7 ms·
Audience collectively groaned at Apple's Vision Pro price
- symic 3y agoI don’t understand the complaint on pricing. A camcorder in 1986 cost around $1900 in today’s money and it sold well. It was far less capable, far less elegant, and far more bulky. This device is a computer, camera, MR headset, and replaces monitors. I think $3500 is a very reasonable price given its specs and what it does.
- wmf 3y agoThe tech elite already have monitors, TVs, etc. and don't want to re-buy them.
- symic 3y agoI think your view is too narrow and short sighted. The tech elite had Blackberries, iPods, and laptops when the iPhone came out and didn’t want to re-buy them. They didn’t rebuy the the first two items but did buy iPhones. This is a similar situation in my opinion.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoNot only that, but a few years later it will be affordable for those specs.
- _zzaw 3y agoYeah, I'm somewhere between "that's fucking expensive" and "if it can legitimately replace a monitor for hours on end, that might well justify the price." I'll admit one sticking point for me is the lack of noise cancellation on the earphones. I'm sure that is coming, so holding off for a generation or two might be a good bet.
- symic 3y agoI think the noise cancelling will come from AirPods. If they can pull off noise cancelling from the headset alone that would be quite impressive.
- MontyCarloHall 3y agoBecause, when it comes to consumer electronics, we have experienced massive deflation for the last ~50 years, to the extent that we simply do not expect to pay big bucks for any electronics. Spending more than $1000-$2000 on a gadget is way outside most people's norms. Remember, the original Macintosh cost $6000 in today’s money, which most people would consider an absolutely ludicrous sum for a computer (of any kind) today.
- symic 3y agoYes, that is true. My wife and I are childless. We could buy two of these devices and immediately get rid of our two TVs, sound system, and monitor. I don’t think I’ll ever buy another monitor, sound system or TV again. I doubt I’ll ever buy an iPad or laptop again either. I think there’s a big enough market for this device at the $3500 price point. Obviously I could be wrong. I hope not because I’m excited about the possibilities of this device.
- netsharc 3y agoDo you really want to "jack in" just to watch a movie or listen to some music? Isn't the point of a TV to relax on the couch, maybe cuddle with the wife?
- symic 3y agoI think a person can relax on the couch with the headset. Cuddling is an issue. I would much rather use the headset than a TV. For one, I can resize the screen as I see fit. One problem in my house is that my oled TV doesn’t do well in sunlight. I can watch a movie while seeming to be at any location I desire. I hate the idea of the electronics waste that comes with 70 inch TVs when the time comes to replace it. I don’t like the hdmi cables and plugs. I’d rather have less clutter. I like the idea of an all purpose, high quality media and internet consumption device that is small that will replace a lot of products that I currently have.
- amanaplanacanal 3y ago
- etempleton 3y agoI think given the amount of tech and at least presented level of quality of experience (which I do not doubt) the price is fine. I think the problem is it is $3,500 in search of a problem to solve. A camcorder has a clear use case. It let you make home movies. They failed to articulate the use case in a compelling way and every scenario I can think of is extremely hampered by the 2 hour battery life. Business is out. Everyone outside Silicon Valley that can afford this thing will be rejected if they show up with a weird uncanny valley avatar to a meeting. Travel sounds good, but 2 hours really limits it. You better have a seat charger and even then it must be pulling down how many watts? Will seat chargers on planes have enough sustained power to do more than prolong battery life? Watching movies at home? Sure. If you are alone and you are plugged in. What else? Weird VR computing and web browsing? The friction of putting on the headset is too much to make up for however good that experience is.
