4 ms·
Which is interesting, because if they can't comply within the EU, then how do they comply outside of the EU. With that I mean, if they have concerns that there
by PinguTS 3y ago
Which is interesting, because if they can't comply within the EU, then how do they comply outside of the EU. With that I mean, if they have concerns that there is private data of EU citizens somewhere in that, then that is also in there for users outside of the EU. That said, they do not comply with GDPR anyway. If that its not the case, then they could also enable it for users within the EU.
- capr 3y agoSimple: GDPR (or any EU law) is not enforceable outside EU
- PinguTS 3y agoActually, in case of Google it is, because they still do business within the EU.
- zopa 3y agoThat’s a common belief, but it’s wrong. In principle an EU court could decide to apply the GDPR to conduct outside the EU; and in the right circumstances, a non-EU court might rule that the GDPR applies. Choice of law is anything but simple. Think of geographic scoping of laws as a rough rule of thumb sovereign states use to avoid annoying each other, rather than as a law of nature.
- PeterisP 3y agoGDPR is likely not enforceable if you have no presence in EU whatsoever, if you have no assets in EU and no money coming in from EU. Anything Google does with data of EU residents is subject to GDPR even if that particular service is not offered within EU, and it is definitely enforceable because Google has a presence in EU, which can be (and has been) subjected to fines, seizures of assets, etc.
- skinkestek 3y agoSome nuance: If Google gobble up data about EU citizens then they fall under GDPR. It doesn't matter that they don't allow EU citizens to use the result. If our personal data is in there and they are don't protect it properly they are violating EU law. And protecting it properly means from everyone, not just EU citizens.
- yoav 3y agoThe gobbling happens in realtime as you use it
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- sebzim4500 3y agoIt's a risk mitigation strategy, these things are not black and white. Making it unavailable in the EU decreases the likelihood and severity of a potential fine.