10 ms·
Scientists warned about climate change in 1965
- FredPret 3y agoDidn't they predict ice ages at one point?
- Retric 3y agoNo, some scientists discovered particulate pollution is associated with cooling and there was increasing particulates in the upper atmosphere from human activities, which is a well known effect today. People took it wildly out of context, think day of tomorrow’s ice hurricanes vs the extremely mildly by comparison effect changing ocean circulation was actually predicted to have.
- jakobnissen 3y agoYeah, back in the day fossil fuel emitted more sulphur, which cools the planet (temporarily), offsetting some of the warming. It also causes acid rai and other stuff, so sulphur emissions have gone down. Back 50 years ago some scientists believe the sulphur cooling and smoke clouds would offset the greenhouse effect and lead to overall cooling, but this was always the minority view. We've since gotten way better models, and the warming has become much more obvious so it can be measured directly.
- tzs 3y agoOthers have already mentioned that those who predicted cooling were basing it on increasing particulates. They also knew greenhouse gases would cause warming, but they thought our particulate emissions would continue to increase faster than our greenhouse gas emissions so the cooling would beat out the warming. We they right, or was the majority of scientists who felt that even with our increased particulates it would not be enough to counter the increasing greenhouse gases right? We never got to find out, because the particulate emissions are noticeable enough to the average person and annoying enough to the average person that bipartisan efforts to reduce those emissions can get political support, such as the Clean Air Act of 1970 in the US. This led to a massive reduction in particulate emissions.
- kuprel 3y agoWhen I was growing up the concern was that fossil fuels were a limited resource that we are rapidly depleting. Now the concern is that they are far too abundant and cheap for our own good. Eventually the economics should force us to use renewables if the fossil fuels are a rapidly depleting limited resource, right?
- nyc_data_geek1 3y agoPeak oil was always a lie. As it gets more scarce, it gets more valuable, and innovations in extraction and processing are further incentivized to progress (see:fracking). It's just all living things on Earth that are the collateral damage (read:externalities) to that equation.
- rwc 3y agoThat's awfully dismissive. Not exactly a leap for people to argue: Climate change was always a lie. As the planet warms, the premium for a safe and healthy planet increases, and innovations in clean energy technology continue progress.
- ghouse 3y agoSo long as the supply of oil is finite, it's not a lie. The predictions of timing, however, were clearly wildly wrong.
- thaanpaa 3y agoActually, we have no idea. We don't know how much oil is still in the ground in many of the major oil exporting countries. Even though it was anticipated that OPEC would increase output after Russia was banned from the global market, they didn't. Were the explanations given valid, or might it be that they are no longer able to ramp up so quickly?
- Ekaros 3y agoAnd realistically why would have they. Russia did not stop too much production, just moved where it was sold. And increasing production would have driven price down making in long run less money in total for them.
- arbitrage 3y agoTelevision programs warning about global warming were already on reruns when I was a little kid in the 70s and 80s. Nothing has been being done for a loooooooong time.
- galfarragem 3y agoIsn’t the climate always changing?
- wilg 3y agoThis sort of foolishness is why I prefer the original term “global warming”. The phrase “climate change” was invented by Republican spin doctors and for unfortunately it’s become the standard term. The problem is that the Earth’s average temperature is rising, because of air pollution, which leads to the climate changing in undesirable ways.
- deanCommie 3y agoBad faith debaters will always debate bad faith When it was called "Global Warming", Republican spin doctors were bringing in snowballs into Congress to illustrate how ridiculous the concept is. You STILL hear this from modern conservatives every time there is any unexpected cold snap or "polar vortex": "So much for global warming, amirite?"
- godshatter 3y agoIn this PBS frontline interview Senator Timothy Wirth discusses how he scheduled James Hansen's 1988 Senate hearing on climate change for the day that was historically the hottest day of the year and how they opened all the windows so the air conditioners couldn't keep up prior to the hearing so that it was unbearably hot during the session: https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/hotpolitics/interviews/wirth.html https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/hotpolitics/intervi... Neither side seems to be above "bad faith debating".
- deanCommie 3y agoOne side has truth and scientific consensus on its side, as well the prosperity of the human race, and the LIVES of billions of individuals on the line. The other side to extend corporate subsidies and fossil fuel company profits for another generation and get themselves a nice fat retirement cushion from lobbyist contributions. Comparing their tactics for influence misses the forest for the trees.
