5 ms·
A Baking Soda Solution for Clean Hydrogen Storage
- scythe 3y agoThis is remarkably hard to follow. The actual technology at play here is bicarbonate-formate redox; as the linked paper states: >It is also clear that more integration between the disciplines of electrochemistry and heterogeneous catalysis is needed to overcome the challenges for advancing the HCO3−–HCO2− system as a feasible green alternative for storing and transporting energy. The idea of storing energy by converting bicarbonate to formate has already occurred to me years ago and probably was thought of by thousands of other scientists, because formate is one of the most common hydrogen precursors used in practical chemistry. The storage density is low, but the materials are extremely cheap and stable. Unfortunately, the paper does not seem to be announcing a breakthrough, but tallying up the current progress — which just isn't there yet. https://pubs.rsc.org/en/content/articlelanding/2023/gc/d3gc00219e https://pubs.rsc.org/en/content/articlelanding/2023/gc/d3gc0...
- jfengel 3y agoI suppose... a "hydrogen battery" for solar? Build up formate (in solution? As a salt?) during the day, then burn it at night for electricity?
- rfgmendoza 3y agodensity is not really a critical factor for grid level or onsite energy storage, so it could be feasible in theory
- elcritch 3y agoAs long as the electrodes / membranes for the conversion to electricity are stable and cheap as well. There's a big downside with PEM electrodes requiring platinum and with their longevity and energy density relative to capex.
- chrisco255 3y agoThe article wastes so much time on cutesy fluff. It's almost always a tell that the story is a non-story.
- elcritch 3y agoThanks for linking the real article. It's an interesting read, especially that the Gibb's Free Energy for formate-bicarbonate is so low. Ammonia is about 20-40x higher! Looks like they're using Pd/Pt for the best catalyzers... that's definitely not going to be scalable. Though there should be effective alternatives, but it's surprising how unsophisticated much of the research in this field can be.
- csense 3y agoI don't really have much understanding of chemistry. So possibly the most helpful part for me is the diagram with little trucks, the cost chart, and the paragraph below that says: "The electrochemical regeneration is not optimized...If the cell voltage could be reduced to 2 V and the faradaic efficiency raised to 80%, the total cost of hydrogen would be nearly cut in half...if the regeneration and reaction could be performed at 8 M rather than 3 M concentration along with an improved process and discounted electricity...the cost of hydrogen could drop to just over $3 per kg...[which is] below the cost of on-site electrolysis with full-priced electricity" Why formate? Can't you get hydrogen from any acid, because that's literally the definition of an acid? "If the cell voltage could be reduced" sounds super fishy to me; isn't that just a useless wish that the elements / molecules you're working with have different properties than they actually do? "If the regeneration and reaction could be performed at 8 M rather than 3 M concentration...", why can't they? Doesn't a reaction usually proceed faster in more concentrated solutions? It seems like several breakthroughs that are needed, some of which possibly stretch the laws of physics. But once you have that. But even with those improvements, they still compare formate+discounted electricity to electrolysis+fullprice electricity? Isn't that doing an apples-to-oranges comparison, blatantly putting your thumb on the scale in favor of formate? For that matter, what's wrong with electrolysis for making hydrogen for bulk energy storage? Isn't water electrolysis super well-understood, cheap, simple, scalable, as safe as anything involving bulk quantities of hydrogen gas can be, and only requires water and electricity for inputs?
- scythe 3y ago>Why formate? Can't you get hydrogen from any acid, because that's literally the definition of an acid? Formate releases hydrogen differently: HCOOH >> H2 + CO2 Other acids need an electron donor to produce hydrogen. Formate reduces itself. >"If the regeneration and reaction could be performed at 8 M rather than 3 M concentration...", why can't they? You're getting a little over my head here, but I think there might be some solubility problems. >"If the cell voltage could be reduced" sounds super fishy to me; isn't that just a useless wish that the elements / molecules you're working with have different properties than they actually do? The standard electrode potential does create a minimum voltage, but usually there is considerable inefficiency. I can't answer the other questions, except to mention that formate is very stable and easy to store.
- wilg 3y ago[flagged]
- photochemsyn 3y agoHydrogen is needed for all kinds of industrial processes, but it is best generated at the point of use as needed, as storage and transport is too problematic. If absoultely needed, the most obvious way to ship hydrogen is as methane. Synthesis of methane from water-sourced hydrogen and atmosphere-sourced CO2 is at present a good deal more expensive than fossil natural gas, but that's a somewhat artificial situation: natural gas production is heavily subsidized and many of the costs are externalized to the public (see global warming, air and water pollution, etc.). However, once accomplished you can just feed this renewable methane into the existing natural gas infrastructure, and get the hydrogen back as needed from well-understood processes, i.e. steam-methane reforming.
- hannob 3y ago> If absoultely needed, the most obvious way to ship hydrogen is as methane. Methane has 2 problems: 1. it's a massive greenhouse gas if it leaks, 2. it requires CO2 to make, and in a decarbonized future that can only come from either biomass (limited) or DAC (expensive). You would either want ammonia or methanol. Ammonia does not have any of these problems, but it's very toxic. Methanol has the CO2 problem as well, but it's a liquid, so it's easier to transport. Neither is perfect, but there are no perfect solutions. Methane is the worst of all options. If you want a hydrocarbon, then usually methanol is what you want. And don't trust me on that, just look at what projects are actually planned out there. Plenty of green ammonia and green methanol projects, green methane is exotic at best, barely anyone wants to do that.
- marcosdumay 3y ago> Ammonia does not have any of these problems Ammonia is a greenhouse gas itself, and it tends to react with air creating various nitrous oxides, that are much more potent greenhouse gases than methane, very toxic, and create acid rain (after what it becomes fertilizer). The best shipping option is probably just to face all the issues and ship the hydrogen. But storage is a different matter.
- hannob 3y ago
- bagels 3y ago"In a renewable energy grid, batteries can handle about 80 percent of storage needs." Why couldn't you just add 25% more batteries?
- marcosdumay 3y agoIt's not 25% more batteries. It's some 500% to 1000% more. But those would be used very few times.
- chrisco255 3y agoSo in other words batteries don't get us anywhere close to 80% of the way.
- elcritch 3y agoDepends on how you're slicing it. By the total flux of energy batteries may be able to handle 80% of the "energy traffic" over the course of a day by smoothing out day/night cycles. However that last 25% needs to be stored over long periods where the cost is prohibitive to store in current battery systems.
- audunw 3y agoThere's many ways to judge what "80%" is. The batteries will cycle many times every week. They will have much more energy flowing through them in a year than the storage we need for dunkelflaute would. Yes, in terms of amount of energy stored at full capacity, batteries would not get us to 80%. But those last 20% have reduced requirements for charge/discharge rates, effiency, cost/kWh, which makes many other solutions viable.
- _hypx 3y agoA system that can store 1000% more energy than what is possible with batteries could very well power the entire system. Thus eliminating the need for batteries for this purpose. It's always something that stuck out to me as an obvious point that few have noticed.