10 ms·
This reads as a political ad, not a news story. The ad is good at pulling heart strings and getting people riled up (see comments here) but does not do any act
by godelski 3y ago
This reads as a political ad, not a news story.
The ad is good at pulling heart strings and getting people riled up (see comments here) but does not do any actual reporting. How did California spend the money? Were there leaky buckets? How does California have 50% of the homeless and 12% of the population? Are people being bussed in, making this a federal problem? Who's responsible? Don't just tell me the governor, there's people Newsom appointed. Don't just get me riled up, tell me what's actually going on so that I can inform myself of how to fix this. Don't just say this is a problem and point a singular finger talking about large sums of money, break it down. Tell me why homeless decreased in SF and Orange but increased in LA, San Jose, Oakland, and San Diego[0]. Tell me why it skyrocketed since 2016, starting with Brown and then accelerated under Newsom[1]. Tell me what FL is doing to solve their issues that NY and CA aren't.
Do some investigation. Distill expert information to me. Be a news article, not a political ad.
[0] https://www.ppic.org/blog/homeless-populations-are-rising-around-california/ https://www.ppic.org/blog/homeless-populations-are-rising-ar...
[1] https://siepr.stanford.edu/publications/policy-brief/homelessness-california-causes-and-policy-considerations https://siepr.stanford.edu/publications/policy-brief/homeles...
- tptacek 3y agoCalifornia's homelessness problem is not caused by other states offloading their homeless to California.
- bonestamp2 3y agoThat's a useful answer to one of the questions the article did not answer. Now, do you have a reliable source?
- quest88 3y agoOk..then what is it caused by? Provide your sources.
- cscurmudgeon 3y agoEven if it is caused by other states, is it valid to complain about that? What is the solution to that? Borders between states (while having no borders between countries)? Edit: I dug up some data: https://www.nytimes.com/2019/11/06/us/homeless-population.html https://www.nytimes.com/2019/11/06/us/homeless-population.ht... > As the data shows us, most of the homeless people you pass on the streets every day are in fact Californians. > “This is a local crisis and a homegrown problem,” said Peter Lynn, the executive director of the Los Angeles Homeless Services Authority, the agency that conducts the largest homeless census count in the country. > L.A.H.S.A.’s 2019 homeless count found that 64 percent of the 58,936 Los Angeles County residents experiencing homelessness had lived in the city for more than 10 years. CA considers you a resident for tax purposes if you live in the state for a year but in homeless studies they consider you a resident if you live here for more than 10 years. Really shows the bias.
- ncallaway 3y agoIf it is caused by other states, that would indicate the problem is not uniquely California related, making the likely necessary solutions to be federal. If it is not caused by other states, that would indicate that the problem is something happening in California, and maybe a state level solution is best. You have to start the solution in the right place to have any hope of addressing the root cause.
- throwway120385 3y agoGood luck getting the federal government to do anything to help a coastal state that isn't already covered by the executive branch.
- ncallaway 3y agoI don't think the frame of "does this help or hurt a particular state" is a useful frame for the problem. We should look at it as "does this help or hurt people"
- doctorwho42 3y ago
- beerpls 3y agoIt’s a warm climate with large cities which provide sufficient incentive for people to choose to be homeless over other avenues of living Homeless people obviously want to live somewhere like Cali over Canada for the winter. California also provides massive welfare to homeless. They also have a very open arms policy to illegals who are often poor and homeless These aren’t exhaustive reasons why, but it’s a core part of it. California politicians seem to be unwilling to address complicated social problems head on and instead virtue signal and allow these problems to grow and fester I’m not going to provide you with sources. It’s too politicized of a subject. If you don’t want to accept it for being this way i’ve learned not to argue. But at the very least if people really can’t see why this problem exists as it does, here an entry
- peter422 3y agoYour argument is that an immigrant would rather be homeless in the US than housed in their home country? Almost no data backs that up.
- beerpls 3y agolol people would rather be poor in the US than mexico yes. your dichotomy is a false representation. and a poor one at that
- thebigwinning 3y agoWhy do they live in SF and further north if it's for weather?
- WeylandYutani 3y agoYou think people choose to be fucked up? And what's the solution here, shoot the homeless? Guess what you're in a never ending war. Every day new crazy people are born or made by our wonderful society, poverty keeps spreading (where's my replicators!).
