6 ms·
48 hours will not even ding reddit. Do it for a month and it will count, assuming reddit doesn't simply re-enable the subreddits. But obviously the mods here ar
by jacquesm 3y ago
48 hours will not even ding reddit. Do it for a month and it will count, assuming reddit doesn't simply re-enable the subreddits. But obviously the mods here are walking a fine line between pissing off their users and getting reddit to bend over.
With camarades.com we had a week long outage because of a fire in EV1's DC which then caused the fire marshal to shut everything down for a week (I don't blame them, but that's a failure mode we had not considered). This caused us to go dark completely without an easy way to reach the users to tell them what was going on.
When power came back traffic was where it was before within 20 minutes, and the next day we even had a surge in traffic that we didn't ever pass again. If you really want to see an effect I would suggest a period somewhere between two weeks and a month backed up by a threat to do it for three months if they don't recant. That would have some serious teeth in it and threatens to completely derail any IPO plans they might have.
Anything less and you're just showing that it is reddit that is the boss, not you. A good rule for a community is that if it isn't your domain, database and server it isn't really your community.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Mindwipe 3y agoReddit admin are bricking themselves to be resorting to telling moderators that they will only make better moderation tools if their subs don't participate, so they clearly don't agree 48 hours is an idle threat.
- thumbuddy 3y agoWriting two sentences to scare a handful of people isn't exactly showing their hand...
- Aaargh20318 3y ago> 48 hours will not even ding reddit. I don't think the direct losses of the 48 outage will be what matters here. Rumors are that Reddit wants to IPO later this year. This blackout will put the spotlight on two issues: - Reddit is extremely dependent on the goodwill of the community, especially the moderators who provide an essential service for free. - Reddit is out of touch with its own community, and keeps pissing off the very people their existence depends upon. If I were planning to invest in Reddit, this would make me think twice.
- jacquesm 3y agoReddit has some pretty powerful tools at its disposal to re-enable those subreddits and then they can ask who wants to moderate them instead, I think there will be plenty of takers, if the community is in sync with the mods then the mods' play will succeed otherwise the mods are just putting themselves out of business. This whole thing is a nice illustration how when you use someone else's website for your community you don't actually own the community.
- feyes 3y agoPeople should just go back to forums. It was better when I didn't know about the absolute nutcases and always felt like forum information was superior to the stuff I find on Reddit.
- izzydata 3y agoThis is what I want to happen although I know it never will. Communities used to be spread out across the internet on individual sites that were maintained by enthusiasts as a hobby. I found the interactions among such communities to bar far more enjoyable. Once any community reaches a threshold of users it starts to get unpleasant.
- hipposec 3y agoI think the other thing that made forums a better place was the absence of a upvote/downvote system. It reduced the motivation of just chasing attention with little jokes and threads could stay on the front page so long as there was active conversation going on.
- bombcar 3y agoForums were also dedicated to "mostly related" things (like a subreddit) and it was a bit of effort to create a new account on a different forum, and you were obviously new at that point. So "brigading" and such weren't really much of an issue (and the issue has always been people barging into a community, knowing nothing about it, pontificating on some post/issue, and promptly leaving). Forums still exist, but you need a slightly strange sort of person to continue to put the effort into them when Reddit is "free and easy".
- wraptile 3y ago> 48 hours will not even ding reddit. I feel like 48 hour long outage for a social media website is huge. That's 2 days for people to look around at alternatives. Remember when google plus launches FB argued that they had zero hours to lose and they were kinda right.
- jacquesm 3y agoIt's only 48 hours if reddit lets it.
- alpaca128 3y agoReddit can't force the moderators to return early. Letting it run with no moderation for 48 hours is far more damaging than a temporary interruption.
- jacquesm 3y agoReddit can solicit new mods and ban the old ones. It's probably the quickest way out for reddit and users will likely hardly notice except for those subreddits where the mods are very closely associated with the community itself. But that's definitely not the bulk of them and not the larger ones, though there are some exceptions.
- alpaca128 3y agoAssembling new moderators for 3000+ subreddits on such short notice sounds a bit difficult.
- jacquesm 3y agoI don't think it's all that difficult. Message the top 100 contributors of every subreddit that goes dark to ask if they want to be mods, and if they say yes put them on a two month trial. I remember when Ronald Reagan fired all air traffic controllers in the US, that definitely had me wondering about the wisdom of the move and yet it went off without a hitch. Not a single plane crashed on account of that. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Professional_Air_Traffic_Controllers_Organization_(1968) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Professional_Air_Traffic_Contr...
