11 ms·
CPR's true survival rate is lower than many people think
- Gordonjcp 3y agoYou can't make dead any deader. It might work. You may as well give it a shot, if only to say "well, at least I gave it a shot".
- sccxy 3y agoDo your best to give their family $200k medical bill.
- hnthrowaway8860 3y ago[flagged]
- lljk_kennedy 3y agoOr not, if you're not American.
- Vaslo 3y agoOr prioritize your funds to pay for your healthcare, like most responsible Americans do.
- sccxy 3y agoTwo-thirds of people who file for bankruptcy cite medical issues as a key contributor to their financial downfall. What most people do not realize, according to one researcher, is that their health insurance may not be enough to protect them. https://www.cnbc.com/2019/02/11/this-is-the-real-reason-most-americans-file-for-bankruptcy.html https://www.cnbc.com/2019/02/11/this-is-the-real-reason-most...
- JshWright 3y agoYou can be a very responsible person and still not be able to cover a sudden expense that is a significant fraction (if not a multiple) of you annual income.
- Gordonjcp 3y agoMaybe don't live in a country with third-world healthcare, then.
- fsckboy 3y agohealthcare still costs regardless of who pays for it. And the countries with the most comprehensive socialized systems also pride themselves on their civic-mindedness, think about others, not just yourself: shouldn't you, out of civic duty, balance trying to save the public money at the same time as you decide whether you save a life?
- Gordonjcp 3y agoWhy would they get a "medical bill"?
- whoomp12342 3y agoin defense of CPR, the goal is not to help someone recover. the goal is to buy time until the real medical professionals can react with real equipment.
- MagicMoonlight 3y agoIf your heart has stopped it is generally because you’re dead. It’s not like an arm where it can just break while everything else is fine. In cases where it has only stopped because of a truly external factor eg drowning then it works but it won’t work if you’re just dying.
- willmadden 3y ago[flagged]
- dang 3y agoCould you please review the site guidelines and stick to them? Your comment here broke quite a few of them, including: "Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize." "Please don't post shallow dismissals, especially of other people's work. A good critical comment teaches us something." "Don't be snarky. [...] Edit out swipes." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- willmadden 3y ago[flagged]
- giraffe_lady 3y ago100% agree. Thank you.
- JshWright 3y ago> If I'm dying, I'll take the CPR. It's better than the alternative. No, it isn't... There are many outcomes of resuscitation that are not at all better than simply passing peacefully where you were. A lot of resuscitations end up with someone in the hospital, in a coma, for a few days before finally dying (with an expensive medical bill for their estate). Even worse, folks can often end up with a severe brain injury, but survive for many years with a very poor quality of life. It is totally fine that you would prefer CPR to be performed at your current stage in life. That is the default state, and what will happen if you experience a sudden cardiac arrest. For many people, they would likely make a different decision, given all the information. This piece is intended to help give people some of that information so that they can then have a more informed conversation with their doctor about end of life care, DNRs, etc. I'm also curious why you're hung up on the "state sponsored" bit. NPR does receive a very small amount of federal funding (certainly much less than, e.g. Tesla or SpaceX have received), but that funding does not impart any editorial oversight (nor is there any mechanism for that oversight to take place). This particular post is clearly labelled as a "Perspective" (i.e. an opinion), written by an emergency physician. The notion of CPR in general (prolonging life at all costs) is a very "western" approach to medicine, so if promoting "the values of western governments" was the point of this post, it did a very poor job of it.
- spacechild1 3y agoI didn't know about the low success rate of CPR, but I have been very well aware of the potential damage. When I was a paramedic (as an alternative to military service) I once had to perform CPR to an old lady and I heard her rips crack. One of the worst experiences in those 9 months...
- markoman 3y agoYou're kinda burying the lede here... Was this woman resuscitated by your efforts and do you know how long she survived afterwards?
- lotsofpulp 3y ago*and with what quality of life did she survive? If I am 85 years old, maybe it is better for me to move on.
- EA-3167 3y agoCPR + Old Lady + Not in a hospital = Almost certainly didn't survive, or live well if she did.
