12 ms·
Parents in Ireland town to voluntarily ban smartphones for kids as old as 13
- hammyhavoc 3y agoI wonder for how many of them it'll be a case of "one rule for you, another rule for our child because they're not like the rest of the riff-raff"? A lot of this will be lip-service, that much I am sure of.
- remote_phone 3y agoMy friend said he relationship with his twos sons were irrevocably ruined by smartphones. Before, they would chat throughout all their car rides but as soon as he bought them smartphones, they stopped talking to him almost entirely and spent all their time on their phones. With kids getting to that age, I’m holding off as much as possible, and I’m indoctrinating them to the sociopathy of social media, where the Algorithms don’t give a shit about you, they will do whatever it takes to maximize your engagement on their platform.
- kelnos 3y agoI know as a non-parent I should be the last person being frustrated with others' parenting choices, but it seems weird that your friend just "let" smartphones ruin his relationship with his kids, rather than imposing and enforcing limits on their use. Maybe the smartphones go into the glove box when riding in the car. Or in general, maybe the smartphones aren't always physically accessible to the kids, and are only given to them when they have a need for them, or when it's "playtime". When I was a kid, my parents didn't allow to sit and play Nintendo all day, as much as I wanted to sometimes. The idea that getting a smartphone for a kid inevitably means that they're going to have it on their person and be glued to it 24/7 is just bonkers.
- wiseowise 3y agoThe point is that kids now prefer smartphones over their dad.
- sensanaty 3y agoNot a parent myself but I have 3 nephews. The problem is that screens are just scarily addicting for kids. They have limited, supervised screen time to less than half an hour a day for the youngest (5) and around an hour a day for the eldest (8), yet despite that it's practically all they care about. The only thing they seem to think about is getting back mum's phone so that they can watch youtube or whatever it is they do, despite it being such a short part of their otherwise eventful days. Hell, I've got a Steam Deck that I bring with me whenever I come around to visit, yet they don't care about it at all despite my steam library having around 900 games, they'd rather use my phone!
- pawelmurias 3y agoIntroducing artificial scarcity will make something more desired.
- remote_phone 3y agoYes you sound exactly like a non-parent.
- warning26 3y agoI strongly believe kids shouldn't have access to smartphones until they turn 18. Ideally this would be a legal mandate, which would help to reduce peer pressure. ("Everyone else at school has a smartphone!")
- zarzavat 3y agoSeems a bit extreme. Practically, 11+ year olds are capable of getting their hands on anything they want if they have the money and inclination for it. And they certainly have the inclination to get a smartphone. So the only way to achieve your vision would be to ban giving money to anybody under the age of 18.
- DANmode 3y agoIt's not their vision. At least, not exclusively. There's a whole town about to put this to the test. If nothing else, it should spawn a new generation of young Irish hackers. For better or worse.
- madaxe_again 3y agoWhat 11 year old has a thousand bucks handy to drop on a phone? An incredibly spoiled one, if you ask me. I know this dates me, but mobile phones weren’t a thing until I was at university, and they definitely weren’t smart. I didn’t lead an impoverished childhood as a result, and information was still available to me through a desktop computer.
- piperswe 3y agoYou can get a smartphone that has all the major functionality for much less than a thousand bucks. Much less than a hundred bucks even. $30 will get you something that a kid will be content with: https://www.walmart.com/ip/Straight-Talk-TCL-30-Z-32GB-Black-Prepaid-Smartphone/562383087?athbdg=L1102&from=/search https://www.walmart.com/ip/Straight-Talk-TCL-30-Z-32GB-Black...
- dento 3y ago18? That's ridiculous. I'd understand 14, but at 18 it's not too rare to live alone and have a full time job. And even before, access to maps or Wikipedia is generally quite useful. It's the social media that's the main issue, and not the other features.
