4 ms·
I'll take the devil's advocate here. Why should the employer pay for work that isn't being done? If you rent a car and it doesn't work, would you pay for it?
by toast0 3y ago
I'll take the devil's advocate here.
Why should the employer pay for work that isn't being done?
If you rent a car and it doesn't work, would you pay for it?
If you rent an apartment and its unfit for habitation, would you pay for it?
If you go to the store to buy a product and it's not there, would you pay for it?
It's different if the illness is work related, of course. And it's beneficial to society if people can be sick without worrying about losing income, but is that enough to make employers pay for it? And it also doesn't seem like equal pay for equal work if worker A is sick 2 days a year and worker B is sick 20 days a year, they do about the same amount of work on days they attend and get paid the same amount anually.
- lumost 3y agoTo have a functioning modern society - there must be some equality of outcome. This ensures that - Taking a business risk doesn’t leave you destitute. - Getting unlucky due to health/climate/career doesn’t leave you on the streets. You can either pay for such equality of outcome programs in taxes or by workplace policies. Provided the policy is economically reasonable and all employers are obliged to it - taxes or policy don’t matter much.
- scarface_74 3y agoWhy should society pay for your business risk when you get all of the upside? And there is already unemployment insurance. Whether it is enough and the fact that it doesn’t cover contract workers is a different issue.
- pfannkuchen 3y agoWell generally business success comes with higher taxes, so you don’t really get all of the upside. Whether those taxes are used for anything sensible is a different matter…
- lumost 3y agoWe also have bankruptcy protection, LLCs, trusts and homesteads to protect downside. Followed by unemployment insurance and various forms of welfare depending on the severity of the situation. Risks are good for society, we have buffer to absorb them provided you aren’t betting the farm with BoA. In which case, we really should have tighter regulations to stop people from betting the farm with BoA.
- leptons 3y ago>If you rent a car and it doesn't work, would you pay for it? The rental car company has a fleet of cars, and they will put you in one that works. It happens, cars have many moving parts and they are known to break down - the rental company knows this and will replace the car in almost all cases. Nobody is paying for something that doesn't work, but the rental company pays to get the broken car fixed, which is part of their cost of doing business. >If you rent an apartment and its unfit for habitation, would you pay for it? There are laws about that, for very good reason. Nobody is forcing anyone to live in squalor, though it sometimes comes down to poor people not having money and living in bad situations. People absolutely can and have sued bad landlords, and the city steps in if the people speak up. I know I've had to get the city called out to address a situation before, and the landlord paid to make it right. >If you go to the store to buy a product and it's not there, would you pay for it? Come on now, this is getting ridiculous. This is a non-issue. If you pay for a product and don't receive it, then that's fraud and at worst you can sue to get your money back. Usually you just get your money back. >Why should the employer pay for work that isn't being done? This is much like the rental car in that the employer has to pay to keep the employees healthy. They employ people to do the work, and they need to be hired, on-boarded, trained, and gain experience in the role. People aren't like cars and can't be replaced as easily. The employer should understand this and much like the rental car company keeps a fleet of cars, the employer with more than 1 employee has them for continuity of business, and paying them while sick is part of what ensures they won't need to seek a different job that will pay them while sick. It helps retain a trained and dedicated worker. It's the cost of doing business. Or, the business can suffer and be understaffed because the employer didn't account for humans ever getting sick (which humans are known to do pretty often), so if the business wants to cut corners and not pay people, then they will end up being understaffed and their business will suffer. This is really basic business stuff.
- droopyEyelids 3y agoThe fundamental idea is that the employer is a corporation, and corporations exist through the laws defined by the government, which is (in theory) doing the will of the people. So if the people, through the government, decree that an employer needs to pay for sick days, then that's how it would work. After all, the company exists through the combined effort of citizens of the government! and the company trades in money that is issued by the government, and managed by the government through taxes. Of course there's no reason the employer should have to pay directly. Why not have some sort of government program to cover people's illnesses? Or a new form of insurance? In the end, the public health improvement would be the same.
- COGlory 3y agoBecause human beings are complex, social creatures with a range of biological outcomes. If you want to be the chief monkey, you have to keep all the other monkeys safe, healthy, and happy. Otherwise they'll bash your head in and pick a new chief monkey. We can postulate all sorts of modern scenarios and ethics and laws and rights on top of that, but at the end of the day, if you want to have a society, everyone in it needs to be taken care of according to their own needs. Leave too many people behind and there will be upheaval. Alternately, we could not have a society, but then there are no business owners in that scenario.
- NamTaf 3y agoIt may come to you as a surprise, but if my colleague is taking 20 sick days a year whilst I'm taking 2, I'm not jealous of them 'working less' because they are instead sick at home.