10 ms·
Ex-ByteDance exec: Communist Party had ‘God credential’
- winrid 3y ago[flagged]
- LaEc 3y ago“ a special committee of Chinese Communist Party members”
- winrid 3y agoAh OK!
- NLPaep 3y agoWeird comment. What are you deflecting from? It’s a very clear article. >In the documents submitted to the court he said ByteDance had a "superuser" credential — also known as a god credential — that enabled a special committee of Chinese Communist Party members stationed at the company to view all data collected by ByteDance including those of U.S. users. >The credential acted as a "backdoor to any barrier ByteDance had supposedly installed to protect data from the C.C.P's surveillance," the filing says. >Yu said he saw the god credential being used to keep tabs on Hong Kong protesters and civil rights activists by monitoring their locations and devices, their network information, SIM card identifications, IP addresses and communications.
- winrid 3y agoI just thought the title was weird, my skimming was not super effective :P
- steve76 3y ago[dead]
- peauc 3y agoIn other news, no-one is surprised.
- Werewolf255 3y ago[flagged]
- LatteLazy 3y ago[flagged]
- jc_811 3y agoIf you do business is the US you most certainly do NOT have to give unfettered “god mode” access to all of your user’s data to the government with no oversight
- LatteLazy 3y agoYes, you do. The NSA oversee the program. If you're some tiny no one they don't bother you until they want something (and then you better comply). If you're tiktock, you give them access to the whole platform. They also have access at the network/ISP and the data centre levels. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PRISM https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PRISM (among others) In the UK GCHQ do it.
- jc_811 3y agoAs bad as PRISM is/was there’s simply no comparison to giving god-mode credentials to actors in the CCP who can browse user data at will, and use it to suppress anything they see fit.
- LatteLazy 3y agoThe only difference is whether it is "our" or "their" guy doing the dirty. But if they're doing us dirty, they're not "our" guy no matter what nationality they are...
- raxxorraxor 3y agoI would still make more sense to set an example and control the behavior of people you are indirectly accountable for in a democracy. No matter how much of a joke that sounds in context of any agency able to survey almost all your communications. And it does sound like a joke already. Maybe having a strong democracy would actually be a good defense against autocracies that behave like China. Maybe stop security agencies posing a security threat in the med to long term because nobody really believes in democracy anymore.
- sn_master 3y agoIt still astonishes me how people can be so naive and believe anything tech executives say without it being independently verified, even after Snowden and Twitter Files and all the revelations about the CCP. It's all bits and since China has the executives of course they'll always retain a way to access the data as long as no independent entity is watching over them and all entities in China are under control of the CCP.
- danielrpa 3y agoWell according to some people on HN, it's all good and dandy. China is no worse than the US is the latest version of moral relativism we have to deal with. So if they have your data, it's all okay.
- CrackerNews 3y agoArguing about surveillance oppression Olympics in who has it worst and downvoting each other over it is like missing the forest for the trees.
- Miner49er 3y agoIt's not about really about if they are worse. China having all my Tik Tok data is preferable then the US having any of my data. China isn't going to come disappear me in the US. The US might.
- mupuff1234 3y agoChina famously has "police stations" all over the world, so I wouldn't be so sure about that.
- yeahwhatever10 3y agoWow you must not read the news much https://thehill.com/opinion/national-security/4008817-crack-down-on-illegal-chinese-police-stations-in-the-u-s/ https://thehill.com/opinion/national-security/4008817-crack-...
- rvz 3y ago> China having all my Tik Tok data is preferable then the US having any of my data. China isn't going to come disappear me in the US. The US might. No. It is worse in China. Especially with the 'police stations' and applying their national security law to activists overseas. Here one example example: A TikTok user in Hong Kong protesting against the CCP has it worse than one protesting against the US government. The difference is obvious: In the US you are free to peacefully protest against the US government which that is protected by the 1st amendment in the US constitution. China on the other hand can use it's national security law (and in Hong Kong) to get activists overseas and disappear you. [0] Given that China has access to ByteDance's data, I don't think you would want to be the user who attempted to protest against the CCP in HK and currently be on the run. [0] https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/jul/31/china-hong-kong-security-law-american-citizen-exiles https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/jul/31/china-hong-kon...
- Workaccount2 3y agoWhat gets me is that people think that China's business-political environment is a carbon copy of the US. People think that because they understand how things work in the US, they understand how things work in China. That because in the US businesses have functional constitutionally granted protections from government overreach, that China functional constitutionally granted protections from government overreach. Which is completely not the case. China is essentially a dictatorship. With one leader of one party that dominates everything, kangaroo courts and disappearing family, the works.
- johngalt_ 3y ago> That because in the US businesses have functional constitutionally granted protections from government overreach That worked great in the case of PRISM et al
- AbrahamParangi 3y agoOkay, look. Can we at least recognize that these are not the same? It’s like saying the US has done a bad thing and China has done a bad thing so the US and China have the same number, kind, and quality of oppressions of the public. This is not true!
