12 ms·
Could seaweed be the 'fastest and least expensive' tool to fight climate change?
- bthallplz 3y agohttps://archive.is/F0tHC https://archive.is/F0tHC
- quijoteuniv 3y agoNo (to the question in the title), this is someone trying to sell a magic solution. You do not need to fight climate change, we need to stop it. And the first thing that needs to stop is the greed of the superrich. Unless the seaweed gives a conscience to the superrich then no, seaweed cannot help.
- nadermx 3y agoHow do you stop it? I don't think the greed of the super rich is per say the problem. Perhaps there needs to be a shift in economic incentive
- NumberWangMan 3y agoYes. A revenue-neutral carbon tax (often called "Carbon Fee & Dividend") is a politically feasible, fast, efficient way to reduce carbon emissions. To drive emissions down to zero, without massive economic disruption, start small and increase the tax gradually every year. Coupled with a "border adjustment" (a tariff on goods coming from countries to compensate if they have less aggressive climate policies) you can solve the problem of industries being outsourced to countries where GHG pollution is cheaper, and simultaneously put pressure on those countries to implement similar policies.
- appleiigs 3y agoEasier to blame the 1% for 99% of the problems.
- olddustytrail 3y agoIt certainly is when they're to blame.
- Tiktaalik 3y agoWe need to make it profitable to do the good things and not profitable to do the bad things. This way people will do the good things and not the bad things. The most straight forward way to do this would be to make doing the bad things more expensive, which means taxing carbon emissions. Alongside this would be to create alternatives that are cheaper and easier to use. Unfortunately this would mean actually spending money, making investments in public works, and changing things away from the status quo, and apparently this is impossible. So we're going to sleep walk into our doom rather than do basic things like making gas more expensive and building public transit.
- worik 3y ago> The most straight forward way to do this would be to make doing the bad things more expensive, which means taxing carbon emissions. Yes. This is the solution starting in 1990. It is too late now, for this to be the solution. It is a good idea, but. We are going to have to shut down hole industries, and the owners will loose their investment. We are going to have to make a lot of very rich people, ordinarily rich. This is very hard to do in a democracy.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- snapcaster 3y agoOkay cool, so what is your timeline for how long will it take to stop humans from being greedy? You realize any solution that is "rich people stop being greedy" is no solution at all?
- ethanbond 3y agoWhat do you think nation states are? They’re systems to prevent “most muscular and monstrous man wins everything.” We build such systems all the time and they do appear to be stable. The modern world couldn’t exist without their success.
- svachalek 3y agoAre you thinking of democracy or something? There are plenty of nation states that are simply "most muscular and monstrous man wins everything".
- snapcaster 3y agoNation states are able to retain stability while having greedy rich actors. That's why it's a solution and yours isn't
- bequanna 3y agoWho are these greedy people exactly? “Being greedy” is having food on the table, a roof over my head, and a few nice things?
- ben_w 3y agoEach of those words may be carrying more load than you intended. Food on the table — Rice, lentils, peas: not greedy; Beef burgers, caviar, civet coffee: kinda is. Roof over your head — traditional hut, not greedy; penthouse suite in Dubai, greedy. A few nice things? So many options. Once was, aluminium and purple(!) both cost more than gold. Is it "a nice thing" or "greedy" for me to fly to some paradise island for a week vacation? Or to own a fursuit? Or a normal suit? Or to get an electric bike instead of a manual one? (I'm in favour of raising everyone to the level of current royalty; I think this can be done without wrecking everything, but we have to solve some problems first).