- mc32 3y agoThere are lots of things people predicted, most of which did not come true (take a look at any future predicting writings, the serious ones: pop "explosion", starvation, social collapse, etc). We can only act now on what we know today. We cannot act retroactively. You can’t go around and say someone sometime somewhere said something and use that as evidence. Just as in law you can’t take a confession as sole proof of something. It has to be independently confirmed.
- pleb_nz 3y agoPretty sure someonen in the hate 1800sv warned about it as well
- BigCryo 3y ago[dead]
- reaperman 3y agoThis is underselling the timeline a bit. Climate change due to industrial emissions of CO2 has been known and published in mainstream news articles since at least 110 years ago.[0][1] It's been known and discussed in public by professional scientists for over 140 years[2]. The great inaugural Nobel Prize winner, Arrhenius, wrote a paper on the topic in 1896[3] which cited Fourier's publication from 1827[4]. More generally, global greenhouse effect of CO2 has been known for at least 185 years[4], a decade earlier than the last founding father of the United States died. ---------- 0: The Rodney and Otamatea Times (Aug 1912) https://www.livescience.com/63334-coal-affecting-climate-century-ago.html https://www.livescience.com/63334-coal-affecting-climate-cen... 1: Popular Mechanics (Mar 1912): https://books.google.com/books?id=Tt4DAAAAMBAJ&pg=PA341&lpg=PA341 https://books.google.com/books?id=Tt4DAAAAMBAJ&pg=PA341&lpg=... 2: Nature (1882): https://www.nature.com/articles/027127c0 https://www.nature.com/articles/027127c0 3: Journal of Science (Apr 1896) https://doi.org/10.1080/14786449608620846 https://doi.org/10.1080/14786449608620846 4: M ́emoire sur les Temp ́eratures du Globe Terrestre et des Espaces Plan ́etaires, M ́emoires d l’Acad ́emie Royale des Sciences de l’Institute de France VII 570-604 (1827): https://geosci.uchicago.edu/~rtp1/papers/Fourier1827Trans.pdf https://geosci.uchicago.edu/~rtp1/papers/Fourier1827Trans.pd... (English Translation)
- toofy 3y agoand i’m quite literally seeing posts from people earnestly asking why they’re having a hard time finding property insurance in florida. and others earnestly asking “who could have seen this coming?”
- mustacheemperor 3y agoA friend from high school’s parents were vehemently, angrily, argue-with-kids-in-the-car in denial of climate change and 15 years later they have moved to the border of Canada because the winters in southern new england aren’t the same anymore and the summers are even more uncomfortably hot and humid. Per my friend, they are still positive that climate change is a big hoax and have a list of confabulated explanations for why that’s as long as ever. (I remember one frequent highlight being that you can’t trust historic temperature readings, because the scientists just “changed how they read the temperature,” because they “want more funding”. It always came back to the duplicitous capture of “funding.”) It just seems like a completely different view of the world at its fundamentals.
- ararar 3y agoSame situation for antibiotics. Fleming, in the actual Nobel prize acceptance speech, warned: "It is not difficult to make microbes resistant to penicillin in the laboratory by exposing them to concentrations not sufficient to kill them, and the same thing has occasionally happened in the body." <https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/medicine/1945/fleming/lecture/ https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/medicine/1945/fleming/lect...> And so today we have infections resistant to practically every known antibiotic. And it's getting worse.
- myshpa 3y agoApproximately 70-80% of antibiotics are used in animal agriculture, primarily to promote faster growth or ensure animals survive until slaughter. I wonder how big is the impact of residual antibiotics in meat and dairy on bacterial resistance.
- wunderland 3y agoScientists warned about climate change in 2023. Nothing was done
- prometheus76 3y agoThis will open up a huge can of worms, but I am asking in good faith, because I have never really heard it articulated clearly. What is bad about the climate changing? Here's what I understand so far: The climate is a complex system, which means it's the interplay of many complex and/or chaotic systems, which means it's inherently unpredictable. The climate changes. It has changed dramatically over the course of the earth's existence, as far as we can surmise from available geologic records, etc. The main argument I have heard is "yes, the climate changes, but not at this rate! Ever!" Which seems like a very dubious claim, in my mind, because we don't have very good weather data going back very far, so we don't actually know if that's the case. I really want to understand the fear and anxiety people are experiencing with regard to climate change, because from my current understanding of the data and of the inherent unpredictability of complex systems, I don't. Tangentially related: if we are anxious about the climate changing, why do we think it should stay the same, and also, what would "ideal steady state" look like? I am prepared for "You're obviously an idiot..." kinds of comments. I'm genuinely asking these questions in good faith, hoping someone can help me understand the panic.
