5 ms·
I wish people pushed for a more targeted approach. This seems like a baby-with-the-bathwater situation. I know it's easier to do that way, but you can do lots o
by viraptor 3y ago
I wish people pushed for a more targeted approach. This seems like a baby-with-the-bathwater situation. I know it's easier to do that way, but you can do lots of things with your phone apart from social media. For example there's lots of books I read on the phone as a teenager just because of I could easily access them on the go. But on top of that, why limit 1:1 communication? Email? Maps access? Etc. I hate the "screen time" idea personally, because it's generalising way too much. We don't take away "reading time" just because kids could read the wrong thing.
I hope a few places that overreact this way will make it more popular to provide restricted tech experience rather than a full ban.
- jasonhansel 3y agoThey're banning smartphones, not (say) laptops. Presumably the latter are less of an issue since you're not tempted to be using them constantly at all times.
- TheSpiceIsLife 3y agoIn what ways do you believe your comment to be a response to the parent?
- sycamoretrees 3y agoQuite simply, they’re saying that all those things can be done on a laptop if necessary. Duh.
- TheSpiceIsLife 3y agoThey didn’t make that claim. For many people the only computer they have is their phone, I’d say well over half the people I work with have only their phone, and especially young people. I’ve got one, two, thr… I don’t, maybe nine computers, and have read zero on any but the phones.
- madaxe_again 3y agoBooks are also available as these big papery things - they don’t have adverts, videos or other distractions, though. These strange papery things are also rather portable.
- RGBCube 3y agoBut they cost money and are not as easy to access when you want a specific one. Especially ones in other languages.
- madaxe_again 3y agoThey frequently cost less than ebooks, particularly if you buy them second hand. I don’t think I’ve paid more than €1 for a book (apart from rare volumes) in years. Abebooks have it all.
- makeitdouble 3y agoThere's this cute little series that could be fun for a teenage girl learning French. Not that expensive, tell how much it costs at Abebooks: https://www.amazon.fr/Angélique-5-révolte-Anne-Golon/dp/2266322613/ref=sr_1_266?__mk_fr_FR=ÅMÅŽÕÑ&crid=25H1J0BFOR5J5&keywords=les+huguenots&qid=1685941686&sprefix=les+hugenots%2Caps%2C287&sr=8-266 https://www.amazon.fr/Angélique-5-révolte-Anne-Golon/dp/2266...
- madaxe_again 3y agoBetween less than €1 and €3. https://www.abebooks.co.uk/servlet/SearchResults?sts=t&cm_sp=SearchF-_-home-_-Results&tn=Angelique&an=Golon https://www.abebooks.co.uk/servlet/SearchResults?sts=t&cm_sp...
- rocketbop 3y agoYou can get them for free in these things called libraries.
- 3y ago
- gls2ro 3y agoWhat is your exact proposal? Kids - specially young ones cannot self regulate against billion dollars corporations that build features to keep people hooked So please tell me a concrete applicable way that we can apply today to protect them. I will not accept as solutions because is not applicable today by parents: - retricting social media account (the ones over 7-8 years old will find ways to say yes to a screen that asks for age) - saying Facebook or Tiktok should fix it - they will not - saying we should give them restricted phones - does not work practically - family should educate them - that works individually but it does not work society wise So how do you protect the kids from this as a society?
- viraptor 3y ago> saying we should give them restricted phones - does not work practically I'm not sure why you dismiss that one. Whitelisting apps works - that's the whole idea behind kiosk devices. There are guides available, but basically you enable only the allowed apps, uninstall webview, lock the account. Yes, it's not trivial and not everyone will want to do it. (It's available though https://support.google.com/families/answer/7103340?hl=en#zippy=%2Cselect-your-always-allowed-apps https://support.google.com/families/answer/7103340?hl=en#zip...) That's exactly why I wrote the last paragraph. Full access was one extreme. The ban is another extreme. (And is not exactly easy to implement either) Once enough places overreact with the complete bans, the lockdown mode will get better documented, more popular, known by schools, finally (hopefully) easily available from the installation screen. > because is not applicable today by parents That's ok. This problem will still exist in a couple of years and this will be a bit easier to do each month. It was actually impossible to implement a few years ago, but we made progress.
- pookeh 3y agoMy nephews were showing me how kids in their school were using Google Docs comments as a social network. Point being, humans are highly adaptive creatures. You have to cut the source.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- marttt 3y agoLargely agreed, +1. However, a loosely related example: I think I have benefited quite a bit from never ever having seen neither of my parents drink vodka (aside the traditional shot for the deceased at funerals). Because of this, it is easy for me to avoid the mental and physical addiction of alcohol altogether in my adult life. It just wasn't part of my childhood culture, period. Youtube algorithms and the most stupid smartphone games are obviously addictive, so it does make sense if parents step in with a well-considered "thou shalt not" at times. This is far from a perfect solution, but in the long run, it is very probably better than doing nothing at all. I've seen really horrible results of screen time overuse on a teen girl -- basically, a lively and clever 7yo developed into a 18yo with no social skills whatsoever, and the habit to even scroll her phone while brushing teeth! It's like decidedly putting away those candies when you sense your child has had too much for today. The same thing. No need to punish the child's brain and coping mechanisms for the parent's inability to... parent. Best solution, obviously, is simple parental role model: the entire family putting away smartphones for the evening. (In our case, for example, nobody in the family has a smartphone; only dumb phones here. So far, with our oldest child being 9yo, I don't notice this being a problem. He is clearly fine not having one.) I have also observed that careful explanations of what gaming or smartphones do to the child's brain also make a lot of sense. Our son is clearly interested in these effects, so he is always setting himself timers to limit his gaming. (Doesn't always follow them, but often, nonetheless, does; I think it is the purpose that counts, not 100% execution.) I think children need to see cause and effect of smartphone overuse already at early ages. They need to understand and feel that by reasonable, down-to-earth limiting, parents are actually protecting them and their brain.
- hammyhavoc 3y ago> I think I have benefited quite a bit from never ever having seen neither of my parents drink vodka Counterpoint: my partner's father was an alcoholic who abandoned her after her mother died and ended up homeless for two decades, her aunt was also an alcoholic. She didn't grow up to be an alcoholic and doesn't drink alcohol. I don't drink alcohol. Most adults are capable of managing themselves. > I've seen really horrible results of screen time overuse on a teen girl -- basically, a lively and clever 7yo developed into a 18yo with no social skills whatsoever, and the habit to even scroll her phone while brushing teeth! Could equally be undiagnosed autism and/or ADHD, which is infamously underdiagnosed in women.