7 ms·
I'm going to take a wild guess that 90+% of things we describe as 'autoimmune' are in fact initially caused by some bacteria/virus/pollution we haven't yet iden
by londons_explore 3y ago
I'm going to take a wild guess that 90+% of things we describe as 'autoimmune' are in fact initially caused by some bacteria/virus/pollution we haven't yet identified.
I'd like to see research done on mice to reduce the number of viruses and bacteria they are exposed to - for example by sterilizing all air, water, and food for many generations. Then see which ailments go away.
- haldujai 3y ago> I'm going to take a wild guess that 90+% of things we describe as 'autoimmune' are in fact initially caused by some bacteria/virus/pollution we haven't yet identified. As a wild guess probably a bit high but viruses like EBV are being increasingly suggested as causative of many autoimmune diseases. > I'd like to see research done on mice to reduce the number of viruses and bacteria they are exposed to - for example by sterilizing all air, water, and food for many generations. Then see which ailments go away. May not be the panacea you expect, on the other hand some people think too clean is the problem. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hygiene_hypothesis https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hygiene_hypothesis
- londons_explore 3y agoI think the hygiene hypothesis will turn out to be false, and data pointing in its direction will be the effects of cleaning products.
- Buxato 3y agoAll the herpes family causes tons of health problems, HSV 1 & 2, EBV, Citomegalovirus .... (some of that problems recently discovered but also the main suspect in many other diseases)
- haldujai 3y agoThe question becomes why do only certain people get the illness? 50-90% of the US population are EBV or CMV positive yet it’s a much smaller percentage that develop autoimmune illnesses. I’m the farthest thing from a rheumatologist but it seems like the favored explanation is a combination of infection and abnormal immune response.
- TeMPOraL 3y agoAt which point could this just be pure random chance? I.e. what if EBV or CMV or similar viruses poking at the immune system are like comic rays hitting non-ECC RAM? Most people won't notice most of the time, and some people will experience mysterious crashes or data corruption that don't seem to have any apparent cause.
- haldujai 3y agoGood question, I’m much more familiar with the oncology literature and there is definitely causative evidence linking EBV and to a lesser extent CMV with lymphoma/lymphoproliferative disorders (particularly in the post-transplant setting). I believe the evidence for autoimmune disorders is much weaker (with the caveat that this is well outside my scope of practice), I’ve heard it being implicated in MS from my neurology colleagues but my understanding is it’s a weak correlation at the moment. I can’t offer more than uneducated conjecture on other autoimmune diseases. UpToDate says the following: “One difficulty in proving a link between EBV and MS is that serological evidence of EBV can be found in 83 to 90 percent of adults in the Western hemisphere [99,101,102]. On the other hand, EBV seropositivity among adult MS patients is near 100 percent, significantly higher than healthy controls [91,102-106]. Additionally, children with MS are significantly more likely than healthy peers to have serological evidence for prior EBV infection, at an age when EBV seropositivity is much less common than in adults [107]. However, there is conflicting evidence concerning the presence of EBV in brain tissue of patients with MS [108-111].”
- PaulKeeble 3y agoHerpes viruses generally. It seems to reactivate on other infections and spread to new cells causing increasing problems in the body. EBV and Herpes seem to hack the immune system to stop these cells from being destroyed. We could do with antivirals that expose these cells or recognise them and destroy them.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- CommanderData 3y agoI don't think we'll cure HSV. A drug to limit cell to cell transfer and a vaccine to prevent new spread to other people. But those living with the virus, it is unfortunate it will remain in our bodies forever, it is just too clever, hidden deep within our bodies in many cell types and impossible to remove without rna editing.
- A_D_E_P_T 3y ago> "I'm going to take a wild guess that 90+% of things we describe as 'autoimmune' are in fact initially caused by some bacteria/virus/pollution we haven't yet identified." Not directly. Autoantibodies are the direct cause of many, if not all, autoimmune diseases. It's possible that certain environmental factors, combined with genetic factors, kickstart autoantibody production. (i.e. are upstream of autoimmune diseases, and causative.) But nobody knows for certain. And the reverse hypothesis is also quite popular: An environment that's too clean, that leaves too little for the immune system to do, can induce a restless immune system into producing autoantibodies. "Idle hands"...
