4 ms·
> Gensler's SEC has also been intentionally obtuse about how those securities laws should apply to cryptocurrency. No. Coinbase’s complaint is that the SEC has
by ceejayoz 3y ago
> Gensler's SEC has also been intentionally obtuse about how those securities laws should apply to cryptocurrency.
No. Coinbase’s complaint is that the SEC has been clear, but that they don’t like the clear answer.
https://assets.ctfassets.net/c5bd0wqjc7v0/5NRidtW8lvwVEfSHpndWQm/78f95afa4f0ebaaefb303e1a4f172d03/Coinbase_petition_for_SEC_rulemaking.pdf https://assets.ctfassets.net/c5bd0wqjc7v0/5NRidtW8lvwVEfSHpn...
> Rather than initiate new rulemaking, Chair Gensler has repeatedly stated through speeches and testimony that the vast majority of digital tokens are securities, and has asked issuers and exchanges that offer, sell, and trade them to come in and register. We disagree that the majority of digital assets are securities. For those digital assets that are securities, registration under the current rules is, for many market participants, either not possible or not economically viable given the associated and unnecessary compliance burdens.
- nickff 3y agoWell, the SEC told everyone to register, but didn't actually tell them how they could. From what has been made public, it seems like the SEC strung Coinbase along for about two years, then said that their application was inadequate (without stating any criteria).
- ceejayoz 3y agoI promise you, a procedure to become a registered securities exchange exists (demonstrably, as registered securities exchanges exist widely) and Coinbase has enough people and money to find it. (I’m not the expert to hire for this, but https://www.investopedia.com/terms/s/sec-form-8-a.asp https://www.investopedia.com/terms/s/sec-form-8-a.asp looks promising.)
- everfree 3y agoThe question is whether a procedure to become a registered exchange of crypto securities exists, and that promise seems to be a lot more dubious. Coinbase doesn't care if it can offer its customers shares of AAPL or TSLA. They care whether they can start brokering the types of securities that are found on public ledgers.
- ceejayoz 3y agoThe process is the same; securities are securities, crypto or otherwise. They don’t like that process, so they’re asking for a special one just for them. The SEC just said no.
- everfree 3y agoMy understanding is that the corporate framework that securities licenses require is literally impossible to satisfy when trading current public blockchain assets. As in, to trade crypto as a security on your exchange, you would need to walk up to every dev team of every crypto you wanted to trade and kindly ask them to KYC/AML every single user of the blockchain so that you could be in compliance. In practice this just means it's de-facto impossible for any centralized exchange to carry crypto securities.
- KingOfCoders 3y ago"is literally impossible to satisfy" Then you can't be licensed. Simple. "But I really really really want to be licensed" "..."
- everfree 3y agoIt doesn't mean that companies can't be licensed. It just means that they will move out of the USA (to another country that has strong financial infrastructure but sane securities laws like the UK), get licensed there, and exclude US customers from their platforms. Coinbase and a16z have already publicly stated that they have plans to set up international arms to hedge against US regulatory risk. So your statement "then you can't be licensed, simple", comes with the corollary of "the USA's strong fintech industry may move entirely offshore within the next decade." If everyone is cool with that, then yeah, go ahead and blanket ban all US residents from trading any financial instrument that's recorded on a public digital ledger.
- KingOfCoders 3y ago
- everfree 3y ago"Vast majority" isn't clarity. "Here is how we interpret the Howey test in relation to cryptocurrencies, and here is a ten step process for how we determine whether each particular cryptocurrency is a security" is clarity. Can you imagine if, back when the SEC first formed in 1934, they put out a press release saying "the vast majority of stocks are securities and need to come register, but not The Bank Of New York, their stock is not a security". Imagine that the SEC didn't elaborate on why they didn't consider that one stock to not be a security, and they didn't elaborate on the reasoning process that led them to that decision. That's what's happening right now, but with cryptocurrencies. The 2023 SEC is very different from the 1934 SEC.
- ceejayoz 3y ago> Can you imagine if, back when the SEC first formed in 1934, they put out a press release saying "the vast majority of stocks are securities and need to come register, but not The Bank Of New York, their stock is not a security". This is basically what happened. Mortgage loans and certificates of deposit, for example, aren’t securities by judicial clarification, not definition in the law. (See: Marine Bank v. Weaver) The Howey test isn’t that complicated, and Coinbase Earn ticked all four boxes.
- everfree 3y ago(Removed, I had confused Coinbase Earn with Coinbase Lend.)
- ceejayoz 3y agoCoinbase is being sued specifically for Earn. How is it not relevant?
- everfree 3y agoSorry, I confused Coinbase Earn (staking services) with Coinbase Lend, which was a previous loan product of theirs that was targeted and shut down by the SEC in 2021. Still, Earn may well be a security, but that's a product that will fit very cleanly into current securities law when it reaches the court, and it concerns a company's product rather than an entire new asset class, so it's not so egregious that the SEC doesn't provide clarity on it. The big problem is with their lack of clarity on the cryptocurrencies themselves.
- mthoms 3y agoSEC: "The vast majority of digital tokens are securities!" Anyone: "Okay then, is [insert ANY crypto here other than BTC] a security?" SEC: "We decline to answer, or give a hint, but the vast majority of digital tokens are securities!" I really don't care what happens, or how it got to this point, but this state of affairs is absolutely and unequivocally ridiculous and absurd. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VhA1dZXeao0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VhA1dZXeao0
- ceejayoz 3y agoCoinbase: “We list dozens of coins, including all the big ones. Maybe they’re all in the tiny minority?” SEC: “No. Stop playing games. You have to register.”
- everfree 3y ago> Maybe they’re all in the tiny minority? Coinbase lists less than 300 of the tens of thousands of cryptocurrencies out there - indeed a tiny minority of them, and they do have some kind of legal review process, so while that claim may well be untrue, it's not absurd on its face.
- ceejayoz 3y agoAnd you think all the SEC’s “hint hint, time to register!” for years was understood by Coinbase as “you guys are fine, we’re not talking about you”?
- everfree 3y agoI don't agree that a regulatory agency saying "hint hint time to register" for years on end is an effective way to regulate. The first step of effective regulation is to state exactly what is out of compliance, which they finally did only a few days ago by listing which particular coins are the ones that put Coinbase out of compliance. The second step is to explain why those particular coins cause them to be non-compliant and why other coins (Bitcoin) are exempt, in such a way that Coinbase has rules they can apply to determine whether a particular new coin is compliant or not. That clarity is the part we're still waiting for.
- cypress66 3y agoA congressman asked gensler face to face if ethereum is a security and gensler declined to answer. So no, the SEC has not been clear.
- 8note 3y agoFor what definition of Ethereum? The one with staking?
- mthoms 3y agoDoesn't matter. He refused to give any indication either way. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VhA1dZXeao0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VhA1dZXeao0
- growse 3y agoWhy are people so desperate to seek legal advice from law enforcement?
- mmahut 3y agoIt happens when the law is not clear and the law enforcement has to take a stand on it to enforce it.
- growse 3y agoThere's lots of laws that aren't "clear", but people don't phone the police up and ask them what they're going to do. They talk to a lawyer and get advice.
- hef19898 3y agoThe opinion only shows how little, read none what so ever, experience some people have in figuring out compliant business processes. Yet another rude awakening for the, let me be blunt, cluelessly naive and in some cases outright criminal tech crowd that seems to flok in huge numbers around crypto in general. That attitude started aroind the time Uber got big. Maybe even with AirBnB. In a sense, crypto is exactly the tech eco system we deserve. Good that there is finally some enforcement of rules that apply tp basically everyone else.