7 ms·
I will never participate in weird internet caste systems
- chrisco255 3y agoMan there's plenty of amazing examples of caste systems on the internet, but Discord Nitro ain't it. Discord is a free app without ads. Nitro is a reasonable monetization strategy for a chat app that works incredibly well and fosters probably millions of communities.
- roncesvalles 3y agoTFA's point isn't that Discord shouldn't be monetized - it's that the monetization model is based on creating visible class differences. A different monetization model is easily conceivable that gives paid users better functionality instead of (what the author calls) "aesthetic perks" that only serve to evoke class envy, as if like jewelry. I don't have a strong position on the author's point. Just making sure the right thing is being discussed.
- ZekeSulastin 3y agoAs noted in the post, Nitro users do get enhanced functionality for things like file upload sizes and streaming quality; I imagine that more intrusive better functionality than that would cause a much higher uproar than avatars or emoji, and given that this is a chat/voicechat/streaming app any functionality is necessarily going to be quite visible to other users.
- purduekenny 3y agoWhat's the difference between functionality and aesthetic perks? Isn't the fact that one good is held by a group that is not you what evokes the envy? It doesn't matter if it's themes or if it's the ability to send larger messages. I find the distinction useless.
- picometer 3y agoStraight from the article > this post is mostly about the aesthetic perks. the things that cost discord exactly nothing I presume the second sentence is shorthand for: no marginal cost for Discord, after the development is done. So, two distinctions going on, which happen to be correlated: 1. Things that cost Discord extra resources (eg bandwidth/ storage space for larger uploads) vs things that don’t (extra emoji) 2. Things that allow you do more with Discord (upload large files with any type of content) vs things that allow you to express yourself more (use certain emoji) The second distinction might not matter to everyone, but it certainly has a specific social component.
- fastball 3y agoIsn't the current model better? Is it not (objectively) better for free users if they get all the same functionality as premium users?
- jabbany 3y agoThis is really interesting if you consider a different vertical, like competitive gaming. The whole concept around that is that, monetizing "functionality" would be unfair (breaks balance), so the healthy strategy is actually monetize "aesthetics" (skins, effects etc.) I also don't have a clear framework to judge this, but at least in my subjective opinion, I would much rather a platform be monetized via the creation of powerless "figurehead elites" through aesthetics, than to tax the commoner when actually doing something productive. If economic realities imply there must exist different castes of users, won't it be better if the difference is purely a social rather than practical construct?
- thefz 3y ago> A different monetization model is easily conceivable that gives paid users better functionality instead of (what the author calls) "aesthetic perks" that only serve to evoke class envy, as if like jewelry. With a group of friends we subscribed to Nitro to boost our private server's capabilities, which we use almost every day so the "better functionality" is definitely there. Quite tired of this particular author/blog on HN and their edgy take on everything.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- adamnemecek 3y agoDiscord is arguably the smoothest experience there is, like bar none. How do you suppose it should be paid for? Discord Nitro is the least obtrusive way.
- kashkhan 3y agohave it owned by users and benefactors.
- adamnemecek 3y agoHas that ever worked?
- kashkhan 3y agoyeah except the capitalists killed it. napster, bitorrent etc... being tried now with mastodon et al...
- kmbfjr 3y agoArguably, Napster and Bitorrent had issues that made killing them a tad easy. Wonder what they were?
- lmm 3y agoNah. They were easy to kill because those in power wanted to kill them. The same excuses would have worked on plenty of other things that weren't killed, because those in power were happy for them to survive.
- adamnemecek 3y agoLike what.
- lmm 3y ago
- 14zadz 3y agoThis seems like a dramatic way to say you don’t want to pay to support Discord. I think individuals who actually live in a modern day caste system would be extremely offended by this comparison.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- debacle 3y agoI agree with other commenters. Before Discord, voice over internet was not easy. Skype, Google Meet, Vent, TeamSpeak, and that other one I can't remember the name of that we used for a while. Discord works. It works well. It might just be the most "desktopy" Internet app that I've ever used (yes more than GDocs). If you don't want to pay for things, you get ads. And the ad market has been slowly deflating for over a decade. Just look at Twitch's most recent actions for just how well the ad supported Internet is treating users and content creators. Pay for shit, or else.
- thaumasiotes 3y agoWhat did Twitch do?
- fragmede 3y agoThey've walked it back now, but they initially updated their content guidelines to basically say no non-Twitch advertising on their platform. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36221942 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36221942
- Solvency 3y agoWait, what was wrong with TeamSpeak?
- ramblin_prose 3y agoDo you think Discord should be free? Strange hill to die on..
- ahansen 3y agoI feel like Discords version works a lot better than Slacks for public communities. Someone has the option to pay as an individual rather than requiring a workspace owner to pay for everyone, which is impractical when there are 1000+ members.
- zach_miller 3y ago[dead]
- langsoul-com 3y agoInternet caste systems is just social status hierarchy. Or rather, showing off to others you're higher on the ladder. People don't buy sports cars, or extremely expensive clothing because it's functional. But rather to project their above the plebs. Games have skins or icons marking how high up you are. Most importantly, very expensive skins. Honestly, discords isn't bad, you're not constrained by being a free user. In fact, we should thank the nitro users cause they keep discord free for us.
- elbigbad 3y agoThe sports cars analogy doesn’t resonate with me because there’s a functional difference between regular cars and sports cars. And plenty of people buy sports cars like Miatas, which have less than zero cachet or coolness factor, and thus can’t really project being “above” anyone. Clothing with the modifier “extremely” probably makes sense though.