- mikepurvis 3y agoYeah, that's what I got from lifeguard training. The best chance of doing anything positive with it is going to be on an otherwise young and healthy person whose heart stopped due to a very unusual trauma. And CPR and artificial respiration is never a miraculous eyes-opening recovery like in the movies— it's pretty much just putting oxygen in the brain to buy a few extra minutes for the ambulance to arrive and take over.
- spacechild1 3y agoCorrect :-(
- EA-3167 3y agoI'm sure you did everything you could, the sad fact of life is that eventually it ends.
- mjevans 3y agoSalient data from the article: TL;DR CPR slightly increases the odds for someone otherwise healthy and young but is much less effective for the old and the chronically ill. IIRC from prior CPR classes (own life data), 'correctly done' chest compressions are extremely violent, they often break ribs to get that compression of the heart between the rib cage and spine. It's a last-ditch effort with COSTS. If there's an AED around to use instead that would be FAR more preferable. """ But the true odds are grim. In 2010 a review of 79 studies, involving almost 150,000 patients, found that the overall rate of survival from out-of-hospital cardiac arrest had barely changed in thirty years. It was 7.6%. Bystander-initiated CPR may increase those odds to 10%. Survival after CPR for in-hospital cardiac arrest is slightly better, but still only about 17%. The numbers get even worse with age. A study in Sweden found that survival after out-of-hospital CPR dropped from 6.7% for patients in their 70s to just 2.4% for those over 90. Chronic illness matters too. One study found that less than 2% of patients with cancer or heart, lung, or liver disease were resuscitated with CPR and survived for six months. """
- starwatch 3y ago> 'correctly done' chest compressions are extremely violent. For a good visual of this take a look at a LUCAS machine in operation [1]. I'm a (retained) firefighter and have seen paramedics deploy a LUCAS - it's quite a thing to behold. > If there's an AED around to use instead that would be FAR more preferable. Sadly AED's aren't always appropriate. They need a "shockable rhythm" - that is if your heart is in ventricular tachycardia or ventricular fibrillation [2]. One interesting fact I recall reading (source long forgotten ...) is that collapsed women are less likely to be helped with AED's by passers by. This is because they feel uncomfortable uncovering the chest to apply the AED pads. [1]: https://youtu.be/G-oPJV1LYaE?t=314 https://youtu.be/G-oPJV1LYaE?t=314 [2]: https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/heart-arrhythmia/in-depth/automated-external-defibrillators/art-20043909 https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/heart-arrhyth...
- EA-3167 3y agoThis is sadly true, a friend and colleague of mine passed away about 7 years ago from sudden cardiac arrest. There was an AED in the building, but unfortunately he was in asystole, nothing there to shock. Having said that AED's do save a lot of lives, but like CPR they aren't magic.
- dheera 3y agoI'm a survivor of cardiac arrest and was resuscitated with an AED and CPR. I've gone through a lot but I'm glad to be alive, have an implanted ICD now, and I'm glad some employee didn't refuse to do CPR on me. I wasn't conscious for the event and the entire following week, but they didn't break any of my ribs. Maybe the AED allowed them to be less violent.
- zahma 3y agoSounds like you were fortunate to have multiple people around, an AED nearby, and someone well-trained. You’re probably right that AED helped prevent physical damage, though that may also be due to good technique and or your anatomy. The sooner that the AED goes on and restarts sinus rhythm, the fewer compressions required. Happy to hear you are doing better.
- dheera 3y agoYep it happened at a boat race, so there were paramedics already on-site. On one hand I was told to avoid competitive-intensity sports in the future, but I was also super fortunate that it all played out at a boat race and not while climbing some mountain. And having the ICD means I can still hike non-strenuous mountains.
- hirundo 3y ago"The 2000 Federal Cardiac Arrest Survival Act grants those who administer CPR or use an AED immunity from civil charges, except in instances of willful misconduct or gross negligence." That should make it less risky to try and help in the U.S. But apparently it can still be a choice that's easy to get wrong. That makes me less likely to jump in as a bystander, and to bias intervention toward healthier looking victims who look like they could tolerate the treatment. https://www.cprcertified.com/blog/can-you-be-sued-for-performing-cpr https://www.cprcertified.com/blog/can-you-be-sued-for-perfor...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dghlsakjg 3y agoOn the other hand: More payouts are made for people NOT providing lifesaving care when they should. https://newsroom.heart.org/news/legal-risk-of-not-performing-cpr-higher-than-providing-lifesaving-assistance https://newsroom.heart.org/news/legal-risk-of-not-performing...