- 0xr0kk3r 3y agoTo ELI5 your question: the infrastructure that makes the world go round is located in the zones that will be flooded as sea level rises. It will be a huge cost to migrate this, and it isn't being done, which means a potential for massive disruptions in everything that makes society possible. It is SO expensive to address, 95% of the world's politicians are just pretending it isn't happening.
- Kapura 3y agoThe magnitude of the change is far beyond anything that has been experienced over "recent history" where "recent" is on a geological time scale. It's not on the order of the "little ice ages" and such of the past. It is extreme. Change, apropos of nothing, is not positive or negative; but when the climate changes so much that the ocean turns into acid and the animals start to die off, people will have concerns.
- steve1977 3y agoI guess the problem is actually fast climate change. Faster than evolution can adapt maybe, at least for many species. And it’s just potentially gonna change life as we know it. For example, the currents in the oceans are changing. This could potentially eradicate a large number of maritime species pretty fast. Which in turn are food not available anymore to other species. And so on.
- hitpointdrew 3y agoYeah, and the predicted we’d all be dead by now, how wrong they were/are.
- 2479411230 3y ago> predicted we’d all be dead by now I don't think that's what people were predicting. If I'm understanding your argument correctly, it's that people have been worrying/predicting issues with the climate for a while, but everything is currently fine? If that's a correct understanding (and apologies if it's not), then here's my argument: If someone told you that "50 years from now, there's going to be an earthquake in this exact spot; here's the data to back me up," it'd be kind of silly to say 25 years later "there's no earthquake. I don't see what all the fuss was about."
- hitpointdrew 3y ago> If someone told you that "50 years from now, there's going to be an earthquake in this exact spot; here's the data to back me up," it'd be kind of silly to say 25 years later "there's no earthquake. I don't see what all the fuss was about No, it would be like someone saying they had scientific proof that an earthquake would happen in 25 years and 50 years later not so much as the tiniest tremor ever occurring. There is no scientific “consensus” that there is a climate “crisis”. Just a small minority of loud fear mongers with political motivation. There are literally hundreds of other pressing issues that are real crises that deserve attention way before climate.
- 2479411230 3y ago> that an earthquake would happen in 25 years and 50 years later not so much as the tiniest tremor ever occurring. First, we are already seeing early effects of climate change https://news.un.org/en/story/2023/04/1135852 https://news.un.org/en/story/2023/04/1135852 Second, is your argument that "if climate change was going to be very bad, it would've happened by now?" I'm not aware (tho please correct me if I'm wrong!) of analyses saying that sea levels should have significantly risen by 2023, or the more catastrophic effects that models are currently showing. > There is no scientific “consensus” that there is a climate “crisis”. Just a small minority of loud fear mongers with political motivation. The data doesn't support that it's a minority of scientists. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientific_consensus_on_climate_change https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientific_consensus_on_climat... dives into the data, but surveys of scientists (who have published in peer-reviewed journals) consistently show that over 97% of scientists believe in human-caused global warming (see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Surveys_of_scientists%27_views_on_climate_change https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Surveys_of_scientists%27_views...). I also want to push back on the "political motivation" portion. As the OP notes, scientists have been warning about climate change for decades. Carl Sagan testified before congress about it in 1985. This is older than the current left-right political divide in America. George Bush gave a speech in 2001 in which he says that we need to stop emitting greenhouse gases to stop climate change https://georgewbush-whitehouse.archives.gov/news/releases/2001/06/20010611-2.html https://georgewbush-whitehouse.archives.gov/news/releases/20... > There are literally hundreds of other pressing issues that are real crises that deserve attention way before climate. I agree that we should be combating other issues, too!
- 29athrowaway 3y agoFreon was phased out, that was a big win.
- Ekaros 3y agoFreon was in the end relatively small thing to change. Other chemicals could replace it and deliver nearly same cost and performance. Same can't be said about global scale we use fossil fuels.