- spicyusername 3y agoA wise move. I suspect you'll see many more cities across the globe follow suit over the coming decades. There is absolutely no reason a child younger than that age "needs" a phone. At best they are potential conveniences. But they are basically guaranteed to be harmful to some degree. Easy net benefit to these kids.
- newanalog 3y agoSome medical devices like the Dexcom CGM and insulin pumps use smartphones to communicate and upload their data to the cloud where parents are able to follow their child’s readings. So, there are some reasons. The phone isn’t the problem. Social media is the real issue. For children who have a healthy relationship with their parents, and are able to correctly handle peer pressure, it can be fine.
- eganist 3y agoSounds like a great market for a health-only iot device or basic wristband with an e-sim. Tailor made for kids, at least to start.
- NovaDudely 3y agoI'm glad you mentioned this. There is always an exception to the rule and this is one of those. While this is a case of were there should be a dedicated machine, until that appears, the phone is a decent middle man machine.
- whywhywhywhy 3y agoCan't they just check it when the kids get home? Like what are they going to do from their work anyway. Silly we have to throw all kids mental health and attention spans down the toilet just to satisfy some fringe cases like this that all existed before smartphones.
- tomjen3 3y agoTotally agreed on social media and endless youtube, but in the case of a medical need you can lock the phone down with screen time locks.
- gnabgib 3y agoDupe of [0](original, 2 days ago, 10 points, 2 comments, low traction), [1] (1 day ago, 50 points, 5 comments). (HN guidelines: "Please submit the original source" which this submission credits/links to) [0]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36174753 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36174753 [1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36180835 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36180835
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- bigyikes 3y agoThis seems like a great idea. If all the kids are offline, there is much less peer pressure to be online. This solves the problem of kids being ostracized because their parents limited their screen time or didn't buy them a phone until they were too old.
- 29083011397778 3y agoSounds like it'll be the new drivers license. Instead of waiting to take the test and get a car, which has fallen out of vogue in many circles, some will impatiently wait for their 13th birthday to join their friends in the forever-online world. Grand for those with early birthdays, less great for those born late in the year (assuming they weren't bumped one grade higher or lower based on birth date).
- selcuka 3y agoOur kids are not allowed to have their own phones, but they can use our phones for a limited amount of time every day, to communicate with their friends (under our supervision). There are middle grounds, it is not a all-or-none decision.
- cpursley 3y agoThis is a great idea!
- germinalphrase 3y agoWhat level of supervision do you employ?
- selcuka 3y agoThey are only allowed to use Messenger Kids, which doesn't require them to create Facebook profiles (I have to have one, though). They can't delete their messages once sent, and we can also view their conversations on another parent's phone while they are chatting. They can technically install another app and add random people as contacts, but it would be very hard to do that without our knowledge.
- astrostl 3y agohttps://www.waituntil8th.org https://www.waituntil8th.org : "The Wait Until 8th pledge empowers parents to rally together to delay giving children a smartphone until at least 8th grade. By banding together, this will decrease the pressure felt by kids and parents alike over the kids having a smartphone."
- lotsoweiners 3y agoWhat about a smart phone as a safety device (parental leash) though? I have a 10 year old going into 6th grade next year, he has aged out of the after school program so I'm considering letting him walk home (about 1/2 -3/4 mile). There is no way in hell I would let him do that unless he has some way I can contact him and see where he is. He is at a charter school so there are far fewer neighborhood kids he could walk home with and no bus or anything like that. We're also not too concerned about screens since we let him use his iPad as much as he wants as long as he has nothing else he is supposed to do. Just curious if it seems reasonable as a safety (at least in my mind) device.
- easytiger 3y agoWhat did parents do before 2012 or so? What element of safety does the phone confer?
