10 ms·
If Android is a "stolen product," then so was the iPhone
- amartya916 15y agoBy the way, a much better and more detailed commentary can be found here: http://www.billbuxton.com/multitouchOverview.html http://www.billbuxton.com/multitouchOverview.html Bill Buxton is currently a Research Scientist at MSR and he more than knows what he's talking about.
- binarybits 15y agoI link to that page in my story. I tried to interview Buxton but Microsoft's PR people turned me down.
- amartya916 15y agoSorry, I'd missed that link in your article. Although I don't claim to know him personally, I've interacted with him a few times and I know that he takes an interest in getting the mainstream tech. media to cover or correct popular myths (such as Apple pioneering multi-touch). Next time around, drop him an e-mail. Never hurts to ask, although I know why Microsoft's PR might have turned you down :).
- binarybits 15y agoI did email him. He told me I needed to go through Microsoft PR, and after I explained the topic of my story Microsoft PR declined to let me talk to him.
- ceejayoz 15y agoIf you focus only on the single feature that is multi-touch, sure, but it's the entire package that likely pissed Jobs off. Pre-iPhone, Android's demo phones looked like a BlackBerry clone: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Android_mobile_phone_platform_early_device.jpg http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Android_mobile_phone_platf...
- kenrikm 15y agoApple did not invent multitouch however they did invent how it was used to make a phone with a very specific interface that was then copied feature for feature by Google who had intimate knowledge of its design.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- bunderbunder 15y agoPre-iPhone, they were also demoing devices that did not look quite so much like Blackberry clones: http://www.osnews.com/story/25264/Did_Android_Really_Look_Like_BlackBerry_Before_the_iPhone_ http://www.osnews.com/story/25264/Did_Android_Really_Look_Li...
- gnaffle 15y agoNovember 2007 isn't exactly pre-iPhone?
- ceejayoz 15y ago> We're talking November 12 2007 iPhone was announced January 2007 and released June 2007. That's hardly pre-iPhone.
- tcskeptic 15y agoAnd I think the real point of contention was that Eric Schmidt was a member of the Apple board starting a year before that and as such had seen early iPhone prototypes. That in particular is what Jobs was angry about.
- wisty 15y agoI can guess why that's a much bigger point of contention. Steve Jobs must have really sold the board on the viability of next-gen smart phones: "guys - our work on iPods shows us we are just about at the point where almost-PC-class processors, RAM, and hard drives can be crammed into a mobile-phone sized package, without wiping out the battery in 12 hours. You know what will happen next?" If that was the reason Google put so much effort into Android, then Google effectively stole Apple's strategy. Sure, some random Googlers would have thought of it, but it may not have been sold as well at the top level. Remember, Steve Jobs was an unbelievably good strategy salesman. It's inevitable then that Android would follow the market leader - that's what products do.
- jbrennan 15y agoI'm not sure anyone is arguing the iPhone invented all these individual technologies, and if anyone is claiming that, they shouldn't be as the evidence is overwhelming to the contrary. I think the real meat of the argument is "iPhone synthesized all those individual pieces into something coherent and incredible.". It's kind of like how the Macintosh and Lisa took the ideas from PARC, perfected them, and turned them into a real product. I think the stink is being made that Android is copying that aspect of the iPhone, instead of just a piece or two. Maybe that's not what's actually being argued, but that's what I think should be argued at least.
- horv 15y ago"I'm not sure anyone is arguing the iPhone invented all these individual technologies, and if anyone is claiming that, they shouldn't be as the evidence is overwhelming to the contrary." Isn't that what the current legal battle over slide to unlock is over? I'll be the first to agree that the iPhone put all the pieces together, but it seems like every other week there's a new lawsuit over some iPhone or Android feature that is more of a common sense thing and probably shouldn't have been granted a patent.
- fpgeek 15y agoThe battle over slide-to-unlock is particularly ludicrous because neither Apple nor Android invented it. To the best of my knowledge that honor (in the context of a smartphone) belongs to Neonode with their N1m (though I wouldn't be at all surprised to find out someone had anticipated them, as well).
- angersock 15y agoI mean, do we really want to support synthesis of other people's work as something that can be protected legally? Especially when most development nowadays is clicking cogs together anyways? This doesn't seem like a meme we should seek to perpetuate.
- 0x44 15y agoIf the resulting synthesis is something new, why wouldn't we want to protect it legally? To make a literary analogy, any book written in an established genre necessarily synthesizes work that went before it… are these new works less worthy of legal protection because the ideas and tropes (and in the case of works synthesized from the Commons characters, setting, etc.) are things we've already seen? In the technology fields, it is common to base new innovation on that which came before. So long as the prior art is referenced in the claim for protection, aren't the useful arts strengthened by legal protection in exchange for continued disclosure of innovation, even in the case of innovations synthesized of prior development?
- sbuk 15y agoArs is getting worse.