- deviantbit 3y ago[flagged]
- phd_n_physics 3y ago[flagged]
- wmeitzler 3y agoAnother complex question asked in good faith: Nothing has been done? Nothing? This seems like an overtly emotional value statement to the global response to a complex problem-- our industrial activities have side effects that effect our environment. The challenge is, what can we do about it, and what has worked so far? Can we explore this issue from a not-panicked perspective? Off the top of my head (feel free to hit me with Cunningham's Law): - Aerosol CFC's were a problem we addressed - Leaded paint and gasoline were another example - There is a dramatic increase in interest in electrification, which seems to be spearheaded by the environmentalist movement - I see more discussion about E-waste now than I did 10 years ago. Right to repair seems to be gaining speed in the Reduce/Repair side of the 3 R's - Are we seeing increased efficiencies in extracting fossil fuels? Fracking seems to fit that niche "Nothing was done" seems to be a value statement. If we are to agree on progress, we have to agree on who we are serving. Nether Molech (Unbounded consumption at the expense of the human) nor Malthus (Humans are an evil virus) strike me as great options.
- toofy 3y agoi hope you don’t read this as snarky as it’s going to sound, i really don’t mean it snarky at all… but people were pushing for changes decades ago in a non-panicked way.
- saulpw 3y agoYeah does anyone remember "An Inconvenient Truth"?
- blooalien 3y agoI didn't even have to be "pushing for changes" to be ridiculed by most everyone I knew (with the exception of my mother and my 5th grade teacher). All I had to do / say was be in agreement with the scientists who actually understood the issue. That was enough for most to label me a "tree-hugging hippie". Truth is that the ridicule just pushed me even further toward serious concerns about the future of our environment, because it opened my eyes to the fact that most people aren't gonna worry about it until it directly impacts their lives in a truly undeniable way (by which time it's already far too late).
- steve1977 3y agoNothing was done is not true. A lot of campaigning and lobbying by big oil was done.
- scythe 3y agoJohn von Neumann — not only a very prominent scientist, but a self-identified conservative — described climate change in a Fortune article titled "Can We Survive Technology?" in 1955: http://geosci.uchicago.edu/~kite/doc/von_Neumann_1955.pdf http://geosci.uchicago.edu/~kite/doc/von_Neumann_1955.pdf >The carbon dioxide released into the atmosphere by industry's burning of coal and oil-—more than half of it during the last generation—-may have changed the atmosphere's composition sufficiently to account for a general warming of the world by about one degree Fahrenheit.
- wrycoder 3y agoSo, half a degree centigrade in twenty years - 0.25C per decade. That’s higher than the actual warning of the global troposphere observed over the most recent forty years. But, maybe his “generation” is more than twenty years.
- scythe 3y agoVon Neumann may have meant the cumulative delta-T as of 1955; he may have also been referring to the expected equilibrium delta-T given the total emissions as of 1955. I don't think he meant the change over a generation; he was saying that CO2 emissions over the preceding generation were as large as all of the emissions before it. If we take the simple, cumulative change interpretation, he was off by about a factor of 2 using the usual start date of 1880; the equilibrium is harder to reckon. To make things more confusing, the years 1883-1920 were actually much colder than the preindustrial norm due to the eruption of Krakatoa, which he also mentions; using these as the baseline, one degree Fahrenheit is quite close to accurate (but no longer solely human-forced). The Krakatoa anomaly is why pre-1880 is usually chosen as baseline.
- _8j50 3y agoThere is this idea that governments should do stuff about climate change and I think only people enjoying the fruits of indistrialization in developed countries think that way to the most part. The side of climate change solutions I like are the people working to make clean tech cheaper. The world was an unpleasant place in 1965 and it has been largley fossil fuel enabled changes that have seen a lot of famine, sickness and poverty reduced. HDI has improved a lot! My point is not to say how nice fossil fuels are but how much no one gives a shit when their people are starving and fighting wars over resources. The cheapest tech wins. Wanna kill fossil fuel? Come with a cheaper solution (and there are already plenty). R&D and infra spending is better than tax incentives and forcing companies to do expensive things. Smarter spending too, E.g.: 10s of billions will go into ev chargers in cities but none to making cheaper electric trams and rails for public transport in cities.