- reustle 3y ago> There is no way in hell I would let him do that unless he has some way I can contact him and see where he is. I'm not saying you are wrong or right for wanting this, but it brings 2 thoughts to mind. One is a reminder that our parents and beyond always joke about, back in the day throwing a few blankets in a car and driving 12 hours north for the weekend and having no way to contact anyone and "they were fine". Second is this feeling of overlap between having a child grow up with a phone constantly on them, and our mental attachment to having them. Everyone is aware of this emptiness / stress that occurs with many people when you leave the house without your phone these days. You feel this strong mental attachment / reliance on this connection to the world. Now, are we forcing children to have that same mental reliance on these devices by starting them so young? Again, not saying you are right/wrong to want it, just something that came to mind.
- foreverobama 3y ago[dead]
- viraptor 3y agoI wish people pushed for a more targeted approach. This seems like a baby-with-the-bathwater situation. I know it's easier to do that way, but you can do lots of things with your phone apart from social media. For example there's lots of books I read on the phone as a teenager just because of I could easily access them on the go. But on top of that, why limit 1:1 communication? Email? Maps access? Etc. I hate the "screen time" idea personally, because it's generalising way too much. We don't take away "reading time" just because kids could read the wrong thing. I hope a few places that overreact this way will make it more popular to provide restricted tech experience rather than a full ban.
- jasonhansel 3y agoThey're banning smartphones, not (say) laptops. Presumably the latter are less of an issue since you're not tempted to be using them constantly at all times.
- TheSpiceIsLife 3y agoIn what ways do you believe your comment to be a response to the parent?
- sycamoretrees 3y agoQuite simply, they’re saying that all those things can be done on a laptop if necessary. Duh.
- TheSpiceIsLife 3y agoThey didn’t make that claim. For many people the only computer they have is their phone, I’d say well over half the people I work with have only their phone, and especially young people. I’ve got one, two, thr… I don’t, maybe nine computers, and have read zero on any but the phones.
- madaxe_again 3y agoBooks are also available as these big papery things - they don’t have adverts, videos or other distractions, though. These strange papery things are also rather portable.
- PrimeMcFly 3y agoReally it should be on a case by case basis. At 11 or 12, maybe even 10, I would have been pretty interested in trying different roms for phones and stuff like that. In that sense they would be denying a kid an opportunity to self-learn, which I don't agree with.
- Slava_Propanei 3y ago[dead]
- throwaway2729 3y agoWe've decided to wait till 10th grade to give our kid a smartphone. We might get a dumb phone sooner than that if they need to call us. It's easy to see kids getting addicted to any type of screen - TV, laptops, etc. Having a phone with them all the time seems like a terrible idea.
- ramraj07 3y agoYou could easily give them a basic iPhone with full lockdown on every app with just basic communication and internet browsing abilities.. why not that option?
- camhart 3y agoiOS screen time/parental controls are a joke to bypass. To be clear I'm not aruging that parental controls are bad or not worth it--I'm arguing that Apple's built in mechanisms fail far too easily. https://protectyoungeyes.com/12-ingenious-screen-time-hacks-how-to-beat-them/ https://protectyoungeyes.com/12-ingenious-screen-time-hacks-...
- antonyt 3y agoWhy spend a few hundred dollars to turn an iPhone into a $50 phone? Feature phones give you communication and basic (if often painful) internet browsing abilities.
- russellbeattie 3y agoJesus. Learn how to use the parental features and turn off access to mindless apps. Not letting your child take photos, look up info, share their location or a million other uses for a mobile phone besides TikTok is just short sighted.
- numlock86 3y agoThat would put extra effort on the parenting side. Yuck. That's not why people get kids! Parenting ... It's easier to just ban it and not think about such things. And those kids won't be able to do this on their kids because the lack of contact points in their childhood, too. So yeah, just ban it. Problem solved for generations! /s
- camhart 3y agoParental features fail far too often. As someone deeply knowledgable about the space, it makes complete sense why some parents opt for a dumb phone or no phone and its not due to the parent being lazy.
- kelnos 3y agoIs there something inherent about how parental controls have to function that means that they can't be made reliable enough, or is it that Apple and Google have dropped the ball and could do better?
