4 ms·
How to Cite ChatGPT
- catchnear4321 3y agothe tl;dr is that the citation is largely useless and relies on trust. but let’s go through the motions.
- Curzel 3y agoNot necessarily the same, but you can share a readonly link to conversations with ChatGPT, for example: https://chat.openai.com/share/2ec10eb6-a7f1-4b27-9f56-0ec7f2701edf https://chat.openai.com/share/2ec10eb6-a7f1-4b27-9f56-0ec7f2... (share icon the side menu)
- digitcatphd 3y agoWhat is worse, citing ChatGPT or citing oneself?
- schaefer 3y agoAt the foundation of academic writing, there is a given: that you and the authors you are citing have made an effort to present factual arguments with citations when applicable. ChatGPT doesn’t do that. And so I think it should almost never be cited. — I think of chatGPT as more of a writing coach. You tell it what you want to write about, and it puts together a sample response that, above all else, sounds convincing. If it happens to know relevant facts it will put them in (but not with citations). If chat GPT doesn’t know relevant facts, it uses made up facts as a placeholder, just to give an example of how a convincing response could be structured. It’s then our job as an actual writer to take this sample, hunt down the relevant facts (with citations), and put forward our final argument. — Perhaps the only time it makes sense to me to cite chatGPT is if you are explicitly writing about it as an entity.
- rcfox 3y agoText generated by ChatGPT that you have reproduced should be cited, if for no other reason than the fact that you are not the author. Taking credit for work that is not your own is unethical.
- barefeg 3y agoGhost writers are not always credited in books. Is it because they receive money in exchange?
- IanCal 3y agoGeneral books are not the same as academic papers. (I am aware there are academic books)
- ghaff 3y agoI would assume that most books written by CEOs, professional athletes, general celebrities, and the like are significantly cowritten with someone whether they were entirely ghostwritten or not.
- gms7777 3y agoGenerally speaking, plagiarism (as in, passing off other's words and ideas as your own) is not illegal except in cases where it intersects with copyright law. In the case of ghost writers, they transfer copyright to the publisher, so legally speaking there's no issue. In academic writing, there's a standard that the authors are the sole authors of the text that is upheld by academic institutions, academic communities, and the academic publishing industry (but not the legal system itself). This same standard doesn't exist in the same way in non-academic publishing (or a lot of other media) so not crediting ghost writers is considered acceptable.
- pests 3y ago> Taking credit for work that is not your own is unethical. Almost hilarious that ChatGPT doesn't give citations or give credit to anything it writes, despite its entire knowledge being derived from us.
- Spivak 3y agoI really don't get why people are being so weird about this. People are writing papers about Llms, and citations aren't only for "knowledge" that you're referencing.
- simonw 3y agoThe APA is the American Psychological Association. These are not guidelines generally aimed at people writing papers about LLMs.
- h_mirin 3y agoIn principle, citations should give credible sources of information to the reader and let them reproduce the result ultimately. However, this is impossible for ChatGPT because it generates answers probabilistically and its random number generator cannot be controlled. (Though perhaps this could be partially achieved by setting the temperature to zero through the API?) I hope open-sourced models will achieve better performance soon.
- throwanem 3y agoThis is an exciting innovation! Making ChatGPT output a first-class and citeable source will massively increase the rate at which academic psychology generates research output, without significantly changing the quality of data or the soundness of conclusions drawn.
- huijzer 3y agoYou are clearly making a joke, but like so many jokes I think there is some truth in it! It might even improve the quality or at least make it easier to spot false information. Funny also how the APA article ends with > We, the APA Style team humans, appreciate your patience as we navigate these unique challenges and new ways of thinking about how authors, researchers, and students learn, write, and work with new technologies. So, they see this as an unique "challenge" only. Not as an opportunity.
- throwanem 3y agoI'm not making a joke.
- OscarCunningham 3y agoI don't think it says what to do if you just use ChatGPT for rephrasing and grammar. I guess you just don't cite it, in the same way you wouldn't cite Microsoft Word.
- ipieter 3y agoOur university recently recommended the same thing, and I think this is a very bad idea for two reasons. 1. Not every sequence of words deserves to be cited. GPT-3 and ChatGPT are often confidently wrong about facts, why would you want to add a citation to this? When writing a paper, this needs to be fact-checked anyways, so why not add the original (actual) source? 2. It also breaks the citation graph. Imagine all papers now point to a catch-all reference from OpenAI (2023). Adding a citation is about saying where you got certain information from and this current format doesn't give enough to do that, it just points to the catch-all. With any other citation you can either look up the paper or—in the rare case of personal communication in a citation—ask the cited source directly. You can't ask chatGPT "hey, why did you say this in paper X" and expect a meaningful answer.
- pests 3y agoI find this very odd too. If I search google and it gives me an instant answer at the top (which is some snippet of an actual site or article)... It feels like I should cite google as the source for that info if I follow the same guidelines as we are discussing here.
- 2h 3y agowow, what a terrible idea. I guess APA has never heard of hallucinations? https://wikipedia.org/wiki/Hallucination_(artificial_intelligence) https://wikipedia.org/wiki/Hallucination_(artificial_intelli...
- spencerchubb 3y agoThe only time ChatGPT should be cited is when the purpose of your paper is to study the behavior of ChatGPT. I think it should be morally okay to use ChatGPT in the research process and to improve the quality of your writing, e.g., "Make this more clear and flow better" If ChatGPT must be cited, I think for maximum transparency the citation should include the model, date retrieved, prompt, and output in an appendix.
- karencarits 3y agoI agree that if chatgpt is used as an alternative to grammarly or Word's spell check, then it shouldn't be cited
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- RecycledEle 3y agoThey give the version as a month and day without a year. Maybe they should think that through a little more.
- jll29 3y agoThe purpose of giving a source is to permit the reader to track/vet/verify the same. ChatGPT does not preserve what it said, so there is no proof possible. Therefore, you might as well cite /dev/random.
- ryan69howard 3y agoUp next: How to cite your internet provider
- EMCymatics 3y agoIs this the new wikipedia? (joke)