6 ms·
Democracy Is the Solution to Vetocracy
- LapsangGuzzler 3y agoI love the idea of this, but I see one huge obstacle to making this happen: the current property owners. The whole reason we're in this situation is because the power asymmetry between property owners and renters seems to be growing at a significant rate. Rapidly rising property values benefit property owners at the expense of the renters and redistributing the rights of a property owner to the community would have massive ramifications for how real estate is valued. The main hurdle to overcome is finding the politicians you'd need to take power from property owners to give to non-owner residents, and the big problem (at least in the US) is that even at the local level, governments tend to be run by property owners and supported by property-owning donors. Money is fundamental to who gets elected, and as long as this is true, balancing the power disparity and giving real voting power to non-property owners to determine what happens to property will be a massive challenge.
- uoaei 3y agoUp until the phrase "real estate" this same argument could be applied to all sorts of ownership/rentership dichotomies, e.g. subscription-based services (streaming, SaaS, etc.) vs ownership of content media (buying albums, self-hosting, etc.). Software and digital media more generally really calls into question the notions of property per se.
- tommy5dollar 3y agoThe benefit of this proposal is that it pits property owners against each other. It might be in the interests of property owners as a class to not build in order to see values increase but the greed of individual owners will lead to some cracking and building in order to maximise their individual wealth.
- AmpsterMan 3y agoGiven there are enough property owners, this is expected. But in the presence of a few property owners, the opportunity for collusion is higher because the opportunity cost of defecting is higher than the opportunity cost of not defecting. This centralization of property into a few owners is something that is happening all over the Anglosphere.
- dionidium 3y ago> The main hurdle to overcome is finding the politicians you'd need to take power from property owners to give to non-owner residents The opposite is true. We need to overturn Euclid and similar rulings that took rights away from individual property owners. Property owners should be allowed to build housing on their own land. There is no legitimate public interest in preventing it (beyond banal, ordinary preferences that are better expressed in a market) and an immense public interest in allowing it. You get rid of the veto point by restoring property rights, not by further limiting them.
- arrosenberg 3y agoThis might work if you put a hard cap on how much property any entity can own individually or by proxy. Otherwise Blackstone, et al. will build the cheapest apartment blocks they can everywhere and lock average Americans out of ownership until the revolution comes.
- ZoomerCretin 3y agoHomeownership only has value because it's effectively (buy-in) rent control. Without rent being too expensive, there's no real need for homeownership. It's actually a negative when you consider reduced mobility and the cost of selling.
- lotsoweiners 3y ago> It's actually a negative when you consider reduced mobility and the cost of selling. A lot of us homeowners enjoy the things you described here. I want to live in a neighborhood with people who have lived here 5-10+ years. The last thing I want is for my family to be amongst a transient population who have no vested interest in their neighborhood.
- mannyv 3y agoDemocracy is essentially mob rule. It's great when the mob is doing what you want, not so great when it isn't. Currently most Western democracies are designed to protect minority rights against the majority because of this. In fact, the Bill or Rights in the US can be seen as a great example of this: it prevents the current majority from removing rights deemed essential. If you look at states that have weak individual property rights (all the communist states, most of the Iberian colonies) you can see the issue: weak property rights by individuals go hand in hand with authoritarianism. Those who want "change" always want to destroy the system. Historically speaking, that has led to disasters of one sort of another.
- tommy5dollar 3y agoThe UK is one of the Western democracies without the protections you're talking about (no written constitution, no ability to bind future parliaments, law passed by a simple majority of parliamentarians, first-past-the-post and strong third-parties leading to parliamentary majorities with ~35% of the vote) but has one of the longest and proudest histories when it comes to freedom and liberty. Mob rule is always a risk but it's often better than rule by an out-of-touch elite.
- nemo44x 3y agoWhy does the elite automatically have to be out of touch? They are the most invested in it all and are incentivized to have a functional state. Democratically elected representatives have no such incentive. Their only incentive is to convince enough people to grant them power. An aristocratic monarchy is preferable to an oligarchical “democracy” like we have today.
- HereBePandas 3y agoThe US has had the Bill of Rights and its constitutional system / property protection for a long time but only recently has had the degree of NIMBYism that it's had. It's easy to pretend the bug is actually an important and noble feature, but sometimes it's just a bug that needs fixing.
- mynameishere 3y agoThe solution to people not wanting their neighborhoods destroyed is to destroy them anyway. You are properly understood. "Aberfeldy Village" is apparently a poor area, and so the ruling class just kind-of exasperatedly assumes that they can run roughshod, and I find it pleasant that it's not the case. Why don't the rich fucks knock over their own houses if that's such a wonderful thing?