- boringg 3y agoWhat's the point of this article? Are we trying to get rid of CPR now so that people don't bother doing it because it has a low success rate? It is literally a last desperate effort to save someone in a really bad situation. I don't think anyone is under the allusion that CPR has like a 95% success rate do they?
- nordsieck 3y ago> I don't think anyone is under the allusion that CPR has like a 95% success rate do they? When I was first taught CPR in school, it was taught without any reference to the survival statistics. The impression I got was that it was very effective. I don't know about 95% success rate, but I'd bet a lot of people think it has at least a 70% success rate.
- querez 3y agoWhen I was thought it, it was clearly pointed out to me that chance of survival is ~5%, but increases significantly if an AED can be used in time. I've also been told about the rib cracking etc. Just as a counterpoint.
- basisword 3y agoWhat use is this information though to someone performing CPR? It’s important in the sense that maybe better techniques can be developed but if I need CPR it doesn’t matter one bit if the person doing it knows it’s success rate. In fact probably better they don’t know. If they know the odds are low perhaps they’ll give up too soon.
- WJW 3y agoI could see an argument that knowing the statistics could help the CPR-giver in the aftermath. After all the patient is very likely to die and if the CPR-giver was under the impression that it is likely to work, then they may feel a lot of unwarranted guilt.
- dragonwriter 3y ago
- groestl 3y agoI was actually surprised to learn that survivors are in the upper single digits. After all, when you start CPR, people are already dead. Personally, I had to do CPR twice (as a paramedic), and sadly neither of the patients survived.
- Faaak 3y agoMaybe dumb question here, but does it at least help to salvage the organs later on (if the donor was okay with it) ?
- uberuberuber 3y agoCritical care medic here. Adult CPR at least has some evidence in its favor on a population level, but only as a bridge to using electricity. CPR alone is merely slowing deaths arrival. There is NO evidence to support any of the commonly used advanced cardiac life support drugs in terms of functioning brain leaving the hospital. Epinephrine (for arrest, not shock or anaphylaxis), atropine, lidocaine, amiodarone, procainamide, digitalis, etc. Its electricity or bust. Just one of many reviews on this: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4129833/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4129833/
- JumpCrisscross 3y agoWould it make sense for households with those at risk of heart attack to invest in an AED?
- rdmirza 3y agoEven better is installing an implantable cardiac defibrillator (ICD) in those at high risk.
- noughtme 3y ago> at high risk. Before an event? I’m not sure what insurance would cover this. I don’t really want open heart surgery before I need it.
- Calavar 3y agoPlenty of insurance plans cover ICD implantation because it is recommended by the American College of Cardiology for specific situations: 1. moderately to severely reduced systolic function of the heart due to a heart attack that persists > 40 days after the heart attack 2. severely reduced systolic function of the heart of any cause that does not improve after 3 to 6 months of pharmacologic therapy 3. personal history of sudden cardiac death with a persistent risk factor ICD implantation is not open heart surgery. It is a relatively quick procedure that is done by a cardiologist rather than a cardiothoracic surgeon.
- YetAnotherNick 3y ago> The traumatic nature of CPR may be why as many as half of patients who survive wish they hadn't received it, even though they lived. It's the peak of coming up with data to make a story. The study was only for old people with chronic disease, where lot of them wouldn't want any life saving treatment let alone CPR. And even in that group if >50% of said they were happy to have gotten CPR.
- imglorp 3y agoA common expression is, if they need CPR, they're _dead_ at that point and you can only improve their chances of reaching definitive care, even if it's long odds. And yes there will probably be side effects to complain about. If the patient decided they didn't want that, ahead of time, they could have a DNR in place.