- beerpls 3y agopeople who take this emotional and illogical approach is exactly why the homeless suffer to the extent they do stop virtue signaling and start thinking or kindly avoid this topic because you’re only causing harm
- bluGill 3y agoThere is no one cause. Anyone who says there is, is wrong. CA has many problems. Houses are expensive, and that makes it impossible for poor people to buy a house. This is something that CA can fix over time, and those who are only homeless because they cannot afford a place to live are low hanging fruit. They only need to build a lot of housing (reforming zoning for example) There are also people who are homeless because of some other problem. Mental issues, drug addiction, and other such things. they are harder to deal with - I'm not sure what can be done about it: I've seen a lot of proposals, but people proposing them tend to be overly optimistic about the ability of their ideas to work without downsides. There are more issues as well, but those are the big ones, and you cannot treat them the same.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- milesvp 3y agoI'm not sure you can make such a bold claim. If California is spending money on homelessness, then all things being equal, it will attract more homeless people than if it didn't spend money on homelessness. Some percentage of these homeless will come from other states. For any two states there is going to be migration of homeless between the 2, and the attractiveness of the state is very much effected by the amount of spending for homelessness. So California could very much be net importing homeless from many of the other states that choose not to spend on homelessness (thus offloading their homelessness problem). I actually think this a fundamental problem with homelessness, any locality that chooses to affect change, may actually see numbers that make the problem look worse, when in reality they are helping to improve things globally. Worse, is it's all a collective action problem where each player can benefit by not spending on the problem. So there is constant pressure to do nothing with the problem. I wish I had solution to these kinds of problems, they're the type of thing that requires governments to tackle, but it quickly becomes political, and I'm not sure it gets any easier there either.
- gotoeleven 3y agoHomeless people aren't stupid and they aren't immobile house plants, they respond to incentives like everyone else. If you want to live on the street and do drugs and be crazy the best place to do that is CA because the weather is great and they largely don't enforce vagrancy, shoplifting, and drug laws and they spend billions of dollars subsidizing homelessness (free needles etc etc etc). >>> "any locality that chooses to affect[sic] change, may actually see numbers that make the problem look worse, when in reality they are helping to improve things globally" I think the people who think they are positively effecting change are usually actually making things worse. There's a difference between making it easier to be homeless (ie the CA way) and making it easier to not be homeless (ie a way that might work).
- milesvp 3y agoI certainly agree that how you spend money could just encourage people to become homeless, I’d hoped to convey that idea by talking about percentage increases in the homeless population, since not every new homeless is going to be a transplant. I wish there were better guides as to what spending actually helps. I suspect soup kitchens are a general positive good, but they may only make it easier to be homeless by allieviating some of the pain. I personally think access to housing should be a basic constitutional right, but I’m also weary of things like projects and tenements which may purpetuate more problems than they help. But I think we agree that this is not an easy issue. Unrelated, I thought I was using affect correctly, but seeing sic in your quote and spending a few minutes googling, I still don’t know if effect was more correct than affect :/
- tropdrop 3y agoAs others have pointed out, the problem has many sources. Other states/cities busing their homeless to California has historically been at least a minor contributor. California won a suit against the city of Las Vegas, Nevada, for specifically the practice of closing a psychiatric hospital, placing its freshly unhoused patients on Greyhound buses to Sacramento or San Francisco with one-way tickets, and giving the patients instructions to "call 911" when they arrive. [1]. 24 persons were documented and cared for by San Francisco specifically, but allegedly Nevada's largest mental health hospital did this with approximately 500 people. 1 - https://www.sfgate.com/bayarea/article/S-F-Nevada-reach-tentative-settlement-in-6552026.php https://www.sfgate.com/bayarea/article/S-F-Nevada-reach-tent...
- rqtwteye 3y agoReal data is not fashionable anymore to report. Same in health care and education. Tell me where all the f...ing money goes and why it's going up all the time. Don't single out one bad player but provide a full breakdown. That's what journalists should be doing.
- testfoobar 3y agoSerious answer: there is no need to be fully transparent. The majority of voters don't vote that way.