- tommy5dollar 3y agoHuh? The impoverished residents of the estate voted to have it "destroyed" (from which they would personally gain) but it was rich elites that blocked it because it's a vote winner in the wider community to be viewed as anti-development
- II2II 3y agoIt's an odd situation, but I can see where the sentiment comes from. Poorer communities are usually the target of redevelopment, frequently with promises on how things will improve, only to discover that the promises were hollow down the road. In a case like this, where there is supposed to be an incredibly large change in the demographic of the community, I can understand how some would interpret the small increase in social housing as being a hollow promise.
- RobotToaster 3y agoSo they want to replace an estate that is 76% social housing, with one that's 23% social housing? I can see the objection.
- fallingknife 3y agoIt adds to the total number of social housing. You need to look at the absolute numbers and not just the percentage.
- RobotToaster 3y agoAn increase in the number of properties perhaps, but I would like to see the number of people each property can comfortably house. There's a difference between a three bedroom house and a 1 bedroom flat or bedsit.
- II2II 3y agoYou have to look at both. Consider a simplistic example: what would prevent the new majority from holding a vote to convert the social housing into market housing? (More realistically: they owners would either lobby to change the agreement or outright break the agreement, realizing they have the community support.) Yes, there has to be an increase in the absolute numbers. It may be acceptable to compromise on the composition of the community to get those numbers. On the other hand, ignoring the percentages altogether will produce a change in dynamics that will ultimately be detrimental to those in need of social housing.
- tommy5dollar 3y agoIt seems foolish to say we can never do anything that makes the life of the poor better just because it also helps the non-poor
- abdullahkhalids 3y agoOP's identified problem: Sometimes good projects are unable to proceed because some small set of losers of the project veto it. OP's policy proposal: "for a development worth doing, it should be possible to pay off most of the people who object and still make the development worthwhile." OP recognizes that some people will pretend that their losses are very large even when they are quite small. "But if we could clearly and strictly demarcate the “true losers” from a project, and allow them to retain their veto, we would perhaps be on the way to making this intractable problem tractable " They don't really have a clear idea on how to correctly identify the "true losers". In fact, I would argue that identifying true losers is where the intractability of the larger problem emerges from.
- tommy5dollar 3y agoWell, it sounds like you could come up with a set of useful heuristics, like living next door to the property. It feels intrinsically pretty cheems to just say "this sounds tricky so we shouldn't bother" when the existing system is completely dysfunctional
- abdullahkhalids 3y ago> Well, it sounds like you could come up with a set of useful heuristics, like living next door to the property. This is a political problem, so it recurses quite a lot. Whatever set of heuristics you come up with, someone will object to them because they will be losers if we use those heuristics. Then someone will object to the composition of the committee that generated the heuristics. Then someone will object to the system that system that came up with the committee.... Of course, we should try to figure out solutions. But these are "wicked problem" [1]. Solutions are not easy to come by, and there will always be objectors. You can't turn this into a well-defined technical problem with a well-formed solution. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wicked_problem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wicked_problem
- NoMoreNicksLeft 3y agoPart of the problem is that this isn't as fungible as economics leads us to believe. If some working class knob will lose his home, then it's often enough to just offer him twice as much as the home is worth (maybe with helping him find another equivalent home). Such a person knows that it's a good deal, and they end up better off for it. Any perceived reluctance is often just a negotiating tactic, and can be quickly resolved by making the bargain sweeter. But if Sterling Fitzbillionaire has a mansion with the most beautiful and exclusive view of the shoreline has to put up with an offshore windmill... there's literally no amount of money that makes up for him losing this. You could offer him $10 trillion, and the money is worthless because the mansion with that view is rare enough (or even unique) that money can't buy him another one like it with an unspoiled view. You've reached the fungibility limits of money/property. Say whatever you want about greed or spitefulness, there is a much more fundamental issue going on here, and it doesn't seem very tractable. It's only aggravated by the plain fact that such people are often in much more influential positions, if not in political offices outright. The best I can come up with is by disallowing the vetoes entirely, unless they are accompanied by some counter-offer that outlines what would be required for them to withdraw it. Wouldn't matter so much whether the terms were absurd (or seemingly impossible), by forcing them to draft those, it might shift their mindset enough that negotiations (however troubled) could commence. I'm not certain this works, you'd have to run the experiment. I think it might solve some minor fraction of these issues, maybe that improvement's better than nothing.