- querez 3y agoNot sure what the situation is in the US, but I've taken 3-4 first aid courses in my life (it's compulsory to get a driver's license where I live). Every time, they told us that CPR survival rates were abysmal if we aren't also using an AED. IIRC, with an AED the survival rate goes up significantly -- though this article states that in-hospital survival rates are only at 17%, which indicates it's not all that great with AED, either.
- zackkatz 3y agoThis article doesn’t really address statistics for younger people. I feel like the headline should be: should elderly people be given CPR? For me the answer is a strong no. Why on Earth would you give CPR to a 90-year old person!? > survival after out-of-hospital CPR dropped from 6.7% for patients in their 70s to just 2.4% for those over 90
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- themantalope 3y agoWeird way to say that people should talk to their doctors about how they want to die before the time is upon them. Major problem in the US. See it every day at my job.
- williamDafoe 3y agoThe real point of CPR is to bridge their life while you rush to get them an AED. Without the AED the chance of their heart restarting permanently is vanishingly low ... Last few times I had first responder training it was said to be less than 15% chance of survival for a patient given CPR, and you'll only hear about this if you ask. The last time I had first responder training the guy sitting next to me was drowned by a surfing accident but it was his great fortune that on shore there was a national expert giving rapid water rescue training and they had this guy out of the water and his heart restarted in 5 minutes. So that is why he was taking first responder training himself!
- User23 3y agoThumpversion sometimes works too. Interestingly it was also invented by Dr. Bernard Lown, who is best known for inventing the DC defibrillator.
- robbiep 3y agoIt almost never works, unless you are seeing a witnessed cardiac arrest and know how to administer. That is the right ‘indication’ for a précordial thump, but the success rate is still terrible.
- three14 3y agoComplete anecdata, but a few months ago a neighbor of mine successfully resuscitated another neighbor with CPR. There was an AED present, but from what I heard, it did not recommend a shock. The person who collapsed is around 70 years old. Sometimes, it does work! There clearly are some cases where it would be crazy not to try it.
- JshWright 3y agoCPR alone is very, very unlikely to reverse cardiac arrest. It's possible your neighbor lost consciousness, but wasn't actually without a pulse, and CPR just woke them up.
- anonymousiam 3y agoI was dead on the street at 15 after being hit by a car (my fault). A good Samaritan stopped, administered CPR and resuscitated me. Forty six years later and I never got to thank him. I only know his first name (Mark). CPR is a good thing and hopefully this article will not make people think twice before administering it.
- mbac32768 3y agoI took a rescue diver certification course and after they went through lots of procedures for how to rescue someone, perform CPR, etc and drilled you in varying ways about it, at the exact end of the course they level with you and say the odds of someone actually recovering from these kinds of dive accidents is dismal. Don't beat yourself up if your patient doesn't survive, you tried your best :thumbsup: I agree these interventions are worth trying but it's definitely important for first responders to be realistic about the success rates so that they aren't haunted by the failures.
- davycro 3y agoCPR shouldn’t work on someone dead from a traumatic injury. For example chest compressions will only hurt someone dead from having their chest crushed against a steering wheel in a car accident. What happened to you is a true miracle and far outside the norm.
- gerdesj 3y agoIt is a good thing: obviously - you were resuscitated. I did a first aid course a few months back and one of the attendees (six in total) had done a similar job for a colleague a few years back. Their description was quite something. To be told first hand what happens, corroborating the instructor is a lesson and a half. It isn't pleasant at all and I won't spell it out here. As well as CPR we covered quite a few other things and you are far more likely to encounter choking and the correct response is far more likely to have a good outcome than CPR, so first aid courses are a very good thing. If I end up having to deliver CPR, I will do it without hesitation. I will do the checks first, mindful that I will be performing what amounts to ABH. A small success rate is better than nothing. OK so something like 5-10% is the real success rate for CBR. Now, would you be interested in something like 75%? DEFIBRILLATOR. A defib will talk you through how to use it but a short course will get you going much quicker. They are just like jump starting a car but instead of croc clips, the wires are connected to sticky pads that you stick on the person. They are battery powered and can be very small and portable. They are nothing like as big as you see on old school TV dramas. Upside: ~75% chance of resuss. compared to around 5-10% for CPR. No need to potentially break ribs or other unsavoury side effects of battering a person. Downside: Costs around £1000 a pop - they are reusable. If you own a business, why not grab one, slap it on the wall near to the first aid kit and get the staff clued up. When you get to a certain age (over zero) why not get one at home? I have not yet followed my own advice yet but I think I will quite soon! Have a chat about it with your staff, family and whoever will listen. I think that CPR should be likened to camping without a tent, in the Arctic. A defib: glamping, with free Cava! That said, I will still cause ABH on someone that I deem needs it if nothing else is to hand.