- hoppyhoppy2 3y agoThere's another fine line the mods walk: in the past the reddit admins have threatened to simply clean house and appoint new subreddit moderators in the event of an extended subreddit blackout.
- jacquesm 3y agoI think I covered that?
- api 3y agoTwitter has proven that not even that would matter. Network effects are too powerful. People use Reddit therefore people will use Reddit. Once a company has a large enough network effect they can do almost anything and people won’t leave. I’ve come to believe that it’s the most powerful form of lock in.
- thumbuddy 3y agoThanks to LLMs traffic can be artificially boosted to the point where ghost towns feel like they have momentum. That problem just won't be getting any better.
- jacquesm 3y agoI actually did quit Twitter and nothing will be able to make me go back there. Principles and all that. But I suspect that the fraction of people that followed through on their statement that they would leave Twitter is super small. I also haven't gone anywhere else and I feel much the better for it.
- redeeman 3y ago[flagged]
- jacquesm 3y agoThis does not follow.
- dang 3y agoHey, can you please stop posting unsubstantive and flamebait comments? We already had to ask you that (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34972773 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34972773) and it's still mostly what your account is doing. We have to ban that sort of account. I don't want to ban you because you've also posted some fine comments - e.g. these: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36234093 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36234093 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36125818 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36125818 but unfortunately we have to moderate by the bad things people post, not the good things. If you wouldn't mind reviewing https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and taking the intended spirit of the site more to heart, we'd be grateful.
- casenmgreen 3y agoThis argument, regardless of its factual correctness regarding the impact on Reddit, is an argument of helplessness - it argues there is no point in acting, because nothing will be achieved. Sometimes you have to act, even if it will have no effect, because it is the right thing to do, where our sense of moral indignation is so great we are motivated to act regardless of the overall outcome or what we may or may not reasonable expect to achieve.
- jacquesm 3y agoIt simply points out what the ground rules are, if you want to make a point then you can do that but it won't amount to much if it doesn't lead to results. There are actions that would be much more likely to result in a response, the mods are clearly engaging in a balancing act rather than a principled stance and I predict that if they stay this course they will simply be supplanted by more pliable individuals. A credible threat requires some actual work and preparation, not just the clicking of a link that another party controls anyway.
- lewisflude 3y agoI agree, this won't by itself ding Reddit enough to properly move the needle, however it will raise awareness massively, and suddenly every user who has noticed a subreddit they follow has gone dark will have a "take" on how they feel about the whole situation. I think what Reddit would prefer is a "rip off the bandaid" situation where they just get all this over and done with as quickly as possible, with the least amount of noise possible. I think this is one major reason that until the AMA that's happening today, all official communication has been happening in backchannels despite effecting a large number of Reddit users, whether they are effected directly by a 3rd party app going away, or indirectly, by a subreddit they are a member of being moderated with worse tools.
- thumbuddy 3y ago[flagged]
- meowkit 3y agoThis second paragraph is extremely unhinged. I would suggest reevaluating beliefs here.
- seanalltogether 3y ago> But obviously the mods here are walking a fine line between pissing off their users and getting reddit to bend over. I'm actually surprised reddit hadn't introduced more democratic options for controlling subreddits that reach a certain size. There may be a lot of users that really don't care about 3rd party apps and want to keep their content flowing
- OkayPhysicist 3y agoI think you're misinterpreting how mass protests work: unlike, say, a strike, the goal doesn't have to be to directly apply pain to the target until they yield. Instead, a large scale protest demonstrates, first and foremost, the ability of the opposition to organize (lending credence to the threat of further, more extreme action), and to pull more people into the organized opposition. A two-day blackout is a warning shot.
- jacquesm 3y agoYes, I totally understand the principle, but the persons creating the blackout are themselves entirely optional and they don't seem to fully realize this. Protests are much stronger if you have a viable alternative lined up. They don't have any.
- sangnoir 3y ago> Do it for a month and it will count, assuming reddit doesn't simply re-enable the subreddits Any subreddit that does this will have the community forked before the end of the first week - without the involvement of Reddit Inc.
- PUSH_AX 3y agoThey are the boss..