- quantum_state 3y agoObserving the behavior of a democratic system as a whole and over time, it seems inevitable that it leads to polarization and many other undesirable behaviors at the system level … just share this as a straw man for ideas to improve…
- zoogeny 3y ago> Bottom line up front: I think the solution is to let small groups of people most directly affected by a new development vote on the development. I think this would make it possible to buy them off, and win the support or compliance of the most motivated opponents of the things we need to build. This shifts the problem from one place to another. Who do you decide gets to vote? > I realise that this is a very vague categorisation. Who is to decide what “significant” losing out means here? Bear with me, but ultimately that is what I’m going to suggest is the big, interesting research question for anyone who wants to solve vetocracy. Oh. So the solution is: I don't have a solution so I'm going to move the problem from one place to another and state that it is an interesting question for someone else to solve. This goes on and on for a ridiculously long article stating how awesome this would be, if we could only accurately identify those affected by change. Sure. Just given a sufficiently smart compiler. Given an omnipotent genie. We can all solve all of the problems when we bury them in some impossible wish. All we need are the right people to vote. None of the wrong people. And then we can bribe the right people to vote the right way. Then democracy will work. /sarcasm If your solution to vetocracy is to limit democracy then you aren't using democracy. Democracy becomes subordinate to the mechanism you are using to define the limit. At that point, the mechanism that determines that limit becomes your solution. So hand-waving it away as "an interesting research problem" means that you haven't solved anything at all. You could just as well get rid of democracy and keep only the mechanism of limit and the bribes.
- tommy5dollar 3y agoIt seems useful to identify the right problem. It's better to know you just need the right compiler than the think the issue is something else as you can then work on building the right compiler. Obviously democracy should be limited to the relevant franchise. We don't let children vote, we don't let people who don't live (and are not from) an area vote. The entire point is to identify the right set of people who should vote, based on those who suffer from the related externalities. It seems unfair to say the article just moves the problem elsewhere, it touches on proposed solutions such as street-level development votes.
- zoogeny 3y ago
- cyberax 3y agoLook, this might work in the UK where the space is at a premium. In the US there is plenty of land available, and in some states you can buy houses for basically free. What we need are policies to make sure jobs don't flee from into several monstrously oversized cities. Sidenote, the industrial collapse of 90-s and 2000-s was the reason a lot of US states veered hard-right.
- HereBePandas 3y agoWhat kinds of specific policies do you have in mind? Seems like the reason people in the US don't build houses in the empty patches in the US is because the economics of agglomeration mean much greater efficiency/economic growth when you build them in existing large cities. How do you fight this without making the country much less economically dynamic?
- cyberax 3y ago> What kinds of specific policies do you have in mind? Limit the amount of office space density (cap&trade style, or with a direct tax). Promote decentralization via tax credits, etc. These are all old ideas, but these days they can be turbo-charged by promoting WFH. > Seems like the reason people in the US don't build houses in the empty patches in the US is because the economics of agglomeration mean much greater efficiency/economic growth when you build them in existing large cities. Yes. It's more efficient to open an office in a large city, where you have access to a larger talent pool. And in turn, it's more advantageous to live near a dense city core, as it provides you with more options for employment. This leads to a never-ending densification and price growth spiral. Manhattan is a good example of the end-game of this kind of death spiral. And these are exactly the same kinds of market forces that forced companies to dump toxic waste into rivers. After all, if you take care to clean up your toxic waste, then your products will be more expensive and less competitive.
- fzeroracer 3y agoYou're looking at a side effect, deeming it the problem and trying to solve that problem rather than solving the actual issue at hand. For example let's look at Japan. Japan does not have what you dubbed a densification and price growth spiral despite having cities far more dense than any city in the US. This should tell you that your initial problem is the wrong problem. The answer is that they develop high-speed transportation to and from dense cores in addition to smaller sparser towns. This means property value is far lower because distance doesn't matter and in fact housing value inverts where it purely depreciates. If we did what you propose, you would see what's happening to cities like Austin. Where offices are built in a purely sprawling fashion, highly dense traffic and shifting property value to areas along traffic corridors.
- nologic01 3y agoThere is at the beginning a comparison of various structural differences between the UK, France and Germany to motivate the piece so I was sort of expecting to see at some point how decision making structures compare and the impac to that. Anecdotaly NIMBY behavior and vetocracy is quite widespread across Europe (at least). Or, to turn the argument around, if there are concrete practices that can be shown to have worked elsewhere one does not need to reinvent the wheel.
- hef19898 3y agoThat article pretty much ignores centuries of political scienes and historians' work. All based on some unconnected charts and a personal opinion on what projects are "good" and which ones are not.
- tptacek 3y agoWhat political science work is it ignoring?
- hef19898 3y agoEverything regarding how democracies and voting work. There countless of ways how it implemented, studies on how those affect outcomes, you name it. I didn't see a single reference to that body of work in this blog post. In short, everything.
