5 ms·
The rational response to this point-counterpoint is to decentralise power & let people take their own risks as far as we are able for the truth is a rare and de
by roenxi 3y ago
The rational response to this point-counterpoint is to decentralise power & let people take their own risks as far as we are able for the truth is a rare and delicate flower which we cannot reliably identify. The only fair option is to let people make their own decisions.
But for some reason the level of abstract thought required to justify that is just too high and people can't overcome their instincts. It seems nearly every time there is a crisis the body politic centralises power and, usually, gets a much worse result than just letting people do what makes sense to them. Then people just assume that because they did something and the world didn't literally end in fire that they what they did helped. Then in the good times they do their level best to run down whatever reserves are available and prepare to go in to the next crisis with nothing but elbow grease and optimism.
Human nature: the biggest threat we face.
- dash2 3y agoI don't think that is really relevant. You can't decentralize the decision to (e.g.) increase or decrease criminal sentence length by ten per cent, which is why we need good economic studies to estimate its effects. In general, many policy choices cannot be decentralized away. Also, even if you decentralize them, people still want to know what their choices will do. Suppose I'm considering getting a divorce and I want to know how it will affect my children. Is everyone in this position supposed to do their own literature review? Or just "use their own good sense" and guess what the effect will be?
- golergka 3y agoYou can. Polycentric law and charter cities.
- notahacker 3y agoBoth are poor at yielding useful results for social policy. "Charter cities" and equivalents will give you all sorts of results that don't generalise (judging by the number of businesses that relocated their tax domicile to this underpopulated area, a 1% cut in corporation tax could lead to a 1000% rise in GDP per capita) and "polycentric law" won't really resolve any legal questions other than "in which circumstances can x persuade/force y to accept arbitrator z's decision"
- constantcrying 3y ago>You can't decentralize the decision to (e.g.) increase or decrease criminal sentence length by ten per cent You absolutely can. It also exists right now in the form of federalism, where people can, to some limited extent, choose their own legislation and policies.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- roenxi 3y ago> You can't decentralize the decision to (e.g.) increase or decrease criminal sentence length by ten per cent. Sure we could; different laws in different locations; let people see what works. That is how the world does things now - note that different countries have different legal codes and by experiment everyone comes to a sort-of consensus on what works, with lots of variance between jurisdictians when people don't agree. That diversity of law can be re-done at any practical scale. I quite like the idea of different cities having different laws (oh, for the world to have a few more Hong Kongs in it! And note how well single-city legal entities usually do).
- pixl97 3y agoI mean, we already have that. For state crimes we have state sentencing, for federal crimes we have federal sentencing. >That diversity of law can be re-done at any practical scale. Eh..... Only at an extreme cost. I mean in a few minutes of actually thinking about the problem I hope you could see how this would totally fall apart. For example you live in BumFkt Nebraska and sell widget X. Totally legal in BumFkt. Your neighbors in Timbuktu Nebraska order X on your website and you ship to them. Oops, you've both committed felonies in Timbuktu, and now if you ever go there you'll be arrested on site and imprisoned. Typically every state constitution in the US holds itself as the highest authority in that state. Cities and make their own regulations, but the state is the final arbiter in setting the limits to their power to keep petty squabbling shit from damaging the citizens of said state. After that the federal government can step in, and quite often has as some particular states love to violate human rights dependant on the minority group you're in.
- constantcrying 3y agoYes, there is also a huge mismatch between what politicans want from "science" and what "science" can provide. Any legitimate scientific field is in a constant faction war, on various issues and making serious political decision based on that is insane. And the consequence is various highly suspect policy decision which were essentially purely based on some "scientific" subfaction gaining political power and enforcing their beliefs. The effects of these decisions are usually, likely by design, impossible to measure and subject to an enormous amount of confounders. "Success" and "failure" thus become largely up to chance and a "consensus" emerges, which is in truth largely based on coin tosses and more or less meaningless.
- cshimmin 3y agoYes! In the US particle physics community, they came up with a solution to this. Every ten years, the field as a whole gets together and sets an agenda for the field that self-prioritizes funding, before making a case to the national funding agencies and Congress. The idea is that if the high energy folks are computing with the neutrino folks, and things get nasty to the point where people on each side are saying stuff like "neutrinos suck, here's why you shouldn't fund them and fund us instead!"... All the suits are going to hear is "physics sucks here's a bunch of reasons we shouldn't fund them". The process/report is called P5 (particle physics projects prioritization panel), and it's actually happening right now to form the coming decadal report.
- walthamstow 3y agoAssume you meant competing rather than computing? Either could work!
- naasking 3y agoSounds like a great way to setup an echo chamber.
- geraldhh 3y agoconsensus chamber?
