11 ms·
Don’t store cash in Venmo and PayPal, US regulator warns
- vezycash 3y agoForget insurance, paypal terminates accounts on a whim. I've not logged into my PayPal account in at least a year but got a termination notice for policy violation. That's the real threat.
- LinuxBender 3y agoAdding to that their plans to engage in fining people for "misinformation" [1][2] They back-peddled but I would not be surprised to see them take another stab at it. [1] - https://www.forbes.com/sites/emilymason/2022/10/27/after-paypal-revokes-controversial-misinformation-policy-major-concerns-remain-over-2500-fine/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/emilymason/2022/10/27/after-pay... [2] - https://jolt.law.harvard.edu/digest/paypals-misinformation-fine-sparks-backlash https://jolt.law.harvard.edu/digest/paypals-misinformation-f...
- tifik 3y agoI would put "misinformation" into quotes, because iirc the policy was written so vaguely that it basically allowed them to fine you for whatever they disagreed with.
- LinuxBender 3y agoAgreed, I should have caught that. [Fixed] That is one of the reasons I terminated my account of 20 years without hesitation.
- ajkdhcb2 3y agoIsnt that what misinformation always means?
- wizzwizz4 3y agoNo. Some organisations go to great lengths to try to narrow down what counts as "misinformation". But it's tricky: the campaigns they're trying to protect against are usually politically-motivated, and international regional politics is a fast-changing field, and any policy you put in place will be immediately gamed. It's like SEO, but with more lying.
- vwcx 3y agoAnd it's been the threat for 20 years. Wayback Machine (May 23, 2003): https://web.archive.org/web/20030523125359/http://paypalsucks.com/ https://web.archive.org/web/20030523125359/http://paypalsuck...
- AH4oFVbPT4f8 3y agoThey also like to suspend funds when they want or when it benefits them.
- pavlov 3y agoThis is their entire business model. The service they offer is predicated on aggressive fraud detection with lots of false positives. Don’t use PayPal if this doesn’t sound appealing.
- zamalek 3y agoI have heard this has happened so many times that I'm curious they consider terminated accounts as a source of revenue.
- xp84 3y agoYup, and all because they are (and always have been) “not a bank” — just a tech company that you deposit your money into, who makes loans and investments with that money, and provides services to help you move that money around. It’s completely different, see?
- 14zadz 3y agoMeanwhile I’ve been trying to get them to close my account for over a year after they allowed fraud to occur and still tried to make me pay up even though my credit card deemed it fraud as well.
- seydor 3y agoIn europe, they are a bank which means that deposits are insured In any case, evidently Paypal has been more stable than banks. There's a real need for digital payments and none of the regulatory frameworks in europe or america take that seriously. So people will keep flocking to those easy to use ubiquitous services
- madsbuch 3y agoIn Europe you have SEPA. That insures that you can send EUR between all European banks instantly for free.
- teetertater 3y agoReceiving SEPA is not instant however, it usually takes 24 hrs or longer in case of weekends. When I lived in Canada I really took e-transfer for granted and was surprised to learn it's not a thing in other places.
- hocuspocus 3y agoThe SEPA Instant Credit Transfer rollout has started a few years ago, it's really common today. But even old school SEPA transfers shouldn't take more than a few hours nowadays, outside weekends and holidays.
- rini17 3y agoThere's instant SEPA being rolled in, if sender and receiver bank support it.
- thou234i32434 3y agoAll this seems so primitive compared to India's UPI.
- hocuspocus 3y agoIt is! To be fair it's easier to build something right when you don't have 20 years of legacy systems that need to keep running. Also, while SEPA covers fewer people, there are 36 countries involved. I believe https://empsa.org https://empsa.org members should eventually be interoperable with UPI, among others.
