3 ms·
Why should it be _illegal_? AWS egress fees are clearly documented, it's not like they are some kind of hidden deceptive fee. Companies are free to impose what
by cyberax 3y ago
Why should it be _illegal_? AWS egress fees are clearly documented, it's not like they are some kind of hidden deceptive fee.
Companies are free to impose whatever fees they want. You can simply just choose to not have business relationships with them. Monopolies complicate the question, but AWS is not a monopoly.
- zarzavat 3y agoBecause it may be viewed as an anti-competitive business practice intended to prevent customers from switching providers. Yes, AWS’s customers knew what they were signing up for, but AWS’s competitors and potential competitors have a right to enter the market and compete with AWS, and they can’t do that effectively if AWS is hoarding all the customers with punitive switching fees.
- cyberax 3y ago> Because it may be viewed as an anti-competitive business practice intended to prevent customers from switching providers. S3 egress rates do not prevent you from switching. Transferring out data costs about the same as 3 months of regular storage. > AWS is hoarding all the customers with punitive switching fees. The fees are not punitive. The Internet egress fees are similar to inter-region transfer fees within AWS itself.
- sitkack 3y agoSounds like a libertarian trope. Their house, their rules. AWS and all the clouds are too big. They structure prices to milk the most of their captured customers. They all price their products within parity, so on the whole there isn't a huge difference in moving. This also makes a nice natural churn between them. The clouds themselves offer almost no innovation in the computing space. You know who the real rubes are? Everyone else, chip manufacturers, storage, etc. They all made commodity things using shared protocols and people are just pissing it away. And this sht replacing everything is worse than the stuff getting recycled, hardware, ideas, all of it.
- cyberax 3y ago> Sounds like a libertarian trope. Their house, their rules. Well, yes. I support regulation when it makes sense, but this situation isn't it. > They structure prices to milk the most of their captured customers. They all price their products within parity, so on the whole there isn't a huge difference in moving. You've got to make your money somehow. And expense structures for various large providers are pretty similar, there's no shady conspiracy here.
- immibis 3y agoYou asked why it isn't against the law, and the law about these things is libertarian. The law says that since the fee was clearly communicated to you and you had a choice to use the service or not, there's nothing wrong with that.
- Y_Y 3y ago> Companies are free to impose whatever fees they want. You can simply just choose to not have business relationships with them. Maybe in libertarian paradise, but this line gets parroted a lot for something so patently untrue. Even in the US there are plenty of laws that rightfully limit the freedom of vendors for the benefit of consumers.
- goodpoint 3y ago> Companies are free to impose whatever fees they want. Wrong. You seem to be unaware of the whole concept of anti-competitive behavior.
- 1letterunixname 3y agoYou maybe conflating limited circumstances of enforcement and other countries such as those in Europe with ideals. If it's a US company, then there is little meaningful regulation. "Laissez-faire" and "the invisible hand" are the prime directives.
- goodpoint 3y agoNo, I never claimed that US is currently enforcing antitrust laws often. But that does not mean they don't exist. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_antitrust_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_antitrust_law