- onlyrealcuzzo 3y agoEasier said than done. Dig into the data all you want. If you dig deep enough, you'll most likely find what you're looking for... Anything political like this is going to have competing "sources of truth" which are largely funded by Super PACs and essentially just arms of political parties. Either party can "show you the data" now to come to whatever conclusion they want. This is a useful gambit to game all the people who claim to want to be "data-driven". Sometimes, it's useful to zoom out to a 1000 foot view and simply observe that something is clearly broken, and the current solution does not appear to be making it less broken. Maybe this is something everyone can agree on - but, that won't be very helpful - as there's unlikely any changing solution that both parties will agree on. I'll simply note - at the 1000 foot view - there are 115,000 homeless people, and $17B was spent on them. That's $147k per person. And all that happened is the problem got worse at MUCH faster rates than it did in almost every other state in the US, nearly all of which are spending much less on the problem. Draw your own conclusions...
- josho 3y agoThe problem is that some groups have no problem taking facts and distorting them into untruths. We truly are living in an age of alternate facts. I’ve read papers put out by research groups that were easy to debunk. Most people won’t go to that effort and will take the glossy material and legitimate sounding author as being truthful when in fact every conclusion made in the report is a lie.
- pauldenton 3y agoI think there are alternate facts. Both left and right have sources of information and narratives as to what is helping this country and what is harming it. Alternative facts are like alternative religions. Alternative orientations and life goals
- kelseyfrog 3y agoThey are, among other things, ideologies in the sense that they take experiences and narrativize them. It's important, and I think you get this already, is that the symptom of our time is that there's no getting outside of ideology. We can draw from Zizek for example, that the idea that we can be outside of ideology as blinding ourselves to whichever ideology we are using. That's sort of the final step and the bridge between post-modernism towards meta-modernism.
- erehweb 3y agoIt sounds like you're asking for a whole book. That's valuable, but not every newspaper story can be that in-depth.
- josho 3y agoYou’ve correctly identified the issues with media today. Rage inducing articles are easier to read and get more views. As soon as you introduce facts then very quickly it becomes a nuanced debate on the issue which is far less interesting because and worth less revenue. We really need some kind of regulations to disincentivize companies from producing drivel and more incentives for well researched material. I don’t know what those regulations would look like. But without them we are drowning in material that does society more harm than good.
- indigochill 3y agoBack when Mizzou had their J-school's something-centennial celebration and a bunch of editors and such descended on the school for the celebration, they had a panel where people could ask them questions. I asked them, given that journalism's job is to be the journal of the community, why does the business model instead align on advertising? The unanimous answer from the panel was that people wouldn't pay for journalism. Now, you can take this one of two (or more) ways: 1. Journalism as widely practiced in the present environment isn't worth paying for, so of course people won't pay for it. 2. Even if journalism was "objectively" worth paying for (lemme hand wave that judgement for the sake of argument), maybe people still wouldn't value it to the extent they were willing to pay what it would cost to produce. And we can drill into #2 even deeper: in practice, some kinds of reporting are already funded entirely by its audience. For example, Janes has made a business for decades of compiling open-source intelligence about military hardware. That's a kind of reporting, and provably one that some audience is willing to pay for. Other kinds of reporting though may be valued differently. One of my professors won a Pulitzer prize for a story on AIDS in the Midwest. This is probably not something you can build an industry around reporting on, especially not in the way she went about it, but clearly some people felt it was worthwhile reporting. So now we get back to the question of how we incentivize "good" reporting, which arguably the above two are examples of, but in different ways. One is basically industry reporting which seems like largely a solved problem from a financial feasibility perspective. The other angle is less of a solved problem as far as I know, but I can see two paths to try with it: culture grants (common for certain kinds of projects in some Nordic countries - not as sure about the US) and crowdfunding. In either case, it will probably look substantially different from how we think of journalism today.
- cscurmudgeon 3y ago> Were there leaky buckets Oh, yes. Some samples: 1. https://sfstandard.com/housing-development/city-audit-finds-serious-problems-at-government-funded-homelessness-nonprofit/ https://sfstandard.com/housing-development/city-audit-finds-... 2. https://thefrisc.com/sf-has-fought-homelessness-with-no-bid-jobs-urban-alchemy-has-used-them-as-a-springboard-part-1-49a21521016 https://thefrisc.com/sf-has-fought-homelessness-with-no-bid-... 3. https://sfstandard.com/politics/sf-homeless-nonprofit-housing-united-council-ceo-family-friends/ https://sfstandard.com/politics/sf-homeless-nonprofit-housin... This is common knowledge for folks in the Bay Area.