- jt2190 3y agoSource: Consumer Financial Protection Bureau Consumer advisory: "Your money is at greater risk when you hold it in a payment app, instead of moving it to an account with deposit insurance", June 1, 2023 https://www.consumerfinance.gov/about-us/newsroom/consumer-advisory-your-money-is-at-greater-risk-when-you-hold-it-in-a-payment-app-instead-of-moving-it-to-an-account-with-deposit-insurance/ https://www.consumerfinance.gov/about-us/newsroom/consumer-a...
- reaperducer 3y agoCommon sense. My accountant warned me about this years ago. Just because it acts like a bank doesn't mean it's a bank.
- gregschlom 3y agoIt's not really common sense if you need a professional to give you this piece of advice, though.
- bombcar 3y agoBanks are also more regulated than PayPal and when they screw you over you can complain to a banking regulator who can make their life hell.
- droopyEyelids 3y agoYou're correct and I want to tell other readers that PayPal/Square are regulated by the CFPB and the CFPB is a very useful way for a regular person without a lawyer to fight back when something goes wrong.
- lvl102 3y agoPaypal and its CEO are the worst. They screwed over so many people during the pandemic.
- matthewgrossman 3y agoI recently had my venmo account terminated out of the blue, and this is the best explanation they could give me: > We have systems in place that monitor activity on Venmo, but please note that we don't reveal information about our internal systems in order to keep these systems robust. However, I'd recommend looking over our User Agreement for information on our policies surrounding acceptable use and high risk activity. > I apologize that we're no longer able to assist you. Thankfully I was able withdraw my cash, but I've been telling everyone I know to be careful when dealing with venmo; you really can't trust them
- twelve40 3y agonow that zelle has adoption I don't even know what venmo adds anyway I still use the old paypal for juggling payment methods, like when I leave a credit card at a bar and cancel it, I don't have to punch in a new one everywhere, just paypal. but cash transfers to people have been bank to bank anyway so no need for extra services there anymore.
- mulmen 3y agoI can never get zelle to actually work. I get into some endless loop of email validation and can’t actually send anything.
- somsak2 3y agobe careful with Zelle, if you send to the wrong person / get scammed, there's no way you're getting that money back. With Venmo / PayPal, you have a much better shot. https://www.aura.com/learn/zelle-scams https://www.aura.com/learn/zelle-scams / https://assets-global.website-files.com/6082ee0e95eb6459d78fac06/62f412a6287f5e8159a0ba83_Payment-app-vs-fund-recovery.png https://assets-global.website-files.com/6082ee0e95eb6459d78f...
- iinnPP 3y agoPaypal locked my account and won't do anything unless I provide data to prove something I care not to prove. All unsubscribe mechanisms are locked behind a login... The result has been a complaint to the CRTC(Canada) for sending CEM emails without an unsubscribe mechanism. Oops.
- Izikiel43 3y agoAnd what happened afterwards?
- lowbloodsugar 3y agoQuestion: why are they not regulated like banks? They look like a bank to me.
- mwsfc 3y agoThey are licensed as a money transmitter like Western Union. It is a lessor form of regulation. So while they look "bank like" in some things they are not legally a bank.
- tgv 3y agoThey can ask to be considered a bank. That would require them to implement all those regulations. I'm sure they don't like the idea.
- xp84 3y agoGood lobbying. They just do everything a bank does without any of the obligations. Honestly I’m surprised some real banks have not tried to become like PayPal to allow more sleaziness.
- neilv 3y agoAlso, I wouldn't give them direct access to my main bank account. You don't want online fraud or some dotcom's Kafkaesque behavior to unexpectedly empty your main account of money that you need to pay rent, and have the dotcom simply refuse to talk with you. In general, I try to minimize how much money I have sitting in dotcoms ('move fast, break things, disregard regulations, cash out' sociopathy). Relatively trustworthy are some traditional institutions (e.g., Fidelity Investments, some retail banks and credit unions).
- toomuchtodo 3y agoGood timing with FedNow going live, negating the need for these wallets. CFPB at the top of their game.
