4 ms·
TSMC seems real low for a company with a 100% share of the high performance chips market, with a really high moat, and lots of hype that chipmaking will be gett
by londons_explore 3y ago
TSMC seems real low for a company with a 100% share of the high performance chips market, with a really high moat, and lots of hype that chipmaking will be getting lots of government investment and lots of demand with AI wanting massive amounts more compute...
- dvhedvsa 3y agoYeah, but it’s in Taiwan. The Geo political situation as such that people discount it’s future prospects
- londons_explore 3y agoAre there betting odds anywhere for regime change/invasion of Taiwan? I would put it as ~1% per year right now, but perhaps other investors see it differently.
- zamadatix 3y agoI think the big thing in this space was Buffet recently pulling out of TSMC saying he loved the company but thought the tensions made it too risky. I don't know what that puts the odds for a full on invasion of Taiwan at but tensions in the area are definitely impacting real investment decisions.
- candiodari 3y agoThis seems inaccurate. If China will invade (at least 50%), they will definitely do so in the next 10 years or so. So a reasonable guess based on that assumption would be ~6.5% per year.
- pc86 3y agoBased on what? This sounds like you just pulling numbers out of the air, in which case 1% vs. 6.5% means comparatively nothing. And what makes you so sure that if China invades Taiwan they would definitely do it by 2033, and there's a 0% chance it'd happen in 2034? I'm not trying to be [overly] pedantic but HN is littered with comments basically just making shit up in a language of confidence and precision.
- jcranmer 3y agoI believe Xi Jinping has said something to the effect of "Taiwan should be a part of China by the end of this decade," although I'm having a hard time pinning down the exact quote. Although it should also be noted that Xi also tends to emphasize his desire to see Taiwan unified peacefully rather than force, so it's difficult to assess with accuracy how likely China is to invade Taiwan to compel an unwilling unification. As you say, 1% versus 6.5% is a level of precision that isn't helpful. The way I prefer to think of it is that a Chinese invasion of Taiwan is sufficiently probable as to warrant making contingency plans for such an event, but not so probable as to warrant making active efforts to avoid Taiwan.
- theironhammer 3y ago"it's difficult to assess with accuracy how likely China is to invade Taiwan to compel an unwilling unification." Taiwan is 30+Million people. I should imagine that would require a massive military undertaking.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- cm2012 3y agoHe doesn't deserve downvotes, he gave his assumptions and people can make their own judgements. His odds sound reasonable to me.
- usaar333 3y agoMetaculus puts the odds much higher - around 3%/year. https://www.metaculus.com/questions/11480/china-launches-invasion-of-taiwan/ https://www.metaculus.com/questions/11480/china-launches-inv... https://www.metaculus.com/questions/5320/chinese-annexation-of-half-of-taiwan-by-2050/ https://www.metaculus.com/questions/5320/chinese-annexation-...
- hankphot 3y agoIf you believe that Taiwan has a 1% chance of being invaded per year and that this event would remove your ownership then the long term value of purchasing this stock is negative
- red-iron-pine 3y agoExactly
- Ekaros 3y agoMaybe further question is, would invasion of Taiwan change the ownership structure in total sense. Or just for example 51% moving to Chinese hands. Production capacity losses might be realistic scenario and sales to west going down.
- hankphot 3y agoThe image of some western white guy complaining about unfair it is the China invalidates his ownership in the TSMC following a genocidal invasion of Taiwan is pretty good, I’ll give you that.
- dirtyid 3y agoReally what odds for TMSC disruption which is much different and permissible.
- nixcraft 3y agoTSMC is at risk due to geopolitical tensions, particularly between China and the USA. These risks led to Warren Buffett's Berkshire Hathaway selling its stake in TSMC. Investors are worried about that. That s my best guess. Apple also opened three factories in India and other places to mitigate this risk.
- arroz 3y agoWell NVIDIA depends entirely on TSMC
- addaon 3y ago> Well NVIDIA depends entirely on TSMC Yes and no. If NVIDIA loses access to TSMC due to geopolitical events, presumedly their competitors do too. There might be a couple years where they face increased competition from their own used market if they're unable to produce chis competitive with the previous generations', but at some point Samsung et. al. will catch up on capability and capacity, and NVIDIA will be as well positioned relative to their competitors to take advantage of that as they are today. The only case where this would be significantly different is if one of NVIDIA's major competitors was independent of TSMC and thus could use the lean times for NVIDIA to leapfrog them; but that would require considering Intel a real competitor.
- paulmd 3y agoArguably in this sense their only competitors would be screwed even harder. The last non-TSMC GPU that AMD has released is based on GloFo 12nm/14nm, NVIDIA would actually be ahead with Samsung 8nm. Intel's only dGPUs are TSMC as well, they flatly don't have a product without TSMC.
- addaon 3y agoI think Intel's advantage in this hypothetical is access to foundry space. Porting their current CPU designs from TSMC to their own foundry is non-trivial (although it can't be that hard -- their integrated graphics are fabbed on their own process, and share quite a bit with their discrete units), but at least having completed that effort they have somewhere to go, instead of fighting over what will be extremely over-subscribed Samsung fabs.
- lumost 3y agoTSMC is capex heavy. They will see margin compression with higher interest rates, at least in perception - their most over intel is only their ability to efficiently deploy capital.
- klelatti 3y agoThis. The value of a stock should (in theory) be based on discounted cashflow with the emphasis on cash. A company can generate massive earnings but if it needs to invest huge amounts of capital to support those earnings then it should have a lower valuation.
- Sohcahtoa82 3y agoIsn't being CapEx heavy a sign of constant expansion, though? I would think that selling (or choosing not to buy) a stock because their P/E is low because their CapEx is high is short-sighted unless you don't think their CapEx spending is going to pay off. It's like...back in 2012, I was talking to one of my wife's relatives at a Christmas party. He said he'd never buy Amazon stock because they've never been profitable. I said they're not profitable because every dollar they make, they put back into R&D. He would have 10x his money now if he had bought their stock.
- lumost 3y agoSoftware R&D is a special type of capex, in principal - successful R&D execution buys recurring free cash flow in near perpetuity. Contrast this with TSMC who needs to outlay ~50 Billion every 2 years on a new Fab which will deprecate over ~6-7 years. If TSMC stopped buying fabs, then intel would beat them in ~2 years time - and TSMC would be out of business in 6-7 years. Software R&D may be less efficient then the above math would imply, but there is a big range between perpetuity and some depreciating time horizon. R&D can also boosts growth prospects by expanding markets.
- Sohcahtoa82 3y ago> Contrast this with TSMC who needs to outlay ~50 Billion every 2 years on a new Fab which will deprecate over ~6-7 years. Oof, that's the bit I forgot. TSMC's CapEx isn't just expansion, it's replacement. They're constantly upgrading to manufacture new technologies. It makes sense now, thank you.
- adam_arthur 3y agoI've thought the same. It seems to me that they don't use their moat to really drive price. I don't know if it's cultural or what, but they could easily extract higher prices given their position. I seriously doubt Apple, AMD or NVDA would walk to another fab and give up a huge performance edge in their offerings. While TSMC's gross margins are 60% which is already quite high, their customers also have close to 50% margins... which implies room for higher chip prices