- dghlsakjg 3y agoGenerally CPR is performed when there is no pulse or breathing as a last ditch effort to keep a brain viable until a full medical team can do their work. In other words CPR is performed on people who show no signs of life/are already dead. The survival rate for the control group is 0, so it is kind of a miracle that anyone survives.
- brianwawok 3y agoIt’s not that simple. People who do not get CPR live. Others who get CPR didn’t need it. Control group of 0 is missing the complexities of real life.
- dreamcompiler 3y agoIt is that simple. CPR -- if done properly -- is only done on dead people. Dead people don't come back on their own. And if CPR is done on somebody who "doesn't need it" then by definition it was done wrong, because they weren't dead in the first place.
- akvadrako 3y agoIt will be done wrong, so you have to take that into account.
- shkkmo 3y agoThis is wrong, CPR almost never brings people back. What CPR does is provide minimal bloodflow and oxygenation until electricity can be used to get the heart beating properly again. By doing this, you extend the window during which an AED (or other defibrilator) can be used successfully and hopefully reduce brain damage in the event of that success. Indeed, if you have an AED, delaying its use to provide CPR is bad.
- dathinab 3y agoworse CPR doesn't do what people think it does CPR is not a live saving measure, it's a temporary live extension if it's not followed up with other measurements it's likely to not save a live. And that's assuming it does work, and is done correctly. but anyway it gives people another chance at live they most likely wouldn't have had otherwise
- aaron695 3y ago[dead]
- null-shell 3y agoMy father two years ago had a heart attack and a stroke, I found him and yelled for my mom and sister, then started CPR until the paramedics came. He survived and is doing very well, but it's crazy to think there was only a 10%~ish chance of it working.
- sokoloff 3y agoI read this brief but powerful related story of compassion and leadership last year and feel like it's worth sharing here: https://twitter.com/tjwebbmd/status/1557229120131588098 https://twitter.com/tjwebbmd/status/1557229120131588098 (warning: covers aspects of the death of a young child)
- DoreenMichele 3y agoThe title was changed and not necessarily for the better. This is a piece about the right to die with dignity, the right for elderly people to say "Yeah, I'm ready to let go. Heroic measures to keep me technically alive make no sense at this point." In some cases, you aren't prolonging their life. You're dragging out their death and torturing them to do so. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19598562 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19598562 I am also reminded of the scene in Aliens 3 where the android asks Ripley to simply shut him down because he's lost so much functionality that keeping him "alive" has no appeal for him.
- e40 3y agoYep, my mom (84) had an older friend years ago. Had a medical directive that said "do not resuscitate" and her daughter ignored it. She spent a year in hospice before she died totally angry at her daughter for not following directions. Her quality of life was terrible. My mom has talked about this many times and sternly told me not even think about ignoring her directive.
- jgeada 3y agoBut there is so much money to be made on the heroic measures front! Estimates range from 12% to 25% of lifetime healthcare expenses are accrued on the last year of life [eg https://www.cms.gov/Research-Statistics-Data-and-Systems/Research/ActuarialStudies/downloads/last_year_of_life.pdf https://www.cms.gov/Research-Statistics-Data-and-Systems/Res...] For profit healthcare is an obscenity.
- Arrath 3y agoI'll always remember my Great Uncle, who begged my Grandfather every time he saw him, to bring him a pistol so he could end it and escape the torture that was his chemo treatments. There is absolutely a point past which all quality of life is destroyed and it isn't worth continuing care.