- camhart 3y agoParental controls/monitoring are an acceptable invasion of privacy. There's been a big push by these companies to at least appear to care about privacy, which results in parental control apps being limited in what they can do. A few companies that really care have innovated to try and help, but its still a challenge and often forces a bad UX on the child and parent. Offering parental controls built into the platform appears to always be an after thought by these big companies. They'll release a non-innovative copycat solution as lip service eventually so they can claim they care. Beyond that, based on how poor their solutions are and how difficult to setup/maintain/use, seems like they don't actually care. The "dangers" on smartphones are not limited to just a few apps. Dangerous content is found everywhere. Social media, texting, chatting, web browsing, video games, etc. Dangers include accessing "bad" content, but also simply accessing good content too much. "Bad" content is found everywhere, including "acceptable" sites/apps. So whatever the solution is it needs to work on every app. For example, loads of apps use a Webview (built in web browser in the app). A child could use an "approved" app by mom n dad to then access the web to view whatever content they wanted using the webview. Its actually a very difficult problem to solve. Think of the headache tech has moderating content... now you have to moderate with very limited knowledge about whats actually being done on the device (each platform has different limitations). And to make it worse each parent and child has a different set of rules for what is okay vs not okay for that child based on their beliefs, age, culture, etc (basically a custom set of moderation rules). How do you build a solution thats easy for parents to use but actually works? Its difficult. A dumb phone or no phone is often a wise choice, especially when the child is young. Eventually parents need to realize its their job to prepare their child for adulthood, so that means giving them unfettered access to a smartphone (ideally with some parental monitoring) so they can coach them to use it responsibly.
- can16358p 3y agoGreat. "Let's make our children much less tech-savvy in this world where importance of tech skills is skyrocketing, just because we can't be bothered to parent them well so they turn to tablets and phones for entertainment." Absolutely terrible move. Good that it's voluntary.
- easytiger 3y agoIf you think using a phone makes one "tech savvy", you aren't very "tech savvy".
- can16358p 3y agoUsing a phone enables access to information, which can make a person tech savvy.
- bentley 3y agoThe decision to ban smartphones generally comes from a weighing of the benefit of the information they provide access to versus the damage phone usage causes to childrens’ psyche.
- easytiger 3y agoIs there information to further this desired information that can't be accessed from a £400 laptop or pc? I've been coding for over 30 years. I don't recall using a phone to bring up an API document
- valine 3y agoCouldn’t agree more. The older generation didn’t go to school in a world with Google, and they dont’t understand what technology prohibition does to kids. I’ve gone to school with people who weren’t allowed access to technology. Saying it puts them at a disadvantage is an understatement. Technical literacy needs to be cultivated. We should be teaching kids to use technology productively, not banning it.
- 3y ago
- reustle 3y agoRelated: Japan offers these cute kid phones that are basically a clock and preset contacts list, that's it. I saw them quite regularly. Thought some here would find it interesting. https://www.docomo.ne.jp/product/ky41c/ https://www.docomo.ne.jp/product/ky41c/
- deafpolygon 3y ago"As old as"? More like, "as young as". Most kids that age shouldn't even be using smartphones. Ask yourself: Why do they need it? Why do they need a computing device with nigh full access to the Internet 24/7? It's unhealthy, and for kids staying in touch with friends; kids need _plenty_ of break from their peers in order to grow and develop as an individual.
- maddogfog 3y agoFYI Insider reporters are on strike and are asking folks to refrain from clicking on their links until they're back at work.
- cat_plus_plus 3y agoBan all phones for kids? That's a terrible idea, what if they are in a ditch with a broken leg after falling off a bike? Only smartphones? Perhaps, but a dumbphone is just a smartphone with restricted set of apps. It seems better to restrict apps based on appropriate age and individual needs than have a hard to tweak limit. For example, Maps is pretty useful when lost and Zoom is helpful with school events while away from home.
- SV_BubbleTime 3y agoWhat do you think the rest of us did? Also, is the topic pretty phones or smartphones?
