3 ms·
The plaintiff's complaint is so contrived that I almost wonder if it's all a setup to get this law overturned. No judge in their right mind would award anything
by lolinder 3y ago
The plaintiff's complaint is so contrived that I almost wonder if it's all a setup to get this law overturned. No judge in their right mind would award anything close to the damages that they're asking for, and their argument in favor of the damages is the perfect illustration for how bad the law is:
> Eshelman asserts that when the men corner-crossed — stepping from one piece of public land to another at a four-corner intersection with his ranch — they damaged him by up to $7.75 million.
> That’s based on a 25% devaluation of the Elk Mountain Ranch, appraised at $31.1 million in 2017.
> Rinehart would discount the ranch by 30% if corner crossing was declared legal, he said in an affidavit. His figure would raise alleged damages to a total of $9.39 million.
So the argument essentially is "this law gives me de facto ownership of 25% more property than I actually own, and these guys trying to cross it somehow sets a precedent to set that land free". IANAL, but on the face of it that makes zero sense because two dudes breaking the law doesn't undo the law.
However, if they're not actually trying to win, this is a pretty solid argument to make if you're trying to persuade a judge to legalize corner crossing.
https://www.gillettenewsrecord.com/news/wyoming/article_a5197326-df94-53ce-82bd-e640acd1929d.html https://www.gillettenewsrecord.com/news/wyoming/article_a519...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- londons_explore 3y ago> However, if they're not actually trying to win, Is it illegal to take a case to court with the intention to lose yet set precident?
- lazide 3y agoNo, but that’s not what the rancher did. He tried to bully them using massive and inflated claimed damages, and it backfired.
- User23 3y agoNo. And this is a common trick the government has used. Have a friendly party bring a suit and then refuse to defend effectively to force the judge to rule against. That’s how prop. 187 got nuked.
- sobellian 3y agoI don't know about "illegal" but it seems the Case or Controversy Clause has bearing in that hypothetical. If no actual controversy exists between the parties - for example, if both sides have agreed on who is to win the case - then the courts generally don't like to issue a ruling. Further, if a litigant fails to raise an issue while arguing a case, and the court therefore doesn't consider it, then the precedent doesn't necessarily control a future case where a litigant does raise that issue.
- COGlory 3y agoNo, that's just really what these "ranch" owners are like. I've been shot at on legally-accessed public land, escorted off legally accessed public land by private security, and had public roads blocked off all by overzealous asshat "ranchers" who think they own the public land. I'm going to be honest, it takes a great deal of restraint to be shot at (not seriously aimed at, just warning shots across the bow, but still terrifying) and not shoot back. I put ranchers in quotes because these people roll in from Texas or California (or they're mega corps like Farmland Reserve LLC or the Gates Foundation), purchase a ranch or farmland, lay almost everyone off, shut down basically all active ranching (I believe this might be part of Gates's anti-global warming schtick), and then do nothing with the land beyond sell private elk hunts. And of course they don't want me shooting animals on the neighbouring public land, so they hotly contest those with signs, fences, gates, private security, etc. The fine for blocking a public road in Montana is laughably small. Something like $50/day, which isn't even pennies for these people.
- throwaway2037 3y agoThe fine for blocking a public road in Montana is laughably small. Something like $50/day, which isn't even pennies for these people. Hat tip! I never knew about the strategy to deter access to public lands. I did a bit of Googling and found: Fines for failing to remove the encroachment would rise from $10 per day to $100-$500 per day. Ref: https://www.bozemandailychronicle.com/news/environment/lawmakers-hear-bill-to-increase-fines-for-illegally-blocking-roads/article_9a32d308-82f5-5620-abdf-07a4339b44bb.html https://www.bozemandailychronicle.com/news/environment/lawma... Then following the link from the article, you can see the actual bill in Montana Legislature: https://leg.mt.gov/bills/2023/billhtml/HB0486.htm https://leg.mt.gov/bills/2023/billhtml/HB0486.htm Finally: "Current Bill Progress: Became Law" here: http://laws.leg.mt.gov/legprd/LAW0203W$BSRV.ActionQuery?P_SESS=20231&P_BLTP_BILL_TYP_CD=&P_BILL_NO=&P_BILL_DFT_NO=LC1956&P_CHPT_NO=&Z_ACTION=Find&P_SBJT_SBJ_CD=&P_ENTY_ID_SEQ= http://laws.leg.mt.gov/legprd/LAW0203W$BSRV.ActionQuery?P_SE... I'm very impressed so much information is available online from the legislature! More details about what exactly defines "blocking": https://www.plwa.org/closing-a-rural-road https://www.plwa.org/closing-a-rural-road
- 3y ago
- kubectl_h 3y agoThere is land throughout the west that encircles (or otherwise makes it difficult to access) public land that it borders that goes for obscene amounts of money for the very reason that it, defacto, has exclusive access to this land. This landowner purchased this land for that reason, and it was almost certainly marketed that way by the real estate listing.
- nobodyandproud 3y agoYou underestimate the sense of entitlement by these owners. https://archive.ph/ag4Lv https://archive.ph/ag4Lv “My dad used to hunt some private property in Montana,” said Mr. Hettick, a forester with the U.S. Forest Service. “And one year they told us, ‘Sorry, you can’t anymore — we leased it to an outfitter.’ I was crushed. And I was like, you know what? This is never going to happen to me again.”