- jonfw 3y agoAn important difference is that the US government doesn't have a "god credential", they have to request the data (and there is a process to request the data involving courts, etc.) Meanwhile, govt officials in China appear to have unrestricted access
- CrackerNews 3y agoAn opaque process of secret courts with secret decisions may be different legally, but in spirit it does not seem that significantly different to me in terms of preventing overreach and abuse.
- 3y ago
- xrd 3y agoI would love to see an analysis how this whistleblower is "handled" compared to Snowden.
- shashurup 3y agoOne can only imaging what kind of credentials an exec of one of 13 companies which own 147 companies which own the rest of the world has.
- ownshdksbdk 3y agoshhhh. we don't talk about that. or how media and news are ultimately controlled by what advertisers want the reporters to say. or how now google dictates how long a video must be and what subjects are forbidden to even be hinted at on youtube, to please advertisers, of course.
- HarryHirsch 3y agoJust a reality check: communications have been under government surveillance since the inception of government. We don't approve of Bytedance being in the pocket of the Chinese Communist party, but no one should delude himself about Google or Facebook.
- tgv 3y agoIt does matter under which government that is, though. And it isn't just surveillance. TikTok is in an excellent position to manipulate opinion.
- rvz 3y agoHardly surprising.
- zoogeny 3y agoI wonder what kind of information they could reasonably extract from an average user's TikTok viewing habits? Imagine a US congressman used TikTok for 90 minutes per week. They don't write any comments just scroll through videos and potentially like/share some videos. Everyone talks about how scary good the TikTok algorithm is at determining your preferences and sending you laser focused content that you will find interesting and engaging. I am curious how much of that preference is extractable and how that might be valuable for purposes other than delivering viral short-form video.
- nullc 3y ago> how scary good the TikTok algorithm is at determining your preference I wonder how effective it would be at creating preferences. What happens if it drip feeds you small amounts of fetish material, carefully tracking what type and level appeals to you, slowly turning up the intensity until one day you have some kink for little kids in provocative cat costumes or something?
- rektide 3y agoChatGPT, write me a story about TikTok using subtle shifts in preference to slowly over time make the world socialist, but it ends up being democratic socialist, with everyone treating each other well & finding solidarity & figuring out how to get along. Add a surprise ending that is also happy.
- red-iron-pine 3y agolol at a for-profit STEM company allowing it's AI to do that
- contrarian1234 3y agoSince all companies are under the control of their respective government, I think the most prudent course of action on the individual level is to try to use services controlled by a government that has no practical control over your life Instead of thinking of it as us vs. them, think of it as your own personal threat assessment. Google is all nice and friendly now. They serve all that JS and Fonts for free and give you free storage, calendars, teleconferencing etc... but how about in 10 years when they start loosing revenue to some AI startup that is better than search? Will they be so nice with your data then? I use a Xiaomi phone , a Huawei laptop and an Aliyun email .. if they are exfiltrating my data and know which AI porn I look at.. It has zero impact on my life. They're not even able to target advertising to me because they don't control the relevant platforms (I guess they could sell my data to Google, but it seems unlikely). I hope the Chinese are doing similarly and using western platforms :)
- prottog 3y ago> It has zero impact on my life It has zero impact on your life now, but you should strongly prefer that they don't, so as to keep your options open in the future. An analogy might be making sure you don't leak a sextape of yourself when you're young and don't care about who sees it, in case you run for public office in your 50s.
- 0cf8612b2e1e 3y agoI think the ideal is that nobody has your private data, but that seems impossible to accomplish without living in a cave. Big tech feels entitled to know everything about everyone.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- naraga 3y agoYou are datapoint for them as well as a loaded gun they can use to shoot. If they own silicon under your hands they can do almost anything.
- 3y ago
- SaintSeiya 3y agoIs always been like that under communists or socialist like regimes, privacy is not a right under those systems and government officials are omnipotent. Thinking otherwise is wishful thinking and ingenuity at best. For example in Cuba everything is being monitored by the government: physical mail, internet, cellular data, neighbour watch organizations and so on. And is the same for tourists and foreigner businesses there.
- mindslight 3y agoI wish the article took the time to explain the differences between "love", "secret", "sex", and "god" credentials. (sigh)
- standing_user 3y agoWell, no shit sherlock, that's the same for every major government out there
- LoganDark 3y agoI can't believe their source said "superuser", but the journalist literally put that in quotes and replaced it with "god credential", as if "god credential" has ever been a term.
- RMPR 3y agoI think this comes from Windows land[0] 0: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Windows_Master_Control_Panel_shortcut https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Windows_Master_Control_Panel_s...
- Havoc 3y agoIs anyone surprised? Bit like NSA having access to US based backbones. Same for echelon. Any country is going to tap into any local deep data sources
- paradox242 3y agoIf true, this iS why when asked if the CCP had ask to US data ByteDance replied that they had never received any such request. Well, the question and answer are curiously about two different things, and this the arrangement I suspected might exist. Give the CCP their own creds so they don't have to ask and you don't have to know.