3 ms·
I used to love GTD. I've been using it - or rather trying to use it, then increasingly personalized variations of it - for almost two decades. I still appreciat
by TeMPOraL 3y ago
I used to love GTD. I've been using it - or rather trying to use it, then increasingly personalized variations of it - for almost two decades. I still appreciate the wisdom there, but I wish someone would've told me 15 years ago that it assumes a certain way your brain is wired. Maybe it's good for the majority, but it still sucks to be the one with a brain that requires inverting or replacing some of the book's ideas.
Like, keeping your head clear is a wonderful selling point, but externalizing all the tasks also makes them no longer feel like they matter much. Keeping a list of projects and next actions is a good idea in theory, but much harder to benefit from in practice, when your visual system starts erasing the TODO list from your visual field, like it was a piece of negative space, an external equivalent of the blind spot in your eyes.
> But if it's an expense report, probably just do it already.
Maybe I'm doing something wrong, but I've never had an expense report that took me less than 2 hours to complete. Usually it's half a day, as it involves scanning and attaching receipts.
> Break projects into actionable sub-tasks.
To this day I have a really big problem with the "actionable" part. My attempts always end with tasks that are either too big (and therefore too scary), underspecified (actionable, but not to completion - always getting blocked by something mid-way), or overspecified (20 steps, half of which take less time to get done than it took to write them down, and getting 1/3 through the steps usually invalidates most of the rest anyway). I just don't know how to get to that magic point of actionable tasks that you can just pick and do.
> Separate calendar and to do list.
This is interesting in that for people with ADHD, this advice gets reversed: it's more important to have one system for everything, as the more of them you have, the less likely it is you'll actually use any of them. Don't know how widely this applies, but it's definitely true for me.
- ilyt 3y agoI kinda wish for a mix of todo/calendar system where I could say, for example "remind me of this maintenance task in 6 months" and it would disappear out of anything directly visible for that 6 months then pop up in todo list without due date, as just a thing to do. Calendars are good for stuff that needs to be done at this exact date and hour but not great if it is just some routine maintenance task that can be easily shifted a month in any direction (say "replace oil and filters on car")
- ghaff 3y ago> I kinda wish for a mix of todo/calendar system I imagine there are various ways you can do this with existing tools. I just mostly find it useful to separate calendaring from needs to be done in the next month or two from bigger/more aspirational/not fully defined projects. So I generally (if loosely) separate them into different spaces. The main thing IMO is not to put stuff with loose (and maybe never) dates on your calendar where you now have 50 overdue items on your calendar which just encourages never wrapping anything up. (Worked with someone like that once.)
- TeMPOraL 3y ago> The main thing IMO is not to put stuff with loose (and maybe never) dates on your calendar where you now have 50 overdue items on your calendar which just encourages never wrapping anything up. Thank you. This killed all my attempts at planning using Org Mode and agenda views. I'd schedule a few things for the day, and then invariably fail to do half of them, and then they would show up on next day's agenda, sorting above that day's planned tasks, and displayed with emphasis. This was both distracting and created an "emotional repulsion field" for the agenda view, leading to more tasks not completed, and a week down the line, my agenda view would have 20+ items due days ago. The second-to-last time around, I started pushing due dates on those incomplete tasks into the future. But this didn't help anything - soon enough, I'd be staring at an incoming blast wave of random uncompleted tasks, which I then had to push back again some more. The system eventually collapsed under the emotional weight. Last time around, I forced myself to simply unschedule such incomplete tasks - remove due dates from them entirely. But that only cut to the thing I still haven't figured out (one of many such things): how to represent tasks that have some temporal component to them, but a fuzzy or flexible one. Like, "do X anywhere between next Friday and Tuesday in the week after - but I don't want to be reminded of X before that very Friday". Or, "do X somewhere between September and November". Basically, trying to walk a narrow line between the system being not specific enough to be useful, and being so overwhelming that it actually makes everything worse.
- ghaff 3y agoMy approach, quite frankly, has been either my weekly hardcopy calendar or the whiteboard in my kitchen. And keeping my Google Calendar as a calendar. So I have my actual calendar and things I need to deal with at some point in the near or indefinite future. Not saying it's the right approach but virtual/physical separation works for me.
- ghaff 3y ago>Maybe I'm doing something wrong, but I've never had an expense report that took me less than 2 hours to complete. For a big international trip, it can definitely take a while. But I also have a lot of monthly cell phone bill, went into town for a customer visit, etc. that really don't take very long. (They're still more of a hassle than I'd like but they have to be done and they're pretty quick.) ADDED: I do get the unification aspect, but I personally like the separation between this has to happen on or by this date, needs to get done within some reasonable time horizon, and maybe/someday projects.