- kelnos 3y agoSo because we had it worse when we were kids, we should make sure kids today don't get to take advantage of anything modern? When I was a kid, I got to play with the cast-off computers my dad would bring home from work. If he had your attitude, he would have thought, "oh, we didn't have computers when I was a kid, so certainly there's no value in my son having one".
- SV_BubbleTime 3y agolol, who said we had it worse? We had it way better.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- 9dev 3y agoThat’s hyperbole. The computers you were lucky to grow up with weren’t entry points to multi billion dollar industries with the sole intent of pinning a child to a screen and sell them stuff. Smartphones introduce children to addictive behaviour way too early in their life, and that’s a completely different situation than tinker devices of yore.
- 3y ago
- thefz 3y agoLots of commenters here comparing smartphones and books... Hell, ever lost track of time reading because you were so deep in a book? There's no better feeling and doomscrolling is the exact opposite, it's a mindless activity.
- raptorraver 3y agoWe have decided that we are not going to give smartphones to our younger children. Our oldest has, she got it already at age 7, and we have realised that it was a mistake. We have relatively strict regulations for it (only 1 hour per day - sometimes even less etc.) but still we have noticed how it is affecting and changing how she feels about the world around and herself. One girl in her class doesn't have phone at all! The girl gets complaints from her parents because she reads too much books, spends time outside much more than our kid and does all kinds creative projects. It's same time inspiring and bit depressing to see in comparison how the smartphone free childhood looks like.
- za3faran 3y ago> but still we have noticed how it is affecting and changing how she feels about the world around and herself. Are you able to elaborate on what you noticed? > The girl gets complaints from her parents because she reads too much books Do you mean complements?
- another2another 3y ago>> The girl gets complaints from her parents because she reads too much [many] books > Do you mean complements? I'm pretty sure they meant 'complaints', but maybe you meant 'compliments' ? I sometimes complain about my son's reading - too fast. I recently bought a Dogman book for him that cost 7 GBP, and he'd read it within 30 minutes. Pound for pound, not worth the money as it has basically zero re-use.
- jskrablin 3y agoHow much time do you spend outside doing stuff with your kid? How much time do you spend talking with your kid re stuff she's doing at school, or stuff she's seen on her phone? How do you moderate smartphone usage (apart from the time limitation)? How do you motivate her to go outside and explore nature? You want to see her spending more time outside? Try starting with getting out yourself, taking her with you.
- v-erne 3y ago>> One girl in her class doesn't have phone at all! The girl gets complaints from her parents because she reads too much book I would not beat myselfe up too much in this situation. I happen to have two children who were risen almost identically with little to none restriction of access to phones, tablets, streaming and computer games. Older daughter just turned 10 years old and is reading more books than I (she even got her own library card made Matilda style), has quite good sport results (third place at schools olimpic running with older children), and even have time to do some group dancing, bringing handful of medals from competitions. And she is doing all this while spending lots of time with her friends outside. My 7 years old son, on the other hand, is none of this. After two years of access to tablet he still have problems with letting it go. An he does not want to start reading anything, despite me reading him books for most of his life. I think, we as parents, like to believe that we have some influence over "emerged" behaviours of our children, but somehow in the end it all comes down to their nature and is mostly accidental.
- Jedd 3y agoHere in NSW Australia our new state government is implementing a no-mobile-phones-in-high-schools (11-18yo) policy, scheduled to come into effect the last term (quarter) of 2023. This extends a similar existing policy in primary schools (5-11yo). I think in general it's a well received policy, and pushes questions and decisions about ownership and usage outside of school back onto parents. It may shift some of the economics favourably for parents that want to hold off a little longer in providing their kids with a phone. The problem - inasmuch as it's a problem - is evaluating the long-term success of such a policy in the absence of any kind of comparable control group. https://www.nsw.gov.au/media-releases/nsw-government-begins-mobile-phone-ban-public-high-schools https://www.nsw.gov.au/media-releases/nsw-government-begins-...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- everyone 3y agoJust fyi Greystones is a super exclusive wealthy area with insane property prices. probably every structure there would sell for at least 1 million euro. It's a satellite town of Dublin with a big motorway going by it that people commute to Dublin city centre on. Also on the coast with nice beaches and multiple golf courses for the rich assholes. I was interested in article but once I saw Greystones, I just thought, gross. Of course the wealthy elites can afford (in terms of time, money, education, opportunity cost etc.) to take steps to be more healthy.
