3 ms·
I am far from an expert. But from the article, it seems to me to be more likely that it casts doubt on the approximations they're using to do the calculations.
by AnimalMuppet 3y ago
I am far from an expert. But from the article, it seems to me to be more likely that it casts doubt on the approximations they're using to do the calculations.
- cwillu 3y agoThat's my understanding: the math required to get a concrete prediction of a model is complicated enough that “either the theory, or the experiment, is wrong” excludes the most likely possibility: that too much error is being introduced by the approximations that they're (necessarily) using to get a tractable computation out of the model.
- andrewflnr 3y agoWell yes, but our understanding of what approximations should work is not really separable from the theory itself. E.g. from the article, > Van Kolck contends that some of the parts deemed less important and routinely ignored are in fact very important. So it's still good science IMO.