3 ms·
> And an RS485 or 10BASE-T1S or CAN connection so that they can coordinate their I-V characteristics Note that simply voltage/frequency alone can communicate e
by londons_explore 3y ago
> And an RS485 or 10BASE-T1S or CAN connection so that they can coordinate their I-V characteristics
Note that simply voltage/frequency alone can communicate everything necessary to evenly distribute load. For example:
Output frequency = 60 + X Hz
Where X varies between -0.1 and 0.1, indicating the percentage of max load the inverter is under(in charge or discharge direction).
Such a scheme will self synchronize any number of inverters, even of varying capacities, into a stable grid, and they will all be the same percentage loaded. The grid can even have a few dumb gas generators on too and remain stable. No fancy comms needed.
- amluto 3y agoI think this works for discharge, possibly with some extra cleverness needed if the batteries are at different SoCs. But I’m not sure how it could handle being tied to the grid intelligently or how charging could be managed without some additional controls. Also, can a pure frequency-based scheme handle the case where a whole bunch of inverters are in parallel and a load that’s much larger than any one of them can handle individually starts up?
- londons_explore 3y ago> extra cleverness needed if the batteries are at different SoCs The scheme as presented keeps the inverters under equal fraction load, but does not guarantee the batteries end up at equal state of charge. The formula can easily be modified to over time achieve this too: X = 60 + (fraction load of inverter)*0.1 + per_battery_factor The per_battery_factor would be set based on the batteries state of charge and/or any user instructions from buttons to charge or discharge a specific battery.
- londons_explore 3y ago> handle the case where a whole bunch of inverters are in parallel and a load that’s much larger than any one of them can handle individually Yes, but with caveats... The grid will startup, smoothly (ie. gradually), but during startup every inverter will be at its maximum configured load (with the maximum load config ramped during startup). When the maximum load is hit, the frequency sits at the minimum design frequency (59.9 Hz in this case), and voltage drops instead. So your large device will see a sine wave at 59.9 Hz that starts at zero volts, and increases in amplitude to 230 volts gradually over many seconds, and as soon as it hits 230 volts, the frequency will almost immediately become 60 Hz. For large motors, thats a problem. Large motors typically don't like line frequency at a reduced voltage - they can end up not having enough torque to turn, and will just rapidly heat up. They would do better without the gradual startup ramp - but that startup ramp is necessary to ensure the inverters stay in sync. In reality, this scheme works for AC type motors rated up to about 30% of the capacity of the inverter set, or up to 100% as long as another motor is already running on the same grid.
- marcosdumay 3y agoThat's not simple to create with inverters alone. Yep, inverters can easily read the frequency change to adapt their output. But a device that reads the network load and translates it into a frequency change is really not trivial. Grids do this because mechanical generators do that translation, but the easiest way to add it to a non-mechanical grid is adding a mechanical device. Lines exclusively fed by inverters will naturally get undervoltage, instead of frequency shifts.
- londons_explore 3y ago> But a device that reads the network load and translates it into a frequency change is really not trivial. Nah - it's pretty simple. Have your inverter measure it's own load - for example by measuring the current through the main switching element. Compare that to the max current that switching element can handle. That is your percentage load that you are under. (negative if current goes backwards) Then use that to decide what frequency you will output, using the formula. There is one extra element to this... At startup, to avoid large transient currents, you need to start with the 'max switching element current' for the formula at zero, and then increase it smoothly only while the calculated load figure is under 100%. Within a few seconds you will get sync with any existing network. Such a scheme also works for blackstarting an isolated grid, or with many other inverters with the same strategy. This scheme has a big benefit that there is no need to measure the grid frequency precisely - which is actually a fairly hard thing to do on noisy small grids. And it turns out thats all thats required to maintain grid sync. As long as supply capacity exceeds demand at all times, this grid will be stable.
- londons_explore 3y agoBy the way, the reason big national grids don't allow this scheme is because it is too stable. Ie. if your house, containing some inverters like this, is disconnected from the national grid, it will continue independantly. Your house and the national grid will continue on their own paths, with slightly differing frequencies. Reconnecting two grids at differing frequencies is hard.