- slushh 3y agoThe irony is that adults in Ireland like everywhere else spend hours online or watching tv. Everybody could have time to offer a healthy environment. As a community, what do you need more than a room for a library and a field to run and play soccer? Polo, golf and sailing are not the only sports that build character. The requirement is not wealth but being committed. That's even more difficult but easily ignored when lack of wealth seems to be the obstacle.
- Supernaut 3y agoWhat's your point? That mental health initiatives are only worth discussing if they originate in working class communities? Also, I grew up in the vicinity of Greystones and painting it as a kind of Irish Beverly Hills is daft. Everyone I knew from the town was regular middle class.
- Nathanba 3y agoThe underlying issue is obviously that children have nothing better to do than to be on a smartphone and that school is an oppressive, boring, hostile, unnatural environment. The answer isn't to take away their coping mechanism, it's to treat a human child like it should be treated. A young boy should be offered opportunities to partake in martial arts clubs, hunting clubs, robotics and programming competitions, fitness training, house building projects, general machinery and electronics projects and on and on the list goes. My honest opinion why society absolutely refuses to help children is because it is full of adults who envy and fear the children. They know that a 12 year old could do 80% of their job within a year if given the smallest amount of encouragement and instruction. Real life isn't allowed to compete with the virtual world, that's why the virtual world is winning in the child's life.
- grumpyprole 3y agoAll the above sounds great but costs money. In the UK, the ruling class have consistently cut school budgets in real terms over decades. For example, music lessons are 30 to 1, sing or bring-your-own plastic recorder. For sports day, my child wasn't in the top few of the class that got to actually run on the last patch of grass that hasn't been sold off.
- 9dev 3y agoSo… forgive me for jumping onto that, but I found the way you phrased it interesting - is it only boys allowed to do all that stuff? What are girls supposed to be doing, knitting and cooking?
- stainablesteel 3y agoi completely agree with this notion i've been wanting to out-compete the current schooling paradigm by using kids as little innovators and having them graduate with the skills to set up or participate in a functional business, no college necessary.
- imbnwa 3y agoAmerica use to have technical and vocational secondary schools, I went to one of the last ones in a top 3 major city, right before the last remnants of that legacy were phased out. In the 1960s, my high school had automobile shop, architectural drafting, wood shop that produced professional level artifacts at the senior level; in the 1940s, it had put together a plane. Today, it is yet another "college prep" competing for funds via standardized testing results, segregating students who are capable at purely academic demands and exercises from the vast majority of everyone else. This shift was likely initiated both by the beginnings of austerity in the US and by a trends towards a cultural prejudice toward being able to work right out of high school (likely incubated that austerity), an outcome in no way exclusive to blue-collar work, but carried that connotation anyway and so became frowned upon (I distinctly remember this being a problem in the 90s, even though my grandfather worked his entire life at a General Electric factory, had bought a home for his family of 6, etc)
- valachio 3y agoFunny because if China did this, everyone will think of them as evil.
- WinstonSmith84 3y agoSeems very accurate to me. While I'm looking forward to this experiment, it feels so much like all what adults (many of them) are forbidding to children, thinking it will be better off preserving their innocence, until they turn 18. They've suddenly access to cars, alcohol, sex and more, and when mixed together, especially the alcohol part, after 18 years of obedience, this sometimes doesn't end up very well. On another hand, some parents educate their children drinking small amount of wine and/or beer - is that worse?
