4 ms·
The SEC is not part of the executive branch. It is an independent agency. While it is also not part of the legislative branch, the legislative branch is the one
by JohnFen 3y ago
The SEC is not part of the executive branch. It is an independent agency. While it is also not part of the legislative branch, the legislative branch is the one that effectively controls it.
- pylua 3y agoThanks for the insight. It does feel like the organizations ability to interpret the laws is more related to a political agency than the letter of the law. There should just be a letter of the law , analytical meaning branch of government.
- JohnFen 3y agoIt's also useful to know that Congress created the SEC in response to the 1929 stock market crash. Their primary purpose is to prevent the conditions that caused that. > There should just be a letter of the law , analytical meaning branch of government. I don't think that's a thing that is possible. You can't write laws to cover every possible case, and writing them to be "self-interpreting" would be an extraordinarily difficult thing. Interpretation will always be required.
- pylua 3y agoThat’s why it’s a systemic failure . Years of law study to interpret laws with context long dropped. The fact that the sec let Coinbase last this long is proof the system is over complicated and cannot be maintained efficiently.
- anonymouskimmer 3y agoIt's a systemic failure of analytics, not a systemic failure of the law. > The fact that the sec let Coinbase last this long is proof the system is over complicated and cannot be maintained efficiently. There are numerous other possible reasons it took this long for the SEC to take action, other than the system being overly complicated or inefficient (lack of workers, bigger fish to fry [prioritization], the evolution of Coinbase into less of a commodities trader and more of a securities trader). Complications and inefficiencies usually require additional time and effort, but additional time and effort is not an absolute indication that something is complicated or inefficient.
- rtkwe 3y agoYeah for the longest time Coinbase was mainly hosting the relatively old coins that tended to be closer to commodities than securities. While they were doing that it's a very different regulatory environment.
- JohnFen 3y ago> The fact that the sec let Coinbase last this long is proof the system is over complicated and cannot be maintained efficiently. I disagree with this assessment, but reasonable people can hold differing opinions on this.
- knewter 3y ago"you can run a company for nearly a decade while spending a great deal on lawyers talking to the government the whole time and still have no clue if your business is legal"
- paulddraper 3y agoThere's a spectrum. Is it reasonable to have them be completely unambiguous in every circumstances? No. Is it reasonable to have them be unambiguous in the vast majority of circumstances? Yes.
- ikiris 3y agoThis is never how the law has worked
- mrguyorama 3y agoIt's so much worse than that. "Laws should be exhaustively comprehensive" is a completely unworkable system. You cannot predict every possible combination of context and law, and attempting to do so would be literal combinatorics explosion. People who push that kind of system know this, and want the system to be hamstrung by exactly that situation. They want a system that can only outlaw their new, explicitly harmful scheme after an entire game of politics in congress, such that they could prevent something becoming law by encouraging the already bad stonewalling in congress. They want government agencies to be so bound up by poorly written law that they cannot administrate at all.
- pjc50 3y ago> There should just be a letter of the law , analytical meaning branch of government. This is called "a court". (There is a particular phrase for "the law is unclear so I'm going to sue the regulator in advance to determine if something is legal", but I've forgotten it. It's linked to judicial review)
- semiquaver 3y ago> The SEC is not part of the executive branch. You are mistaken. The SEC is very much a part of the executive branch. > It is an independent agency So is the CIA. This just is a term of art for a particular type of executive agency distinct from a cabinet department with additional insulation from political control. SEC commissioners are nominated by POTUS and confirmed by the senate, a characteristic unique to the leaders of executive branch departments. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Independent_agencies_of_the_United_States_government https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Independent_agencies_of_the_...
- JohnFen 3y ago> The SEC is very much a part of the executive branch. Not according to the government, and they're the horse's mouth on this. > SEC commissioners are nominated by POTUS and confirmed by the senate This is correct, but not really to the point.
- semiquaver 3y ago> Not according to the government, and they're the horse's mouth on this. You seem to be referencing some specific statement that you didn't provide. I'm guessing that you are confused about the phrase "independent agency". Or possibly you're remembering cases like Lucia v. SEC where certain SEC staff were (unsuccessfully) challenged as not conforming with the Article II appointments clause. The insulation of these sort of agencies from direct presidential oversight continues to be a source of debate in conservative legal circles, but where these agencies sit in the constitutional order is not remotely controversial. They're not part of the judiciary and they're not part of Congress so they can only be part of the executive. > The executive branch also includes executive departments, independent agencies, and other boards, commissions, and committees. https://www.usa.gov/branches-of-government https://www.usa.gov/branches-of-government > The SEC is an independent federal agency https://www.sec.gov/strategic-plan/about https://www.sec.gov/strategic-plan/about QED. More to the point, congress lacks the ability under the constitution to create government structures outside the three branches. The language establishing the SEC makes very clear that its structure conforms with how Article II defines the executive branch: > There is hereby established a Securities and Exchange Commission (hereinafter referred to as the ‘Commission’) to be composed of five commissioners to be appointed by the President by and with the advice and consent of the Senate. https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/COMPS-1885/pdf/COMPS-1885.pdf https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/COMPS-1885/pdf/COMPS-188... > he shall nominate, and by and with the Advice and Consent of the Senate, shall appoint Ambassadors, other public Ministers and Consuls, Judges of the supreme Court, and all other Officers of the United States, whose Appointments are not herein otherwise provided for, and which shall be established by Law: https://constitution.congress.gov/constitution/article-2/ https://constitution.congress.gov/constitution/article-2/ The SEC is established and appropriated by congress, staffed by people who receive government paychecks, led by presidential appointees, etc etc. I'd be interested to know whether you think it's either - not part of the US government - part of a different branch - part of the US government outside a branch that the constitution specifies