- stuaxo 3y agoIt's a weird article. The focus on productivity is odd, especially comparing productive parts of the country to others. A lot of those parts of the country serve as dormitory towns to London, it's simplistic to say they are not productive - yes, but it's ignoring that all the jobs are in London and a few other places. A bad thing about many of these places is they don't have much "place" to them, there is barely any investment in the things that would make that happen. Even in places that don't suffer this there is short term thinking that means compared to London there is virtually no investment in transport outside of roads.
- Guthur 3y agoIt can never work, it just never has and smarter people than us have tried. Democracy will be captured and corrupted like it already has, by an oligarchic elite. It happened to the Greeks, it happened to the Romans and it's happened to us. And now we have such hypnotic tools like mass/social media that mass delusion can be instilled at the drop of a proverbial hat. And no, Science wont save you as it can be bought too. Even tobacco and sugar companies were able to deny the obvious by purchasing a few scientists of fortune.
- elcritch 3y ago> Even tobacco and sugar companies were able to deny the obvious by purchasing a few scientists of fortune. For a time, but then the science won out. First culturally then legally for tobacco. Now sugar industry is loosing culturally and more realize the effects of overconsumption.
- Guthur 3y agoThat's not as good as it first looks, it was well understood by the turn of 20th century that there was a strong correlation between smoking and disease, it took the better part of a century to bring this to the fore. Imagine how prevalent a misconception could be if the disconnect is less clear. Science is a methodology nothing more. The problem is any appeal to human authority, it was quite easy to keep smoking and say "but the science says so...".
- pc2g4d 3y agoI appreciate the thought put into this, and really don't get the nihilistic response of "Oh, it will never work, why even bother trying". If you have suggestions for improvement, raise them, or critiques that need a response, raise them. My suggestion would be to combine this approach with quadratic voting. Then there's no need to decide who does or doesn't get to vote on a development proposal. People who care about it will use their votes on that. Those who don't will use their votes elsewhere. Because votes are finite, people have to prioritize.
- pessimizer 3y agoNo, vetocracy has always been the solution to majority votes. What's the problem with majority rule? That when 100 people vote, 51 can vote to take away the vote from the other 49, 26 can vote to take away the vote from 25, and so on until you have 2 voting to take away the vote from the third. The major problem of democracy is the preservation of minority rights, and this article takes an enormous amount of time to say that, and to propose a further question (should the minority affected by the decisions of a group have a bigger say than everyone else?) which has been discussed to no consensus since the Greeks. edit: if there's any answer, it's that a group needs to come up with a set of shared principles/axioms, and develop their decisionmaking process based on those (and how deliberative bodies have justified their processes in the past), rather than trying to cargo-cult some high-level framework built on sand.
- bedobi 3y agoAgree with some of what you say... in the case of fundamental rights. But that's not what the article is referring to. Vetocracy in practice is usually small minorities of privileged people protecting their right to keep things that aren't even theirs - in the case of NIMBYism, their "right" to keep a neighborhood from changing in any way, whether in terms of what types of homes are allowed to build there (no multifamily homes, even if they're constructed to be indistinguishable from the other homes!), whether there should be street parking should or not (of course, already wealthy detached home owners love being able to park their vehicles on public streets, at all other taxpayers expense), whether a bike lane should be allowed to pass through the neighbourhood or not (looking at you Chelsea Kensington), if a school, hospital, 7-11 or any other kind of service or business should be allowed to be built in the area or not etc etc. These are things best decided by majority and not left to vetocracy.
- thsksbd 3y ago[dead]
- Razengan 3y agoLet AI optimize everything to minimize the number of people that are unhappy. (without killing or drugging the unhappies)
- amrocha 3y agoI think there's 2 things being conflated here. 1 is opposition to large scale government projects, for example demolishing existing houses to build infrastructure. 2 is opposition to smaller development, for example building something in a lot you own. 1 should be under scrutiny, especially given governments history of screwing over their minority citizens. 2 should be completely outlawed. I believe we need a "mind you own business" approach to development. No, a developer doesn't need to ask the local community before building something (that complies with zoning) in a lot they own.
- specialist 3y agoThis otherwise very fine article misses one simple explanation, esp wrt France vs UK: The majority of the UK is owned by very few people. Cite: "Who Owns Britain" by Brian Cahill. This ownership has not been transparent. Nor do they pay their share of taxes; rather they receive an outside amount of subsidies. The first step to fixing UK's vetocracy by fixing UK's gini coefficient. I'm sure Thomas Piketty would say much the same, but I haven't read his books yet (just reviews and interviews). Of course, the plantation class will continue to wage class war to prevent any reasonable reforms.
- User23 3y agoThe system is of minor importance. What's of major importance is the benevolence and competence or lack thereof of the decision makers.