- elforce002 3y agoCash is still king. I don't want to live in a society where few corporations and banks have control over the money supply.
- cherrycherry98 3y agoAgreed, we need larger denomination notes to keep cash usable. Despite decades of inflation the largest notes printed are $100 and it has been that way since 1969. Even $500 note doesn't get us back to buying power parity (it's about $800 btw).
- sowbug 3y agoThe Bank Secrecy Act requires banks to file a currency transaction report when a customer makes more than $10,000 of cash transactions with the bank in a single day. "Structuring" aggregate transactions to stay under the limit can get you thrown in jail, and your money seized. That law was passed in 1970. The amount hasn't been adjusted since then. It would approach $80,000 today if it had been indexed for inflation. Don't know about you, but I don't foresee anyone sponsoring legislation to relax these reporting requirements, or otherwise making it easier to conduct private cash transactions with anything but toy amounts of money.
- internetter 3y agoI've been to places that only accept credit card and it's infuriating as a consumer, and confusing given my relationship to small businesses. Consumers expect the same price regardless of their method, but the card fees are painful. Especially given our (former) payment partner (but really the CC companies) are doing everything they can to take more money[0]. [0]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34996006 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34996006
- JCharante 3y agoI've been to places that only accept cash and it's infuriating as well, so I boycott them. Cash is dirty and annoying to deal with for customers and merchants (as a young adult I used to work in a high-volume coffee shop).
- AH4oFVbPT4f8 3y agoI learned this the hard way nearly many years ago. Sold an item via eBay, customer paid via PayPal. PayPal accepted the funds I shipped the product and thought all was well until PayPal takes the money back saying the customers card was stolen. So then I was out the item and the money. I don’t keep a cent in the account for a second longer than I have to now.
- wcoenen 3y agoWhen you accept Paypal payments, you are accepting credit card payments. Credit card payments can easily be reversed. For the payer this is a feature, and for the payee this is a risk. So this doesn't sound like a Paypal-specific issue. The same could have happened if you accepted credit card payments through some other entity like Square.
- xp84 3y agoYes and no. PayPal and eBay are both notoriously “buyer-biased” - meaning the chance of a buyer dispute being resolved in the seller’s favor is basically none, while with a normal credit card, it’s possible for a seller to win if you have good evidence. It’s guaranteed that if you buy a laptop, even from a seller with a great reputation, and send them a picture of a box with a brick that supposedly was delivered, PayPal and eBay will both rule in your favor. They can afford to completely burn sellers like that (who may not even have a viable plan B) more than they can afford word catching on among consumers that you can simply lose your money to fraud on the platform.
- wcoenen 3y agoNote that AH4oFVbPT4f8 said that the claim was that the card was stolen. Evidence from the seller that the item was really shipped is not going to matter in such cases. So I don't think this is specific to Paypal or Ebay.
- pessimizer 3y ago> When you accept Paypal payments, you are accepting credit card payments. When you accept Paypal payments, you get no access to the customer's credit card information or identification. This is either a legal interpretation that allows Paypal to push all of its risk down to its customers and make money for nothing, or the actual law is explicitly allowing Paypal to push all of its risk down to its customers and make money for nothing, but either way it's corrupt.
- KingOfCoders 3y agoA company I've worked for transfered all money out of PayPal each night.
- booleandilemma 3y agoSurely I can continue to leave the $20 I have in there?
- StimDeck 3y agoAssuming you can afford to lose it.
- activiation 3y agoOr you can send it to me ...
- heliodor 3y ago> But industry trade group the Financial Technology Association, which represents both firms, defended the safety of the funds. > “Tens of millions of American consumers and small businesses rely on payment apps to better spend, manage, and send their money. These accounts are safe and transparent,” the group said in the statement. “FTA members provide clear and easy-to-understand terms in all their products and prioritize consumer protection every step of the way.” I don't see where the defense is in that statement!
