4 ms·
I stand with Ukraine, and I support foreign aid to help them repel the Russian invasion. However, even if they eventually win the war the sad reality is that Uk
by nradov 3y ago
I stand with Ukraine, and I support foreign aid to help them repel the Russian invasion. However, even if they eventually win the war the sad reality is that Ukraine is probably doomed as a distinct nation and culture. Even before the current war their demographics were collapsing. Now they are suffering heavy casualties on the battlefield, and millions of young people have fled the country as refugees to avoid violence and conscription. Realistically most of those people are never coming home.
https://zeihan.com/demographics-part-6-the-orthodox-predicament/ https://zeihan.com/demographics-part-6-the-orthodox-predicam...
In 30 years I expect the population of Ukraine to look vastly different with a lot more immigrants from Africa and the Middle East working in agriculture and resource extraction. And to be clear I'm not claiming that this is a good thing or a bad thing, just that it seems inevitable based on demographics and geography.
- 0xDEF 3y agoThe demographics of Ukraine spells economic stagnation however ~25-30 million is more than enough for linguistic and cultural sustainability. My country, Denmark, only has 5 million people and Iceland only has 300,000 people. I don't know if you're American but immigrants in Europe assimilate slower and keep their linguistic and cultural identity alive for generations. Young 3rd generation Turkish and Pakistani people in Denmark (whose grandparents arrived in the 1970s) are still able to speak Turkish and Urdu/Punjabi.
- OrvalWintermute 3y agoThey won't have 25-30m after this war. Russia has already taken several oblasts and joined them in proper to Russia. More of this is coming as they take 4 more oblasts.
- perfect_kiss 3y agoRussia will not take any single oblast. In fact, it has retreated from two oblasts in the past 6 months. And now retreating from part of Belgorod. Good luck contradicting reality, bro.
- OrvalWintermute 3y agoThat was prior to them growing their force by over 500K more troops. While they did get overextended with a fairly small force before, the Russian juggernaut is now just ramping up and will continue to escalate. Remember, it was the Russians that destroyed the Wehrmacht & the Waffen-SS on the Eastern Front.
- perfect_kiss 3y agohttps://t.me/kordon1991/446 https://t.me/kordon1991/446 -- video of russians retreating from Orikhiv today. Next Tokmak and Melitopol. And then Crimea.
- OrvalWintermute 3y agoRussians are willing to trade space for human lives. Then, it is another cauldron and the artillery storm all over again.
- datavirtue 3y agoI expect the same thing in the US with different immigrants.