2 ms·
Per page 399 'Although Chicago is well beyond the 100-mile limit for CBP activity, the entire city (and 100 miles southward into Illinois) are all subject to ex
by anigbrowl 3y ago
Per page 399 'Although Chicago is well beyond the 100-mile limit for CBP activity, the entire city (and 100 miles southward into Illinois) are all subject to extended Border Patrol enforcement authority and the “border search exception” because Chicago is adjacent to Lake Michigan, which is considered an “external boundary.”'
I don't think the ACLU is claiming the 100 mile zone exists de jure but rather that CBP and successive executive branches rely on a specious claim, it's extremely hard to sue them, and so the 100 mile zone is a de facto reality. You can of course tell a CBP agent to get bent and that you'll fight it in court, but (assuming you're driving) you'll probably stop if waved down.
I agree with your legal analysis, but absent a court or executive order explicitly stating the CBP has no such authority, they act as if they do. It is this reality which the ACLU is describing, howbeit shallowly.
- tptacek 3y agoRight, and I'm observing that 'jcranmer went and looked at the statutory definition of "external boundary" and it conclusively does not not include Lake Michigan; I even cited the statute for you. :) A reminder here that Lake Michigan is entirely bounded by the United States. I think it's as internal as the Great Salt Lake.
- kasey_junk 3y agoThe times I’ve seen Lake Michigan claimed as an external entry point it’s because you can come by boat from outside the US to it. This is of course ridiculous because by that definition lots of US cities sit next to that sort of body of water including any city on the Mississippi.