- sbuk 15y agoAs is Hacker News apparently. It's a trollbait article that say nothing of merit or value. Frankly I'd've said the same were it a story about Android being a rip off of iOS. You 'haters' of whatever denomination are just ridiculous and it's about time you all grow the fuck up.
- binarybits 15y agoDid you read the article or just the headline? You can disagree with my conclusions but I think patent policy is an important topic.
- sbuk 15y agoHow arrogant. Yes I read your opinion piece. As I said, you have said nothing new. You have added nothing to the debate except for regurgitating the same old trite arguments to drive yet another pointless flame war over a topic that is of actual important. And the net result is merely more ill-informed opinion.
- infiniteburp 15y agoSteve Jobs saying he's going to spend billions and billions on frivolous lawsuits should make still independent developers wary about getting boxed into his walled "ecosystem". Perhaps it's time to revise the laws on "thought property" to declaw the patent and copyright industries. We need more competition, not more "I have a lot of money therefore I get even more money" monopolies. Geez. Patent law is just turning into a subsidy for Silicon Valley.
- fpgeek 15y agoOf course, all of those lawsuits might also make independent developers think that the only "safe" place is his walled "ecosystem". Yes, you pay taxes and you live at the pleasure of the king, but at least most of the time he's more interested fighting with the enemies outside than the subjects inside.
- zefhous 15y ago> Jobs called Android a "stolen product," but theft can be a tricky concept when talking about innovation. This article is heartily missing the point. Android is basically a stolen product. It's a direct successor and competitor to the iPhone, and the direction of Android in it's current form has been and is extremely influenced by what Apple has been doing. Sure, the iPhone is a bunch of "stolen" technologies and ideas, but Apple brought them together to make something great in a way that had never been done before. What Apple did took vision, discipline, and execution. That is what Apple brought to the table, and that is what innovation is. Nobody was making products that resembled the iPhone before Apple, but now everyone is trying. We don't need to get all emotional about this. This doesn't have anything to do with the quality of the products, it's just the history about how this stuff came about. You are still free to like Android or WebOS or iOS or whatever you want. It's fine. Just recognize innovation for what it is.
- nextparadigms 15y agoLook around in any industry you want. How would you define competition, if nothing but very similar products to the original product of that type in that particular market? This video describes very well how inventions get created and then evolve for the benefit of everyone: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wq5D43qAsVg http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wq5D43qAsVg
- wvenable 15y ago> Nobody was making products that resembled the iPhone before Apple That's blatantly false. Every smartphone I owned going back to 2003 resembled the iPhone. Smartphones of the day either resembled the iPhone or they resembled the blackberry but both designs were out there in number. After the iPhone was released almost everyone dropped their blackberry-like designs (except for RIM). Apple's innovation was the capacitive multi-touch screen and finger-friendly interface. I'm not even sure that's a revolution just an evolution of existing designs.
- nwjsmith 15y ago> That's blatantly false. Every smartphone I owned going back to 2003 resembled the iPhone. Which phones?
- freyrs3 15y agoIndustries converge around good ideas. This isn't "stealing", its progress.
- nextparadigms 15y agoI agree. Apple had a lot of great ideas for their phone, and sooner or later someone would've copied them to be able to compete in the same type of market, and then build on that platform. In turn Apple ended up copying some of the later ideas from their competitors, too. It's how progress happens. Too bad people are so quick to blame others with "stealing" when this happens.
- fudged 15y agoI thought 'we' as a tech community had moved passed this. It's been dragged through the mud time and time again.
- YooLi 15y agoArs must he hurting for some ad impressions.
- discreteevent 15y agoBell Labs and Xerox Parc. I wonder what percentage of the contemporary computing experience wasn't invented in either of those places.
- Apple-Guy 15y agoThe problem is, Apple made the unfinished parc products usable, and invented drag and drop. Here from page 4 of an article: http://obamapacman.com/2010/03/myth-copyright-theft-apple-stole-gui-from-xerox-parc-alto/4/ http://obamapacman.com/2010/03/myth-copyright-theft-apple-st...
- jff 15y agoWhat's that, Apple-Guy? A website billing itself as "Apple iPhone, iPad 2, iPod News, Celebrity Mac Users, and More" claims that Apple did all the real, important work? Wow!
- YooLi 15y agoPoor article. Show multitouch before the iPhone, show "touchable" screens before the iPhone, conclude the iPhone was just a copy. Meanwhile all phones since the iPhone look a heck of a lot like it.
- binarybits 15y agoI'm pretty sure I didn't say "the iPhone was just a copy."
- sirclueless 15y agoLet me put this in hacker terminology: Have you ever looked at someone else's product and said, "Well that's stupid, I could remake it in a week and it would be even better"? But even if that were true, you weren't the one who took the risk and built the damn thing. Other people here are talking about "vision" and "innovation" and while these are certainly things Apple had in abundance, the bottom line is that Samsung's lack of vision is not what Apple is complaining about. It's all about risk: Apple took a risk, they pioneered a whole metaphor of a smartphone made of a giant touchscreen and little packaged apps. They had to convince a whole legion of consumers that their highly simplified interface was the elegant solution they needed, and that takes a lot of money and a lot of risk. Now Apple wants their day in the sun to last as long as possible, they want as much of the payoff from the risks they took as possible, and they feel entitled to a degree of exclusivity.
