4 ms·
This “poor people will be affected more” is a tired refrain. That is always obviously true, given the consequences of being poor. Not every solution can or ha
by lotsofpulp 3y ago
This “poor people will be affected more” is a tired refrain. That is always obviously true, given the consequences of being poor.
Not every solution can or has to solve the wealth/income gap. Solve congestion with one solution, solve wealth redistribution with another.
- rileymat2 3y agoRationing by payment is only one strategy though. Choosing that strategy brings in wealth disparities. So it is fair to bring it up when that is the chosen strategy.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoEverything brings in wealth disparities, except for redistributing wealth. That’s an inherent part of one person having more wealth than another, it allows them to buy more. It is a waste of time to bring it up every single time. We know being poor sucks, but that is its own issue with its own solution separate from solving too many vehicles in certain parts of Manhattan at certain times.
- nonethewiser 3y agoHow does increasing free parking bring in a wealth disparity? Or increasing capacity or lowering the price of public transit?
- lotsofpulp 3y ago> How does increasing free parking bring in a wealth disparity? Increases distances between destinations, which means more energy and time to travel between them, which means higher cost. > Or increasing capacity or lowering the price of public transit? This would qualify as redistributing wealth.
- grumpy_coder 3y agoThe actual dollar amount also matters. London's charge has tripled since it was introduced. The unforeseen consequence of this type of charge is it becomes a lever to reduce traffic by forcing poorer people off the roads everyone pays for.
- nonethewiser 3y agoHow could this toll be anything of not that?
- Wowfunhappy 3y agoAlso, at least with congestion pricing, those wealthy drivers will be funding the public transit system for the rest of society.
- nonethewiser 3y agoTrickle down?
- Wowfunhappy 3y agoQuite the opposite, I'd call it a tax on the rich.
- ironmagma 3y agoThere's no evidence the taxes will be used to improve the public transit. Where are the current improvements to the public transit? Oh right, the subway hasn't been updated in 100 years.
- paganel 3y ago> is a tired refrain. Only non-poor people can say something as reactionary as that. Or people who are not friends or relatives with poor people. A populist backlash that will bring some of the middle-class egoism down is long over-due, and not only in the States.
- ethanbond 3y agoI grew up quite poor in rural Arizona, now live in NYC, and I think they should congestion charge the absolute daylights out of anyone driving through Midtown. “This will hurt poor people” is a very very bad argument in this case. There you go, point disproven.
- jeroenhd 3y agoSetting the price based on income can help prevent the problem without disparaging the poor. It works for traffic tickets in vaeious countries so it may just as well work in anti congestion systems. That's just one approach. You can also use monthly quotas that you can't buy your way around or other restrictions. Of course I don't expect such approaches to be a very popular approach in America, but there are ways to do it. All you need to do is let go of the idea that anything can be gained through purely monetary means.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoThat is needlessly convoluted and leads to many externalities and unintended consequences. Straight forward, simple, easy to implement and audit solutions are best for society. Sure, let’s take wealth from richer people and give it to poorer people, but handle that via taxes, not via the road congestion pricing in certain parts of Manhattan.
- nonethewiser 3y agoIt’s obviously true though, isnt it? Poor people cant afford the ~$20 toll like a rich person can.
- Wowfunhappy 3y agoIf you're poor, you probably aren't driving in Manhattan in the first place. And in all honesty, if you are driving in Manhattan, you should probably stop doing that.
- ironmagma 3y agoIf you're poor, you probably aren't eating anyway. And in all honesty, if you are eating, you probably should stop doing that. If you're poor, you probably aren't getting your cancer cured anyway. And in all honesty, if you are getting chemotherapy, you probably should stop doing that. See how none of this makes sense?
- Wowfunhappy 3y agoNo. As far as I'm concerned, nobody should be driving in Manhattan. Private vehicles shouldn't even be allowed here. Congestion pricing is a compromise.
- ironmagma 3y agoIt’s a bad compromise, one that leads to gentrification instead of betterment. Just rip off the bandaid by banning cars.
- Jcowell 3y agoin the context of the area it does make sense. the Poor are majority in the outer boroughs and uptown manhattan with the only poor community I can think of near the area is in Chinatown and you would have to question: What is someone from chinatown doing with a car in FIDI? they’re not going to brooklyn since they would’ve taken the Williamsburg bridge or even the Queens Midtown tunnel. No way they’re looking to just chill at Battery Park or the seaport since the 6 train is right there. Someone from the Bronx or Harlem could drive there for work but both places have public transportation options that makes driving not make much sense and neither places require going through downtown in order to access south brooklyn.