- prottog 3y ago> You do not need to fight climate change, we need to stop it. The correct answer is neither; we need advanced technologies and material wealth that will allow us to master the environment more robustly. Consider that in the past 50 years of climate change, the human population more than doubled yet the number of deaths from climate-related causes dropped to one-third[0], mainly due to the growing wealth of developing countries that allowed them to better shield themselves against extreme weather conditions. The state of man in nature is "solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short". Anyone who has spent any time outdoors in remote places or tried to build even a rudimentary shelter knows how true that is. There has never been a time when the climate was conducive to human flourishing except when humans made it that way by ever-increasing per capita energy expenditures; hence today, despite everything, we are the most insulated from the effects of climate on ourselves. To "stop" climate change is like telling Glurg the caveman no, you cannot light that stick on fire to keep yourself warm, because think of the CO2 emissions! [0]: https://library.wmo.int/doc_num.php?explnum_id=10989 https://library.wmo.int/doc_num.php?explnum_id=10989
- rhaway84773 3y agoWe already have the technology.
- ethanbond 3y agoWe also extincted broad swaths of our ecosystem while keeping the rich westerners well air-conditioned. So… you know. No free lunch. Hope we, as biological creatures borne of a billion-year old evolutionary process, don’t actually need the system that birthed us (for some reason).
- prottog 3y agoMy sincere hope is that the poor non-Westerners will also be well air-conditioned. And yes, you are quite right that there is no free lunch. In my analysis, the opportunity cost of going all-in on degrowth and solar/wind is precisely that the global poor will remain poor. I'm by no means advocating that we destroy nature for the fun of it! But if the alternative is between us destroying nature or nature destroying us, I know which side I'm going to pick.
- StrangeATractor 3y ago[flagged]
- qup 3y agoYou just attacked NG in the same breath where you confessed you don't even read it. I'll take my chances that the NG reporters put in more effort, at the very least.
- ecommerceguy 3y agohttps://www.nationalgeographic.com/magazine/article/editors-note-gender https://www.nationalgeographic.com/magazine/article/editors-... Hardly Bible themed...
- blondie9x 3y agoThis kind of reminds me of what Marine BioEnergy is trying to do with kelp harvesting https://www.marinebiomass.com/ https://www.marinebiomass.com/ to make biofuel.
- foota 3y agoI wonder how much you'd need to farm to have an equilibrium reduction in fossil fuels (e.g., trap carbon in in flight kelp)
- dpflan 3y agoHere are more related HN posts 1. Banking on the Seaweed Rush - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35322725 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35322725 2. Ocean Farming: Seaweed is having its moment in the sun - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35176560 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35176560
- dang 3y agoThanks! Macroexpanded: Banking on the Seaweed Rush - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35322725 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35322725 - March 2023 (46 comments) Ocean Farming: Seaweed is having its moment in the sun - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35176560 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35176560 - March 2023 (45 comments) Amazon funds seaweed farming at offshore wind farm to test CO2 capture - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34839380 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34839380 - Feb 2023 (91 comments) Feeding cows seaweed cuts 99% of greenhouse gas emissions from their burps - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28243731 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28243731 - Aug 2021 (59 comments) Red seaweed supplementation reduces enteric methane by over 80% in beef steers - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26540737 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26540737 - March 2021 (289 comments) Feeding cattle seaweed reduces their greenhouse gas emissions 82% - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26495536 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26495536 - March 2021 (9 comments) Australia to produce seaweed cattle feed that reduces methane emissions by 80% - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24574992 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24574992 - Sept 2020 (314 comments) Tasty Seaweed Reduces Cows’ Methane Emissions by 99% - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20711498 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20711498 - Aug 2019 (393 comments) A diet supplemented with red algae could reduce greenhouse gases emitted by cows - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18521471 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18521471 - Nov 2018 (20 comments) Feeding cows seaweed cuts 99% of greenhouse gas emissions from their burps - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18385384 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18385384 - Nov 2018 (82 comments) Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmosphere than expected (2017) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17704479 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17704479 - Aug 2018 (159 comments) Seaweed in Cow Feed Reduces Methane Emissions Almost Entirely - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17036221 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17036221 - May 2018 (264 comments) Scientist discovers particular seaweed nearly eliminates cow methane emissions - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12998395 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12998395 - Nov 2016 (147 comments)
- Eumenes 3y agoBetteridge's law of headlines is an adage that states: "Any headline that ends in a question mark can be answered by the word no."