- heavenlyblue 3y agoAnd then when they accidentally catch something very mild the whole population is dead because they never developed the means of fighting it.
- haldujai 3y agoThis is a bit dramatic but many think the RSV crisis was a result of naive immunity due to COVID-19 public health measures. https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1002/ppul.25582 https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1002/ppul.25582
- giraffe_lady 3y agoOR immune damage due to covid itself, which was a more popular theory with more mainstream medical support last time I looked into it about ten months ago.
- haldujai 3y agoThis isn’t true (that your hypothesis is mainstream), there is no evidence the virus itself was more severe or resulted in more severe illnesses than expected to support the impaired immune system theory[0]. There is endless literature on this but the majority of “mainstream medicine” subscribes to the “every kid got sick at once for the first time” theory[0-2]. Anecdotally, I was working at a pediatric hospital for parts of the RSV wave and my conversations with PICU/ER colleagues was condordant with literature in this space. [0] https://publications.aap.org/pediatrics/article/149/2/e2021053537/184564/RSV-Epidemiology-in-Australia-Before-and-During https://publications.aap.org/pediatrics/article/149/2/e20210... [1] https://www.thelancet.com/journals/laninf/article/PIIS1473-3099(22)00544-8/fulltext https://www.thelancet.com/journals/laninf/article/PIIS1473-3... [2] https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1473309922005254 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S147330992...
- londons_explore 3y agoThats why you don't do this for humans :-P But it would help the search to find out which viruses/bacteria/pollutants are harming us, and eventually when they are identified they can be eliminated, for example with a vaccine.
- bawolff 3y ago> I'm going to take a wild guess that 90+% of things we describe as 'autoimmune' are in fact initially caused by some bacteria/virus/pollution we haven't yet identified. Wouldn't it still be described as autoimmune? An autoimmune disease initially caused by an external agent is still an autoimmune disease.
- deemster 3y agoMy wild guess aligns with Dr Gabor Mate. Dr. Mate emphasizes the significance of psychosocial factors, including stress, trauma, and emotional experiences, in the development and progression of various diseases, including autoimmune conditions. He suggests that chronic stress, adverse childhood experiences, and unresolved emotional issues can contribute to dysregulation of the immune system, potentially triggering or exacerbating autoimmune diseases. According to Dr. Mate, unresolved emotional stress and trauma can disrupt the body's natural balance, leading to chronic inflammation and an overactive immune response. He emphasizes the importance of understanding the underlying emotional and psychological factors that may contribute to the development or worsening of autoimmune diseases.
- fidotron 3y agoThis is a circular argument. If you have an undiagnosed auto immune condition the result of it will be things constantly occurring outside of your control and thus you will have chronic stress which probably will make things worse.
- monktastic1 3y agoIt would only be a circular argument if autoimmune conditions were the only way to become stressed. As it stands, this sounds more like a "vicious circle" (whereby one caught in this cycle has a hard time exiting it).
- 2devnull 3y agoIs there evidence that stress can occur and not lead to a vicious cycle of inflammation and autoimmune disease? I am a big fan of Mate, but I think his ideas are oversold if not by him then by many he has “helped”.
- irdc 3y ago> According to Dr. Mate, unresolved emotional stress and trauma can disrupt the body's natural balance How does that differ from Germanic New Medicine? (see https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Ryke_Geerd_Hamer https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Ryke_Geerd_Hamer)
- francisofascii 3y agoThere is also a school of thought (don't know how prevalent) that many autoimmune cases are not autoimmune at all. And that the unidentified bacteria/virus/pollution etc. is still present or persisting, so the immune system is continually fighting that hidden pathogen rather than one's own normal cells. And so conventional autoimmune treatments that suppress the immune system are allowing to unidentified pathogen to persist.