- tlrobinson 3y ago> A study by the London School of Economics found pupils at phone-free schools performed better in GCSE exams, especially those in bottom 60% of KS2 tests https://www.theguardian.com/education/2015/may/15/mobile-phone-bans-improve-school-exam-results-research-shows https://www.theguardian.com/education/2015/may/15/mobile-pho...
- pleb_nz 3y ago13 year old with phones? Crazy. My kids right have phones until at least 15 and that seems fairly normal in my circles
- dools 3y agoI'm not giving my eldest daughter a smartphone until she is 15. She has an iPad, a laptop, an apple watch and a 4g Nokia, but when she gets a smartphone with a SIM in it, it's the last thing she will ever look at. I'm just trying to get her exposed to as much real life as possible before that happens.
- sam_goody 3y agoMy community discourages smartphones for all ages, and strongly discourages them through primary and high school. The next community over has no such attitude, and I live on the border. My two cents: 1. It's a great idea. Good luck to the Irish. 2. Anecdotally, the kids without smartphones really are much more socially connected, better problem solvers, less lazy, more respectful of others, and more focused. They exercise more, they hike more, they build more. 3. Most of the technical complaints are easily solved. Communication can be done excellently with dumb phones (or smart watches that have a phone built in). Education tasks can be solved with a desktop computer. eInk book readers without an internet connection is fine and encourages reading. If that is too hard, a large tablet is a good compromise - annoying enough not to be impulsive (especially if you use a separate modem) but otherwise with all the benefits of a phone. 4. There is a strong tendency in our community for the kids to learn programming. Not sure if that is related, but the lack of smartphones is clearly not an impediment. 5. That said, there are things you miss, and it is a price to pay. For me as an adult, probably the lack of WhatsApp is the biggest issue. However, the price is WELL worth it.
- 5- 3y agoall kaios 2.5.1 phones should have whatsapp. https://www.gsmarena.com/results.php3?sOSes=10&sOSversions=10250 https://www.gsmarena.com/results.php3?sOSes=10&sOSversions=1... https://www.kaiostech.com/help-center/whatsapp-on-kaios/ https://www.kaiostech.com/help-center/whatsapp-on-kaios/
- GuB-42 3y agoDoes it has anything to do with smartphones though? It looks like it is simply a case of caring for your kids. Smartphones are an easy solution for parents, give them one and it keep your kid occupied while you are doing your stuff. Having your kids "socially connected" typically involve getting them into clubs and the like. For hiking, they probably need someone to get them to the hiking place and at a younger age, accompany them. Even more complicated now that leaving your kids live their live outside without constant physical supervision is more and more frowned upon.
- 3y ago
- fullspectrumdev 3y agoWhat’s funny is, it used to be a social norm here (in Ireland) for you to not be allowed get a phone until you were 13 or so (usually: just before you went to secondary school). Of course, people from fucking Greystones would make out that this is a revolutionary new concept. I can’t see it lasting, they will be back to letting the iPad raise their kids within the year.
- BiteCode_dev 3y agoNo need to go that far, banning phones from schools would already go a long way.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- LatteLazy 3y ago[flagged]
- tohnjitor 3y agoThirteen still seems too young but good for them.
- slifin 3y agoI hope they have provided adequate alternative things to do Or areas of the town that are safe from cars for them to play together in as an alternative
- LatteLazy 3y agoNo, that would take time and effort and money and self discipline and speaking to their kids. This is a free (actually cheaper than free), quick thing they can boast about doing at dinner parties.
- Mindwipe 3y agoEspecially when it doesn't actually happen because people tend to lie and compliance levels will be low.
