3 ms·
> Detroit’s world-beating automotive industry squandered its technological and manufacturing advantages in a rush, pushed by Wall Street and its own financial m
by ChrisMarshallNY 3y ago
> Detroit’s world-beating automotive industry squandered its technological and manufacturing advantages in a rush, pushed by Wall Street and its own financial managers, to earn easy profits from inferior products.
That sounds familiar…
- MrBuddyCasino 3y ago[flagged]
- saagarjha 3y agoThey called it "evil racism" because that's exactly what it is. Your comment is, quite honestly, appalling–integrating minorities into cities is not "politically motivated ethnic cleansing" by any stretch of the imagination.
- Taniwha 3y agoBut until relatively recently San Franciso was SV adjacent, not really part of it, more like the grown up cousin up the road where the traditional bankers lived. San Jose has always been the big city in Silicon Valley
- MrBuddyCasino 3y agoThis is true, those are not the same issues. My understanding is that the center of gravity of the tech scene has moved from Palo Alto and Mountain View to SF in recent years.
- bartread 3y agoIt wasn't just this though. Japanese (and later other far eastern countries') cost of labour was far lower, so they could build a better product at a lower price point than American manufacturers. That's not to say that lack of focus on quality and overly-aggressive cost-cutting by Ford and others wasn't a problem - it absolutely was - but the article is substantially oversimplifying the situation. I haven't yet come to a conclusion as to whether that's forgivable in its pursuit of making a bigger point: The Spectator does have a tendency towards superficially high-minded but ultimately ineffectual chatter (which at least fits with its name).
- DebtDeflation 3y agoThe period from 1973-1983 was known as the "Malaise Era" for US Automakers: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Malaise_era https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Malaise_era The issue wasn't mainly labor costs, it was a combination of new emissions regulations and rising gas prices along with US Automakers refusal to adopt fuel injection instead doggedly clinging to ever more complicated iterations of the carburetor (the computer controlled carburetors of the early 1980s with their rats nest of wires and vacuum hoses reached peak Rube Goldberg status). Meanwhile, Bosch introduced fuel injection in 1973 and within a couple of years FI was standard on most European and Japanese cars; US automakers waited a decade to adopt it en masse.
- ryandrake 3y agoAviation is even more doggedly clinging. You can still buy brand new airplanes with carburetors. The industry is being dragged kicking and screaming into the FI era, and we're also starting to see electronic ignition and even FADEC systems emerging, mostly in the Experimental category.
- hodgesrm 3y ago> The Spectator does have a tendency towards superficially high-minded but ultimately ineffectual chatter (which at least fits with its name). The article draws rather thinly supported conclusions about SV from the collapse of Silicon Valley Bank. Yes, the bank failed but so did others like First Republic, and for similar reasons: interest rates went up and left them holding low-interest bonds that undermined their balance sheets. This is plain old bad management. The Fed response is similarly explainable by fear of contagion. It would have been a stronger argument if the Spectotor pointed out that many large VC-funded firms look like pyramid schemes. Wework and Uber are two obvious examples, along with numerous recent database IPOs--firms that still have no clear route to profitability. Not only that, prominent VC firms seemed to double down on the strategy, as evidenced by A16Z funding Adam Neumann (again) after Wework. [0] [0] https://a16z.com/2022/08/15/investing-in-flow/ https://a16z.com/2022/08/15/investing-in-flow/ Edit: typo
- VHRanger 3y agoDetroit's decline is a product of two main factors: 1. Protectionism 2. Recalcitrant unions Protectionism from the tariffs like the Chicken Tax made the US auto industry easily profitable for decades. This meant the industry didn't evolve like the japanese/korean/european counterparts. They could profit even with substandard cars. Unions aren't necessarily bad, on their own. Arguably, the USA needs more unions right now. But they can worsen problems of inefficiency by reducing the adaptability of the org.
- actionfromafar 3y agoI'd go so far as to say, that recalcitrant unions are more of a symptom of protectionism than a separate thing.
- xg15 3y agoI think a good counter example is the pivot of the Ruhr area from a mining and heavy industries hub to an economy centered on tech and services. It happened despite strong union presence in the old sectors. I think one of the deciding factors was a strong social safety net and an active strategy of the state to bring over the employees into the new sectors and don't just leave them stranded with obsolete skills. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ruhr#Postwar_period https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ruhr#Postwar_period https://www.ruhr-guide.de/freizeit/industriekultur/das-ruhrgebiet-die-entwicklung-und-der-strukturwandel/21960,0,0.html https://www.ruhr-guide.de/freizeit/industriekultur/das-ruhrg... (Couldn't find a good article in english unfortunately)
- nradov 3y agoDetroit's decline had as much to do with shitty product designs as with protectionism and unions. It wasn't union members who designed the Ford Pinto or Oldsmobile diesel engines.
- VHRanger 3y agoThose designs are the result of the lack of competitive pressure coming from the fact that the Detroit automakers effectively had the US market captured.
- threeseed 3y agoManufacturing is always going to chase places with the cheapest wages and the laxest of regulations. US didn't squander anything. They just made a choice that the health and wellbeing of workers are important. Just like China has been making which is why many types of manufacturing are moving to South East Asia and India.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- HDThoreaun 3y agoExcept American automakers designed shit cars that no one wanted. By the time they had fixed their designs they had acquired a reputation for poor performance cars that break down quickly that sticks with them to this day. American automakers quickly moved production to Mexico, but that wasn't enough to save them from their own shitty designs.