- bschne 3y agoCouldn't you tell this apart by the kind of damage caused to one's own cells and what kind of antibodies are present? e.g. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antinuclear_antibody https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antinuclear_antibody
- francisofascii 3y agoDepends on the type and quality of the test. Serological tests can yield incorrect readings.
- haldujai 3y agoAh ANA, the wonderful test that everyone orders and then shamefully consults rheumatology because no one knows how to interpret it[0]. Almost a rite of passage in medical training now. I jest but I think these tests are still a bit of a mystery (as in why these autoantibodies are made and what their significance is) especially as some people with high titres have no symptoms and vice versa although there is an association. I think what parent is alluding to is that the trigger for production may be an infection, even if the damage is mediated by one’s own immune system. [0]for a chuckle this is a humorous but accurate depiction: https://twitter.com/DGlaucomflecken/status/1371901346413117442 https://twitter.com/DGlaucomflecken/status/13719013464131174...
- FollowingTheDao 3y agoAnd then try convincing your primary care doctor that an ANA test could be negative and you can still have lupus or any other autoimmune disease.
- LatteLazy 3y agoDon't autoimmune disorders get WORSE in "cleaner" environments?
- pyrale 3y ago> I'd like to see research done on mice to reduce the number of viruses and bacteria they are exposed to - for example by sterilizing all air, water, and food for many generations. Then see which ailments go away. If something is common in the environment and would not cause harm to people if not for disproportionate response from the immune system, I would say that the issue is the immune system, not the common element.
- londons_explore 3y agoRemember that the population of humans a million years ago used to be ~20,000. It is now 7 billion. Some diseases have big and obvious effects, while others are undetectable/unknown. Assume that diseases mutate a fixed amount per human they infect. All 7 billion of those people are one 'pool' for disease spread - as evidenced by covid. That means that the rate your immune system 'sees' entirely novel diseases - not only novel to you, but also novel to all your ancestors - is 350,000x higher than it used to be. The true figure is probably lower, because many diseases infect multiple species. But still, there is a strong argument that we are asking our immune system to do something far outside what it has evolved to handle.
- pyrale 3y ago> Some diseases have big and obvious effects, while others are undetectable/unknown. A disease is a pathological process, something that goes wrong. If someone lives their life without a symptom, they are not diseased. Your immune system doesn't see "novel diseases", it encounters molecules it doesn't know. These molecules may be pathogenic (i.e. they cause a disease), or they may be harmless. Your immune system reacting disproportionately to harmless stuff, is what's called autoimmune disease.
- mrcode007 3y agoThe part about immune system reacting to harmless stuff is not true. Autoimmune diseases are diseases in which a body responds to itself. Not to external factors. Think of it as threat classification errors
- refurb 3y agoThat's still autoimmune though. The body has a immune reaction against something foreign - however the antibodies created co-react with proteins found in your own body.
- reubenswartz 3y agoI am not a doctor, but I'm guessing that your experiment would solve some problems and create others. If the immune system has nothing to deal with, it may deal cause more autoimmune problems (see the "hygiene hypothesis").
- jvanderbot 3y agoMy expectation is it's mostly environmental pollution like pm2.5 causing inflammatory responses, which trigger immune function unnecessarily. I base this on the fact that when I moved to a pollution filled city my hair fell out from autoimmune disease, then when I moved out, it stopped happening.
- greenthrow 3y agoThat's not how infection works. You don't clear it up by just stopping exposure. The patients in the article weren't constantly being exposed to lupus for decades. Putting them in a bubble would not have cleared up the infection. You are making wild guesses from a place of ignorance. If you want to learn more about the science of immunology the resources are out there to learn about it.
- londons_explore 3y agoPutting them in a bubble for multiple lifetimes might... Clearly that isn't practical for humans, but for mice, it is, and the results of that can inform further research.