- best_one_there 3y agoIt's not clear that you _can_ make a cheaper solution. Solar and wind have lower EROEI than fossil fuels.
- _8j50 3y agoI thought both EVs and Wind were cheaper in the ling run; same with nuclear
- ZeroGravitas 3y agoOne of the original EROEI researchers recently re-assessed this and came to the opposite conclusion. https://www.mdpi.com/2071-1050/14/12/7098/htm https://www.mdpi.com/2071-1050/14/12/7098/htm Doesn't really matter as EROIE is a dumb measurement that people use wrong anyway, but for people who think it is meaningful that should be worthwhile info to update your opinions.
- PeterisP 3y agoFrankly, if people got a magic crystal ball and after hearing that warning in 1965 they would be able to know that there would be a 1.1C temperature rise by 2023 - in 58 years - then it still would make all sense for them to do nothing. For these people, even if (a big if!) there would be a global consensus, then they would not approve significant cuts to the industry and consumption in order to prevent the limited effect that we're seeing now. The world was a much poorer place in absolute numbers, and wellbeing was directly linked to physical goods unlike the digital economy we have now, so even with perfect foresight, the big priorities of that era would still be increasing agriculture (through mass use of fossil fuels!) to feed people and increasing industry (through mass use of fossil fuels!) to reduce global poverty. The Green Revolution and economic changes of 1965-1985 were an enormous boon to humanity, and sacrificing THAT to slow down climate change would not be a good deal for us. And of course, unilateral sacrifices make even less sense. At the height of the Cold war, neither the west nor the USSR could agree to simply restrict their industry while the other would do nothing, because then you suffer all the drawbacks and climate change doesn't get prevented anyway.
- beerpls 3y agoNot to mention that developing tech faster can lead to subsequent tech that will help clean the mess. We don’t talk about climate change as an engineering project, but it absolutely could be. Think if we spent a fraction of what we spend on war every decade and instead dedicated that to tech to cleanse the atmosphere or oceans, or maybe even fusion.
- gmuslera 3y agoThat 1.1°C is not your everyday weather temperature. Is the global average over a year. It’s not like the temperature at 13:58 on Monday will be 1.1°C higher than what it was exactly 60 years before. That kind of increase is making frequent enough 1 in a century extreme weather events, Canada got 2 years ago nearly 50°C in a town, floods in all continents, increased frequency and strength of hurricanes and so on. And to make it worse, it is not the end of the change, and enough of the current warming is fueled by the warming itself, due to positive feedback loops, so it will keep going on even if we stop emissions. Things will keep getting worse, and will keep worsening probably for centuries. And things will stop being, let’s say, pleasant, closer to today than to the end of that process.
- anonymousiam 3y agoScientists warned then-president Nixon about climate change in 1972. They were concerned about GLOBAL COOLING, NOT GLOBAL WARMING. News article about the Nixon global cooling letter: https://www.thestreet.com/economonitor/us/an-important-letter-sent-to-the-president-about-the-danger-of-climate-change https://www.thestreet.com/economonitor/us/an-important-lette... CIA report about global cooling from 1974: http://www.climatemonitor.it/wp-content/uploads/2009/12/1974.pdf http://www.climatemonitor.it/wp-content/uploads/2009/12/1974... In the 70s, they said there'd be an Ice Age: (Linked to Google Cache below because the USG has removed the original (very well cited) content from the climate.gov website.) https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:vtKwOKv93IsJ:https://www.climate.gov/teaching/resources/70s-they-said-thered-be-ice-age&cd=10&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=us https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:vtKwOK...
- 2479411230 3y agoI'm a bit confused. What's the implication of this?
- anonymousiam 3y agoThe implication is, at the very least, there were SOME scientists concerned about global cooling in the 1960's and 1970's. I was around then, and it was very much publicized in the media. I never heard anything about global warming until decades later.
- 2479411230 3y agoSorry, I'm still a bit confused. I guess I phrased my question poorly. > there were SOME scientists concerned about global cooling in the 1960's and 1970's I get that the existence of the letter implies that people were thinking that way. My question was more, what do you see as the implication of the fact that some people were thinking this way. That is, how does this play into the discussion of the article.
- anonymousiam 3y ago
- JakeAl 3y agoCurrent green movement was started by Maurice Strong, former oil executive. He died a billionaire living in China. Play both ends against the middle.