- stuaxo 3y agoGuilty of not reading the article yet - even the headline reads like a political ad.
- gamblor956 3y agoTexas and Oklahoma openly bus their homeless to L.A. Rick Perry (former governor of Texas) openly bragged about it during his presidential campaign. An LAT series of articles on homeless populations in Hollywood found that more than 60% of Hollywood's homeless, and more than 80% of the drug-abusing homeless, were not L.A. or even SoCal locals, and had come to L.A. from out-of-state. More than half of the homeless came from the Southwest, with the majority coming from Texas. Even LAHSA's own survey of the homeless reveals that most of the homeless in L.A. weren't local to L.A. prior to becoming homeless in L.A. (However, because LAHSA's funding is based in part on the number of homeless, they characterize anyone that has been in L.A. for over a year as local, even if that individual has never had an actual residence in L.A. and was homeless upon arrival.)
- boucher 3y agoL.A.H.S.A.’s 2019 homeless count found that 64 percent of the 58,936 Los Angeles County residents experiencing homelessness had lived in the city for more than 10 years. Less than a fifth (18 percent) said they had lived out of state before becoming homeless.
- ripberge 3y agoI'm not sure that LAHSAs homeless count is a good source of data. https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2022-09-24/doubts-raised-over-the-los-angeles-homeless-count-is-it-time-for-a-new-way https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2022-09-24/doubts-r...
- boucher 3y agoI don’t know how relevant this story is to the question of whether people who are homeless in California are from California. In any case, the claim was made that the LAHSA data showed something which I found no evidence of, and in fact found that it showed something quite different. Lots of other data also suggest that a large majority of homeless do not come from other places. If someone wants to share other data about this issue I’m happy to read it.
- DoreenMichele 3y agoHow does California have 50% of the homeless and 12% of the population? It doesn't. It has 25 percent of the nation’s homeless. It has 50 percent of the unsheltered homeless -- i.e. people camped outside. It has so many unsheltered homeless in part because parts of the state are temperate and dry. Much of the time, it's not a hardship to sleep outside in some parts of California.
- giantg2 3y agoSimilar to what I've seen in HI. I imagine there would be more in HI if it didn't cost an expensive plane ticket.
- hackernewds 3y agoThere are. And they're vastly undercounted. Au contraire, the HI govt often deports the homeless off the island
- thebigwinning 3y agoSF and further north are hardly nice weather locations.
- bobthepanda 3y agoSF isn’t a tropical paradise, but temperature extremes that cause death aren’t very common.
- ricardobayes 3y agoDefinitely, the winter I visited Mountain View it was 2C (35F) and ground frost.
- recursive 3y agoI think above freezing in winter might generally be considered nice weather.
- 3y ago
- s1k3s 3y agoNon-american ignorant here. Why don't they just build the houses? 17B sounds like a lot.
- russdill 3y agoEveryone wants that solution. No one wants that solution in their neighborhood. Even unsubsidized low cost housing.
- s1k3s 3y agoThat makes sense, thanks.
- labcomputer 3y ago> Everyone wants that solution. [Just building more houses] I'm not sure I completely agree with that. Suppose you wanted to build the maximum amount of free housing as quickly as possible. What would you do? You'd pick someplace rural (where land is cheap, and there are fewer people to raise objections), buy a bunch of land and just build the homes (and services needed by the people who would live in them). You would then invite anyone who needed shelter to come live there for free. But if you actually try to do that, "homeless advocates" will say all sorts of mean things about you and block the project. So I would argue that not everyone wants the solution of just building enough homes for everyone. They want homes built in specific places, and those specific places happen to be highly desirable and very expensive places to build acquire land and build homes.
- mbfg 3y agocan you point to an example where they built homes and the infrastructure to support those homes where people blocked the project for reasons other than 'not in my neighborhood, or 'not with my tax dollars', but more of what you seem to imply "It's not good enough?"
- 4RealFreedom 3y agoA year ago, there was a study about Denver spending anywhere from 42K to 102K per homeless individual. If I remember correctly, that was only a partial amount because they couldn't get all of the financial information. I think we all need to ask how much of this money actually reaches the intended population and how much is administrative overhead. It never pays to fix a problem. If the issue is an impossible scenario, the cash spigot is always running.
