2 ms·
> If it matters ethically When you use the word 'it', are you referring to "giving credit", or the question "Do I need to give credit"? The former would mean
by Dylan16807 3y ago
> If it matters ethically
When you use the word 'it', are you referring to "giving credit", or the question "Do I need to give credit"?
The former would mean "If giving credit matters ethically, then asking the question provides the answer [which is yes.]". But that's just asking the same question as OP. Does giving credit matter?
The latter would mean "If you felt like you might need to give credit, that the answer to that question matters ethically, then that provides the answer [which is yes, you need to give credit]". But that sounds wrong to me. That kind of logic would turn every positive impulse into an instant obligation.
- brudgers 3y agoEvery ‘it’ is the same. Ethical behavior is erring on the side of caution in the face of uncertainty, ambiguity, or doubt. That’s what makes it ethical behavior. Giving unnecessary credit is not unethical.
- Dylan16807 3y agoDonating to and volunteering for every good cause you see, every time you see it, will bankrupt you and deprive you of sleep pretty fast. You can't err on the side of nicety in every single situation. If an argument depends on there being no cost, then you're not actually making an ethical determination, you're just saying "better safe than sorry". Caution and ethics are not the same thing.
- brudgers 3y agoI didn’t say anything about volunteering.
- Dylan16807 3y agoYour argument was that I should err on the side of ethical behavior every time I'm at all unsure, right? Donating or volunteering is more ethical than not donating or volunteering, right? If both of those are true, then every time I consider donating or volunteering I would be obligated to do it.
- brudgers 3y agoI have been explaining. I am not arguing. It is fine by me for us to have differences of opinion.