- symic 3y agoI think this headset has a clear use case. For one, it’s a way better recording device than what currently exists. With the headset appearing transparent it will not be too much of barrier to interacting with what you are recording. One can record the birthday party while interacting with the party in a way very similar to how you would if you had no device. Recoding a birthday party using a phone is much more dystopian in my opinion than using this headset. Another use case is getting rid of monitors and freeing up space on a desk. I imagine in the future I’ll have a sever in a closet and the headset will allow me to get rid of my TV, keyboard, mouse, monitor, laptop, and Apple TV. My wife and I can each put on a headset and have customized picture/sound while synchronously watching the same show. She likes the TV to be a lot louder than I do. I will be able to play board games with friends across the country and it will be as if we are all in the same room interacting with the game board. This thing would be great for online teaching or tech support.
- bennyelv 3y agoThat first bit sounds like a very hot take to me - the headset quite literally blocks and intercepts the standard human signals for attention and emotional response and then tries to recreate them on an OLED screen with a CGI model. I can't see how that's better than filming on a phone, where although the eyes are looking at what's going on on the screen, their response is still clearly visible in the raw form.
- HyperSane 3y agoMy parents bought me a $2,500 PC in 1995, which is $5,045.96 in 2023 money.
- bitbeq 3y agoI feel like I’m part of the small majority thinking that it’s a reasonable price. It’s the first generation of the product so I’m looking forward on seeing how it changes in the future.
- Turskarama 3y agoIt costs 7 times as much as a Meta Quest 3, for that you get: 1) double the resolution. 2) better (perfect?) passthrough (not sure how good it is on the Quest 3, apparently a lot better than the quest 2 which was pretty bad). 3) native hand tracking. This is again in beta for the Meta Quest, and I expect apple to do it better but again how much better is the question. 4) A front screen to show your eyes: this is ridiculous and I don't know why anyone would care enough about this feature to pay for a high resolution curved screen on the front of the device to enable it. If it's a short conversation you don't need to see my eyes, if it's a long conversation I'm taking the thing off. Technologically impressive but feels like a huge gimmick.
- netsharc 3y agoTo point 4, I wonder if someone did the pros and cons and decided it was worth it. Imagine sitting around a table with several people "jacked-in" to their own headsets (e.g. all in a conference with the Berlin office), but you want to converse quickly with someone in the room - hah your camera will then be looking at Janice's front screen and this will be considered eye contact (although I guess it's not much different to a Zoom call). Looking forward to someone writing an app that tracks faces near the device and fakes giving them attention...
- Turskarama 3y agoWith face tracking and 4 people wearing the headset you could just put them anywhere in you FOV if you wanted to, no need to pass through and see physical screens showing a face through two levels of camera + screen. The whole point of VR is it's immersive, what "immersive" activity are you doing while also holding a conversation? The use cases are at odds. Sure I can imagine edge cases where it's kind of cool but I would pay exactly $0 for this feature if it was optional.
- Dban1 3y agoand its iterations are only going to get more expensive.
- CharlesW 3y agoThe “Pro” in the name is a clear (IMO) signifier that this isn’t the mainstream consumer edition of the Reality product line. It’s for developers, for enterprise and military evaluation, and for early adopters who want a bleeding-edge experience. A sub-$1,000 non-Pro edition will be available in 2025, maybe sooner.
- skellyclock 3y agoIt seems to be almost 3x the size of something like the 'Bigscreen Beyond.'
- etempleton 3y agoI will say this: If you can plug that thing into a PC and use it like ever other PC headset they will have a lot more people interested. They don’t even have to advertise the function. Just make it something that works. It will take a 4090 to push the 8k+, likely 120hz +, but it would make it a lot more of a compelling of a product at launch.
- deafpolygon 3y agoIt's smart. 1: it will fund the product, 2: you only get rich people and youtube fans talking it up (price-quality heuristic bias), rather than regular consumers talking it down, and 3: when the price comes down (inevitably when they release a non-'Pro'), everyone will clamor and that thing will sell like hotcakes.
- justinclift 3y agoHeh, sounds like Apple's "Magic Leap" moment. ;)
- rocket_surgeron 3y agoMy fetish is listening to and reading complaints about how Apple prices their unnecessary luxury goods. The next year is going to be glorious.