- choeger 3y agoWhich would imply there's at least one tool that is either faster or less expensive, which would be good news, wouldn't it?
- Vecr 3y agoNukes. Already paid for, so no more cost. Faster, should stop most emissions in a few weeks, after the fires go out.
- sitkack 3y agoIsn't apparent that a Nuclear Winter would actually occur. Now if we could nuke the moon and cause a dust ring to form ...
- qup 3y ago> Does Betteridge's Law of Headlines Reveal a Lifehack For Climate Change? No.
- 3y ago
- jansan 3y agoNo, blowing H2S and SO2 into the stratosphere is cheaper.
- marssaxman 3y agoThe probability that this will end up happening leaves me feeling glad to be mortal.
- UncleOxidant 3y agoAs in glad you won't live long enough to see it?
- jfengel 3y agoI'm certainly glad that I won't ever have to say, "Yeah, global acid rain seems like a good answer to the problem of global warming." But only because I'll be dead, and it will be other people having to say it.
- FrustratedMonky 3y agoWait? Is someone really planning to do it? I just read 'Termination Shock' and it was big plot point. Didn't think anybody would really do it.
- marssaxman 3y agoI don't know of any such plans, but it seems unlikely that global industrial civilization will reduce its CO2 emissions anytime soon, which means that very hard times are coming for billions of people's children. Someone will be desperate enough to try it.
- jansan 3y agoI do not understand this logic. Only because something has a certain probability of happening makes you glad to be mortal? If you could choose now between being mortal and immortal, would you choose mortality because there is a certain probability that SO2 and H2S will be blown into the stratosphere? BTW, I am not advocating this approach. I just wanted to answer the question in the headline which can only be a clear "No".
- eklitzke 3y agoIt's a cool idea but I don't see how this is a viable long term solution, even if done at a large scale. Global oil production is on the order of 90M barrels/year, each barrel contains about 300 lbs of oil, so we're currently producing something like 27B lbs (~12B kg) of oil per year. I'm not sure how much of this ends up as CO2 in the atmosphere versus e.g. plastics, but I think it's safe to say we're probably emitting at least 1B lbs/kg carbon into the atmosphere per year just based on these numbers. Seaweed grows quickly, but it's almost entirely water by mass, and this strategy will really only work in coastal regions. If this strategy was adopted at a wide scale globally how much time does this really buy us? And this isn't even considering things like the unknown ecological effects of the plan.
- bobthepanda 3y agoI’m wondering what pitfalls we’ll fall into here. Twenty years ago algae hyped up many of the same benefits and that didn’t really pan out.
- gdudeman 3y agoI like this back-of-the-envelope estimate, but it's even worse than that. The carbon in oil is lightweight relative to the two oxygens it combines with (atomic weights 12 and 16 respectively) from the air, so 1kg of oil emits about 3kg of CO2! Punchline: we emit around 34 gigatons of CO2 per year.
- _fizz_buzz_ 3y agoBut wouldn't it be a carbon chain again in the seaweed without oxygen? So, we can ignore the weight of the oxygen? Still, the numbers are huge. But I think at this point we have try everything at once.
- thechao 3y agoMy argument is that we're probably going to kill the Gulf of Mexico, anyways, with global warming; so, let's go ahead and dump 34 gigatons/year of serpentine in it. That'll 0-out the CO2 we're releasing, at the cost of dramatically changing the Gulf's ecosystem. At this point, I really do think we (humanity) are going to have to make some pretty hard trade-offs.