- api 3y agoI agree as long as it doesn't endanger others, but when it does you start to have a more complicated ethical problem. E.g. I'm generally in favor of at least a pressure to vaccinate for vaccines that are effective at reducing spread, but less so in cases of vaccines that are not sterilizing. In that case you're only taking a risk with your own health but are having a negligible effect on the overall spread of the disease. Things also get more complicated when dealing with minors, such as when parents refuse medical treatment for minors due to religious (or "new age" or political) reasons.
- RandomLensman 3y agoNot sure why you ignore that a lot "regulation" also came from the private sector because they didn't want to deal with stuff going wrong all the time so they self-regulated. People on their own do decide that there is stuff they don't want to leave to chance. Also, your proposition means people need to be able check out of society proper - good luck with that. Otherwise someone else will need to pick-up the tap for those "own decisions".
- biomcgary 3y agoPeople often decide they don't want to leave competition to chance. Regulatory capture is frequently used to reinforce entrenched power. Most recently, Sam Altman of OpenAI fearmongering for AI regulation, since OpenAI is currently in the lead. If he agreed to shut down OpenAI for the greater good, he'd be a bit more credible.
- anonymouskimmer 3y agoIt seems to me robotics companies are "in the lead" on AI as it pertains to (semi) autonomous decision making.
- RandomLensman 3y agoNot quite sure how that relates to private rule making, i.e., no politicians involved
- pixl97 3y ago"Private rules" = "no rules" Or I should say, the rules can only exist where natural monopolies exist, any competitive market will descend into chaos as the number of entrants in the market will increase and will quickly defect from any private rule set.
- RandomLensman 3y agoNot true at all, have a look at how people got around to regulating steam engine boilers, for example. Not natural monopolies, either.
- brookst 3y agoI don’t entirely disagree, but I think you lean too far in seeing the world as entirely populated by independent individuals whose actions don’t affect others. I am 100% fine with seat belt laws because other peoples’ fatality collisions affect me financially and in traffic jams. Society is a complex system and I don’t think “just let everyone do whatever they want” is a great answer when many of those things impact others, directly or indirectly.
- jonhohle 3y ago[flagged]
- pas 3y agowhy assign more inherent value to life than the one actually dying does?
- jonhohle 3y agoIt’s a stretch to directly couple seat belt wearing to one’s own value of their life. While (afaik) seatbelt research is pretty definitive a very closely related area, car seat research, is plagued with confirmation bias, FUD, and a lack of interest in exploring alternatives (car seat makers are the ones who fund the crash tests)[0]. It’s crazy to go to hyper modern cities that don’t put children in car seats (Seoul, for one) while in the US you’d hear shrieks of horror if your kindergartener got into a car without one. So who benefits from car seat laws? It seems like primarily car seat manufacturers. Back to seatbelts, I don’t know why someone would choose not to wear one, but if they have a reason that they value more than the safety a seatbelt provides, ultimately it affects them and their family far more than it would ever affect me. People need agency over their own lives. Not wearing a seatbelt seems like a minor inconvenience to most people, may impede others. New Hampshire doesn’t require adults to wear seatbelts and doesn’t have as many per capita motor vehicle fatalities as neighboring states. In fact, it has the second lowest rate of deaths per 100M miles traveled in the country (obviously very different from large urban areas). So an assumption about seat belt laws equaling fewer vehicle deaths may not even be a valid assumption. 0 - https://freakonomics.com/podcast/how-much-do-we-really-care-about-children-ep-447/ https://freakonomics.com/podcast/how-much-do-we-really-care-...
- nathan_compton 3y agoIf this were really the optimal solution to all problems we would already see it not just at the level of human society, but all over nature as well. And yet we don't. Group behavior is extremely powerful. It might be the case that atomized individuals will find "truth" faster, but a collective can leverage truth much more efficiently when it is found. Not only that, but nature is replete with organisms for which group behavior is clearly an advantage. I think its interesting that you say, ultimately, that the rational response can't work because of human nature. But if that is the case, then it can't be the rational response. The rational response would be the optimal response that takes human nature into account. I can't say I know what that is, but I doubt its anarchy.
- webnrrd2k 3y agoIf you really think that leting people ”take their own risks as far as we are able" is the answer then I'd love to take my own risks by ignoring all traffic laws. And if, as you claim, "the truth is a rare and delicate flower which we cannot reliably identify" then I'll even start a giant Simpsons-style tire fire in my backyard. Clearly it's unpossible to identify the hazards of such an enterprise.
- p_j_w 3y agoI wonder how GP would feel about his neighbor operating a meth lab.
- renewiltord 3y agoI think it is possible to modify his idea with the concept of externalities to make it work. Do you feel that is not the case?
- anonymouskimmer 3y agoThe problem with trying this for scientific investigations are that funding is the fundamental bottleneck. Labor is the other bottleneck, and it's one that is fundamentally at odds with the entire concept (as scientifically trained laborers can't work on their own ideas, but must work on the ideas they are employed to work on).
- mcguire 3y agoHow would you identify and impose costs for externalities without immediately being accused of "nannying" or legislating the outcome?