- fastball 3y agoWe use Discord as the primary communication channel for our two-man startup and love it. Both me and my co-founder pay for Nitro not because we want to participate in an "internet caste system" (my-founder is basically the only person that would actually see my "Nitro" status and vice versa), but because we want to support a great product that has served us well over the years. Some of the perks are fun but generally go unused by us.
- dvt 3y agoImagine comparing paying for a free service for a few irrelevant perks to a millennia-old systemic social system of oppression (that’s de facto still around, by the way). How tone deaf can you actually be? Next up: paying for Twitter Blue is slavery.
- cf100clunk 3y agoI did not infer a direct comparison, personally. To me it was more of a dictionary use of ''caste'' as opposed to an encyclopedic one. No censorship required in this case, please.
- cf100clunk 3y agoSpeaking of dictionaries, there is a zoological use of the term ''caste''.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- kgwxd 3y agoMy first kid had some struggles with understanding why it was absolutely ridiculous to spend hundreds of real dollars to e.g. get a particular Dominus in Roblox. It caused a lot of fights for about a year, but it finally sank in. When my second kid started playing he started down the same path. Caused a few arguments for a little while but, one day my first told him it was pretty stupid to spend real money on fake stuff and that was the end of the problem. I personally buy into things like that in places I want to continue to exist for a long time e.g. Rocket League, a handful of YT channels through Patreon, and even Roblox. Turns out it's really fun to play it with your kids if they're not constantly browsing the item shop and begging for Robux. I've never witnessed anyone talking down to the "lower class" except from insignificant trolls no one in the community respects anyway. Maybe it's different on discord but, if it is, I would blame the members of the community first, discord didn't invent the idea of selling cosmetics to keep the servers running and everyone needs to learn how to get over jealousy at some point in the their life.
- strken 3y agoNitro, or at least server boosting, gives you some non-status benefits. The obvious ones are upload size and stream + audio quality. The article doesn't mention server boosting, but that's where the real desperation and social pressure comes in. Nobody I've met cares if you've got nitro, but admins definitely do pressure members into boosting.
- kgwxd 3y agoDoes that pressure go much beyond every YT channel with a Patreon mentioning it in every video? I really don't mind that kind of thing compared to "relevant" ads and all the tracking involved in that industry.
- SkipperCat 3y agoI applaud your perspective, but if you want to truly break caste systems, seek social justice. Seek educating people who don't have access to affordable schooling. Seek public health care. Seek affordable housing. Seek fair elections. Seek prison reform. Seek fair wages. Seek everything that affords people the dignity of live that everyone deserves.
- handsaway 3y agoIf not having access to "super reactions" or special avatars on Discord make you feel a genuine and affecting sense of envy and self-consciousness I uh... don't know what to tell you. It's some gifs, you just can't post some gifs. This feels monumentally overblown to me. I don't pay for nitro but I clearly benefit from all the people who do and if they get some fun, silly little perks that's fine.
- wly_cdgr 3y ago...We really front paging emo high schoolers on HN now?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Invictus0 3y agoDiscord: you can do text/voice chat with your friends for free, but if you want to use certain emojis, then we charge a fee This guy: I'm being oppressed
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- cortesoft 3y agoI am sure people in actual caste systems would be pretty excited if they could join a higher caste for $3 a month.
- cf100clunk 3y agoYou are taking the person's use of the term ''caste'' too literally.
- vore 3y agoThey should have picked a word without these connotations then.
- cf100clunk 3y agoPerhaps you should take up your struggle over the term with zoologists then: caste: (zoology) A class of polymorphous eusocial insects of a particular size and function within a colony. https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/caste https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/caste
- solarman5000 3y agoI get the point, and appreciate their input to the discussion.. but I'd rather pay money to matrix / element.io and make their service better. These kinds of problems don't seem to come up so often with FOSS. I don't use discord, but I can def see this kind of thing impacting children who do use discord.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 3y agoThe person doesn’t even like Discord: https://j3s.sh/thought/using-discord-is-morally-lazy.html https://j3s.sh/thought/using-discord-is-morally-lazy.html So it seems weird to publish a rant about Discord Nitro.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- paxys 3y agoThey are harmless cosmetic features. Some people are into it, and don't mind paying a few dollars a month to keep the site up and running for everyone. If you don't care for it then don't pay, just like the majority of the user base. Just don't make up some righteous bullshit about why you are actually superior for paying nothing and still enjoying the benefits the service offers (while also showing everyone that you don't know what a caste system actually is).
- nperez 3y agoA bar is giving away free beer, but if you pay $10.00, you get a party hat. So you grab a free beer and notice a group of people wearing party hats. Idk, still seems like a pretty good deal to me. Wouldn't hurt to support the joint either. Interesting read, though. Some communities really are full of people who judge the worth of others from little status symbols, and I can understand wanting to stay away from that. But it's not Discord's fault if people can't just be adults about it.
- raspyberr 3y agoDoes Discord actually make enough sustainable money from Nitro? It doesn't seem feasible.
- vcg3rd 3y agoMight be a better tactic to help people realize envying check marks and emoji isn't healthy. I'm curious if the author realizes how much potential envy having access to the internet and a blog and the ability to read and write might produce in a real world caste system. To be producing content on the internet is participating in a caste system. Ironic, that.
- korse 3y agoIRC still exists! Come hang out?!