- ckemere 3y agoWhoa - the microbiome is hugely important for health in multiple ways. Most humans have about the same number of bacteria in their bodies as their own cells (https://www.nature.com/articles/nature11234 https://www.nature.com/articles/nature11234). I think the consensus is just the opposite as what you're suggesting - that early exposure to more things is beneficial for a healthy immune system. I suspect that the culprit is much more likely environmental contamination (microplastics, PFAS, etc), which I guess is one thing that you list. But "sterile" is not the solution, and unfortunately we have pretty badly contaminated the whole planet at this point...
- ajuc 3y agoThere's a significant psychological factor in many autoimmune diseases. For example I had asthma and allergy since forever, but I got colitis ulcerosa for the first time when I was 18 and had final exams in the high school, which decided what university I can go to. Even asthma attack can be caused by stress alone.
- aksss 3y agoAsthma is, of course, an immune system response but is not an autoimmune disease[1]. That said, mental and physical stress are a significant factor in autoimmune disease flare-ups and chronic hypertension is linked (one of many things) to AI disease onset. [1] https://www.healthline.com/health/asthma/is-asthma-an-immune-deficiency#what-is-asthma https://www.healthline.com/health/asthma/is-asthma-an-immune...
- janeway 3y agoI have to argue against this - humbly as an expert with several degrees in microbiology, immunology, genetics, host-pathogen interaction, university lecturing, etc. The genetic basis of immunology is amazingly complex. To assign 90% autoinflammatory type disease triggered by pathogens is an unfounded assertion. There are many strong examples of monogenic causes of complex phenotypes, while separately the clinical microbiology explanation of many diseases is also perfectly clear. I am certain that there will be many pathogen triggers, as you say, but the number 90% does not make sense based on the last 100 years of the science.
- SQueeeeeL 3y agoDon't you realize this is hacker news and baseless overconfident claims by random code bros that use "intuition" to argue against well established scientific knowledge trusted by domain experts is mandatory
- coldtea 3y agoIt's also healthy. "Established scientific knowledge trusted by domain experts" shouldn't be taken for a gospel, even if you're not a domain expert.
- SQueeeeeL 3y agoAhh yes, and random 23 year olds who in aggregate thought crypto made economic sense are definitely the crowd who we should trust to point out meaningful holes in that gospel
- catchnear4321 3y agono. but there shouldn’t be gospel.
- coldtea 3y agoWell, if that kind of simplistic strawman argument is what defends the "scientific consensus", we could do with less of it...
- PragmaticPulp 3y agoThe Hygiene Hypothesis actually suggests that limiting exposure to microorganisms in childhood might result in worse immune tolerance, leading to a higher rate of autoimmune issues: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hygiene_hypothesis https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hygiene_hypothesis
- m3kw9 3y agoBut I’d say even if it is, it’s because one’s genes are susceptible to it while others won’t have issues
- thenerdhead 3y agoI don't think you can only say germs/pollution. You also have the many elements of "stress" as described in "The Stress of Life" by Hans Selye.
- mondocat 3y agoThat's... what happens: https://www.science.org/content/article/can-dirty-mice-save-animal-research https://www.science.org/content/article/can-dirty-mice-save-...
- nullc 3y agoI suspect you wouldn't think that if you look into how the adaptive immune system works: A process called V(D)J recombination shuffles and rearranges the genes responsible for encoding the antigen receptors on T cells and B cells. The cells are then tested for compatibility against your own tissue and cells that match your own tissue are deactivated. So new immune cells are essentially created by fuzz testing. Once deployed, immune cells that find lots of matches clone themselves amplifying their immune effect. So an autoimmune problem can be as simple as a newly minted immune cell escaping the compatibility testing or just being slightly reactive enough to your own tissue to cause problems while still inactive enough to pass the test. With that in mind its surprising to me that autoimmune disorders aren't a lot more common!
- Llamamoe 3y agoViral reactivation and basically everyone nowadays having a compromised gut microbiome are definitely two large factors in many chronic health conditions.