- vacri 15y agoThe sword cuts both ways - here on HN we've had a number of stories about the 'little guy' who makes a software package (eg cloud music manager), taking the risk, then apple comes along and implements the same thing, destroying the little guy. The little guy takes risk that's big from his point of view - does this mean he's entitled not to be copied by Apple?
- fpgeek 15y agoAnd Motorola took a risk on the cell phone in the first place and Rio took a risk (including a make-or-break lawsuit) on the first mp3 player and on and on... Has Apple been fair to those companies by their own standard?
- rbarooah 15y agoWasn't Steve Job's comment driven by his belief that Eric Schmidt used his insider knowledge of the iPhone project to inform the direction of the Android team? It seems to me that he wasn't calling it stolen because it was a similar product - other comments of his indicate that he was was well aware that the technology would be cloned. He was calling it stolen because he felt the time-to-market advantage had been stolen by an insider who breached his trust. I think this is what drove his animosity. Android is obviously deeply influenced by the iPhone. The iPhone is obviously influenced by a whole load of other products (though not to quite the same extent). What makes it 'stealing' is whether the influence was underhand or not. We don't know whether Eric Schmidt did use inside information in breach of trust, but if he did then Jobs' position seems a lot more supportable.
- arjn 15y agoFunny how the article mentions the LG Prada pre-dating the iPhone and then dismisses it. The software would of course be different but the LG Prada's physical design - full capacitive touchscree etc. - was public knowledge before the iPhone came out (and they also won a couple of awards for the design) : http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LG_Prada http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LG_Prada
- j45 15y agoMy Palm Treo was the original smartphone. Blackberry, iPhone, and everyone else stole from that. No wonder Apple has never sued Palm, or now HP who owns all the IP. Palm had half the iPhone probably patented lol.
- joenathan 15y agoIt appears that the majority of people commenting haven't even read the article...
- DanBC 15y agoThe iPhone isn't even the first thing called an iPhone with a touchscreen that makes telephone calls and connects to the internet. From 1997: (http://groups.google.com/group/comp.dcom.telecom/msg/f62a1ffc289424ba?dmode=source http://groups.google.com/group/comp.dcom.telecom/msg/f62a1ff...)
- vacri 15y agoWell... that's a desktop phone, not a mobile, but true, it's branded an 'iphone', connects to the internet, makes calls, and has apps http://aaworldtrade.com/phones-accessories.html http://aaworldtrade.com/phones-accessories.html
- ricardobeat 15y agoThe article goes a great length to mention other companies' and persons' accomplishments in the field, all the while completely ignoring Apple's research on it since the 80s. They get to the point themselves: Indeed, what made the iPhone such a great product was precisely that Apple drew together a number of innovations already developed separately—touchscreen phones, capacitive touchscreens, sophisticated multitouch user interfaces—and combined them in a product greater than the sum of its parts. And then Android just imitated that precise sum of parts (full touchscreen, swipe gestures, on-screen keyboard, apps, desktop-class browser, accelerometer, great graphics...). Android looked nothing like it is today before the iPhone OS.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- caycep 15y agoI suspect it isn't so much the design (although as has been pointed out the jump from treo-like to iphone-like is telling), but that a member of a board of directors used his access to proprietary company secrets/internal information to directly benefit a competitor company - its a conflict of interest issue at best, and corporate data theft at worst. And I think Jobs took it personally because the Larry, Sergei, and maybe even Schmidt had soliticed his mentorship and advice and for them to turn around and do this to him would seem to me like it would be felt as a personal betrayal.
- shpoonj 15y agoThis conversation should have ended years ago... Are people really still bickering?
- 51Cards 15y agoRe: IBM's 1993 Simon: "The e-mail app even included the ability to click on a phone number to dial it." Would that not constitute prior art in one of the patents Apple asserted against Android recently? I am only vaguely aware of the finer details so I'm probably mistaken on some point.
- fpgeek 15y agoActually, it would. Apple is asserting a patent (from 1996) against Android's "Linkify" functionality which does exactly that. Other prior art would be Ward Cunningham's WikiWikiWeb (1994/1995) for turning CamelCase into links and, my personal favorite, Netscape Navigator 2.0b1, for "Live URLs" (that recognized URLs and email addresses in mail and news text and made them clickable). I've been following this off and on, and AFAICT, HTC didn't bring up any of these piece of prior art, which makes me seriously question the quality of their prior art searches.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- bane 15y agoI swear to god, this would be such a non-issue if people would just stop acting like human history started with the release date of their favorite Apple product.
- noble 15y agoHow Similar is a Galaxy Nexus to iPhone 4S ? My question is , who is leading and who is following?
- fpgeek 15y agoAt this point that depends on what you consider important.