4 ms·
This feels like the author jumped to the conclusion that Wikipedia was at fault because it's a common enough story and sounded good, but it doesn't add up. See
by lolinder 3y ago
This feels like the author jumped to the conclusion that Wikipedia was at fault because it's a common enough story and sounded good, but it doesn't add up. See addaon's comment for an explanation of why heraldry here isn't as cut-and-dry as we're used to for, say, the US flag.
But even aside from that, the author neglected to check the full edit history on the Wikipedia file: the very first version of the flag (25 Nov 2005) had the red tiara that the article decries, citing Open Clip Art as the source [0]. That suggests the "wrong" version was already highly circulated before Wikipedia got the image.
The caption on the main photo goes so far as to suggest that the Vatican itself is using Wikipedia as a source for printing its flags. Indeed, the UN has a photo of the flag of the Vatican shortly after it was raised there in 2015, and that flag has the red tiara [1]. It's hard to imagine the flag flown at the UN being done as a rush job from a Wikipedia article.
It's a cute story, but it looks like the simpler truth is that the Vatican doesn't particularly care about the coloring of the tiara.
EDIT: Kudos to zokier for finding a Twitter thread with more examples [2]. Apparently the flag taken to the moon and back by Apollo 11 had the red tiara.
[0] https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=File:Flag_of_the_Vatican_City.svg&offset=&limit=250 https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=File:Flag_of...
[1] https://dam.media.un.org/asset-management/2AM9LO46AB5A?FR_=1&W=1920&H=947 https://dam.media.un.org/asset-management/2AM9LO46AB5A?FR_=1...
[2] zokier's comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36118232 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36118232
- adhesive_wombat 3y ago> It's hard to imagine the flag flown at the UN being done as a rush job from a Wikipedia article. Maybe the UN has their buttons on, but at the Olympics, displaying the wrong flag, an incorrect flag or the right flag upside-down happens now and then.
- lolinder 3y agoI imagine so, but in this instance the flag is a big stinking deal because the UN had just allowed the flags of Palestine and the Vatican (Observer States) to be flown for the very first time. This wasn't a case of "we've got to print out flags for every single country and fly them all at once", these two flags were given special attention. Also note my edit: the Twitter thread zokier found shows Benedict XVI seated next to a red-tiara'd flag in 2005, as well as the one that was sent to the moon in 1969.
- msla 3y agoOh, the Olympics has done worse: https://www.npr.org/2012/03/23/149244038/ceremony-plays-borat-kazakhstan-anthem-by-mistake https://www.npr.org/2012/03/23/149244038/ceremony-plays-bora... > Kazakhstan won the game but lost the award ceremony. A parody of the country's national anthem was played by mistake after a Kazakh athlete won a gold medal. Organizers of the shooting competition in Kuwait are apologizing for playing the Kazakhstan anthem from the comedy movie Borat.
- ytdytvhxgydvhh 3y agoMaybe the Olympics have done worse but your link isn’t Olympic-related.
- operatingthetan 3y agoWhoever is downvoting this please ask yourself when the last time Kuwait hosted the Olympics was...
- msla 3y agoThe next time it does, it has the opportunity to do something extremely funny.
- irrational 3y agoNo idea, but I’ll guess the answer is never?
- operatingthetan 3y agoThat's a bingo!
- wombatpm 3y agoThat was right after Nelson Mandela died in prison
- msla 3y agoOh, damn. I Googled for Olympics wrong anthem and that came up. It's a meta-screw up. Apt.
- msla 3y agoYeah, this looks like "Wikipedia is wrong because it's Wikipedia" as opposed to the encyclopedia actually being wrong.
- TeMPOraL 3y ago> It's hard to imagine the flag flown at the UN being done as a rush job from a Wikipedia article. I imagine, given enough time, graphical equivalent of citogenesis[0] might kick in. Even assuming that, and that in a hypothetical reality, the Internet somehow confused both the UN and Vatican officials as to what the Vatican flag was, at some point you're better off just making it official and letting kids 50 years later have a laugh when learning about it on history lessons. -- [0] - https://xkcd.com/978/ https://xkcd.com/978/
- iLoveOncall 3y ago> It's hard to imagine the flag flown at the UN being done as a rush job from a Wikipedia article. After working years for a famous international company where anyone from the outside would imagine incredible efficiency, precision, mastery, etc., it is really not hard AT ALL to believe.
- Aeolun 3y agoI very much imagine they pulled it off wikipedia.
- varenc 3y agoAdding more evidence to the pile, here's a red-tiara version on the Vatican's own website from a page last updated in 2001: https://www.vatican.va/news_services/press/documentazione/documents/corpo-diplomatico/corpo-diplomatico_internazionali_elenco_en.html https://www.vatican.va/news_services/press/documentazione/do... and the WaybackMachine confirms it's been there since at least Jan 2002: https://web.archive.org/web/20020112222602/http://www.vatican.va:80/news_services/press/documentazione/documents/corpo-diplomatico/corpo-diplomatico_internazionali_elenco_en.html https://web.archive.org/web/20020112222602/http://www.vatica... edit: Also the very first version of Wikipedia's Vatican City flag uploaded in 2005 also had a red tiara! It only stopped being red in 2013: https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=File:Flag_of_the_Vatican_City.svg&dir=prev https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=File:Flag_of... (look for the 1st upload in the history) (side note: the Vatican keeping the same URLs up for 2+ decades is a refreshing change of pace!)
- acqq 3y agoAlso, note the flag behind the Pope in this 1998 picture during his official visit: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36121563 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36121563
- SamBam 3y agoYeah, what this really shows is that flags are not nearly as precise as we sometimes imagine them to me. For instance, most old heraldic crests and flags have their official formats described in plain text: "Blazon or, three lions passant guardant azure, langued and armed gules." That's the final word on the matter. It's then up to the flag maker to read that and create it correctly. This can result in flags that look subtly different, with variations in how lions or whatever were drawn. Google "Royal Banner of Scotland" and you'll see a number of variations in how the red lion is drawn. Ditto, say, "Coat of arms of Finland." These days those Google searches will show more and more the same images, with the Wikipedia effect (or general internet) but you can still find a wealth of examples of how different they used to be.
- IIAOPSW 3y agoHaving just read a bit about what the heraldry rules are and the purpose they serve, it strikes me as very similar to the design ideas of transit maps in modern times. You want the lines to be easily distinguishable, certain colors shouldn't run side by side (so the conventional wisdom says), you choose only from a minimalist simple pallet. In most places, the maps are diagrammatic, the lines can be arranged in any way so long as they connect the right stations in the right order. Convergent evolution.
- Semaphor 3y agoThey link to this dude’s Vatican flag site [0] that has the 2023 version [1] which is a mix of the "correct" (it might be the correct pre-2023 version) and "incorrect" version (2023 seems to have yellow, not bronze, keys, white tiara). I’m left with still not knowing what the real flag is, if Wikipedia is now right, and why the article writer wrote so much without doing any real research. [0] https://mnflag.tripod.com/vatflag/ https://mnflag.tripod.com/vatflag/ [1] https://mnflag.tripod.com/vatflag/official-models1.png https://mnflag.tripod.com/vatflag/official-models1.png