4 ms·
Against Neurodiversity - why the neurodiversity movement has become harmful
- andsoitis 3y agoInto this maelstrom came the neurodiversity movement, whose advocates celebrate autism as a gift that is an integral part of identity. They promise to make the voices of autistics heard, and to improve their quality of life by making the world more accepting of, and accommodating for, them, after decades of being marginalised and victimised. However, in recent years, there has been a backlash against this – growing numbers of people are now speaking out against the neurodiversity movement, claiming that it does not represent them and, more importantly, that it ignores the plight of those with severe autism. and Firstly, neurodiversity advocates can romanticise autism. While many with mild forms of autism might lead relatively ‘normal’ daily lives with little or no assistance, many who are more severely affected cannot function properly without round-the-clock care. Yet John Marble, the self-advocate and founder of Pivot Diversity – an organisation in San Francisco that aims to ‘pivot autism towards solutions which empower autistic people, their families and employers’ – posted on Twitter in 2017: ‘THERE IS NO SUCH THING AS SEVERE AUTISM, just as there is no such thing as “severe homosexuality” or “severe blackness”.’
- supriyo-biswas 3y agoExtracting only this bit takes away some of the nuance of the article.
- viraptor 3y agoI think this article is really lacking in trying to quantify the sentiment. I mean, when some idea goes worldwide, there will always be some wierdos taking the label and claiming it applies to their view. But is it widespread enough that we would actually care, or should we just look at the original goal? For example my mom claiming she's a feminist because women are better does not invalidate or change what actual feminism means or has achieved.
- Arch485 3y agoThe author of this article seems uninfomed about the "neurodiversity movement" - As someone who is neurodivergent, I am an advocate for awareness surrounding neurodiversity etc. and I've never heard someone say that another person is a "eugenicist" or "neo nazi" for wanting a cure. While I'm sure this has happened (and probably still does happen), it's almost certainly a minority of people. Casting a net and saying that everyone in the "neurodiversity movement" does this is untrue (as is the case for all generalizations).
- dekhn 3y agoSee an example here. https://a4aontario.com/2021/03/31/we-deserve-to-be-born-other-reasons-why-we-oppose-autism-speaks/ https://a4aontario.com/2021/03/31/we-deserve-to-be-born-othe... https://medium.com/artfullyautistic/autism-speaks-deception-eugenics-and-abuse-618cf65c094a https://medium.com/artfullyautistic/autism-speaks-deception-... https://www.disabilitynewsservice.com/autistic-campaigners-to-protest-over-study-that-sparked-eugenics-fears/ https://www.disabilitynewsservice.com/autistic-campaigners-t... I knew the researchers at AS a decade or so ago and they were absolutely unhappy and in fact miserable that people kept making up lies about this or intentionally (and even unintentionally) misrepresenting what they were doing, in terms of research and policy.
- Arch485 3y agoIn the case of Autism Speaks, they definitely suck. Not because of their research necessarily, but because of how they paint people with ASD as some terrible burden on their family etc. etc. I'm not saying caring for someone who is low-functioning is easy, but the way AS paints people with ASD is certainly demeaning. In terms of the research protest: I can't speak on that too much because I don't have enough of the context, but I can say that people have similar concerns outside of autism/neurodivergent things (e.g. many people are worried companies like 23andme are using DNA samples to build a superbaby). It's less so villainising a company because they're "trying to cure autism" (which this study was explicity not doing) and more so "nobody trusts a private corporation with that data".