- russdill 3y agoCalifornia has a housing crisis and there is no political will to fix it. Not wanting low cost housing in your neighborhood is something that unites people very strongly across the political spectrum. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_housing_shortage https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_housing_shortage
- hackernewds 3y agoThe implication that there is a Boogeyman political system that doesn't want to house the homeless in their neighborhood is suspect and laughter inducing. Politicians need the will of the people to persist. It is the PEOPLE that reside in these communities that consistently vote down measures for building ANY housing in their neighborhood to inflate their real estate holdings. Housing homeless is an far reaching extension of that.
- mbfg 3y agoi'm pretty sure that's what the op was saying.
- WarOnPrivacy 3y ago> Tell me what FL is doing to solve their issues ... Wait, what? Why do you believe that FL's homeless crisis isn't expanding an a huge scale? Because it absolutely is. Floridians with government jobs and money in the bank are becoming homeless for the first time. ref: Lived next to a huge FL homeless community for 10 years. Ex is frequently homeless. Me and my 5 sons barely escaped homelessness ourselves in 2021 (with long established jobs and savings).
- Justin_K 3y agoI think you are equating the fact that most elected officials in CA are Democratic to this being a political hit piece. With that logic, is anything negative about our largely Democrat body of officials off limits?
- Jackpillar 3y agoI mean what did you expect from an article from the Murdoch owned rag of WSJ that is essentially Fox News with a little sheen on it.
- jahsome 3y agoInadequate reporting is not a partisan or ideological issue.
- wonderwonder 3y agoWhy the homeless move to CA Good climate Cities provide cash payments to them Legal marijuana Open air drug markets Soft on crime prosecutors Liberal population that wants to provide for them Note: I make no judgement value on any of these items, just proposing reasons
- ryder9 3y ago[dead]
- arcticbull 3y ago- Good climate: Absolutely. It's much tougher being homeless in the winter in Chicago than it is in California. - Legal weed: There's legal weed all over the country and the homeless aren't known for buying weed from legal shops are they lol. No 'open air drug market weed' for me, sir, I'm going to the Shambhala Healing Center, says the man strung out on fenty. [1] Missouri and Illinois have legal recreational weed and some of the lowest rates of per capita homelessness [2] so you can pretty much strike this theory off your list. - Open air drug markets: again, drugs may be visible here, but you can buy drugs in any city in this country. Opioids are the real problem, fentanyl in particular, and if you look at this map of opioid deaths by state you'll see the real crisis isn't in California but in West Virginia, which has 4X the deaths per capita. [3] - Soft on crime prosecutors: it does have these. - Liberal population that wants to provide for them: does it? Honestly if the maps say anything to me, it's that all of the US' homelessness is along the west coast where the weather's nice. I think that might be the entire story. [1] https://disa.com/maps/marijuana-legality-by-state https://disa.com/maps/marijuana-legality-by-state [2] https://www.businessinsider.com/map-how-many-homeless-americans-there-are-in-each-state-2019-11 https://www.businessinsider.com/map-how-many-homeless-americ... [3] https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/pressroom/sosmap/drug_poisoning_mortality/drug_poisoning.htm https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/pressroom/sosmap/drug_poisoning_mor...
- wonderwonder 3y agoLegal weed as you are not going to get arrested for possession friend, not where they buy it.
- tlogan 3y agoSadly, I think the problem is much simpler: corruption. Given that California is essentially governed by a single party, it is subject to corruption and inefficiency. Lets take just example from this week: an announcement was made stating that the construction of a tiny house costs $1,600 per square foot [1]. All I can say is this: somebody is pocketing this money. I don't know who, how, or why. Regardless, it's clear that this money is going to someone, and that someone is not homeless. [1] https://sfstandard.com/housing-development/a-builder-converted-a-san-francisco-garage-into-3-mini-homes-for-nearly-2m-progress-or-preposterous/ https://sfstandard.com/housing-development/a-builder-convert...
- luma 3y agoThis parses as "I don't know what's wrong but I know it's the Democrats" which isn't exactly insightful nor helpful.
- tlogan 3y agoI do not think it is Democrat. It think it is because it is one party state.
- ARandomerDude 3y agoExactly. As much as Republicans and Democrats may not want to admit it, we need each other for accountability.
