 15y agoYou are asking to see meticulous proofs in a simple blog post, which is not gonna happen. Also, any article like this will assume that you already know something about what's going on there, or at least in the rest of the world. Eg: If someone says 20-30% inflation rate is high, it's obviously comparing it to the inflation in other countries. So yes, it's damn high. About the metrics, its pretty simple: they just pick the products/services that didn't increase much their price during that period. Of course nobody can't actually live with those products, nobody buys them or even know them. And when they need something real for the index, like the Big Mac.. Well, you know what happens. Automagically its price is reduced to a half, and the product is removed from the menu.
- uvdiv 15y agoThe most disgusting part is where the Argentine government censors private analysis/journalism of economic statistics: "In an extraordinary abuse of power by a democratic government, independent economists have been forced to stop publishing their own estimates of inflation by fines and threats of prosecution." To be fair, even the European Commission drafted something similar in the height of the financial crisis, when they considered "regulating" credit ratings agencies (e.g. telling them what ratings they could and could not issue on sovereign debt). http://www.economist.com/node/21538142 http://www.economist.com/node/21538142
- Confusion 15y agoThere's quite a difference between proposing something and retracting it or having it shot down in a general vote vs. actually getting it ratified and enforced.