5 ms·
The phrase "open source" has become very muddled and unclear these days, and you can no longer assume that software calling itself that is actually OSS. I've c
by JohnFen 3y ago
The phrase "open source" has become very muddled and unclear these days, and you can no longer assume that software calling itself that is actually OSS.
I've come to a place where I just consider the phrase as noise, and generally ignore it. Instead, I just pay attention to the license and if it's acceptable to me, I'll use it. If it's not, I won't. That serves my needs.
I also stopped associating my own software with the term, even when it's actually open source by OSI's definition. Doing that avoids a whole lot of unnecessary arguing.
It's a little sad for me, though. I've been a strong OSS advocate since the Dark Ages, and it's painful to have to disassociate with it.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- shrimp_emoji 3y agoStallman was right yet again: https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/floss-and-foss.en.html https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/floss-and-foss.en.html
- Culonavirus 3y agoI mean, Unreal Engine is open source. That's all you really need to know. It is software "with source code that anyone can inspect, modify, and enhance", you just can't ship anything made with it without paying Epic a cut of your revenue. (Actually you can, Epic has this, well, pretty damn generous setup, where you don't pay anything until you reach $1M in gross revenue per title, then it's 5% of gross revenue above $1M of that title. Just not to shit on Epic as everyone likes to do.)
- palata 3y agoThat is the definition of "source-available", not open source. The first sentence of the OSI definition [1] of open source is: "Open source doesn’t just mean access to the source code. The distribution terms of open-source software must comply with the following criteria:" [1]: https://opensource.org/osd/ https://opensource.org/osd/
- gcoakes 3y agoI don't really care what that organization says. The most obvious meaning of that phrase is that the source code is publicly visible. If someone wants to describe a particular license, then they should refer to it or the category of license (e.g. copy-left or permissive). I'm actually happy that companies like Epic would expose their source code (I'm taking GP on faith that they were accurate). One thing I'm afraid of is the idea of losing access to software that I love because the company goes defunct. I wish this practice was more common even if they don't wish to permit free usage. It's probably only enforceable on a small subset of software though.
- jraph 3y ago> The most obvious meaning is that the source code is publicly visible It's not, really. Words don't live in a vacuum. Their meaning is determined by their actual usage, which is depends on the cultural context, which is itself determined by history. "Open source" started being used when the Open Source movement started, to mean what the OSD means. Before, the phrase was not used. You can't rewrite history and you can't decide for everyone the meaning of a word because it's obvious for you the way you decide. It's not just "that organization". It's the whole computing world. That organization took the Debian Free Software Guidelines, called it the Open Source Definition and called software related to it "open source"... and the whole world picked up this usage. There's nothing you can do about it, history played out like this. The phrase has always had this meaning. Maybe the meaning of the phrase will change over time, but that hasn't happened yet and I don't see this happening in the next years too. What you are expressing is not facts. It's wishes and your taste. Depending on the context, the actual license used is a technicality and you don't want to be this precise. You may need to express the broader concept / context. Open source is recognized more broadly by non-technical people. Try mentioning the MIT or the GPL license instead, you are in for a fun ride. I don't see the point in actively trying to destroy this usage. Now we could discuss on pushing "free software" vs "open source" but this is another topic. I'm saying all this as a free software proponent. I don't quite like it that the OSI came and cast a shadow on the free software movement and pushed for the "open source" phrase. Open source is good but the values pushed by the free software movement is really what we ought to spread IMO (and FWIW, even Bruce Perens, one of the founders of the open source movement and the writer of the OSD, agrees with me [1]). But again, it is what it is, history has been playing out this way. About your second paragraph, I mostly agree with you, but precisely open source / free software is what you really need for this. Source-available is a step in the right direction, but even if the company goes defunct, you still have no rights to adapt the code to make it work on future systems unless an explicit clause tells you otherwise. You can decide to do it anyway but you expose yourself to legal risks. So if it's important to you, you should advocate for open source / free software specifically, and not merely source availability. And you need to use the right words the way people understand them for this because the subtleties matter. [1] https://lists.debian.org/debian-devel/1999/02/msg01641.html https://lists.debian.org/debian-devel/1999/02/msg01641.html
- jraph 3y agoThat's source-available. What's with people in this HN thread knowing full well about the open source definition but advocating for this confusing use of the term anyway, don't you strive for clarity and ambiguity-free expression when talking about something? And also... what is the link between unreal engine and this text from RMS about the different philosophies behind the Open Source and the Free Software movements?
- bityard 3y agoThis is a picture-perfect example of how just in the past few years, proprietary software producers have successfully diluted the terms coined and widely used by grassroots developer communities that have been around for decades.
- wmf 3y agoI don't think he was. If the term "open source" was never invented we'd be having this same discussion but it would be about startups twisting the meaning of "free software" to benefit themselves. Anything successful eventually becomes buzzwordified.
- Dalewyn 3y agoThe way I see it, it's very simple: If I can view the source code, it's open source. Open source has nothing to do with whether something is free-as-in-beer or commercial, whether something is free-as-in-libre or proprietary, or whatever else. Open source simply means source code that is open for public viewing, all other rights reserved unless declared otherwise. Obligatory IANAL, don't take legal advice from random internet comments.
- singpolyma3 3y agoExcept that we literally have a different term for that: "shared source"
- JohnFen 3y agoThis is the first and only time I've heard that term used.
- palata 3y agoThere is a first for everything ;). It's also called "source-available": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Source-available_software https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Source-available_software
- JohnFen 3y ago"Source available" is the term I know. But I love learning new things! It makes me just a little bit less ignorant.
- orra 3y agoMicrosoft used it a lot, before they pivoted to somewhat embracing open source.
- JohnFen 3y agoI understand your definition. The problem is that not everyone agrees with it. This is a great example of why I don't use the term -- there is no longer a real consensus on what it means, exactly.
- GuB-42 3y agoIt is unclear because people have different ideas on what "open source" means. Between the FSF, the OSI, the distinction between free, libre and open source, etc... For me open source means that the software comes with its source code, that's all. It may not mean much from a freedom perspective, but it is not noise. Simply having access to the source code is still great, if anything because it is the most complete and accurate documentation you can get. Now, if you want to actually work with the software, check the license. BSD and GPL are both unambiguously open source, and yet, they are very different. And back to the subject of AI. Calling a model "open source" makes no sense to me, no matter the license. These models don't have a source code, if they had, that would be the code that performed the training along with its dataset, which most people won't have the resources to use anyways. Call it "open" if you want, whatever that means, but "open source" in that context is ridiculous.
- JohnFen 3y ago> It is unclear because people have different ideas on what "open source" means. Between the FSF, the OSI, the distinction between free, libre and open source, etc... Yes, but the definitions are objectively clear, really. They're the ones put forth by the organizations who defined them in the first place. The confusion comes from people who are misrepresenting, or are ignorant of, those definitions.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]