3 ms·
Well, it's true. Third party apps don't have to deal with the entire server side of Reddit, ie hosting text, images, video etc. They're just dealing with the cl
by satvikpendem 3y ago
Well, it's true. Third party apps don't have to deal with the entire server side of Reddit, ie hosting text, images, video etc. They're just dealing with the client side off a free API, of course they're profitable. At least the CEO is honest that companies exist to make money, of course.
- asdff 3y agoHosting the text content is one thing, but reddit willingly became a multimedia hosting site not all that long ago. The site grew and users got by fine using imgur and what not before i.reddit.com and v.reddit.com ever existed. They also decided to do presumably costly ui rollouts that a lot of their most veteran community members opt out of.
- satvikpendem 3y agoDo you know why Reddit actually built their own multimedia platforms via i/v.reddit? Because Imgur didn't want to host Reddit content anymore [0]. This is about NSFW but more generally there was a cooling of relations between Imgur and Reddit because essentially Reddit users were freeloading on Imgur's platform without Imgur necessarily being able to show ads due to how Reddit linked directly to the image and not the Imgur link. Therefore, Reddit was forced (and yes, also wanted) to build their own versions. There is no free lunch. Someone has to pay the bills on hosting, and I'm sure Reddit thought it'd be cheaper to do it themselves at scale than to pay someone as a middleman. [0] https://www.theverge.com/2019/10/18/20920977/imgur-reddit-nsfw-images-support-business-at-risk https://www.theverge.com/2019/10/18/20920977/imgur-reddit-ns...
- Matheus28 3y agoAccording to that article you linked, Reddit started hosting their own images 3 years prior to that change. As I recall, it was Reddit who moved away from Imgur, not the reverse.
- satvikpendem 3y agoThis is the Reddit announcement about their hosting [0]. At that point in time, Imgur was already redirecting direct image links to the non-direct wrapper page so that they could show banner ads. This made it difficult for Reddit to show images in the site and app well, thus the cooling of relations between both I had mentioned. It's interesting since Imgur started off as "an image hosting service that doesn't suck" according to the creator, on Reddit [1]. [0] https://old.reddit.com/r/changelog/comments/4kuk2j/reddit_change_introducing_image_uploading_beta/ https://old.reddit.com/r/changelog/comments/4kuk2j/reddit_ch... [1] https://old.reddit.com/r/reddit.com/comments/7zlyd/my_gift_to_reddit_i_created_an_image_hosting/ https://old.reddit.com/r/reddit.com/comments/7zlyd/my_gift_t...
- stavros 3y agoEverything doesn't suck until you have to make money with it.
- matkoniecz 3y agoimgur started as site to host and hotlink images published at reddit (they wanted to change it to be profitable, but entire point of Imgur was to enable "freeloading on Imgur's platform")
- rapind 3y ago>They also decided to do presumably costly ui rollouts that a lot of their most veteran community members opt out of. The original UI works well, and it's great they kept old.reddit. Everything since has been horrible, along with the dark patterns pushing their mobile client. It reminds me of all the craigslist UI redesign posts on hacker news many years ago that completely missed the point. Reddit has definite value (really important as Google quality declines IMO), and I'd love if they could find a way to sustain without destroying the community... but I'm not optimistic.
- amir734jj 3y agoGoogle has become unusable recently, maybe my expectations increased since chatgpt but Bing is way superior now.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- binkHN 3y agoHe's myopic. It's not like any of the third party clients were drowning in millions in profits. The CEO basically shut out his best content producers in one fell swoop. If you're already looking to a third party client for Reddit, clearly it's something you value and that's now been destroyed.
- satvikpendem 3y agoReddit doesn't care about users who use third party apps, that's simply a fact. It doesn't matter if they are content producers as there are 500 million monthly active users on Reddit and once people either migrate to the official app (or quit, but I highly doubt that since people say they'll quit a lot of things but never actually do), they'll continue to churn out content.