- pvaldes 3y agoNo The cow burp effect is a myth. With five minutes thinking about it, is easy to see why is a no solution. I have explained here before why will not work. Most of the seaweeds are water. And the dry matter is salty. Coastal areas are extremely busy. You can't remove Honk Kong city to culture seaweeds. You can't block maritime traffic routes to culture seaweeds, or stop all commercial fishing near the shore, or ban tourism. In most areas is a no-way. And there are other problems and obstacles that could be spotted easily by biologists, for example that water temperature is rising.
- worik 3y ago> Coastal areas are extremely busy. No. Ports are busy. The coast is huge. Most of it, on the wet side, is mostly not busy at all Sea lanes are further out, land dwellers on the dry bit.
- pvaldes 3y agoIf you think that you can obtain a permit to put such eyesore as a seaweed farm in front of Copacabana, well... good luck with it. But we could of course build it in the middle of nowhere, and then spend lots of fuel to move the product to the far-far-away markets, and even feel good about our ecological trace for a couple seconds.
- worik 3y ago> permit to put such eyesore as a seaweed farm in front of Copacabana, well... good luck with it. I think you should think about what I actually said. Copacabana is right by a port > But we could of course build it in the middle of nowhere Often, in ,any places, wild and unpopulated wet bits are right beside transport routes on the dry bits. Less than twenty miles from where I sit
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- selimthegrim 3y ago
- rqtwteye 3y agoI am skeptical of any remedy to climate change that’s not reducing emissions. Whatever you do, be it seaweed, carbon capture or other stuff, would have to be done on an insane scale to make a difference. Who knows what the side effects of growing that much seaweed would be ?
- dubcanada 3y agoWhile I agree, how do you recommend we reduce emissions immediately, which is basically when it needs to happen. It seems like largely people just don't care about the environment on a "general global" scale. There are pockets are people/groups/countries that do. But on average people don't. So that leaves really one solution, which is attempting to reduce the amount of existing emissions to stop the rise to some degree, basically prolonging the enviable. I personally think we probably need to just let it happen so we as a species can grow, or at least grow for a few hundred years till we forget.
- WastingMyTime89 3y ago> It seems like largely people just don't care about the environment on a "general global" scale. The issue is not really people. The worst emitters are out of reach from us. It’s good to make people more conscious of their environmental impact but what good does it really make when what is saved is a minute of energy production by the average Chinese coal power plant.
- sokoloff 3y agoMost of the emissions are people-related: https://www.epa.gov/ghgemissions/global-greenhouse-gas-emissions-data#Sector https://www.epa.gov/ghgemissions/global-greenhouse-gas-emiss... People who want food, transportation, electricity, heat, concrete, etc.
- WastingMyTime89 3y agoThat’s a sector breakdown of emission. That doesn’t address my point at all. Everything human is people related at some point or we wouldn’t be doing it. As you can see the most emitting sector is energy production. That’s mostly driven by countries using coal as energy source and countries with significant oil and gas reserves. It is a lever at the strategical and political level. Same with industry where gains are mostly achieved through regulation. Construction is direly in need of innovation regarding its emission but unless you want people to sleep in the street remains somewhat unavoidable. That leaves agricultures where people have a huge role to play by consuming less meat and somewhat transportation (even if that’s actually extremely linked to the offer of effective public transport). For the rest and as much as I would like to believe in it, most actions I see people doing are actually fairly inconsequential in the grand scheme of things. I’m a bit annoyed by it because it somehow lulls people into thinking they are doing something for the problem while the actual issues stay unaddressed.
- Ingaz 3y agoHm. Is that seaweed is edible by other organisms? Then: more food -> more organisms -> more CO2 It's a level of middle school
- chungy 3y agoHumans eat seaweed all the time.
- euroderf 3y agoTangentially: the Japanese rice crackers wrapped in seaweed are num.
- rs999gti 3y agoEating the seaweed would not be sequestered CO2. Your body, like a furnace, would break the seaweed down and re-release the CO2. Better sequestration, would be to grow the seaweed and then bury it. Then in a million years future Earth inhabitants could dig up that broken down seaweed and have a new oil rush.
