2 ms·
"If the SEC was in the business of making merit-based judgments on companies before they IPOed, they would need to somehow have expertise in everything from ind
by Dylan16807 3y ago
"If the SEC was in the business of making merit-based judgments on companies before they IPOed, they would need to somehow have expertise in everything from industrial filtration to financial management to projection technology to biotech to the manufacture of skincare products, bandages, and mouthwash. It’s simply not feasible, much less desirable."
Yeah that part doesn't make sense. A "merit-based judgement" that requires that kind of expertise is obviously not what is being asked for! The request is for them to look at [sufficiently big] securities [or possibly-securities], in the exact same way they would look at them post-IPO, using their normal realm of expertise.
- growse 3y agoIt's perfectly reasonable that the Coinbase S1 doesn't include any descriptions of activities that are illegal, and for Coinbase to subsequently start doing illegal things. They even list this risk in the S1! The SEC saying your S1 and IPO offering is probably kosher isn't a carte blanche to then do whatever you want without continued regulatory oversight.
- chimeracoder 3y ago> It's perfectly reasonable that the Coinbase S1 doesn't include any descriptions of activities that are illegal, and for Coinbase to subsequently start doing illegal things. They even list this risk in the S1! It's also possible for the Coinbase S1 to contain descriptions of things that are currently not known to be illegal, and which subsequently become illegal, without any changes on Coinbase's part. They also list this risk in the S1 as well!
- lancewiggs 3y agoTheir job is to make sure that the IPO document discloses everything material so that investors can make an informed decision. That’s it. In this case they would’ve been content with the disclosure that the entire business was at risk of being regulated, which is what’s happening here.
- Dylan16807 3y agoOne of their jobs is to protect consumers from unregulated securities. The earlier they act, the better, and right before IPO is the most impactful time they could intervene. > In this case they would’ve been content with the disclosure that the entire business was at risk of being regulated They don't have to do it, but they could make that risk disappear and it would be very good if they did so. So I wish they did have to make those decisions, unless there's some huge downside.
- AniseAbyss 3y ago[dead]