5 ms·
Took me less than a few minutes, to find in the same channel, FSD failing and the human having to intervene. Here it is at the proper time and for a video uploa
by belter 3y ago
Took me less than a few minutes, to find in the same channel, FSD failing and the human having to intervene. Here it is at the proper time and for a video uploaded 10 hours ago... - https://youtu.be/KG4yABOlNjk?t=995 https://youtu.be/KG4yABOlNjk?t=995
And even worst failures...looking at all these I simply do not believe the videos posted are not edited or a selection of a success out of many failed ones.
https://youtu.be/KG4yABOlNjk?t=1252 https://youtu.be/KG4yABOlNjk?t=1252
https://youtu.be/WowhH_Xry9s?t=77 https://youtu.be/WowhH_Xry9s?t=77
https://youtu.be/WowhH_Xry9s?t=196 https://youtu.be/WowhH_Xry9s?t=196
Since the video was live on YouTube no editing was done...
These videos are only posting the successful events, we need to see them all. That is why probably Tesla is not putting their money where their mouth is.
- zaroth 3y agoThis is a great example! I hope people will take the time to click and watch it drive. I think it’s a tough call in this case. The Tesla is trying not to block an intersection where a light is green but there’s no room to clear the intersection on the other side due to traffic ahead. In fact an oncoming car is able to turn left in front of the Tesla because it waited. Probably the law is that you should NOT enter the intersection in such a state, but the human nature would be to make a more nuanced judgement of “how bad would it be” to continue thru and possibly get stuck sticking out into the intersection for a bit until traffic moves again. I would think - how long might I be stuck? Would it actual impede other traffic? Also factors like, am I’m late for work? Am I frustrated because traffic has been horrible or am I enjoying a Sunday drive? Ego (Tesla’s name for the driving software) doesn’t get impatient. It can maximally obey all traffic regulations at all times if they code it to do so, even if human drivers behind might be laying on the horn. This little clip really shows how much nuance is involved in designing these systems, and how doing the technically right thing can either be wrong or at least ambiguously right.
- belter 3y agoThat is not the failure. The failure is that would not move anymore and the driver had to intervene and accelerate.
- zaroth 3y agoAt 16:55 thru 17:15? Where he manually accelerates the car and blocks the intersection?
- belter 3y agohttps://youtu.be/KG4yABOlNjk?t=999 https://youtu.be/KG4yABOlNjk?t=999 16:40 to 17:12
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- szundi 3y agoSeemed to be completely OK, a driver who is on the safe side would have just done this exactly
- belter 3y agoIf you stay there, blocking traffic for no reason, and do not proceed when you are clear to go, as it did until the driver accelerated, you will fail a driving license exam in most countries.
- Phil_Latio 3y agoMaybe it would have moved a second later...
- BHSPitMonkey 3y ago"Most countries" would fail a driver for not crossing an intersection until there is space on the other side? I think you're being a little absurd here. The driver in this case could see that the cars beyond the blue car were starting to move, and thus predict that he could cross a little bit early (betting on the space being available by the end of the maneuver, but risking being the ass who ends up blocking the crosswalk after miscalculating).
- rhtgrg 3y ago> The Tesla is trying not to block an intersection where a light is green What light? There is none if you're talking about t=995.
- jondwillis 3y agoLA has an unwritten law where 2-3 cars make unprotected lefts after oncoming traffic has cleared on yellow/red lights. Letting FSD drive, it can’t honor this “cultural” (technically illegal) behavior. If I am operating it, off goes FSD in that moment.
- martythemaniak 3y agoTesla has been specifically reprimanded by NHSTA for allowing FSD to drive like human rather than to the letter of the law. The rolling stops is one I remember, but basically it'll apply to anything.
- toast0 3y agoDude it's totally following the law. You're allowed to enter the intersection for an unprotected left even if it's not clear to turn (possibly not if the end of the intersection you're going to is full of cars). If you are in the intersection, you're allowed to clear when possible regardless of the color of your light. Most intersections with unprotected left turns let you fit at least a whole car, sometimes two in the intersection to wait, and the third car has its front wheels on the paint, so it's totally in the intersection.
- shkkmo 3y agoWhile you are allowed to enter the intersection during a yellow, you are also considered legally to have been warned and would be consider liable if doing so causes an accident. This extra liability would seem like making self driving cars error on the side of stopping to be in the interests of auto makers who would be exposed to that liability.
- illumin8 3y agoIncorrect. As long as your front wheels pass the stop line prior to the light turning red, you are legally driving through the intersection and should continue and clear the intersection on the other side (not stop in the middle). Imagine how crazy the law would be if this were the case: - Light changes from green to yellow 1ms before your front wheels pass the stop line - Other direction traffic runs a red light and hits you from the side - You're now somehow liable because your wheels entered the intersection with zero ability to react quickly enough (no human can react in 1ms and no car can stop that fast) and the other driver that clearly blew a red is not? That would be pants on head crazy, tbh...
- wilg 3y agoI'm not sure exactly your point. The Tesla does sometimes require intervention, that's why it's Level 2. But it's still attempting to drive in significantly more complicated situations than this Drive Pilot thing. Does Drive Pilot stop at stoplights or make turns? I don't think so. Regarding deceptive editing, plenty of people post their Teslas doing squirrely things and them intervening. So it's not like a secret that sometimes you have to intervene.