- feoren 3y ago> It's a level of middle school Which should be a hint to you that it's not anywhere near that simple.
- cpeterso 3y agoFrom 2022: Running Tide is facing scientist departures and growing concerns over seaweed sinking for carbon removal: https://www.technologyreview.com/2022/06/16/1053758/running-tide-seaweed-kelp-scientist-departures-ecological-concerns-climate-carbon-removal/ https://www.technologyreview.com/2022/06/16/1053758/running-... > At least several of the departures were due, in part, to concerns that the company’s executives weren’t paying sufficient attention to the potential ecological effects of its plans. Some employees were also disturbed that Running Tide was discussing more controversial practices, including adding nutrients to the ocean to stimulate macroalgae growth.
- rjtc 3y agoMost of the ocean is desert lacking the limiting nutrients of nitrogen, phosphorous and iron. If we can cheaply fertilize large swathes of the ocean with these limiting nutrients in a controlled manner, then this could trigger massive algae blooms that on sinking sequester massive amounts of carbon.
- analog31 3y agoUnfortunately, fertilizer presently has a large carbon footprint
- fosk 3y agoCan’t fertilizer production emission be compartimentalized?
- sacnoradhq 3y agoFertilizer isn't a singular thing or a hivemind. Terrestrial ag fertilizers don't have to be produced by fossil fuels. The Haber–Bosch process used to make ammonium nitrate can be solar powered instead of using methane. Phosphate rock processing could greenified for a green "green" phosphoric acid wet process. Potassium from potash is mostly a passive solar evap process. For seaweed aquaculture, iron sulfate is used because iron availability is the most frequent limiting factor. It's frequently a byproduct of steel production, in much need of greening itself, and produced in large quantities. Volcanic ash is another abundant source.
- canadianfella 3y ago[dead]
- ben_w 3y agoMany crop fertilisers have that issue, but fertiliser is not only one thing. One hypothesis is that algae are limited by some single resource which could be gradually dropped out the back of cargo ships as they cross oceans, seeding carbon-absorbing algal blooms as they go. (I heard about this nearly 20 years ago, so I assume that has either been tested or banned since then…)
- variant 3y agoWhat does success look like in the climate change fight? Is there a point where victory can ever be declared? Is that a "correct" temperature (what is it) or a CO2 PPM number (what's ideal)? When industry and scientists stop lobbying for money to fight it?
- alas44 3y agoIdeally, pre-industrial levels of CO2 ppm and stabilization of planetary scale changes (ocean dilatation, melting of glaciers etc). Because of inertia at this scale, for the second part we are already in trouble, even if we were able to magically stop emitting CO2 today
- ZeroGravitas 3y agoThis doesn't feel like a question asked in good faith but, 350 is a reasonable ppm target: https://350.org/about/ https://350.org/about/ edit: better link https://mn350.org/understanding350/ https://mn350.org/understanding350/
- londons_explore 3y agoI suggest 280 ppm is more akin to "pre industrial" levels, as that was the level about 300 years ago. 350 was the level around 1990, which is thoroughly "after we already messed it up".
- nologic01 3y agoThere won't be any ingenious, miracle carbon removal solution and various proposals may even be flirting with ecological disasters of planetary proportions. Anything that expands our footprint in order to mitigate our footprint is a dubious direction. Reminds of an apprentice wizard that panics and invokes a sequence of spells, each one worse than the other. Discussions and thinking around sustainability underestimate the complexity of the problem we are facing. Climate change is but one symptom of the anthropocene (defined as the extremely intensive utilization of planetary resources). In the fullness of time it might prove that climate change isn't even the most dangerous of the anthropocene side-effects. We already have several other channels and signals besides GHG emissions and induced climate change: ozone layer depletion, microplastics, invasive species, biodiversity loss etc. and there is a "smell" about them that's worse than rotting seaweed on a beach. Don't get me wrong, various (bio)technological adaptations may play a role to expand our options, but fundamentally they need to fit together in a package that is conservative and will not lead to more harm and further degradation. The principal component of our collective survival strategy is hard to substitute: Where possible, we need to do more with less. Where that is not possible, we simply need to do less.
