2 ms·
Cave painting is less limiting than an old computer, not more. You can paint anything you want in a cave wall: reproduce a flat old painting; make a graffiti wi
by latexr 3y ago
Cave painting is less limiting than an old computer, not more. You can paint anything you want in a cave wall: reproduce a flat old painting; make a graffiti with a 3D effect; carve the wall to create depth; programatically generate a pattern of colours that is then painted by a robotic arm…
On a computer you’re constrained by the hardware and software. It’s its own smaller world which exists outside of you and has intractable limitations. But if you dedicate enough time to understand the system and keep trying, you may achieve what was otherwise thought impossible. The process of discovery can be more enjoyable, interesting, useful, and artistic than the output itself.
- amelius 3y ago> Cave painting is less limiting than an old computer, not more. What are you trying to say here? That old computer art is the most restrictive artform imaginable?
- latexr 3y agoAbsolutely not. If I said “grey is lighter than black” would you think I was saying “grey is the lightest colour imaginable”? That would be quite the extrapolation. I have never considered what “the most restrictive artform imaginable” is. I’m not even convinced that’s possible to assert definitely. Could make for an interesting thought experiment, though.
- amelius 3y agoI think you missed my point. Let's say for the sake of argument that HP48 art is more restrictive than C64 art. Why weren't the C64 artists using HP48 calculators instead? And why aren't we looking at HP48 art in awe, instead of this C64 "non-art"?
- latexr 3y agoLet’s take pixel art on console gaming as an example. In the early days, games used pixel graphics due to technical constraints. Artists were limited in what they could achieve and had to get creative within the limitations to push the software and hardware to its limits in pursuit of a specific vision. Everyone had the same set of restrictions but thanks to creative technical decisions some rose above as exceptional. There is a particular kind of enjoyment in creating a lot with very little. If your digital art can be hundreds of GBs in size, your 3D rendition of the Sistine Chapel will be judged by its faithfulness; but if you’re only allowed a handful of KBs and everyone believes any kind of 3D graphics are impossible at that size, your dinky little rotating cube becomes an impressive technological feat. Context matters. A tractor pulling a plane is not impressive; a man pulling a plane is. Most people could do the former but not the latter. Furthermore, not all limitations are equally interesting. Nostalgia and popularity also play a role. Today, pixel graphics are an aesthetic choice. Developers and artist can go beyond what was possible when they were a necessity and create something entirely new. Yet some still derive enjoyment and pride from following the limitations of yore to the letter: there are games created in the 2000s which work on the NES. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Micro_Mages https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Micro_Mages https://youtube.com/watch?v=ZWQ0591PAxM https://youtube.com/watch?v=ZWQ0591PAxM