- josephg 3y agoMy prediction is it’ll be like the slow death of Facebook. Did Facebook users quit en masse after the Cambridge analytica scandal, or after The Social Dilemma? No, Facebook was still going strong. But it just doesn’t seem culturally relevant any more. People don’t seem to ask to be Facebook friends now. They ask for my insta or WhatsApp. (And meta buying both of those sites seems like an utterly genius move in retrospect.) I predict the same will happen with reddit. It’ll take awhile for new platforms to mature, and for the good content to leave. But I’d put money on it losing its cultural relevance over the next 5-10 years.
- satvikpendem 3y agoFacebook has 3 billion monthly active users. It's not dead by any definition of the word. Even if you and I don't use it, many people around the planet do. It is simply that we are not in the target market anymore, but don't discount 3 billion people, that's around 30-40% of the world's population. Cultural relevancy doesn't matter as long as Facebook still has the install base to show ads to, which is how it makes its money, and why its stock is still one of the best performing in the business.
- b1n 3y agoOne solution to the profitability problem might be to remove all the non-profitable users. When I browse the home page all I see is anti-work, anti-capitalism, nuance-less politics, etc. As people have mentioned, the free money decade is over - users are going to have to start becoming Customers if they want their voices to be listened to.
- imiric 3y ago> users are going to have to start becoming Customers if they want their voices to be listened to. That would be an improvement to the current "free" platforms that users pay for with their data, or attention to psychologically manipulative content. The web should definitely adopt the business-customer model, and cut out the leechy middlemen. Going a step further, the business should happen not with a centralized platform, but with web hosters, infrastructure companies, and ultimately ISPs. The technology for anyone to publish and manage their data already exists, but is not user friendly enough to be accessible to anyone but the technically proficient. The internet is inherently peer-to-peer. Service silos only exist because user-friendly tools are made for consumers rather than publishers, and the easiest way for users to publish content is via a 3rd party. We have user-friendly web _browsers_, but web servers are still reserved for the technically proficient. There's a lot of work needed in this area, but all the building blocks already exist.
- nologic01 3y agoYep. Its incredible that for decades we havent developed a decentralized internet of "apps" that is more aligned with how the economy works. In some cases the current platform design is totally absurd: like linkedin (or github or azure) thus microsoft having insider knowledge about anything that happens in the digital space. This is basically down to society being largely tech illiterate and various people taking enormous advantage of that.
- imiric 3y agoI think this was a failure of the early web. You can see in the original proposal[1] that the building blocks were a "browser" and a "server". So the web client gets to have a user-friendly application for consuming content, but the web server is just... a server. There's no user-friendly counterpart for publishing content. This would be equivalent to the modern web browsers not existing, and users having to "navigate" using cURL. I love cURL, but it's intended for a technical audience, and the web would've never taken off had it been the default client interface. You can also see in the proposal that phase 2 considered a "universal authorship" goal, and has a rough draft of what a user-friendly publishing interface could be, but it was far too vague, and to my knowledge this phase never came to pass. As a result of this, companies like GeoCities and Angelfire popped up to fill the void of what the web lacked, and later on social media platforms served the same purpose. Advertisers noticed early on a very lucrative opportunity, and tech giants were built to support them. ISPs noticed that the demand was only for downloading content, so they never bothered to build the infrastructure needed to also serve content, and most internet connections were asymmetrical. And, so, here we are. To be fair, there have been some attempts to make publishing easier. I think the best attempt was Opera's Unite in 2009. But by then, it was too little, too late, and Opera being Opera, it never gained traction. BitTorrent is a big one, but it's only a protocol, so it should be a building block of whatever the solution is. Now we have all these distributed projects, web3, etc., but they're still unusable by the average internet user. A part of the problem is education, sure, but I reckon that the average internet user has been conditioned to believe that all these mainstream platforms _are_ the internet. So even if friendly publishing tools existed, and users had the knowledge to use them, they would still choose to use the centralized platforms. Partly because, unfortunately, most people don't care about their data, privacy, etc., and just want to consume content. So I don't think any of this will change. Technical users will keep using niche tools, and the mainstream web will keep being centralized and run by advertisers. [1]: https://www.w3.org/Proposal.html https://www.w3.org/Proposal.html
- whateveracct 3y agoDon't list "hosting text" as if it costs more then a paper bill per month for the entire website.