- leesec 3y ago>There won't be any ingenious, miracle carbon removal solutions OK but I think there will be.
- suby 3y agoWe shouldn't be operating under the assumption that there will be.
- notfish 3y agoHow? Unless you get a breakthrough with fusion, I just don’t see us finding the energy to make carbon removal feasible. You either need huge tracts of land to power forests, or massive amounts of energy from another source to do it with tech, and neither of those is going to be the easy fix people believe is coming.
- 3y ago
- stuaxo 3y agoUsing plants like this has to be a part of it, it saves so much effort.
- renewiltord 3y agoTime to kickstart a real big Azolla Event https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Azolla_event https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Azolla_event
- elihu 3y ago800,000 years is pretty slow, though. Maybe we could speed it up with the right conditions? I think what we'd need to replicate the azolla event is a large fresh-water lake that's very still and stagnant, so that O2 levels in the deep parts are low enough that when the plant dies and sinks to the bottom it doesn't decompose. Or alternatively would could have azolla-harvesting ships that skim the surface, and then we could turn the resulting plant mass into biochar and bury it, or something like that. Azolla doesn't do well in salt water, but maybe we could engineer a salt-tolerant variant. The Black Sea, for instance, has about half the salinity of the rest of the ocean. For some salt-tolerant azolla variant to get loose and cover the whole ocean sounds like it could be a major ecological disaster though, even if it does draw down CO2 really fast. Azolla is sometimes used to feed livestock and as a fertilizer, so it could displace other, potentially more CO2 producing ways of accomplishing the same thing. I think there have been some efforts to use it as a food for humans.
- elmolino89 3y agoSeems that eating Azolla or maybe even animals feed Azolla may not be the safest thing to do: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beta-Methylamino-L-alanine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beta-Methylamino-L-alanine The cyanobacterian symbiont of Azolla, Anabena can produce neurotoxins.
- dave333 3y agoCould recycle plastic into floating kelp forests that consist of a weighted substrate that the kelp holdfasts can lock onto supported at the appropriate depth using lines up to floats. Each deployment could be of sufficient area to be self-sustaining in the open ocean and populated with appropriate fauna. If the floats degrade the entire forest would sink to the seafloor to sequestrate the carbon. Gradually these would congregate in the gyres in the oceans where all the loose plastic ends up and eventually take it all to the bottom.
- uncleenk 3y ago[dead]
- Peter_Green 3y agoHi there. Over the last 2 years, I've interviewed over 200 seaweed innovators, academics and investors to get to the bottom of this question. In answer to your question, YES. It probably is one of the fastest and least expensive tools to fight climate change. It requires next to no inputs, can be cultivated alongside other extractive species which foster biodiversity and clean waterways, and can sequester carbon. The products we can make from it can further reduce emissions. However, we have to be super careful with overselling the solution. To have measurable impact, we need to grow a lot of seaweed OUTSIDE of Asia. Scaling up supply will be a challenge - because market demand for this seaweed as a food/feed/bioproduct alternative has not been completely validated. This will take time, but it will happen. Watch this space. Overall, it's became very clear to me how hard it is to distinguish signal from noise in this sector. That's why the Paxtier Report newsletter is so good. If you're keen to better understand the space, check it out here: https://paxtier.substack.com/ https://paxtier.substack.com/ . The Phyconomy newsletter is also superb: https://phyconomy.net/ https://phyconomy.net/ Hope this helps. And shoot me a message if you have more questions.
- uslic001 3y agoI have been hearing this since I was in middle school in the 1970's. I will believe it when I see it happen at a large scale.