7 ms·
‘It’s not even good for money laundering’: Nassim Taleb lashes out at Bitcoin
- neovialogistics 3y agoI have previously heard that it has found a use case in Vietnam and no other country in circumventing legally unusual financial policy, but I haven't been able to find: * Anything reliable about crypto adoption in Vietnam from a more recent time than March of this year in English (or accessible with Google translate). * Anything comparing different cryptocurrency proof formats by Vietnamese popularity, including differentiation of non-mineable proof of work cryptocurrencies like Monero. * A convincing argument that the Vietnamese cryptocurrency market won't vanish in less than a year when their government caves to the State Department and IMF's lobbying and liberalises their banking and payments laws.
- Demmme 3y ago[dead]
- alephnerd 3y agoI was recently in Vietnam for work and the crypto usecase there appeared to be used as a way to bypass traditional gold+dollar based money laundering after the Viet A corruption crackdown began (roughly around the time I was there for work). For daily commerce, people still used Dong or Venmo-esque services like ZaloPay, Momo, or Mocha. Ik they were investigating a Blockchain based Virtual Dong back in 2021, but idk if the people affiliated with that are still relevant or not in prison due to the graft crackdown.
- antran22 3y agoVietnamese here. Crypto best use case here is usually fast and small international transaction (beside speculation etc.) For daily commerce, we have instant, free, cross-bank transfer. All popular banks provide e-banking apps with fast transaction to all the other popular banks. Polymer money are still used for very small amount (and oddly, buying gasoline), but I have been going 90% cashless for a year. All Blockchain related stuffs are still more or less unsupported by law, not recognizable as assets. So if you get crypto-scammed in Vietnam, which happens a lot, you are more or less fucked
- aaron695 3y ago[dead]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- _8j50 3y agoYou can launder money with bitcoin, if you don't reuse wallets. But typically (not that i would know), a cash conversion mechanism is involved like moneygram or giftcards. You can KYC yourself and trade monero for cash and buy dirty btc with monero and then cash that btc-taxes. Only the dirty btc wallet needs to be fresh each time.
- LatteLazy 3y agoIf people don't see the point of BTC (etc) then they should just... not use it. I don't understand why people get so angry about it. To me, living my life, in my country, with my income etc, it has no use. If some Venezuelan or drug dealer needs it, good for them. Yet everyone seems to want to insist it's either "the future of money and you will all be on it in 5 years" or basically the devil and should be banned. Why?
- mchaver 3y agoI agree with you. Here is my guess. Part of it is invested interests. These parties want it to succeed so they profit and many have show themselves to be bad actors. The other part is it got partially entangled with the US culture war, which bleeds into other countries, so support or rejection of cryptocurrencies shows which side you are on (it's not 100% true but I think there are trends).
- chii 3y agoor some people object to the amount of energy expended on it, which contributes to worsening climate change, from which they derive no benefit.
- LatteLazy 3y agoThat would be fine if they also objected to computer games or reddit or TV for the same reason. But wasting energy is only an issue when it's crypto?! That is where I get confused. Equally I don't actually think Crypto will cure cancer any time soon...
- coldtea 3y ago>That would be fine if they also objected to computer games or reddit or TV for the same reason Many do. But those don't even come close to BTC for the benefit/energy waste ratio...
- coldtea 3y ago
- futurecat 3y agoTaleb thoughts are irrelevant to Bitcoin’s failure or success. Bitcoin has a tremendous potential for many reasons (methane emissions reduction, renewable energy load management, the lightning network for immediate value exchange) and it’s not riskless for sure (regulations, possible hack, UX difficulties).
- thworp 3y ago> renewable energy load managment I'll pick this as the most absurd use-case. Every party in an electricity grid already has to trust all the other parties in the network. What advantage does a trustless distributed ledger have that a more conventional distributed DB and messaging solution doesn't?
- cinntaile 3y agoWhat he means is that when renewable energy output is high, you can turn on the mining facilities to absorb the excess and turn it off when there is no excess. In this case it helps with load balancing. The ledger is irrelevant here.
- futurecat 3y agoAbsolutely. Thank you.
- thworp 3y agoI am honestly dumbfounded. If this is an application of bitcoin, why wouldn't we use that same excess energy to run a giant tesla coil? At least that makes some pretty arcs while wasting the energy. Just a thought: You could also store the energy or use it to do actually useful calculations.
- jakupovic 3y agoBecause these applications are in middle of nowhere. You cannot store/transport the energy, the best you can do is burn it.
- sunshinerag 3y agoAgreed, USD continues to be the currency of the choice for money laundering. Happens in the open through supposedly regulated modern banking system. Launder for years, pay a fine, continue laundering, get slapped in the wrist, repeat.
