4 ms·
> While free speech and access to information is almost always a good thing, people raised with western values should not overlook that the east does things a l
by rayiner 3y ago
> While free speech and access to information is almost always a good thing, people raised with western values should not overlook that the east does things a little differently; not all countries started from the same place and lifting people out of hardship is the primary goal
It’s deeper than that. Generally, asian cultures place a higher value on community and thus have a lower tolerance for antisocial behavior. That same communalism also means they tend to place a lower value on individual life. Hence death penalties for people engaging in antisocial behavior.
It might not be your cup of tea, but Asians tend to think that their “well manicured garden” is desirable. In my view it’s far better than say San Francisco—the embodiment of European individualism taken to its logical conclusion—where you’re stepping over needles and human feces to get to work.
- awuji 3y agoSan Francisco isn't the embodiment of European individualism, it is the embodiment of American mismanagement.
- rayiner 3y agoIt’s mismanagement that arises out of European individualism. Because the individual is sacrosanct, you can’t infringe on individual “rights” like doing drugs or sleeping in parks. You can’t throw them in prison or execute the people facilitating antisocial behavior, like drug dealers. Simultaneously, no value is accorded to the collective right to a clean and orderly commons, free from antisocial behavior.
- nec4b 3y agoThat just not true, there are a lot of places which value European individualism in the US or outside of it where drugs problems are on the same level as in Asian countries.
- rayiner 3y agoSuch as?
- nec4b 3y agohttps://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/drug-use-by-country https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/drug-use-... Looking at the map I think you'll see for yourself your point doesn't stand.
- rayiner 3y agoSo what I'm seeing is Africa/Asia with the lowest drug use, continental europe with significantly higher drug use, the Anglo countries (which are more individualistic than continental Europe) even higher, and the U.S. (which carries western individualism to the greatest extreme) at the top of the charts. There seems to be something weird going on with the former Soviet bloc countries, but overall the chart seems to strongly support the trend I'm talking about.
- nec4b 3y agoRussia, Myanmar, Mongolia, UAE, Belarus are all significantly worse then almost all of the European countries (only Estonia is worse). I wouldn't consider those countries more individualistic than Germany for example. Vietnam and South Korea are at same levels as most of central/western Europe. India and Italy are also similar. There simply isn't any correlation (a formula if you will) between how individualistic a society is and how much drug abuse it has.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- onetimeusename 3y agoI actually think dysfunction in SF is not a result of European individualism. The situation is not best explained by individual vs collective rights. Rather, I think the dysfunction is deliberate and the politicians who control the city are part of a party and belief that repudiates anything European. For example, the city of SF will come down on you like a ton of bricks if you are not from the correct demographic. There is a lawsuit where white police officers are suing the city for denying them promotions and a system of racial discrimination. What about their individual rights? Another example is how the city and state protect homeless encampments but make it difficult for regular people to build homes or other buildings. Or how homeless people and drug addicts attack and harass regular people and the city does nothing about it but it was up in arms when a former fire chief allegedly attacked a homeless person. Individualism isn't broadly accepted, rather it seems the homeless have more rights than anyone else. This isn't individualism and shows that there is a ideology driving the dysfunction.
- camgunz 3y agoI would step over a needle or three to save someone from execution for drug use.
- rayiner 3y agoWhy?
- camgunz 3y agoAssuming this is a good faith question I'll broaden the scope a little. I think the spectrum we're working on here is basically: "society is more important than the individual" and "the individual is more important than society", or more concretely: "society exists to serve the individual" and "the individual exists to serve society". I'd like to avoid debating the extremes, but I think the example of "I'm not willing to put up with a San Francisco level of sanitation, public drug use, and petty crime in lieu of executing users of drugs, including marijuana" is a pretty extreme position. I think it's clear that marijuana doesn't pose the same societal risk as other illegal (in the US) drugs like cocaine, meth, and opiates, or even other legal drugs like alcohol and nicotine, so I don't think using it merits execution: the most severe penalty we impose. Maybe the weed thing is a red herring, so I'll include users of drugs that do pose a significant societal risk. It's well established that drug use is a pathology and addiction is a disease, and that severe penalties have had little effect in discouraging use. US drug policy has failed its (facial) goals of: - reduce economic dependence of foreign countries on drug production - reduce domestic drug consumption - reduce drug violence (The starkest example of 3 has been the unrelenting violence in Chicagoland, which conservatives attribute to a failure of liberal governance, but which is a clear failing of national US drug and gun policy.) Or, put another way, I would hope that if a US administration learned that in 2024 a drug would be released on the market that would have all the effects that the War on Drugs has had (overdose deaths, mass incarceration and surveillance via parole, violence in foreign countries, the HIV epidemic, domestic gang violence) we would act with some urgency to suppress it, but we're actively supporting it to the tune of ~$47B a year. I think the policy position you're advocating is to ramp up the War on Drugs, your evidence is that execution for even minor drug offenses stops drug use as shown in Singapore. This is a pretty common conservative position: if we executed drug dealers--and maybe even drug users--we'd solve the drug problem in the US. The problem is we're soft. My belief here is that would lead to the execution of many, many Black people and children. Lots of kids use drugs! I did and my friends did. Lots of gangs use kids in the drug trade. There's huge overlap between users and sellers of drugs. I and my friends also did this. This is a hard problem, I don't think the US is a society that will tolerate executing kids, but you will absolutely see gangs pressing children even more into service with these policies (just like they do with other vulnerable groups like women and immigrants). So from my point of view, the War on Drugs has failed and not because it didn't go far enough, but because its core conceit was flawed: laws are not effective deterrents. Conservatives really want to think they are, but they are not. They don't even work on educated perpetrators of white collar crime who usually don't even need the money, they certainly don't work on the people in the organized drug trade. Conversely, we've seen success in treatment programs. It's certainly not perfect and there's more work to do, but Portugal is a pretty good example of where this has worked (Oregon is an example where it hasn't, but I think they're starting to rethink how they're getting people into treatment--currently it's entirely voluntary and that dynamic is inadequate). So to come full circle to our society vs. individual here. I think your position is "we must sacrifice individuals who fall prey to drugs and thus become a drag on society for the good of society." My position is "society must help individuals who've fallen prey to drugs so they don't become a drag on society." This is because following your position to its conclusion likely means ratcheting up the War on Drugs--a policy that has failed expensively and beyond doubt--and following my position to its conclusion pursues treatment and decriminalization, an approach that's shown success at least sometimes. I also believe there are fundamental human rights issues when it comes to incarceration (especially given the rates of violence in the US carceral system) and execution, and it's hard for me to accept that drug use merits either of those punishments.