2 ms·
> However, if they're not actually trying to win, Is it illegal to take a case to court with the intention to lose yet set precident?
by londons_explore 3y ago
> However, if they're not actually trying to win,
Is it illegal to take a case to court with the intention to lose yet set precident?
- lazide 3y agoNo, but that’s not what the rancher did. He tried to bully them using massive and inflated claimed damages, and it backfired.
- User23 3y agoNo. And this is a common trick the government has used. Have a friendly party bring a suit and then refuse to defend effectively to force the judge to rule against. That’s how prop. 187 got nuked.
- sobellian 3y agoI don't know about "illegal" but it seems the Case or Controversy Clause has bearing in that hypothetical. If no actual controversy exists between the parties - for example, if both sides have agreed on who is to win the case - then the courts generally don't like to issue a ruling. Further, if a litigant fails to raise an issue while arguing a case, and the court therefore doesn't consider it, then the precedent doesn't necessarily control a future case where a litigant does raise that issue.