- George83728 3y agoThe defense (lie) is here: "These accounts are safe and transparent," Safe: No, people lose their money to these companies all the time. Transparent: No, these companies stonewall people after stealing their money. They claim this stonewalling is legally required by AML laws or to deny information to criminals, but no matter which way you slice it, 'transparent' is a lie.
- digdigdag 3y agoInstead of warning consumers, why not do what regulators do and, well, regulate? Here, you have entities storing unsecured funds and doing god knows what with it. In the interest of the public good, a just government and a conscientious regulatory body wouldn't busy itself warning anyone. Rather, they would be bringing down the hammer on these entities and making them an example of what happens to companies that try to destabilize the financial system.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- nerdponx 3y agoMaybe the problem is that they do not have jurisdiction to regulate these organizations, so the best they can do is issue warnings. That or it's regulatory capture. Hard to say without knowing the details of relevant legislation and case law.
- kevin_thibedeau 3y agoThey really should force US Paypal to become a bank. Clearly that is workable for their European operations.
- chmod775 3y agoPayPal is already a bank in Europe, so it should be workable indeed.
- thephyber 3y ago"it should be workable" sounds suspiciously hand-wavy and sounds particularly naïve about law. EU and countries in the EU bloc are governed by completely different laws than the US (and the constituent states). This particular regulator (CFPB) is considered illegitimate by most Republicans (the bureau leadership has more independence from the Executive Branch than they would like) and is still fighting decade-long court cases to continue to exist. It's not clear how much actual authority this bureau has to force companies to do anything.
- cratermoon 3y agoSo the regulator's solution is not to rein in the problematic behavior using their regulatory power, but to tell people to be individually responsible? It's OK for Venmo and PayPal to go on being predatory because why?
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> the regulator's solution is not to rein in the problematic behavior using their regulatory power What regulatory power does the CFPB have over PayPal in this matter? Particularly in respect of deposit insurance?
- cratermoon 3y agoThat's a fair criticism if we are looking at "regulator" to strictly apply only to the CFPB. However, the government of which the CFPB is a part is able to regulate financial institutions, but has not.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> the government of which the CFPB is a part is able to regulate financial institutions, but has not How? I’m seeing little that doesn’t require new statute.
- zakember 3y agoThe UPI system adopted by India sounds promising to solve problems like these, where users can use the app of their choice and connect it to the bank account of their choice. Eventually, you have a system where bank-to-bank transfers happen instantly with no intermediary apps holding your money. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unified_Payments_Interface https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unified_Payments_Interface
- chaostheory 3y agoThis is harder to discern with Apple Pay since there’s now an Apple savings account backed by Goldman Sachs, an FDIC member https://www.nerdwallet.com/article/banking/apples-new-4-15-apy-high-yield-savings-account-what-to-know https://www.nerdwallet.com/article/banking/apples-new-4-15-a...
- thoughtsimple 3y ago"These apps are also not immune to the same type of panic-based bank run that closed down Silicon Valley Bank and others recently, the agency added." I'm thinking that worrying about Apple going the way of SVB isn't much of a risk.
- esafak 3y agoI previously read here that you should not let them access your bank accounts, either, because they can somehow freeze them too. Is that true?
- bluGill 3y agoThey can't freeze them, but they can transfer money out. It would be illegal, but a lot of effort on your part to prove anything, and until it makes it through the courts you are out the money. The above isn't just PayPal, it is anyone who has your account number.