- belter 3y agoLook at is happening at this point, another additional failure mode, not seen in the links I posted before https://youtu.be/WowhH_Xry9s?t=272 https://youtu.be/WowhH_Xry9s?t=272 See how is confusing the speed limit for cars and trucks, and doing a sudden break. More precisely, at 5:12. So if you have car driving behind you, not expecting the sudden break, this could cause an accident. They are joking with people lives. Ethics matter in Software Engineering.
- iknowstuff 3y agoFYI: Not unique to Tesla, I get plenty of sudden slowdowns when riding Cruise.
- AbrahamParangi 3y agoAttempting and failing is clearly, clearly worse for the general public and in my opinion Tesla should be strictly liable.
- wilg 3y agoIt's not necessarily worse, since there is a person driving the car who can prevent the car from behaving badly. What's the safety difference between this and a regular cruise control, which will happily plow you into a wall or car if you don't intervene? And, empirically, there's no evidence that these cars are less safe when driving this way. Tesla claims people driving with FSD enabled have 4x fewer accidents than those driving without it, and nobody has presented any data that disputes that.
- jondwillis 3y agoAnecdotally, in LA, I turn off FSD basically every minute while trying to use it, due to it doing something slightly “inhuman” or not ideal/too to the letter of the law, signaling incorrectly while staying in a lane that curves slightly, etc. I can’t imagine letting it go for a full hour without causing some road rage or traffic blockage. To be clear there is a definite driving “culture” in LA that is very permissive and aggressive (out of necessity). FSD doesn’t follow this culture.
- belter 3y agoNow imagine it trying to manage a Dutch Roundabout - https://youtu.be/41XBzAOmmIU https://youtu.be/41XBzAOmmIU or driving in a city like OPorto - https://youtu.be/VIWikUUl5YQ https://youtu.be/VIWikUUl5YQ
- rlupi 3y agoOr Naples https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dCE1aUkeMe0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dCE1aUkeMe0
- belter 3y agoWell I was trying to still give a chance to FSD, but as you are raising the stakes...Let's agree to have Marrakech as the baseline - https://youtu.be/SsZlduEIyPQ https://youtu.be/SsZlduEIyPQ And we can also test it in Ho Chi Minh. Tesla says it has superhuman abilities... - https://youtu.be/1ZupwFOhjl4 https://youtu.be/1ZupwFOhjl4
- LeoPanthera 3y ago> signaling incorrectly while staying in a lane that curves slightly This is super annoying, but the most recent FSD update seems to have mostly fixed that. It's still pretty crappy in a lot of other ways, but at least that improved.
- noja 3y ago> but the most recent FSD update seems to have mostly fixed that. I have read this comment before.
- shdshdshd 3y agoNow, lets see Mercedes ones...
- kbos87 3y agoI’m left wondering what this comment proves? The four situations you posted were the most minor of minor annoyances when the car was being too cautious, and you’ve decided they must be cherry picked without any evidence given.
- belter 3y agoIt's shows the system does not have a semantic understanding of what is happening. That is why he stops so far away from the gate, it does not know it is a gate. This is another one, definitely one of my favorite examples ( at correct time) - https://youtu.be/2u6AgLuwVqI?t=86 https://youtu.be/2u6AgLuwVqI?t=86
- fastball 3y agoBut the Mercedes system has a semantic idea of what is happening?
- belter 3y agoThey don't need. They are not trying to achieve Level 5 and are not relying only on cameras. Notice also on this example: https://youtu.be/gzcR8RaC3-g?t=397 https://youtu.be/gzcR8RaC3-g?t=397 They have a driver attention detection system, that works even with dark glasses, as the driver in this case. Also even if you do not take over in the 10 seconds, like in the case for example of the driver fainting, or having a heart attack, the car will stop safely on the side of the road, alert emergency services, and unlock the doors for first responders.
- KennyBlanken 3y agoTesla not only isn't putting their money where their mouth is, they have a lond-standing history of using illegal DMCA takedowns to remove these sorts of videos from Twitter, reddit, Facebook, etc.
- iknowstuff 3y agoIncorrect
- elif 3y agoWhy don't you find a video of FSD failing on a 40mph highway with no lane changes for an apples to apples comparison... Oh wait that is an unreasonably niche scenario to be worthy of consideration in the context of full autonomy.
- belter 3y agoWill almost accelerating straight into the guard rail at 30 mph do it? - https://youtu.be/sNBEHumIHJI?t=14 https://youtu.be/sNBEHumIHJI?t=14 https://www.carscoops.com/2022/05/tesla-driver-claims-model-x-in-autopilot-veered-off-road-mounted-guard-rail-in-australia/ https://www.carscoops.com/2022/05/tesla-driver-claims-model-...
- fallingknife 3y agoThat road is not within the operating requirements of the Mercedes L3 which is only allowed on highways where such turns are never found.
- bhauer 3y agoPlus it's a U-turn situation on ancient version of FSD Beta from two years ago (see the dotted lines in the display, or the YouTube upload date for that matter) that did not support U-turns. And it's not necessarily clear it wasn't going to brake more abruptly if the driver had not intervened.
- Espressosaurus 3y ago2 years ago is ancient for a feature that was supposed to be delivered in 2016?
- fallingknife 3y agoThey are trying to build something that has never been built before, and your criticism is that they are late?
- belter 3y ago"Watch the Self-Driving Struggle" - https://youtu.be/2u6AgLuwVqI?t=88 https://youtu.be/2u6AgLuwVqI?t=88