- bluefirebrand 3y agoIt's really unfortunate that we're socially very willing to let people suffer if that's the status quo, but helping someone end their suffering is considered horrible and is in many cases criminal. Just look at the recent online discussions around the MAID program in Canada. It's meant to be a compassionate end of life for people who have lost all hope, and people are twisting it to mean that Canada is just going to start euthanizing people instead of providing healthcare.
- randcraw 3y ago"An international team of researchers looked at 49,555 out-of-hospital cardiac arrests that occurred in major U.S. and Canada cities. They analyzed a key subgroup of these arrests, those that occurred in public, were witnessed and were shockable. The researchers found that nearly 66 percent of these victims survived to hospital discharge after a shock delivered by a bystander." https://newsroom.heart.org/news/cardiac-arrest-survival-greatly-increases-when-bystanders-use-an-automated-external-defibrillator https://newsroom.heart.org/news/cardiac-arrest-survival-grea... Obviously, 66% beats the 10% survival rate in the original article (getting CPR alone from bystanders). The takeaway: AEDs can make a BIG difference. Curious that the article failed to mention that.
- LorenPechtel 3y agoAlso, a witnessed arrest likely means it's because the heart stopped vs the heart could no longer operate because of other problems. Also, vfib is far more salvageable than not operating at all.
- tinus_hn 3y agoThere’s a curious movement of people who spend their life afraid they will ‘endure’ CPR and live to tell the tale. And they come up with scare pieces like this one. Sorry, if you go as far as getting a tattoo because you’re so afraid you will be resuscitated, you’re in way over your head and it’s time to focus your energy on something constructive.
- JohnMakin 3y agoThis isn't a secret. I was required to be CPR Certified for a decade. Every class I ever took, the instructor made it clear that it only makes a small difference in survival outcomes, in order to teach students that "you shouldn't be scared to do it." If done properly you should break ribs. They also teach this in classes. I don't think anyone is under the illusion that CPR is a hugely high-percentage life saving technique, except maybe the public at large, but the public at large believes a lot of stupid, untrue things.
- strunz 3y agoThis is covered in the article: >In real life, people similarly believe that survival after CPR is over 75%. Also: >I don't think anyone is under the illusion that CPR is a hugely high-percentage life saving technique, except maybe the public at large You don't think anyone believes this, except almost everyone?
- JohnMakin 3y agoIt's unclear what exactly the article is trying to conclude, but it seems to imply there's some agenda to keep doing this technique despite evidence to the contrary - perhaps I should clarify by saying "no medical professional is under the illusion." They know the odds, and have for decades, and it is still recommended training for people, and it should be.
- zdragnar 3y agoThere's at least a small skew in the numbers as well. My wife was instructed to perform CPR by a 911 dispatcher on someone she found who had died in their sleep, and kept talking her through the instructions until paramedics arrived. I'm assuming this is counted in the broader "survival rate" numbers. That's not to say that the overall message is wrong, but CPR being administered to the dead, or those in medical distress who wouldn't benefit from it, will obviously decrease the overall effectiveness scores.
- piloto_ciego 3y agoThe one time I administered CPR both victims of the accident I stopped at died. In retrospect they were already goners (both ejected from the car) and I didn’t know what I was doing - hell none of us really did, but we tried. It was objectively one of the most traumatic experiences of my life and I used to dream about those people’s faces for a long time - indeed I can still see them if I try. Regardless, we tried and I wouldn’t have it any other way. We tried. I wrote a poem about it a few years ago: Violence Do you people know what it looks like when a man dies? What you think his fucking soul flies? As he serenely and comfortably lies, And he flutters his contented eyes? Not at all - there’s blood and pain, And vomit in his mouth, and foul brutal smells of bile and shit, and his eyes look crazy and wild, as you pound on his chest to exhaustion, “Scoop out the mouth - take those kids out of here, somebody fucking call 911!” <ah ah ah ah stayin’ alive stayin’ alive> <ah ah ah ah stayin’ alive stayin’ alive> They don’t tell you CPR never works, Or how the body jerks, Then the EMT smirks, “I can’t zap him again, but dudes dead.” So it was done, and I drove my truck to the truck stop to buy gas and clean the blood from my hands and jacket and reconcile with the two ghosts that had crawled into my head.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]