- hsjqllzlfkf 3y agoI'm glad we agree that USD is better in every respect. This was always obvious for many of us by the way.
- sunshinerag 3y agoYes every aspect. USD specialises in money laundering, terrorist financing , prostitution and child harassment . Till as such time something else supplants it all these things continue to exist and seem to overwhelmingly prefer $$$.
- hsjqllzlfkf 3y agoSo it is better.
- HDThoreaun 3y agoCrypto is easier to carry across borders until you’re wealthy enough to have private Swiss bankers
- lesuorac 3y agoSwiss have been complying with a lot of the open banking stuff. It's really the US that's helping out a lot of laundering by refusing to cooperate with international bodies.
- nottorp 3y agoCouldnt get past the cookie popup on mobile :) It kept expanding and shrinking as I tried to reject stuff so I just closed the page. Not that I think much of Taleb after reading his first book, but I agreed with the summary this time…
- thworp 3y agoWhat about Fooled by Randomness made you think less of him?
- nottorp 3y agoI think I read Antifragile or Black Swan. Thought it was his first anyway. It had one idea repeated 2500 times. He could have written it on a napkin. Plus maybe I didn't read it carefully enough but I found no suggestions on how to deal with randomness...
- LargeTomato 3y agoI read anti fragile. My big take away was that optionality is really useful. It lets you pivot if needed, stay in the game so you can play another day, and capitalize on opportunity if one presents itself.
- nottorp 3y agoDid you use ChatGPT for that summary? :)
- oliwary 3y agoPerhaps the ideas are repeated many times so that if the book encounters a shock (i.e. pages are ripped out, a fire), the book can still carry its message, and thus increase its value when compared to other books that are more... fragile?
- freddealmeida 3y agoIt was never meant for money laundering.
- freddealmeida 3y ago[flagged]
- machina_ex_deus 3y agoIn a world where central banks can print in a few months their entire money supply, doubling it, and can then declare inflation "transitory" and refuse to do their job of raising interest rates for an entire year, there's definitely a demand for sound money. Not sure if Bitcoin will be that, but after the events of last years, nobody can pretend that fiat currency doesn't need competition.
- ethanbond 3y agoThe fact that our economies are pulling through a near-total shutdown relatively unscathed except moderate inflation (so far) is actually a phenomenal positive argument for fiat currency. And it’s another good demonstration of the top-to-bottom uselessness of a deflationary currency. The thing about competition is that no one needs to pretend or believe anything. If Bitcoin were competitive then it’d be competitive. It’s not, because it’s not.
- machina_ex_deus 3y agoI'm not complaining about 2020, I'm complaining about 2021. I'm not sure whatever it was that led to "transitory inflation narrative", it felt like the Fed was acting like a third world country, like Turkey's central bank, ignoring basic economical consideration everyone knows. These levels of irrationality caught me and many others off guard. I did not at all expect the central bank to wait an entire year in what seemed like no brainer rate hike. I'm not sure what they were stalling for, but I already lost my trust in fiat then. Inflation isn't going back down until people are sure that central banks aren't going to be weak again. By the way, just look at the markets. They are all calling the Fed's bluff right now. The markets are screaming "the Fed is weak, he'll pivot". Nobody believes the current Fed has the stomach to fight stagflation. Everybody knows he has to, but everyone already saw him chickening out of raising rates for a full year with "transitory inflation" narrative. EDIT: A full year isn't "few months". It's a whole year. A whole year during which the Fed has completely eroded the trust in the central bank. Inflation was already 4.1% at April 2021, continuing to climb, up to 7% in December 2021, yet only in April 2022 the rate hikes started. That's not rounding error. It's a full year during which the problem transformed from somewhat manageable to full blown economic disaster and this train wreck isn't even close to stopping.
- jakupovic 3y agoNobody cares about Mr. Taleb. Let him continue yelling at the cloud, after cashing in. Maybe he didn't cash out enough and is mad? I'm just asking!
- thecleaner 3y agoHow did he cash out in the cloud ?
- jakupovic 3y ago"The Bitcoin Standard" and his associated money collection during this period. Personally I think he got shafted on some trade or something similar and lost his crypto and is yelling at everyone now. Poor guy.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ekianjo 3y ago[flagged]
- neonate 3y agohttps://archive.md/7yRBo https://archive.md/7yRBo
- jdlyga 3y agoThe bitcoin craze was just about making money. Buy low, sell high. The different with AI is it's immediately useful for people to do their jobs more effectively, just just a vague "in the future" kind of thing.