- throwaway71271 3y agoWe have absolutely failed with any kinds parental controls. I honestly don't care if its instagram or tiktok or snapchat or whatever app, or its generative ai app that generates the most personalized and addictive content possible. We have gotten more 'surveillance' kind of control, monitor where the kids are, which app they are using and for how long, when they go to sleep, when they wake up etc. We can limit which app is used how long, but not what content is consumed, you are what you eat, watch toxic and depressing shit and become toxic and depressed person. The same way a parent can make sure they are buying the right nutrients for their kids, they should be able to make sure they are consuming valuable content. Instead this is left to an extremely greedy algorithm with the only goal of extracting as much attention as it can from the user. The reality is that the recommendation algorithm, the company developing it, the content creators and everyone in that chain, has completely different goals (usually: how to get more money) than the parents of the child, or the child consuming the content.
- kgwxd 3y agoYou can’t actually limit anything. Kids that don’t have even a shred of technical know-how will walk to the ends of the earth to figure out how to get around it. My kid figuring out how to beat iPhone parental controls is my proudest moment as a parent.
- storkhm 3y agoIt is delusional for sure. The kid that hits puberty is going to figure out a way to watch porn on their phone if they have a phone. The phone has to practically be useless for them to not figure this out. Parents are just in denial because the whole subject is so uncomfortable.
- gnicholas 3y agoHow’d he/she do it?
- cjrp 3y ago> The same way a parent can make sure they are buying the right nutrients for their kids, they should be able to make sure they are consuming valuable content It's an interesting parallel, because after a certain age you really can't control everything a child eats. At some point they can make their own decisions, and you have to hope you've explained well enough that eating garbage for every meal will make you feel lousy. It's similar to technology/social media.
- kgwxd 3y agoThis principle and the adults advocating for this should be looked into. The “for the children” crowd is invariably the ones harming the most children.
- mensetmanusman 3y agoPHD tech developer here with an 11 year old daughter. I wish this would happen in the US. Our family is the odd one out, because most parents are not yet aware of the harms of social media and FOMO (esp. for girls). Of course, our daughter is extremely annoyed at us all the time because of peer pressure...
- NickBusey 3y agoI would vote for this in the US in a heartbeat. Give them a flip phone. They can still call, text, even take very bad photos, without the targeted harm that is modern social media.
- tomjen3 3y agoIts a screaming red flag that the people who are most opposed to kids being on smart phones are the tech people. As a potential compromise, an Apple Watch with celular means they can still write to their friends and family, get directions etc.
- Eldt 3y agoThe problem is social life having been transplanted onto the back of social media. Kids are missing out on socialising. They shouldn't have to rely on social media for that, though.
- pawelmurias 3y agoSome of them seem to be outcasts who don't care about them being socially isolated and would love them to stay at home and play Atari games. Obviously stopping the kids from doom scrolling or watching netflix all day is crucial so they don't grown into morons is necessary but being weird and isolated is no fun either.
- 908B64B197 3y agoKeep in mind there's a direct correlation between "screen time" and depression... Meaning that kids that spend 5+ hours per day on their phones are depressed. Up to one hour had no noticeable effects. [0] Now think about why a kid would self-isolate for 5 hours a day and it might give you a clue about why they are depressed in the first place (hint, it's not the magical screen!). [0] https://jonathanhaidt.substack.com/p/social-media-mental-illness-epidemic https://jonathanhaidt.substack.com/p/social-media-mental-ill...
- amriksohata 3y agoIts the rubbish parents that end up indirectly putting pressure on other parents who want to avoid phones for their kids.
- tstrimple 3y agoIt's the rubbish parents who cannot build a relationship with their children without dictating what other parents are allowed to do. If you cannot be a responsible parent because of what other parents are doing, you're the lousy parent.
- amriksohata 3y agoNot a bad point at all. But many parents aren't skilled in parenting to know how to build that relationship and their kids get a lot of peer pressure.
- SliceOfWaifu 3y agoI bet right now some teenager in Ireland is surely stocking up on low cost tablets to sell to those kids at a markup. Anybody who thinks those kids won't just hide their contraband devices from their parents and teachers is a fool who doesn't remember being a kid.