- slt2021 3y agoit will be trivial to reverse unauthorized ACH debit from your bank account to paypal, just call your bank as soon as you notice, create a Fraud complaint case and they will take care of that (clawing money back from paypal/whoever fintech)
- digitalsin 3y agoMy Wife has had a small home-based business for 10 years and her customers pay through PayPal about 50% of the time. It was going great until she had a major surgery and put her business on hold for a few months. When she was able to resume, PayPal decided, seemingly arbitrarily, to hold all customer payments for 21 business days going forward because her sales had dropped. That's all, that's the reason that was given to her. As a small business, this is devastating and there is absolutely nothing that can be done about it unless she increases her sales back to what they were previously, which unfortunately is unlikely given the inflation and economy here in the US. Anyone who runs a small business knows that you need cash to buy more inventory, and if your liquidity is sitting in PayPal so they can get interest on it, your sales are going to slow way, way down. In 10 years (nearly 11) she has had one customer complaint through PayPal. The customer said she never received her item because, according to the customer herself, it was stolen from her porch after USPS delivered it. In what world is that the seller's fault? Only in PayPal's (and apparently this particular customer). That is an incredible track record given that period of time and the number of sales she has had (10s of thousands of purchases over that period). Many of her customers have said they would go elsewhere if she drops PayPal as a payment provider, which will only make things worse (much of her business is repeat business, like 80%). PayPal finds or manufactures reasons to hold the money you worked your butt off to earn so they can sit on it and, I guess, earn interest. You have no recourse. Zero. Stay far away from PayPal.
- jacquesm 3y agoThis is actually the one thing that makes some sense in their fraud policies. It goes like this: if a business is growing then chargebacks that roll in later will roll in against a larger volume of transactions, so the merchant will be most likely flush enough to be able to pay the fees and roll back the charges. If there is a steady state then as long as things don't get into very high risk territory it should all still work. But if a business shrinks then suddenly PayPal itself becomes exposed: the volume in sales could drop faster than the liability from recent sales that are still in the chargeback window reduces and at some point there may be the possibility that PayPal will have to cover chargebacks for the newly defunct merchant. To guard against this possibility any rapid drop in charge volume will result in an increase in the hold back time. So while understandably very annoying it does make some sense. (I can't believe I've found a reason to stand up for PayPal for once and I hate them with a passion but this is simply the way any party that uses a shared merchant account will deal with the problem, if you don't want to have this you'll have to bring your own merchant account along and then things will be a little bit easier, but VISA, MC and AMEX all have similar rules on their books).
- logical_ferry 3y agoI have used PayPal once or twice some 15 years ago when I bought some stuff on eBay, but never since, I never had any need afterwards. I didn't quite understand it back then, I was rather young. Nowadays I buy from web shops when I need something, I give them my one time Revolut debit card number and that's it, risk free. So my question is: Why would someone use PayPal? What is the use case here?
- silisili 3y agoMany sites require PayPal for purchases, unfortunately. I'm not sure how many people just love using it otherwise...
- whoopdedo 3y agoYou would use PayPal exactly the same way you use Revolut since they live in the same space. Neither provides insurance for deposits, which is what the CFPB is cautioning against in TFA. So I return the question to you. Why would someone use Revolut over PayPal? That's a rhetorical question, you don't need to answer. (Law of the internet: if an opinion/review of a product mentions a competing product by name then it is in fact an advertisement for the competing product.)
- PeterisP 3y agoAt least for me (in EU) both PayPal and Revolut are literally banks and both provide deposit insurance - most likely because they don't have a choice.
- nottorp 3y agoI can't pay for Crossover by credit card :) Don't know what payment processor they use but it failed twice for annual upgrades. Said card works fine on a lot of other places, big and small. I could pay with PayPal though. Even though the same card is behind it. Keeping any money on there though... no. Even though I'm in Europe.
- mikece 3y agoI have tried removing the several hundred still in a frozen PayPal account (for over three years now) but PayPal won't give me access to MY money nor will they tell me how to get access in order to remove it. They are nothing more than common criminals in FinTech drag, in my opinion.
- dylan604 3y ago> They are nothing more than common criminals in FinTech drag, in my opinion What state are you in? Maybe you can use some of the fresh anti-drag laws to help /s
- encryptluks2 3y ago[dead]
- trogdor 3y agoInitiate arbitration.