- dragonwriter 3y agoWe need viable political choices with incentives to compete on something other than alienating voters who would be expected to vote for the other side for accountability (which mostly means we need proportional representation.) That is not the same as needing the opposing party in America’s duopolistic system.
- AbrahamParangi 3y agoWell, responsibility is what you get when you're in charge. It's axiomatically correct even if it isn't necessarily helpful (in the sense that there's no guarantee that a counterfactual republican California would have done any better).
- amadeuspagel 3y ago> Are people being bussed in, making this a federal problem? No, quite the contrary: https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/ng-interactive/2017/dec/20/bussed-out-america-moves-homeless-people-country-study https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/ng-interactive/2017/dec/...
- georgeecollins 3y agoA really good and fair story about the problems, including problems with government, law enforcement, neighbors and the unhoused themselves is "City of Tents" https://www.npr.org/podcasts/1156698343/city-of-tents-veterans-row https://www.npr.org/podcasts/1156698343/city-of-tents-vetera...
- screye 3y agoIt is multi causal. Part of it is the routine stuff around activist-abolitionist DAs, lack of housing, NIMBY-ism, weather, decriminalization of drugs, etc. The review Shellenberger's comprehensive book on west-coast homelessness is nice level-headed take [3] But one major cause is the rise of potent p2p meth & fentanyl in the populace. [1][2] So not only are the homeless un-shelter-able (shelters require residents to be clean), but the nature of drugs lead to irreversible mental health issues and irreversible (ie. chronic) homelessness. [1] https://dynomight.net/homeless-crisis/#:~:text=To%20get%20more%20reliable%20numbers%2C%20I%20combined%20sheltered%20and%20unsheltered%20homelessness%2C%20took%20the%20average%20of https://dynomight.net/homeless-crisis/#:~:text=To%20get%20mo... [2] https://dynomight.net/p2p-meth/ https://dynomight.net/p2p-meth/ [3] https://astralcodexten.substack.com/p/book-review-san-fransicko https://astralcodexten.substack.com/p/book-review-san-fransi...
- strangattractor 3y agoThe chronically homeless I encounter in SF are primarily (not all) 1. Addicted to drugs 2. Suffering from psychiatric issues. No amount of affordable housing is going to fix that. No amount of training, educational assistance, universal income etc will fix that. They are not in any condition to work or hold a job or do personal health maintenance. Give them shelter and they wonder off. Affordable housing is affecting the middle class rather severely in that larger portions of the middle class incomes are being spent on housing. These are people that are not homeless. These are people often in trades or hourly labor. Some will become homeless with any disruption of income. Fl has done some things to help with that. "...in recent years Florida communities have embraced evidence-based best practices such as Housing First, collaborative case management, and rapid rehousing."{1} Mathematically speaking there is no reason why CA cannot have %50 of the homeless. CA could have %100 of the homeless if no other states have homeless. It is not related to CA population relative to the rest of the country. The problem IMHO is that results matter more than good intentions. Many of CAs programs mean well but are either not executed well or simply do not work. The proponents continue to promote them and receive money for them despite their inability to get results. That is were all the money goes. {1}https://flhousing.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/Good-News-for-the-Field-Homelessness-in-Florida-is-on-the-Decline.pdf https://flhousing.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/Good-News-f...
- strangattractor 3y agoJust for the record Florida's incarceration rate is rather high so that might also be why there are fewer homeless. https://www.prisonpolicy.org/profiles/FL.html#:~:text=Florida%20has%20an%20incarceration%20rate,than%20any%20democracy%20on%20earth https://www.prisonpolicy.org/profiles/FL.html#:~:text=Florid....
- dragonwriter 3y ago> California have 50% of the homeless and 12% of the population? Are people being bussed in, Yes. States are known to literally ship out their homeless problem to other states and also do so figuratively by criminalization and persecution to drive the homeless out. If you are less aggressive at those things, or provide better services, the net flow of homeless people is going to be in to your state, all other things being equal. This isn’t, of course, the whole of the problem. Housing supply issues and income inequality issues produced by the fact that California has some very successful industries that reward a narrow set of people very well also play a big role, and these are self-inflicted policy problems [0] (both not adequately increasing housing supply, and not leveraging narrow prosperity better for the general good.) [0] Not simple policy problems to resolve, the housing one for political reasons, the improving distribution without killing the prosperity you are trying to improve the distribution of one is actually tricky in policy.