- kccqzy 3y agoI didn't need this warning, for the simple reason that cash stored in those accounts do not earn interest. A real bank account pays enough interest these days to justify the few seconds transferring funds to a bank account.
- jrm4 3y agoFirst to mention crypto? Okay, crypto. I'm of course not suggesting "crypto solves all the problems." I am absolutely suggesting -- it feels like a lot of the haters of crypto forget how absolutely mediocre of a job everything else does with "money" too.
- bunga-bunga 3y ago> absolutely mediocre of a job Yes but crypto has no customer protection. You make the transaction, your money is gone. Seller screws you? Oh well. Your key was stolen? Better luck next time. There’s no perfect system because we’re all out scamming each other.
- jrm4 3y agoThat says nothing against my point. If the "real thing" has little consumer protection as well, crypto comparatively becomes more attractive. There's ALWAYS risk.
- piperswe 3y agoThe same issues arise when people store crypto in exchanges, crypto doesn't really solve this problem at all.
- jrm4 3y agoI said nothing about solving problems, more the opposite. If the "real thing" can't be relied on to an extent, then might as well go with the risky thing.
- Dalewyn 3y agoI use PayPal because it's convenient (lots of places online nowadays accept them) and safer than giving out my credit card information directly (obvious reasons). However, I'm well aware they aren't a bank in any traditional sense so I only keep as much money in my account as I am willing to lose to a random act of god. Needless to say this has worked well for me.
- zie 3y agoI wonder if that regulator realizes that PayPal owns Venmo. Based on the comments, it doesn't seem that anyone here realizes that either.
- cornfutes 3y agoI was locked out PayPal and funds this week. I’ve been outside the country for over year, so my Google Fi access got cut off. I migrated my number from Google Fi to Google Voice, then discovered that PayPal won’t allow Google Voice numbers. Unfortunately, that phone number migration can’t be reversed. I spent hours on the phone with PayPal customer support but they said they can’t override the automated system. They also said they don’t have an escalation path to corporate. I am very skeptical about the current state of PayPal corporate and employees, and whether anyone even has ownership about these systems anymore. Venmo is an equal state of dire.
- bunga-bunga 3y ago> the current state of PayPal corporate and employees I think PayPal has been in dire state for quite a while, both in regular time and internet time.
- tabletcorry 3y agoThe article tacks on Apple Pay, which is a nice grab for attention since Apple Pay can’t store cash (Apple Cash does that) and no Apple product is discussed in the CFPB source…
- bunga-bunga 3y ago> Apple Pay can’t store cash (Apple Cash does that) Being CNN, they probably don’t know the difference
- tjpnz 3y agoGiven how happy PayPal is to outright steal your money this is good advice.
- kkarpkkarp 3y agoI learned this hard way (ok not hard way, I had balance of 2 USD at that time) when Revolut locked me out. They simply stopped releasing new version of their app for Android version I had. Day by day I lost access to my money. I simply got error that I can't log in and I should update an app but there was not any update. Took me two days to get to their support (I don't know how it is now, but at that time all ways was directing me to use support option in app which was not functioning). And support told me if I want to get my 2 USD I should buy a new phone. 2 USD is nothing to continue the fight but I've understood I don't want to give any money to such operator. I am not Revolut user for more than 6 years now.
- xerxesaa 3y agoAnd even despite this negative experience, I would say Revolut is still a safer choice compared to the apps listed in the article. Theoretically, your Revolut balance should be safe from bank failure as it's FDIC insured through their partner banks (according to https://www.revolut.com/en-US/how-we-keep-your-money-safe/ https://www.revolut.com/en-US/how-we-keep-your-money-safe/)
- stefandesu 3y agoI'm not sure how it is in the US, but if you cancel a bank account here in Europe, you're supposed to add your new bank account number so that they can transfer your remaining balance there. The issue with PayPal is that you don't have any rights when it comes to your money. If they lock you out, as far as I can tell, your money is just gone (or in order to even have a chance of getting it back, you'd have to go to court).